NYT: U.S. Making Life Miserable for Illegals -- and Their Families in Mexico

Photo of Clay Waters.
By Clay Waters | May 1, 2008 - 14:45 ET

Once again, the New York Times is expecting American taxpayers to care not only about the plight of illegal immigrants, but on the hardship imposed on their families back in Latin America because of the fitful U.S. crackdown on illegal immigration.

A front-page story on Thursday by Julia Preston blared "Fewer Latino Immigrants Send Money Home."

How did the paper find out? From a poll -- a poll from a Hillary Clinton strategist on Latino issues -- a fact Preston doesn't find fit to mention.

More than three million Latin American immigrants in the United States, responding to the economic downturn and new uncertainties about their future, have stopped sending money home to their families in the last two years, according to a survey released on Wednesday by the Inter-American Development Bank in Washington.

Only 50 percent of some 18.9 million Latino immigrants in this country now send money regularly to relatives in their home countries, compared with 73 percent two years ago, the survey found.

The drop in the number of people sending remittances, as the money transfers are known, is a sign of pressures on Latino immigrants as a result of the slump in the low-wage job market and of the Bush administration's crackdown on illegal immigration, the survey shows. Of the immigrants interviewed, 47 percent said they did not have legal status. The others were American citizens and legal immigrants.

...

Latino immigrants said they stopped sending money to their families because life is becoming more difficult for them here. Of those interviewed, 81 percent said it was harder to find a good-paying job. Almost 40 percent said they were earning less this year. The largest group of immigrants in the survey, 18 percent, worked in construction, which has been especially hard hit in the slowdown.

A large majority of the Latino immigrants in the survey -- whether or not they were illegal -- said they experienced increasing hostility as a result of federal and state efforts to curb illegal immigration and punish employers who hire unauthorized immigrant workers. In the survey, 61 percent of Latinos who were American citizens and 66 percent of those who were legal immigrants said that discrimination had become a major problem for them.

As a result of the difficulties, the numbers of immigrants who said they were considering going back to live in their home countries increased notably. Among immigrants who have been here less than five years, 49 percent said they were thinking of returning home, while only 41 percent said they planned to remain in the United States. Over all, just under one-third of the immigrants said they were thinking of leaving this country.

One of the poll's leading questions, highlighted in a Times graphic:

The anti-immigrant sentiment in the United States is making it more difficult to send money to my family.

Huh? And here's a familiar face:

But Latino immigrant workers who participated in focus groups as part of the survey said they were not ready to leave the United States quite yet, said Sergio Bendixen, the Miami-based pollster who conducted the survey. Instead of going home, the immigrants said they were taking jobs at lower wages or sometimes working two jobs to try to maintain their income, he said.

"These are resourceful people who will do whatever job is available," Mr. Bendixen said. "The major dynamic that is holding them back from sending money is fear. They don't know whether they won't be able to get a job anymore."

What Preston doesn't mention; Bendixen is a Democrat pollster on Hispanic issues for the Hillary Clinton campaign. Preston has even used him before, back in an August 2007 story on the very same kind of poll, also without noting his Democratic affiliation.

And then there's this irony that sabotages the story: turns out that the total remittances to Latin America have actually increased since 2006, from $45.4 billion to $45.9 billion, because those who are still sending money home are doing it more frequently and in bigger chunks.

—Clay Waters is the director of Times Watch, an MRC project tracking the New York Times.

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The only time the word

The only time the word "illegal" appears in this article is in reference to "the Bush administration's crackdown on illegal immigration."

Excuse me...gotta go...

<sound of duct tape being ripped off roll> 

Clay Waters - Nice Catch!

Great eyes, Clay, to catch the NYTimes Poll-Clinton relationship.

Even though I read everything from the NYT with a critical eye, that angle did not occur to me.

Very good work.

Over all, just under

Over all, just under one-third of the immigrants said they were thinking of leaving this country.

Good.

Now all we have to do is make the remaining two-thirds miserable enough to pack up and leave, too. :-)

What the American people are looking for is somebody who can solve their problems. - Barack Obama, April 27, 2008

The U.S. is making life

The U.S. is making life miserable for illegals...and their families in Mexico...

Good!

Fewer latinos send $$$ home...

Boo-hoo!

Go home, wait in line and come here legally.

Simple as that.

I am sick and tired of the burden they are putting on us tax-payers here in so many areas of our economy and health system...enough already.

Cry me a river somewhere else...out of our country.

I'm sick of both parties playing the game they think we are too dumb to see....while it is killing our country at our expense. 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Amen

Yep, "Cry me a river" indeed, and then lets fill it with crocodiles so's that they can't swim back in.

Well, if they're NOT

sending their $$ back to Mexico, maybe they will spend them in the US and help us out with our economical issues ;-)

If these people were not working and sending all that money back to their home countries, maybe our economy wouldn't be in such bad shape after all!!

Agree - we do NOT need the burdens they bring to the American citizens!!!!!!

Saving up

Must be saving for the upcoming McCain Citizenship sale.

HOPE to CHANGE the subject...

Clay. And migrant workers are sending less $ money home also

Back on April 20, the LA Times printed a piece by Ken Ellingwood, Migrants send less money back to Mexico. The bad news is that, "The estimated $24 billion sent to Mexico last year was barely higher than in 2006.."

Unfortunatley for the story, the grapics folks at the LA times attached a chart (not in the web edition) to the shrill piece, which clearly indicated that the that since 1997, the amount of money being sent to Mexico from illegal immigrants here has skyrocketed by 480% - from $5 billion to $24 billion - in only 9 years time.

ENACT THE FEDERAL SAVE ACT (H.R.4088) Before it's to LATE!

We desperately need the Federal SAVE ACT (H.R.4088) before the new president commits him/her to a cataclysmic AMNESTY. More will come afterwards until we are flooded. The liberal news is suppressing the truth about the Federal SAVE ACT (H.R.4088) Read and judge for yourself. Then go after tainted politicians.Democrats are even trying to gut the BORDER FENCE.

I hope they are not counting the 12 to 30 million illegal aliens, because they will be going home. The only other option that people are talking about, is CIVIL WAR? We desperately need the Federal SAVE ACT (H.R.4088) before this serious issue turns into violence.

Demand your sleazy Democrats co-author the Federal SAVE ACT (H.R.4088) because the new president he/she will commit to a massive AMNESTY.

The anti-immigrant

The anti-immigrant sentiment in the United States is making it more difficult to send money to my family.

Funny, my brother-in-law, who is British, moved here with my sister and their two kids (who have American citizenship) and my brother-in-law just received his green card after a few months of applying for it.  He is an immigrant into this country and the key word is...LEGAL...

No one made it hard for him to legally reside here because he did it LEGALLY.  The only anti-immigrant sentiment that Americans have is an anti illegal immigration sentiment.

Darth Dutch

PS - It should also be noted that the pro-illegal alien groups constantly give out an anti-American sentiment in their speeches and their expectations - anyone remember the May Day marches around the country in 2006 when they were tearing down American flags and putting up Mexican flags and flags from other countries.  Now I wonder why our pansy media won't report those things with such tear-jerking, hand-wringing sentiment as this story?

DD

I know you are happy to have your sister and her family all here LEGALLY!  Agree with you - I have absolutely nothing against anyone coming to our country LEGALLY!  It's that word "ILLEGAL" that is very troubling.

As for your PS - Five stars *****  But we must not hold our breath waiting for the msm to do any such reporting!

of course, the government's

of course, the government's been capitalizing on this for a while now...