New York Times reporter Peter Baker questioned whether President Obama’s soaring rhetoric ("the most gifted orator of his generation") was still getting through in his Sunday Week in Review piece "The Words That Once Soared," and even let Obama aides suggest the president's Cairo speech "was responsible for Iranians taking to the streets of Tehran to protest a disputed election."
As the most gifted orator of his generation, President Obama finds speechmaking perhaps his most potent political tool. It propelled him to national prominence in 2004 and to the White House in 2008. And whenever he needs to calm economic fears or revive stalled health care legislation, he takes to the lectern.
The Times finds the Democratic party to be a veritable symposium of “gifted orators.” Obama’s already been called that three times before in the Times, the first instance coming all the way back on March 19, 2006 in a story by Anne Kornblut, before he was even running for president.
Mass. Gov. Deval Patrick joined Obama as a “fellow gifted orator” in a March 27, 2008 story by Abby Goodnough.
In a March 1, 2009 Times magazine story, Matt Bai said that unlike conservative Republican Newt Gingrich, Obama was a “gifted orator.”
In fact, a Nexis search and a nytimes.com search suggest that no Republican has earned the Times’s “gifted orator” appellation, not even Ronald Reagan, although the archives get fuzzier pre-1981.
Going back a little, President Bill Clinton was a “gifted orator” in October 1994, less than a month before he orated his party out of the House of Representatives for the first time in 40 years.
It’s no surprise that former New York governor and perpetual Democratic presidential teaser Mario Cuomo was called a “gifted orator” in May 1992.
It may come as more of a surprise that screaming Howard Dean was considered a “gifted orator” in a June 2003 story, again by Matt Bai.
Moving on: Baker wondered if Obama had lost his magic touch and forwarded a familiar comforting argument: That the Democrats who lost last week “had fatal flaws of their own.” (Which somehow didn’t stop the Times editorial page from endorsing the fatally flawed Democratic NJ Gov. Jon Corzine anyway.)
But the limits of rhetoric were on display last week when the president could not rescue two foundering candidates in governor’s races in New Jersey and Virginia. Has Mr. Obama lost his oratorical touch? Is the magic finally beginning to fade? Does the White House rely too heavily on his skills on the stump to advance his priorities?It may be too soon to reach such conclusions. The Democrats who lost last week, after all, had fatal flaws all their own. But the results do suggest that Mr. Obama’s addresses these days may not resonate quite the way they did. Speeches that once set pulses racing now feel more familiar. And if that remains the case heading into next year, it could make it more difficult for the Democrats’ own Great Communicator to promote his program and carry along allies in crucial midterm elections.
Baker even toyed with the idea that Obama’s speechmaking was responsible for the popular uprising in Iran after dictator Mahmoud Ahmadinejad won a heavily corrupted election.
Unlike Mr. Bush, who recognized his limitations as a public speaker, Mr. Obama and his team have enormous faith in his capacity for communicating with the American people. When he was considering a bailout for the auto industry and advisers warned of a popular backlash, he expressed confidence that he could explain it to the public. After Mr. Obama gave his speech in Cairo reaching out to the Muslim world, some aides argued that the address itself was responsible for Iranians taking to the streets of Tehran to protest a disputed election.
Baker let Obama aides advance that self-serving idea, but left out the inconvenient truth that the administration was mostly silent as the election was stolen, its support for the opposition was muted and reluctant at best. Both the European Union and Britain took a tougher line on the Iranian regime than did Obama, as the Times itself reported in June 2009.
—Clay Waters is the director of Times Watch, an MRC project tracking the New York Times.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Reader
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:11 ET by iveseenitallI will admit, Obama can read the teleprompter better than Sheppard Smith. But his oratory skills, his intelligence, his great education, his writing ability,his leadership, his good looks-- and his ears --are greatly exaggerated.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Maybe I am just completely not enamored
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:17 ET by StarAZI hear his voice--and see that head back and forth, back and forth--and I lunge for the remote. I don't find him gifted--I mean, his speechwriters. Always ten-dollar words--sobering, sober reminder...whatever--are we all drunk with optimism?...The words are always so dry...so blah...Could the man not just say, "Good heavens, I almost cried when I heard a soldier had shot other soldiers--these people are my responsibility, I am commander in chief--if there is a link to organized terrorism, I will find it. I have ordered an investigation. The Army is also looking at its internal procedures--we cannot allow anything like this to happen again. Ever." But no--we are sober now, justice will be meted, zzzz.
wulllll........
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:34 ET by Patriot IImaybe the NYT should "cram" their gifted orators LOL
Star, that was exactly my
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 16:14 ET by motherbeltStar, that was exactly my thought when I saw a bit of his Ft. Hood speech on the news.
Words aside, it looked and sounded just like every other speech he has given.
MB
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 16:16 ET by MrShyThe man is soulless.
mb... I couldn't take it,
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 16:19 ET by bigtimermb...
I couldn't take it, heard some of it after Rush was over, TOTUS started about then...when I heard/saw the same old side to side head movement, the same cold words in monotone...I muted it, went about my business and back to radio.
I've never seen anyone so vacant.
Others are as well...thank God!
'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart
Sorry, ISA
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 16:04 ET by boomerconSorry, ISA, but those ears are the real deal! No exaggeration required.
I'm surprised the founding
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:10 ET by goldboughI'm surprised the founding fathers didn't include among the requirements to be president, "gifted orator." It seems like such an important aspect since everything is honky-dory with Obama orating such great speeches.
Honestly,
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:22 ET by DEVILDOCMOMI have a bridge I want to sell this idiot...since he is trying to sell this malarkey. I could use the extra money since our family, as so many are, is struggling right now.
I could sell him a bridge in his area or any area he wishes...
Gifted?
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:24 ET by NoMoreClintonsIt's apparent that this guy is not smart enough to give a speech without a teleprompter. He makes a great actor though.
It's just a matter of
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:30 ET by HockeyKidIt's just a matter of understanding the language. "Gifted orator" is just someone who receives gifts in exchange for their oral services.
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me
Greatest Orator??? Sheer
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:32 ET by celatorGreatest Orator???
Sheer nonsense.
Great orators create great orations. People remember the words, phrases, ideas of a great orator for generations. Think Churchill, Lincoln, Reagan, even FDR on occasion, the masterful orations in any of Shakespeare's plays.
Nobody remembers what Obama says five minutes after he speaks. The only thing coming out of his mouth is robotic blather. There is no heart in any speech he ever made.
The NYT continues its shameless hagiography of the Empty One.
No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.
Everything is
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:38 ET by Jack BauerEverything is "extraordinary" to Obama.
That and "As I've have always said..."
He's always saying that a great deal...
This guy is to inspiraring oration what Groucho Marx was to ballet.
Jack...Groucho reference is
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:43 ET by celatorJack...Groucho reference is perfect! The image of Groucho in a tutu will haunt me all day.
No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.
LMAO, Jack
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:37 ET by UpNorthand it's telling that his most remembered phrase starts out about him, "As I've always said".
cel... The Empty One
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:03 ET by bigtimercel...
The Empty One indeed!
Shallow, cold, vacant, massive misplaced ego.
'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart
BT. For sure. I drives me
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:09 ET by celatorBT. For sure. I drives me (and everybody else here, I know) completely nuts when I read the MSM worship of this guy.
No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.
"Robotic blather"
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 17:53 ET by iveseenitallRight on, Celator. Great description!
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Reading, not Orating
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:36 ET by slickwillie2001On The West Wing, Martin Sheen delivered some great speeches too, but that doesn't make him Presidential material.
Libs love someone who can
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:39 ET by mattmLibs love someone who can sling the BS...
As far as "gifted orators" go, I hope they're not including President Teleprompter.
Gifted?
Obama, a gifted
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:40 ET by Six String SpiffObama, a gifted orator?
Take away his teleprompter and you're snot sure if he's talking about foreign policy, or super sizing his order.
Islamic Religious Services Will Be Held at the Firing Range At 0800 Daily.
Like Pelosi? Like
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:50 ET by buddycLike Pelosi?
Like Hillary?
Like Harry Reid?
Like Joe Biden?
Like the Governor of NY?
Like the former Governor of NJ?
Like the Governor of Penn?
Like the Governor of Michigan?
Like the Governor of Ohio?
Like the Governorof Maryland?
Like the Governor of Mass?
Where are these gifted speakers?
ever notice when obummer is reading
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:56 ET by larry on LIfrom his teleprompter and his 28yr old speech writer has included a historical mistake , obummer is not capable of picking it up and correcting it in mid stride.we can thank that ignorant moment to our teachers unions.it's easy to talk the talk when it's presented for you ,however when it comes to filling the breach during one of those moments our great orator falls flat on his face.
Talk is cheap, but highly effective
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:08 ET by TheCynicI agree with the Times, actually. Democrats have the market cornered on good speeches and speech writers. Even on the forums, liberals have taken public manipulation to new artisitic heights. The techniques they use are facinating and effective, but it's like some of those pictures of Jesus in the meat loaf. At first you can't see it but once you've seen it, you can't STOP seeing it.
I certainly think that Republicans and conservatives in general need to get on the ball, not to duplicate these techniques, but to understand them.
The important thing is to keep your cool and don't let the liberal change the subject on you (a popular tactic is the "ad hominem", where instead of talking about the subject, you will end up having to verbally defend your right and ability to talk about the subject -- you have to learn how to avoid these types of derailings).
Stick to the facts. Stick to the topic. Know your stuff.
This is why I really love Bill O'Reilly, by the way. I don't like his talk show format but get him out of that format and he's awesome. He knows his stuff. Watching him talk with Letterman is a beautiful thing because he really understands the game and knows how to keep on his central point, not get sidetracked and deliver effective, knowledable counters off the cuff. He is The Man when it comes to this.
More conservatives need to aspire to that level of dialogue. 50% of it is having the knowledge to know what you're talking about and have the facts on your side, the other 50% is avoiding liberal traps meant to derail any conversation that isn't going their way.
Of course, just as the Times is filled with gifted "writers"...
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:09 ET by jazbothat fewer and fewer are reading.
"Democrats; Breeding voters like farm animals since 1962"
Dog chasing a car
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:20 ET by Jeff in Miami BeachIf Obama did fire up the young in Iran to take to the streets, he sure ignored their efforts until the very end (of their life and/or the life of the uprising). Sort of like a dog chasing a car. He got them fire up and would even verbally support them. Now they are chanting Obama (which means something like He who Arrived) or will he not arrive? Those young people in Iran think that our president may say or do something to help their situation. I feel so sorry for those poor fools, Obama cannot even call the shooter at Fort Hood a Terrorist much less help them. The last time we had a weak POTUS we suffered in Iran. I guess it is only fair to let them suffer. I did think we were beyond this kind of childishness. If we are going to help them say so or at least give some F-22’s to Israel now so they can help all of us.
If you think medical care is expensive now wait until it is free!
X
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:21 ET by serfer62I admit his voice has great tone...and its downhill from there.
That whistle, it really is bothersome. The way he ends his sentences is really erksome. But then I can't judge his speeches as within minutes, make that secounds I turn to anything else...
Can't remember who
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:52 ET by StarAZSomeone--trying to be uptown--said the other day that he was a Caesar in the oratory dept--I think they meant Cicero. Not even close.
A Caesar salad,
Thu, 11/12/2009 - 09:40 ET by HockeyKidA Caesar salad, maybe...
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me
Nothing is so unbelievable that oratory cannot make it acceptabl
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 15:59 ET by Dim BulbHas Mr. Obama lost his oratorical touch? Is the magic finally beginning
to fade? Does the White House rely too heavily on his skills on the
stump to advance his priorities?
Perhaps his priorities are the reason for his fading magic; reality has set in: "It is but a poor eloquence which only shows that the orator can talk"~Joshua Reynolds.
Even the most gifted of tongues can push a pile of bullsh*t only so far. Obama has attempted that feat and, as ironic as it sounds, it is his listeners who are beginning to get a bad taste in their mouths. Across America people are beginning to see how unpalatable it all is, and they are beginning to object to this modern day Esau attempting to sell our birth-right for a mess of pottage, excepting of course that pseudo-intellectual enclave known as the New York Times.
Anyway, oratory can be a bane to a nation's political, moral and intellectual life:
"Nothing is so unbelievable that oratory cannot make it acceptable"~Cicero
"Oratory, n. A conspiracy between speech and action to cheat the understanding. A tyranny tempered by stenography"~Ambrose Bierce.
"The object of oratory alone is not truth, but persuasion"~Macaulay, Essays on Athenian Orators.
There is nothing in the world like a persuasive speech to fuddle the mental apparatus and upset the convictions and debauch the emotions of an audience not practiced in the tricks and delusions of oratory"~Mark Twain.
"We fear that the glittering generalities of the speaker have left an impression more delightful than permanent"~Franklin J. Dickman.
Concerning this last quote we can only hope that it is so.
LOTUS may give a good
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 16:01 ET by Scuba DudeLOTUS may give a good speech but that is it. He is still the dumbest and most ignorant piece of fecal matter to hold the office of President of the United States ever.
The Obama Administration: THE most fiscally irresponsible Administration EVER
Words don't mean anything
Sat, 01/16/2010 - 02:21 ET by BettendorWords don't mean anything unless you back them up with action. Churchill was great because he spoke well and did what he had to to help Britain win World War II. Same with Roosevelt, and same with other great leaders throughout history.
"You just don't get it." - Pa Grape, "Veggietales"
Great Orator?
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 18:52 ET by iveseenitallAmong other things, I've spent forty years reading, writing, and criticizing speeches. IMHO, Obama is far from being a gifted orator. His biggest problem is that, most of the time, he truly doesn't believe what he is saying--and it shows. Moreover, he can't think on his feet, he can't adjust or vary from the script with ease. He's stilted.
Never,Never trust a "liberal"
Um, uh, ah, er, Ladies and Gentlemen......
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 19:20 ET by UnsaneIf, uh, I, ah, used ums and uhs, uh, as often as...theeeee...greatest...orator...theeeee...country has.....ever known, I, um, would have been laughed out of several aspects of my life by now. I, um, cannot...ah, say that....His....Majesty The Shahinshah is...a great speaker......or, um, a "great orator"...as the New York Times insists, uh, that He is.
"CONSUMED DEMOCRACY RETURNS A SOCIALIST REGIME" - Slayer, "Fictional Reality", from Divine Intervention (1994)
Barney Frank wins Tweetie Bird Orator award...
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 20:58 ET by Patrick MichaelGive me a break. Obama's speech inspired the protest's in Iran? Too bad the Greatest Orator Ever could not think of any words to say when the protests were on-going to support the demonstrators or at least stay the governments harsh response. His speech in Copenhagen was marvelous wasn't it? Too bad it didn't sway anyone. His campaign speeches for the govenor of New Jersey were masterpieces, they moved the polls an entire...oh, wait a moment, they did not actually move the polls at all.
Stay Free!!!
Well, they were close. The
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 22:30 ET by marvlWell, they were close. The correct term is "gifted bullshitters."
Is some
Wed, 11/11/2009 - 23:17 ET by oldmanateeof that "gifted orator" stuff they are talking about from that speech he plagerized from his pal during the campaign?
(Sorry I can't recall names, but I am sure some of you remember that little episode...)