ABC Frets: Plight of Muslim Soldiers Toughest Since Japanese-Americans in WWII

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

ABC doubled the length of its evening newscast on Friday night and World News used its second half hour to suggest an exculpatory reason behind Army psychiatrist Nidal Hasan's mass killing at Fort Hood -- as anchor Charles Gibson reasoned “treating the mentally wounded can be stressful” -- then to devote a story to the plight of Muslim soldiers: “It's not easy for anyone serving in the armed forces these days, but with America fighting Islamic enemies overseas, Muslim troops face a unique burden.” Reporter Bill Weir despaired:

The Pentagon has made a real concerted effort to create a military that is culturally sensitive and religiously tolerant, but Muslims in uniform today face a challenge not seen since Japanese-Americans fought in World War II. They taste suspicion from some fellow soldiers who question their loyalty and resentment from fellow Muslims opposed to both American wars.

Weir featured a Muslim soldier who lamented “our religion teaches better,” before Weir painted Muslim soldiers as victims of intolerance, highlighting the experience of one Muslim soldier who “began his overseas deployment on 9/11, and taunts followed him throughout his four-year enlistment.”

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Weir acknowledged that “Major Hasan's motives are still unclear,” but he, nonetheless, recalled how “back in 2003 prosecutors alleged it was repeated taunting and religious ideology that led Sergeant Hasan Akbar to kill two of his commanding officers with a grenade.”

With “Stress Factor” as the on-screen heading, Gibson had set up the previous story from Martha Raddatz:

Many troops returning from Iraq and Afghanistan bare the psychological scars of war, everything from anxiety to post-traumatic stress. The alleged Fort Hood gunman was a psychiatrist trained to help these soldiers. And while it's way too early to know why this rampage occurred, we do know that treating the mentally wounded can be stressful as well.

The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the Muslim soldier story aired during the second half hour of the Friday, November 6 World News on ABC:

CHARLES GIBSON: Muslim groups here in the United States have moved quickly to condemn the rampage at Fort Hood after learning the alleged gunman was a practicing Muslim, born in the U.S. to Palestinian parents. The Council on American-Islamic Relations said no political or religious ideology could ever justify or excuse such wanton and indiscriminate violence. Organizations representing Muslims in the U.S. military also are denouncing the attack. It's not easy for anyone serving in the armed forces these days, but with America fighting Islamic enemies overseas, Muslim troops face a unique burden. Bill Weir joins us now. Bill?

BILL WEIR: Charlie, the Pentagon has made a real concerted effort to create a military that is culturally sensitive and religiously tolerant, but Muslims in uniform today face a challenge not seen since Japanese-Americans fought in World War II. They taste suspicion from some fellow soldiers who question their loyalty and resentment from fellow Muslims opposed to both American wars. At the Islamic community center in Killeen today, Friday prayers took place under a cloud of despair. This is where Major Nidal Hasan worshiped, alongside Fort Hood's small Muslim community, including Sergeant Fahad Kamal, just back from a 15-month tour of Afghanistan.

SERGEANT FAHAD KAMAL, U.S. MILITARY: I feel let down because we're better than this. Our religion teaches better, and it just makes me feel hurt and just, I just feel like we're much better individuals.

WEIR: Of the 1.4 million active service members around the world, just over 3,500 call themselves Muslims -- one-quarter of one percent. But members of their community say there are tens of thousands more who keep their faith to themselves, bowing to Mecca five times a day in private to avoid potential conflict with fellow troops.

SERGEANT MCCALL ABDULLAH: My last name's Abdullah, so it's really hard to run from it. It's right there on your BDUs, it says Abdullah.
    
WEIR: Sergeant McCall Abdullah began his overseas deployment on 9/11, and taunts followed him throughout his four-year enlistment.

ABDULLAH: You get called a camel jockey or a sand nigger or, you know, Haji or something like that.

WEIR: While Major Hasan's motives are still unclear, back in 2003, prosecutors alleged it was repeated taunting and religious ideology that led Sergeant Hasan Akbar to kill two of his commanding officers with a grenade. He was sentenced to death for that crime, and he became a symbol for those who want to believe a true Muslim could never choose America over Allah in a war against fellow Muslims. Former Gunnery Sergeant Jamal Gadani could not disagree more.

FORMER GUNNERY SERGEANT JAMAL GADANI, U.S. MILITARY: What some of these individuals do, is they try to take the Koran, the Muslim Koran, out of context and say, well, we can't kill other Muslims. Well, our mission is not to go kill other Muslims. We're there to find the bad guys, al-Qaeda.

ABDULLAH: We are all Americans, and we are all contributing, quite a few of us. And it would do best to remember that before putting people in a box.

GADANI: I feel embarrassed for the Muslim community. The feeling is that, I want to believe that it was the individual, not the religion, that made him do what he did.

WEIR: I asked Sergeant Abdullah how he managed to answer the call to prayer or march while fasting during Ramadan, he said, you just have to want it more than the rest of your guys in your platoon.

ABCNews.com video of Weir's story.

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

 Muslims in uniform today

 Muslims in uniform today face a challenge not seen since Japanese-Americans fought in World War II.

This is just an unbelievable pile of steaming crap!!  Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'll bet a pay check German/Americans and Italian/Americans fought in Europe in WWII.  What the hell is Gibson saying?  I guess he's saying that these muslims aren't Americans.  Does anyone else sense that?  If these 'people' want to be counted as Americans  they had better be willing and able to defend Americans at all cost.  This murderer volunteered for service.  No one held a dull sword to his neck to join up.

And as a Major, you can bet it wasn't any enlisted men gigging him for being a muhammadan, though it would be warranted.  It had to be a commissioned officer at least.  So screw him and screw you Gibson, you lying, slimy POS. 

Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum

Could not had said it better CR

Also, were not the Japanese not put in internment camps, not allowed to serve?

The srm is grasping at any and all straws to justify what this coward did. As far as I am concerned they are just as liable for the next "attack"

 

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

general

Your wording confused me, but then I get confused easily.  If you are asking if Japanese not interned were not allowed to serve, the answer is that they were allowed.  There was a highly decorated group that fought for the Army in Europe.  Can't remember the unit.  I'm not sure if any Japanese were allowed to serve in the Pacific.

If you weren't asking that, pardon the intrusion.

Gun Control - The theory that a woman found dead in an alley, raped and strangled with her own pantyhose, is somehow morally superior to a woman explaining to police how her attacker got that fatal bullet wound.

Thanks,

I had assumed all were interned, I had not even thought about them serving in Europe. And yes, I was certainly looking for insight, Thanks

Do not blame you for the confusion, there were only about 12 more "not"s in that sentence then needed.

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

The "Fighting 442nd"

The "Fighting 442nd" Infantry Regiment.

HARD INDEED

It is especially difficult for those Islamists in the military who shout Alah Akbar and shoot people. I only hope it is VERY HARD ON THIS DEGENERATE PIG! Hang him in public as an example!

They taste suspicion from

They taste suspicion from some fellow soldiers who question their loyalty...

Is this another "apology" thread, or did we switch to the repeal of "don't ask, don't tell"?

Here's the deal ABC (and CNN, NBC, CBS, MSn- ah, nevermind, you'll never get it): Major Hasan killed American soldiers because ultimately, he held greater allegiance is to his faith and the teachings of his particular brand of it than his country or his band of brothers. He was probably conflicted, and maybe he did hear some disrespect from some of the soldiers he was charged with "helping" (you just returned from a theater of war where men with similar names were trying to blow you up, and you have to sit down in front of someone that reminds you of those people and talk about how it made you feel. Maybe some of these guys weren't real comfortable in that situation? Maybe?) So, when faced with the prospect of leaving his cushy stateside job and enter a combat zone -even though it's unlikely he'd be anywhere within 100 miles of a bullet aimed in his direction- he chooses to become a martyr. End of story.

Are you trying to tell me...

this sad excuse for a human being is actually DEFENDING and sympathizing with this murderer??  These traitors are the most wretched and treachorous people I think I have ever seen. They don't deserve to be Americans. I am stunned.

 

"If God is dead, somebody is going to have to take his place. It will
be megalomania or erotomania, the drive for power or the drive for
pleasure, the clenched fist or the phallus, Hitler or Hugh Hefner."

— Malcolm Muggeridge

In other news, Charlie said

In other news, Charlie said he had never heard anything about a '911' or a war in Iraq. "We should probably leave that to the cables," he laughed, as his assistant whispered into his ear that his diaper was full again.

abc

Love that one

WTF!?Once again a

WTF!?

Once again a liberal reporter who doubtlessly knows ZERO members of the military simply assumes that those of us who wear uniforms are all just knuckledragging racists only too happy to harass muslims.

How does he know this?  Oh, from an anecdotal example provided by a discontented soldier.

For the record, I have never seen nor heard an example of anti Muslim bigotry, nor have I heard the derogatory term Sand Nigger, or Camel Jockey spoken by a member of the US military. 

I have heard the discriptive "Haji" used before, towards our enemy in theater and it is appropos since those who travel any distance to take up arms can by extension be likened to those who in arabic are "Al-Haj" or "From the devout journey to mecca" and they use it in nom-de-guerre themselves.

I have probably had more opportunities to have contact with muslim soldiers since I have dealt with linguists who have native skill.  I cannot recall any comments ever directed towards them. Fewer in fact than comments directed at devout christians, Catholics, and particularly mormons.

But I canot recall any recent examples of mormons walking into a Starbucks and shoot all in the extablishment.  Nor catholics walking into a Sizzler on Friday and shooting everyone eating meat.  The concept is rightfully considered ludicrous, but its counterpart - that of a muslim walking into an estaclishement and opening fire is obviously not far fetched and in fact likely.

MSM is way past the tipping point...

It's on now:

ABC News: Many troops returning from Iraq and Afghanistan bare the psychological
scars of war, everything from anxiety to post-traumatic stress. The
alleged Fort Hood gunman was a psychiatrist trained to help these
soldiers. And while it's way too early to know why this rampage
occurred, we do know that treating the mentally wounded can be
stressful as well.

Al Jazeera: "It raises a major question
- how can a person responsible for the mental health of soldiers
returning [from war] be allowed to continue in this profession when he
has these kinds of questions himself?" The rampage occurred at a time of stress for the US armed services
burdened by two wars, with commanders struggling to ease the effect of
repeated combat tours on troops and their families.

-----------------------------------------------------------

No, no, no, not God bless ABC News......

 

 

 

 

Someone explian this

Someone explian this nonsense to me.  If confronting emotional pain is so traumatic for psychologists and thus leads to volence- then surely we have seen grief counselors attack high schools post Columbine.

And I imagine we will be able to find examples of Psychologists who work from airlines taking out terminals full of passengers when they are informed they will have to go treat the families of crashed civilian jets. 

What, you say we have no examples of either of these?

So, what is different about MAJ Hasan?

This is such a bunch of crap...

ABC and Gibson are so full of it...Let the pity party begin...The faith of an American military member should have absolutely no bearing on their being in the service or how they do their duty. Any person considering joining the US military should be able to commit him or herself to this country, and if for some reason a person feels that their faith, whatever it is, prevents them from doing that, then they should find another occupation.

The fact that Hasan is a Muslim should be irrelevant to his being able to serve in a loyal fashion as a member of the US military. The same would be true if he were a Christian or a Jew... his faith should be irrelevant to his service. Many other Muslims apparently serve loyally and honorably in the US military. The problem with Hasan is that he appears to be a radical Muslim Islamist, who has clearly chosen to put his sick, twisted faith ahead of his allegiance to his country.

The question now is, how many other Maj. Hasan's are out there, flying under the radar? I would hope that he is a rare anomaly. The problem facing the US military now is how to find others who feel and believe as Hasan does, and what can be done to keep such people from ever being allowed to serve in the US Armed Forces.       

"The problem is not that people are taxed too little...the problem is that government spends too much." ~President Ronald Reagan

abc

Imagine if the shooter were a balding white male, christian and follower of Jerry Falwell or Pat Robertson, would the dumb prattle from the lame-stream media be the same?

Nope...Every sentence would begin with...

"The middle-aged male, right-wing fundamentalist-evangelical Christian shooter..." yada, yada, yada...

The MSM's tip-toeing around, and in some cases, out-right omission of mentioning Hasan's faith, is both deliberate and disgusting....Heaven forbid, we can't offend the Muslims out there...I have a question for these idiots...Why would mentioning this nut's faith offend them? Are Muslims as a group unable to handle the fact that one of their fellow faith members is a murderous loon? If a mass murderer turns out to be a Christian, I'm not offended by that...What I am offended by is his crime, and I want him (or her) locked up, and fast!  

"The problem is not that people are taxed too little...the problem is that government spends too much." ~President Ronald Reagan

My local MSM Propaganda outlet

posted a story about the "tragedy" as they call it.  I call it a terrorist attack but that's just me.

I posted this at their website regarding their pathetic attempt to cover this story.

First...my thoughts and prayers for the victims of this barbaric attack, their family members and friends.
Political Correctness killed these warriors as surely as the bullets that pierced their bodies.
They knew that this man had made numerous online postings praising suicide bombers and encouraging muslims to "rise up"....yet they did not act.
Fear of retribution, being accused of bigotry or attacks from CAIR or the media in general kept them from acting to protect his fellow soldiers from his religious zealotry.

I find it strange that no mention is made of his shouts of, "allahu akbar" during his attack.  This is Political Correctness at its finest...and must be stopped before it kills us all.
One may rest assured that if the attacker had shouted quotes from the Bible as he killed in the name of the Lord, those facts would be made known in a heartbeat.  The cries from the liberal mouthpieces lambasting Christianity would have left them with spittle round their mouths.  No one would have advised us concerning jumping to conclusions.
In this case the conclusion jumped to me.

 

islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.

Over The Radar

Unfortunately there's probably nothing that can be done about potentially homicidal Muslims in the armed services who are flying under the radar. But Hasan was flying above the radar. An Associated Press story reported that he told his medical school classmates that he was "a Muslim first and an American second." Combine a statement like that with praise for suicide bombers, and you've got real trouble! I can only hope that any others flying above the radar have now been brought to the attention of their commanding officers. 

See no evil

I know just how it feels to be made fun of:  Speaker Pelosi & Majority Leader, Hoyner called millions of us "un-American" for excercising our right to protest.  Obama made snarky references to "people waving tea bags".  The MSM labels anyone who critized Obama, a racist.  Homeland Security put millions of people on their watch list because they are pro-life.

Of course, ABC's Charlie Gibson isn't aware of any of that!

 

abc

Gibson is leaving it to the cables.

He had a third option

If he wanted to take a moral stand, he could have said,

"I'm against the wars" and "I'm not going overseas"

and have taken the consequences.

Plenty of people have refused to serve on moral/religious grounds.

 

New rules ???

I just glanced at the article, but is Gibson saying being made fun of or being criticized or persecuted is now justification for using violence against those doing it?  Is he now O.K. with those of conservative or Christian beliefs using violence against the many vicious left wing "reporters" and talking heads who have spewed forth some of the most vile insults and unfounded charges?  Will he lead the charge to stop such insults from being broadcast?  I won't hold my breath on that angle, because we know anything the left does will still be supported and promoted while everything the right does will still be criticized. 

"Muslims in uniform today

"Muslims in uniform today face a challenge not seen since Japanese-Americans fought in World War II. They taste suspicion from some fellow soldiers who question their"

Oh, and German-Americans never faced those problems when they fought the Nazi`s in WWII? Roosevelt rounded up German-Americans as well as Japanese-Americans. The lib media is trying any excuse possible to excuse that mass murderer,,,including PTSD even though he`s never been in combat. There is only one explanation for it,,,they support what he did. They just won`t come out and admit it. 

My local liberal rag the Anchorage Daily News...

has relegated the massacre at Fort Hood to non-new status.  There is no mention whatsoever of the terrorist attack there.  The story that was on the front page of their online version vanished after being there for one day.

The only mention of this story is that former President Bush visited there, and I had to scan the page repeatedly to find the tiny blurb.

I am beyond disgusted.

islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.

You used "rag" in a story about a Muslim?

Well, you know what's coming next: you're a racist. Even if you don't know it, you are. Report to Keith's Bathtub for a thought reformation session.

 

Oh no!

I shall report in the morning.

islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.

AB.... I see they haven't

AB....

I see they haven't changed a bit since I lived there.

Typical of all the leftist rags.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

where is the bias here? do

where is the bias here? do you not think mulim soldiers get a ton of crap based upon their beliefs?  Do you not think it is currently a topical issue?  you cant just point out a sentense you dont agree with and say it is biased...you have to add a thing liberals like to call an argument, with things liberals like to call evidence.  good luck next time though

nonthinker

Get your head out of your....

"do you not think mulim soldiers get a ton of crap based upon their beliefs?"

If they do, it may be because millions around the world have been waging Jihad and declaring death to Jews and to the West and the modern world for decades. Ever factored that in? 

And while we're on the subject of your "ton of crap" claim, here are the "sob stories" at CMN (Coddling Muslims Network) that was the "horrible tipping point" that led to Hasan's "revenge":

"There was racism towards him because he's a Muslim, because he's an Arab, because he prays," [CMN provides no examples of this "racism", or laughingly thinks it does below...]

"They used to see him dress in traditional Muslim clothing, so he was a bit irritated because of this. Also, the fact that they wanted to send him to Iraq. He decided to leave the Army for good and hire a lawyer because of this matter." [Hire a lawyer from all of the soldiers "seeing him dress in traditional Muslim clothing"....????]

The cousin said Hasan would hear, " 'Yes, you are a major in the U.S. Army, but you are still an Arab, a Muslim, you have your own traditions and values and we have ours.' He was bothered by that a lot. He wasn't respected as he should have been."

 

... all HORRIBLE stuff, huh, non-thinker? Of course, no wonder he shouted "Allah Akbar" and proceeded to kill as many infidels as he could.

 

Yeah, when I wear a kilt

Yeah, when I wear a kilt with my families tartan on it downtown I expect a certain amount of greif.  But he can't similarly expect smiles and laughs when he dresses in a thobe?

He SOUGHT to make himself an outcast by these actions.  He WANTED to feel left out.  It fueled his inner fire.  Most likely when he got his bad OER.  THen he needed a demon to blame rather than face the knowledge he was sub-par compared to his contemporaries.

Dearest unable-to-think:

It's okay to be dumb, we won't hold it against you.  Your opinion is shared by B.Hussein O. and the state controlled media.  The more you voice your ignorance, the more you guarantee a win for conservies in 2010 and 2012.  So, keep on babbling!!

"How strangely will the Tools of a Tyrant pervert the Plain Meaning of Words!" ~Sam Adams

Her ya go circuitalthinking...

Deal with it...

http://www.foxnews.c...

A Muslim veteran affairs
organization says it has not received reports of harassment from
Islamic soldiers, contrary to claims by a relative of the man
authorities say is responsible for the worst mass killing on a U.S.
military base.

islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.

Critical thinking: Muslim

Critical thinking:

Muslim soldiers probably receive LESS crap from fellow soldiers who seek to walk on egg shells around them than their fellow soldiers who are conservative Catholic, Mormon, and a whole host of fundamentalist christians who get MORE abuse than the protected species that is Islam.

But strangely I do not see Catholic Soldiers mowing down groups while screaming out the "Hail Mary."

Nor do I see any mormon soldiers mowing down groups while reciting from the book of Mormon.

But "Allahu Akhbar"  who is surprised he screamed that as he shot his compatriots?

THere is your friggin evidence.

What the H is going on?

All these sniveling whining empty between the ears liberal pondscum whining about the plight of muslim soldiers after one of the camel humpers just murdered 13 people and wounded 30 more?  What in H is wrong with them?   snapped...?  my aching butt!  He disposed of his personal goods, closed out his apartment, bought at least two hand  guns....you think he did all that on the spur of the moment?  These liberals are totally and completely insane imho!!!

Ummm...Dude...i uh...

I have been posting at Jihadwatch for years as AlaskanInfidel.

Thanks to the many contributors there to include Robert Spencer and so many others far more knowledgeable than I, I have some small knowledge of the nature of the Stealth Jihad and the true nature of islam and its never ending demands for accommodation...submission.  I know the koran commands good muslims to see to it that all free men are converted, paying the jizya or dead.  No other options. I will never convert or submit.  That leaves me one option under islam and I am very aware of that.

If the fecal matter strikes the air impeller I am quite prepared to deal with that eventuality as are most of my neighbors.  The attacks that occur every day at the hands of the "misundrstanders of islam" know no boundaries or borders and can occur at any time anywhere.  Mumbai style attacks will eventually occur in a US city just as this one has on a military installation.  

This was not the first or second or third time that a devout muslim in the US Armed Forces declared jihad and killed his fellow soldiers in the name of the moon god allah.  And as long as the infection of PCness continues to spread untreated it will not be the last.

Now...I think I have made my position clear regarding islam...the religion of Blood and Death.  That said...

The use of a pejorative regarding the followers of islam, brainwashed victims of that odious religion for the most part, does nothing to further the cause of spreading the Truth about islam and even though I know you are no racist or bigot, it gives the Charles Jhonsons of this world something to point at.

I fully understand your anger an need to express it but....Dude...

islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.

Maybe charlie is just saying

Maybe charlie is just saying muslims aren't tough enough for the Military.  I'm sure he'd be offended if some took his PC BS that way.