GMA Hypes Food Scare with Latest Doom-and-Gloom CSPI Study

  • Bookmark and Share

If you thought figuring out what to eat was difficult before, the Center for Science in the Public Interest has released a new study called "The Ten Riskiest Foods," which slams four of the five food groups.

On Oct. 6 "Good Morning America's" Sharyn Alfonsi devoted an entire segment to the doom-and-gloom study. But of course she conveniently forgot to mention that CSPI is a radical left-wing kill-joy consumer group that has attacked everything from remote controls to washing machines to Chinese food to casual dining.

The study was discussed in relation to a recent New York Times headline about the 22-year-old girl Stephanie Smith who was paralyzed apparently from E. coli in a frozen hamburger.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The study, Alfonsi said, "puts the spotlight on foods responsible for the most food-borne illnesses over the last twenty years." The "foods" condemned are as broad as "berries," "leafy greens," and "sprouts." These foods, Alfonsi warned, are "responsible for illnesses ranging from an upset stomach, to death, to disability."

The segment ended with a video of Smith in a wheelchair and Alfonsi voicing over, "Smith says she's proof that a single meal - a single ingredient - can change your life."

GMA's Diane Sawyer kept the food scare going, chiming  in, "And again [Smith] seems to have no prior health problems. This can just strike and you don't know who's going to get the most severe reaction." 

The GMA segment failed to mention that careless consumers, not just food industries, can often be the culprits of food-borne illnesses. It also didn't discuss the complaints about the validity of CSPI studies nor did it allow the accused food industries to defend themselves.

CNN, on the other hand, reported on the story, and did two out of the three things that GMA ignored. CNN's Elizabeth Cohen said:

We have reached out to every - all of these ten industries and asked them for some responses. And so here are two of them ... The National Fishery folks, who represent the people who put fish on our plates, says, "CSPI fails to properly highlight the fact that it is not talking about canned tuna. Consumers should take this report with a grain of salt ... " And also we got a response for the Produce Marketing Association, those are the folks who make leafy greens: "It is never in the consumers best interest to scare them away from the very foods that we should all be eating more of ... "

And I think it's important to point out that they - these food folks pointed out that there are different ways to crunch numbers. And so you can look at - you can have just one outbreak and have lots of illnesses. And that's different than having lots of illnesses and many outbreaks. And so I think that's important to keep that in mind.

Cohen finished off the segment by adding, "Some of these cases of food-borne illnesses were preventable. People could have prevented them in their own kitchen, not all, but some of them."

Ironically, 5 of the 10 "risky foods" CSPI booed were also on the organization's list of "10 Super Foods for Better Health."


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Good Food/Bad Food

I decided a long time ago to eat whatever I want to because it's all just going to turn into $hit anyway...   ;)

 

"Reason and persuasion are the only practical instruments against error.  To make way for these, free inquiry must be indulged" - Thomas Jefferson

Whew!

I am glad to hear! I thought I was the only one!

You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?

I've never eaten margarine

I've never eaten margarine since they found out that it too had that nasty unhealthy chloresterol. I'm with you, I eat what tastes good regardless, of the health implications.

BTW these food scares are more than a little overplayed.

Facts are like kryptonite to the liberal.

Apologies to 'Moses'

"You'll have to pry this cheeseburger from my cold dead hands".

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

CSPI is crazy

They've been doing their scare-mongering for years. I remember many years ago when they were doing press releases every month, and the lib media were just dutifully parroting the releases as "news." One month, it was, 'Pizza is bad for you.' Next month, it was sub sandwiches. Then burgers. Etc.

I believe that Steven Milloy over at junkscience.com has some articles on CSPI. *checks Google* OK, yeah. Check out this search:

Google Search

Funny anecdote somewhere in one of those articles: The head honcho of CSPI decided that coffee was bad and took the coffee maker out of their office. After a minor worker revolt, he replaced the machine. :)

I feel a Linda Richmond ("Coffee Talk"-- SNL sketch character played by Mike Meyers) coming on: "I'm getting a little verklempt. OK, talk amongst yourselves. I'll give you a topic: The Center for Science in the Public Interest is neither a Center, nor Science, nor in the Public Interest. Discuss."

 

 I prefer to go with Jack

 I prefer to go with Jack LaLanne's advice: If god made it, it's good for you, if he didn't, don't eat it.  He seems to be on to something. 

xoxo - Ted

I prefer to go with Jack

I prefer to go with Jack LaLanne's advice: If god made it, it's good
for you, if he didn't, don't eat it.  He seems to be on to something.
 

So go eat some cyanide dude, according to your philosophy it should be good for you after all God made it.

Know how to keep a Troll in suspense?  Ill tell ya in the morning.

Is cyanide a food?  Or was

Is cyanide a food?  Or was that your pathetic attempt at humor? 

xoxo - Ted

No it waS YOUR STUPID

No it waS YOUR STUPID STATEMENT If god made it, it's good
for you, if he didn't, don't eat it.  So God made cyanide.

Know how to keep a Troll in suspense?  Ill tell ya in the morning.

Actually it was  Jack

Actually it was  Jack LaLanne's stupid statement.

xoxo - Ted

You still come here?

You still come here?

Like an atom bomb,

Like an atom bomb, stinky. 

xoxo - Ted

Ok one more reply to the

Ok one more reply to the eternally banal Teddy.  You made it yours by posting it here.

Know how to keep a Troll in suspense?  Ill tell ya in the morning.

And like a child, you always

And like a child, you always have to get the last word in.  Carry on. 

xoxo - Ted

Ted, Well, technically,

Ted,

Well, technically, didn't God make everything?

So everything must be good for you.

This is where my comments

This is where my comments are leading?  Yeah, god made the cow, but not the Big Mac.  The beef from a cow contains vitamins and nutrients necessary for our diets, but when you take that beef, grind it up with who knows what, freeze it, ship it, unfreeze it, throw it on a frying grill with the day's worth of grease, slather it with secret sauce - well it's no longer god's creation, and it's no longer good for you.

But did I really have to explain that to you?

xoxo - Ted

Ted, I was just being

Ted,

I was just being facetious.

Did I really have to explain that to you?

Today I'm walking on

Today I'm walking on eggshells around here.  So yes, every intention needs to be explained.  Sorry. 

xoxo - Ted

http://www.youtube.c...  

Are you stalking me now?

Are you stalking me now?  Are you that bored? 

xoxo - Ted

:^)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-3lKbMBab18

The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” -- Chief Justice John Roberts 

Now that's a good link.

Now that's a good link.  Best comedy of the 60s.  No, Butch and Sundance.  Was that a comedy? 

xoxo - Ted

but it cuts short

of the line we all know anyway

"do you want me to stalk you?"

The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” -- Chief Justice John Roberts 

You said it - the line we

You said it - the line we all know anyway. 

xoxo - Ted

I prefer to leave the

I prefer to leave the decision for what one can and cannot consume to the individual consumer...and to tell the self-righteous Gladys Kravitzes of the world (hint, hint) to mind their own business.

"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered."  -George Best

I don't know, fitz.  Can we

I don't know, fitz.  Can we eat eggs?  Some days they're gonna kill you, some days they're the best...wait, the incredible, edible egg. 

xoxo - Ted

Exactly.  When you have

Exactly.  When you have organizations like CSPI manufacturing crises and media outlets promoting this hysteria to generate ratings, you get a lot of people who don't know any better letting junk science rule and ruin their lives.  The same method that gets people in a panic over SARS, H1N1 and "Global Warming", gets people to hyperventilate over the crap produced by Michael Jacobson and his band of nanny state parasites...all intended to soften the populace to ever more intrusive (yet ineffective) government regulation.

"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered."  -George Best

I'm going to call it what

I'm going to call it what it is.  When an irresponsible, self-important, freedom hating organization like the Center for "Science" in "The Public Interest" drops its propaganda to be uncritically parroted by broadcast media in an attempt to damage legitimate businesses through taxation and regulation, that's ECONOMIC TERRORISM.  Michael Jacobson is a terrorist.

"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered."  -George Best

Well, guess I will stick

Well, guess I will stick with Mounds bars, M&M's and Skittles. Maybe a Snickers now and then. Oh! and Jelly Beans!

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Nothing new here

Back in my youth in the early 70's one of my first jobs was working in a hospital in the X-Ray Dept. The Radioligist was Dr. Bean, a very smart man. He gave me some advice about nutrition.

 1. Listen to your own body. When you get real cravings you are probably short of something that is contained within that food. The trick is telling the difference between a real craving and a want like I want some ice-cream.

2. Never ever listen to the latest nutrition advice coming from experts as they really do not know what they are talking about. There are too many micro nutrients found in all kinds of foods that we need and can get no other way. This is still poorly understood.

I have followed that advice for all these many years and no ill effects so far. I am 58 years old so I still have some way to go. No ulcers, no heart conditions, etc... Any thing that restricts the numbers or types of food available will have a direct negative impact on public health as Nutrition is still poorly understood. What is understood is this, don't eat enough and you die, eat too much and you die, just a little later.

 

I'm craving a beer, I better

I'm craving a beer, I better go get one.  :)

Ditto

Gonna get me another one.

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

Interesting ... says hydro

Interesting ... says hydro as he downs a Wendy's Baconator.

mmmm bacon.

____________________________________________ 
The Emperor, he has no clothes

Good burger, tried a

Good burger, tried a Wahtabuger bacon burger and it wasnt as good.  I remember what a real whataburger tasted like and teh Baconator comes close.  Whatburger sold out aand they taste like crap compared to the mouth watering greasy burgers they used to be, teh type taht teh grease soaks the buns.  MMMM GOOOOD.

Know how to keep a Troll in suspense?  Ill tell ya in the morning.

Dan, I remember when I

Dan,

I remember when I was a kid, Wendy's burgers literally dripped grease while you were eating them - man do I miss those.

I remember working at

I remember working at McDonald's as a teenager and my shoes would be covered in grease.  So would the hem of my pants.

Didn't eat there much after that.  

riskiest *foods*?

 Any food handled improperly can make you ill or even kill you.  The people sounding alarms about the FOOD itself are idiots.

read a pamphlet on safe food handling instead.

____________________________________________ 
The Emperor, he has no clothes

*sigh* really?

I just got one thing to say to idiots like these:

Stay the hell out of my grocery store, stay the hell out of my kitchen and stay the hell out of my life!

Morons.  Absolute utter morons.  And don't believe for a second they are well-meaning.

-Jon

Don't dismiss this out of

Don't dismiss this out of hand just because it's utterly stupid.  If we get significant government involvement in healthcare, then these sorts of idiotic proclamations will start to carry more weight and intrude upon our lives. 

G. May, you are exactly correct.

All they will have to do is punch up your purchasing history and see what you have been buying with your debit/credit cards at your local Publix, and what you order at BK, Mickey D's, etc..

Not to mention what sort of adult bevs you have been purchasing.

-Dave

I wonder if there is a correlation between food-borne illness'..

...and the number of illegal aliens in this country handling those foods?

I am guessing there is, and I am further guessing Hell is going to be frozen solid before we ever hear about it, too.

-Dave

Shades of The Jungle...the

Shades of The Jungle...the old Communist litany has never gone away.

Good things we don't still have orphanages (even though I think we should) or else we'd be treated ad nauseum with Oliver Twist/gruel histrionics.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 86% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

A man is stranded on a deserted island.

A cooler filled with 200 Big Mac's floats up on shore. Will eating them kill him or prolong his life? 

 

Hi. My name is John Q. Public, but some just call me racist.

Karma,

Not sure, as it depends on how old the burgers are, but if Lara Logan washes up with those same Big Mac's, I am guessing his chances of being sane upon rescue would be rather high.

Unless he knocks her unconscious and hides from the rescuers, as I would do.  :-^)

-Dave

Aged beef.

Tasty.

I've eaten week-old Arby's out of a glove compartment in summer heat with absolutely no ill eff..

 

 

Hi. My name is John Q. Public, but some just call me racist.

Karma, The food preservatives,contained therein, protected you

However the Arby's left your body, completely undigested, only it's shape was changed..

If bacteria is not interested in, a week old glove box special, why would your body be any different?

On the other hand...

I got Salmonella poisoning once. I know what this bug smells like, so I never had it again.

Using ones nose will help to avoid buggy foods.

If the arby's smells good, then it is!

Looks like you have a nose for such things...

State controlled health care is Tort Reform.

Why, yes.

Yes I do. 

 

Hi. My name is John Q. Public, but some just call me racist.

A Boy and His Dog? First

A Boy and His Dog? First time I saw this was in the Midnight Movies.

Know how to keep a Troll in suspense?  Ill tell ya in the morning.

Don't Look At Me, I Just Don't Like Eating Cow A$$hole...

Pardon me for being so blunt, but as much as I don't particularly care for eating rabbit food, I also don't like eating cow ass-hole. That's essentially what Angus beef is anyway: Cow Ass-hole. Gives a whole new meaning to the term cow pie, doesn't it?

If you don't mind, I'll be eating my Burger King chicken tenders right now. At least I'm sure that I won't be getting any chicken-sh*t out of it.

-"I knew it, I'm surrounded by assholes... Keep firing, assholes!"

-Dark Helmet, from Spaceballs 

The most dangerous food is meat

I think the most dangerous food is meat as it destroys humanity and lead to wars and destroys all ultimately.

Obesity & Magic Pill :

I personally recognize that wheat is a far better diet than meat on the ground it normally exits body with ease and rapidity, and we are well aware that our heath depends upon smooth metabolism and blood stream associated with the immune system and how important our daily workout is, as well.

I still think the critical conditions mostly come from breach of our immune system, and the food that stays long in the body is more likely to become a source where germs, bacterias, viruses and the like multiply.
Sounds outlandish, but wheat might be a principal "clean and healthy" food that has led western society to the most decent culture of all.

Disadvantages of meat consumption :

1. The food that stays long in the body looks more likely to become a source where germs, bacterias and the like multiply, which even gives birth to critical conditions involving prostate cancer.

2. The consumption of meat proved lethal as earlier this year, the expansive, long-term release concluded about a third of more than 500,000 Americans aged 50-70 with this behavior tends to wind up with premature fatality caused by cancer, hypertension and more.

3. The in-take of pork raises risks of catching swine flue and its mutation, costing around the initially estimated $2trillion dollars word-wide and endangering recovery,

(( Genes included in the new swine flu have been circulating undetected in pigs for at least a decade, according to researchers who have sequenced the genomes of more than 50 samples of the virus. The findings suggest that in the future, pig populations will need to be monitored more closely for emerging influenza viruses, reported a team led by Rebecca Garten of the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in a report released by the journal Science.))

Still, media downplay this fact out of small thinking to protect meat industry.

4. All but media influenced by meat industry blame calorie for overweight or obesity rather than fat, I still think Fat equals Fat by definition and common sense.

5. Hot dogs are often associated with food-borne illness. Though other food items carry listeria , FDA (Food and Drug Administration) studies have shown a high level of the harmful bacteria on hot dogs, processed meat and ready-to-eat meat products. And consuming hot dogs and other processed meats increases the risk of cancer

The class-action consumer fraud lawsuit underway in New Jersey is based on a report from the American Institute for Cancer Research.

Its findings included this fact: Consuming one 50-gram serving of processed meat (about the amount in one hot dog) every day increases the risk of colorectal cancer, on average, by 21 percent.

Nitrites, used to keep hot dogs fresh, are the main culprit, according to the suit.

While nitrites are commonly found in many green vegetables, especially spinach, celery and green lettuce, the consumption of vegetables appears to be effective in reducing the risk of cancer. Because these vegetables also contain Vitamin C and D, which serve to inhibit the formation of carcinogenic compounds, they actually reduce your cancer risk.

6. Two thirds of Americans are overweight or obese, which branch into so many different kinds of diseases, excess body fat increases risk for numerous cancers, costing up to $147 billion a year.

7. America needs to put focus on a sustainable energy industry to become a lead exporter, in place of a fast food business where the overall loss outstrips gain more than known, from my stance.

Provided the average temperature is getting higher, accordingly all forms of germs, bacterias, viruses, and influenza etc are more likely to multiply.

Some skeptics say the warning against hazards of climate change is overstated, but judging from more frequent and widespread outbreaks of e. coli, salmonella, and bird, swine flu cases endangering human lives and economic recovery seriously, some prompt measures need to be taken, I guess.

Also, Breathing toxic chemicals in the outdoor air exposes all Americans to a lifetime cancer risk at least 10 times greater than the level considered acceptable under federal law, shows new data released by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Thank You !

You got a source for all

You got a source for all that, chicken little?

You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?

Dvd

That post made me hungry!  I'm going to go to Wendys and get their Baconator for lunch today.

 

"Reason and persuasion are the only practical instruments against error.  To make way for these, free inquiry must be indulged" - Thomas Jefferson

C'mon man!

I have been to the gym every day this week in preparation for a Thanksgiving 5k charity run (thank goodness its an exhibition, because my fat butt can't run very fast), and you want to tempt me with this?

You trying to say Jesus Christ can't hit a curveball?

You are what you eat.

You should at least spit out the hook, line and sinker that you also ingested. 

 

Hi. My name is John Q. Public, but some just call me racist.

wow

that has got to be the most factually innacurate post I've seen here.  I don't even know where to start.

____________________________________________ 
The Emperor, he has no clothes

Tell you what: if this is

Tell you what: if this is your justification for why you behave a certain way, go with God.  The moment people like you think it's appropriate to use this crap in an attempt to hamper our abilities to eat, drink, smoke, drive or use whatever we want to...that's when you're out of line and will meet with the kind of rejection and ridicule you deserve.

"I spent a lot of money on booze, birds and fast cars. The rest I just squandered."  -George Best

In other words, live in the

In other words, live in the woods at least 100 miles from humanity, live off the land, but only fruits and vegetables, and just yank those meat tearing teeth right outta your mouth, because you won't need them anymore.  Stupid god, fooling us with these damn teeth. 

xoxo - Ted

Ted

When my uber-liberal brother starts going on and on about evil consuming man vs. nature stuff, I use the same counter argument.

*Mr. Shy realizes he and Ted are on the same side on this one.*  [head swivels]

 

It's cool, Shy.  Sometimes

It's cool, Shy.  Sometimes I can be extremely reasonable and surprise some of you. 

xoxo - Ted

Ted

You're a good sport, Ted. And for a liberal, you don't take any of this too personally -- yes, you do get whiny and pouty at times, but it IS you against all of us, so that's understandable.

 

We libs are whiny by nature.

We libs are whiny by nature.  After all, they've got all the power in Washington, and yet still can't accomplish anything - and they're still b**ching about you guys.

xoxo - Ted

Ted

Tell me about it. The latest being Reid's desperate move. As a lib, you WILL admit that HC reform of the liberal variety is simply not what a majority in this country wants, as having control of both houses still doesn't give them the votes they need (hence, not enough constituents buying it.) Until Dems have that majority (and we hope they never will) they need to move on. Dot org.

 

It's a surprising change,

It's a surprising change, actually, seeing our congress more interested in representing the voters best interests rather than their corporate donors and big name leaders.  Of course, every one of them has their own health care reform plan, and to give in to another's, everyone else loses credit.  And after all, this is really about who gets to take credit for the reform.  So while they fight, their ability to pass a bill will be lost for another few administrations. 

xoxo - Ted

voter's best interests?

take shelter.  take shelter now :)

____________________________________________ 
The Emperor, he has no clothes

HSR, Just cook it... steam it... fry it....

 
Humans are the only critters on this earth that COOKS it's own food...

Cooking kills germs... all of them....

Try it sometime , and for heaven sakes open the garage door when warming up your car...

 

State controlled health care is Tort Reform.

Half a steer

All this now, after I just put half a steer in my freezer?! Man, I can taste those T-bones now! With french fries and a little wheat bread, with a big slab of butter...

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Sorry, no butter.  It clogs

Sorry, no butter.  It clogs the arteries.  The wheat bread is okay, hopefully gluten-free.  I'm not sure about the fries, since you referred to them as the french variety.  If they're criss-cut fries, you're okay.

xoxo - Ted

The fries may be a

The fries may be a misnomer. In reality I like the tater logs, (mini). But, to each their own...The T-bone should be med-well...

Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!

Oh bass!  Medium-rare!

Oh bass!  Medium-rare!  Medium-RARE!

xoxo - Ted