'Early Show' Uses Woman with Rare Disease to Advocate for ObamaCare

  • Bookmark and Share

It was quite a "two-for" on CBS' "The Early Show" September 25. They got a chance to feature a young woman who'd recovered from a very rare disease, and they also got to advocate for ObamaCare.

"The Early Show's" Maggie Rodriguez talked with Krista Lesinski, who had been diagnosed with Wilson's Disease, a rare and potentially lethal condition that attacks the liver. With Lesinski was Dr. Lisa Sanders, a former producer of CBS News, covering health and medicine. Sanders is currently at the Yale University School of Medicine and a physician at the Waterbury Hospital in Connecticut. Her monthly New York Times' column "Diagnosis" was an inspiration for the hit Fox TV series "House."

Rodriguez asked Lesinski, "You were ... highlighter yellow ... why did you wait to go to the hospital?"

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

"I wasn't that yellow at the time," Krista responded. "I had first looked in the mirror and I saw my face a yellow color. And then the whites of my eyes were a little yellow. I didn't know that there was anything particularly wrong with that other than, ‘Okay, maybe I need to go to the doctor now.'"

That wasn't the answer Rodriguez was looking for, so she turned to Sanders. "Should she have gone sooner, doctor? Is this one take away from this story?"

Taking the cue, Sanders responded, "Well, I think that, uh, she told me when I first interviewed her that she might have gone earlier if she had insurance."

"Ohhh," said Rodriguez.

"But she felt like since she didn't have insurance, she wasn't sure - I mean, she certainly had no idea how sick she was," Sanders said of the otherwise healthy young woman. "Umm, and I think her impulse would have been to go to a hospital sooner, but she had financial considerations. And it's important to know that lack of insurance does kill people. I mean, there's a recent study that showed 45,000 people a year die because they don't have insurance. Fortunately, Krista wasn't one of them."

And it's important to know that Sanders' assertions - along with her agenda - are questionable.

The study she cited was carried out by the Harvard Medical School and was funded by a federal research grant. It was also released by Physicians for a National Health Program, which favors government-backed or "single-payer" health insurance. It's results have been disputed, notably by the National Center for Policy Analysis, a Washington think tank that supports a free-market approach to health care.

"The findings in this research are based on faulty methodology and the death risk is significantly overstated," NCPA President John C. Goodman said. "The subjects were interviewed only once and the study tries to link their insurance status at that time to mortality a decade later. Yet over the period, the authors have no idea whether subjects were insured or uninsured, what kind of medical care they received, or even cause of death."

Of course Dr. Sanders didn't mention any of this. She also didn't mention that last year she made a $2,300 donation to Rob Miller, a South Carolina Democrat who appears to support the public health care option and will be running against GOP Rep. Joe Wilson in 2010.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Uh, I missed the part..

...where the girl said why she didn't have insurance?

 

"The bureaucracy is growing to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy"

 

Why?

Unfortunately Krista never had the chance to explain why she doesn't have health insurance. Rodriguez and Sanders ran her over trying to convince the public -- yet again -- that we're bad people for not supporting the public health care option. No surprise there.

True

I think the irony of Krista's excellent treatment and recovery is also overlooked despite the lack of a public option. 

"The bureaucracy is growing to meet the needs of the growing bureaucracy"

 

Good point ...

... and one that was obviously overlooked by Rodriguez and Sanders.

Consumption goes Up

So Rodriquez and Saunders are providing annecdotal evidence that health care consumption will go up. If they are correct, there will be far more people going to doctors with false alarms than actual illnesses.

Anyway their heroine wasn't harmed by the delay?

....and despite not having

....and despite not having private health insurance.

Here on some words on

i find it strange that

  these kind of stories most often appear on the alphabet stations.i wonder, do they get special dispensation  to bend the facts?

First off... if the woman

First off... if the woman has been smart and watching House M.D., she would have immediately recognized the yellow coloring as a symptom of liver failure without the need to even go to a doctor! Of course... since that show is on Fox, she probably doesn't watch it.

How do you develop a reliable statistic that 45,000 people died because they didn't have health insurance? How do you prove something that didn't happen? And what are the number of people who died even though they did have health insurance and just didn't feel like sitting for four hours in a waiting room?

Am I to assume

Am I  to assume that my death is imminent if I do not immediately upgrade my current health care policy? Saying 45,000 people die each year due to a lack of health care insurance is like saying you're likely to have a car accident if you don't have a collision policy.

"Lies, damn lies, and statistics.

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

Is anyone surprised that all

Is anyone surprised that all of these television medical correspondents (Lisa Sanders at CBS, the execrable Nancy Snyderman at NBC, Tim Johnson at ABC and Sanjay Gupta at Castro News Network) are all identically like-minded leftists like everyone else at their networks?  The fact that all of them are militant, boilerplate leftists ain't no coincidence, boys and girls.

There's one syndrome these people will never be afflicted with..

Acute intelligence.

Green Eyes

This woman can destroy her liver without having to live through all these blasted hangovers and I'm supposed to feel sorry for her

Let's focus

Remember, it's more about the journey; not the destination. ;-)

"What a revoltin' development this is!"

Chester Riley

The Lie of 45,000

Here's your handy link to the debunking of the '45,000' lie if you have lost it:

Junk Science Expert Sounds Alarm on Insurance Study: http://washingtontimes.com

For example:

"They interviewed 9,000 people between 1988 and 1994 and asked, 'Do you have health insurance?' and if you die at some point in the future, they ASSUME your death was caused by the fact you didn’t have insurance during that time you were interviewed."

This doesn't even deserve to be called a 'study', it's complete horsecrap. The people that did it should lose their jobs.

Faux Statistics

Leftists just love faux statistics. I am not even sure where the number of 47 million uninsured came from.   Polling data? The stuff; is just thrown out there without references to support left wing goals.

"I think she said"

"Well, I think that, uh, she told me when I first interviewed her that she might have gone earlier if she had insurance."

But that isn't what she said.  She said she didn't think it was anything to worry about at that time.  She told you that DIRECTLY during the interview, so why do you feel the need to tell us what you think she said?

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

the truth of "no insurance"

I'm sitting at the dentists office the other day waiting for a friend to finish her procedure and a woman is going off about how state insurance "doesn't cover anything but extractions anymore" and is going off about "crazy expensive" her procedure would be. She starts talking about procedures costing thousands of dollars (the actual dr. quote was well under a thousand) and she says "If I had that kind of money it sure wouldn't be going towards teeth!".

 And that my fellow patriots, is the core and root and source of the entire "health care crisis". People who want, but don't want to pay. This is NOT the job of the federal government, just like it was NOT their job to handle the retirement of people who didn't want to save. 

 

 

WWW.GS2AC.COM. 2nd Amendment Grass Roots Action in the Bay Area, CA. We're not all "Breakfast Cereal" folks here! :)

Um, I didn't have insurance, so...

Um, I didn't have insurance, so...

I thought I'd just let myself turn colors and die.

While I feel bad for this person with the disease, if I start turning yellow, I go to the doctor. Even though I HAVE insurance, I go to my usual guy at an Urgent Care up the street. He doesn't take insurance and he is, therefore, affordable.

If I didn't have insurance and my Urgent Care doctor told me it was something serious, I'd do would millions of others do (some of whom are illegals) and go to county.

This is odd. The original

This is odd. The original story from Lisa Sanders or weblogs of the patient herself make no mention of the lack of insurance.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/06/17/magazine/17wwln-diagnosis-t.html?_r=1&pagewanted=print

http://www.wickedlocal.com/malden/news/lifestyle/x50617020/Running-against-liver-disease-Malden-woman-takes-on-Boston-Marathon-in-honor-of-friend

http://transplantcafe.ning.com/profile/KristaLesinski

http://www.liverfoundation.org/chapters/greaterny/faces%20of%20liver%20disease/

They tell of excellent care, a lucky diagnosis, and the fact that she received a liver transplant in 2 days and has fully recovered.

The NYTimes article was

The NYTimes article was actually an enjoyable read.

Thanks.

Funny (strange, that is)

Funny (strange, that is) that there is no outrage from the Libtard Left when 3000 Americans died from no disease, and on a single day.

National health good...national defense bad...baa-aaah, baaa-aaah.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 86% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.

Well, I did a Google search

Well, I did a Google search on Wilson's Disease. I doubt that the young woman was in any danger of dying from this rare genetic disorder.

The interesting fact is that the disease is due to a build up of copper in the body.

 

How is Wilson's disease diagnosed?

If Wilson's disease is suspected, it can be diagnosed by tests.

  • A blood test to measure ceruloplasmin. This is a protein
    that binds copper in the bloodstream. The level is low in nearly all
    people with Wilson's disease.
  • A urine test to measure the amount of copper in the urine. The amount is typically higher than normal.
  • An examination of the cornea by an optometrist or eye specialist
    may show the Kayser-Fleischer rings if they have developed (not present
    in all cases).
  • A biopsy (small sample) of the liver may be taken to look at under
    the microscope. This can show the excess copper in the liver and the
    extent of any cirrhosis. See separate leaflet called 'Liver Biopsy'.

 

How is Wilson's disease treated?

It is essential to treat
Wilson's disease. The earlier treatment is started, the better the
chance of preventing long-term permanent damage to the liver or brain.

  • Penicillamine is a drug used to remove copper from
    the body (it is called a chelating agent). The penicillamine causes the
    excess copper from the body to be passed out in the urine. The dose may
    be reduced to a 'maintenence dose' after about a year when the initial
    build-up of copper has been cleared.
  • Trientine is an alternative to penicillamine. It too is a chelating agent and removes copper from the body.
  • Zinc is an option in certain circumstances. Zinc works by
    blocking the gut from absorbing copper from food. Therefore it does not
    clear excess copper from the body, but prevents any further build up of
    copper. Zinc is much less likely to cause side-effects than
    penicillamine or trientine. It may be an option for people who are
    diagnosed at the very early stages of the disease and have no symptoms.
    Also, a switch to zinc may be an option for people who have been
    initially treated with penicillamine or trientine once the initial
    build up of copper has been cleared from the body.

Now unless these "drugs" are very expensive, I do think that a case has not been made on the need for insurance for the diagnosis and treatment of the condition.

 

 

surfergirl54:I have no

Surfergirl54:

I have no reason to disbelieve the woman was close to death.  The NYTimes article linked by fellow NB Cooltom gives the flavor of what a difficult case is like for physicians.  This woman had fulminant liver disease and hemolytic anemia, both caused by excessive copper in her body.  Death was impending barring proper treatment.

From my favorite meical site, EMedicine:

Mortality/Morbidity

Fulminant Wilson disease leads to rapidly progressive liver failure, encephalopathy, coagulopathy, and, eventually, death if emergent liver transplantation is not performed.


Sex

The fulminant presentation of Wilson disease is more common in females than in males (4:1).

Of note, it is possible to reach a point of no return where proper treatment is of no help.