Gibson Frets: 'Liberal Republican Gets Forced Out, What Happened to the Big Tent?'

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

Following a Monday night look at Tuesday's special election to fill New York's 23rd congressional district seat in which Republican Dede Scozzafava dropped out after falling behind the Democrat and the Conservative Party nominee, ABC anchor Charles Gibson -- instead of wondering why the GOP establishment failed to pick a candidate who upholds basic Republican principles -- delivered the usual liberal media upset over the GOP's lack of a “big tent,” a phrase you never hear when Democrats pick left-wing candidates:

A liberal Republican gets forced out of the race by a more conservative guy who was actually not a Republican, was running on the Conservative ticket. What happened to the big tent in the Republican Party?

John Berman framed the preceding story on the “moderate” Scozzafava “who supports abortion rights and the President’s stimulus plan,” around the premise that going with a conservative candidate will hurt in the long run: “A Republican drops out of a race which might guarantee Republicans keep the seat, which might be bad for the Republican party long term.” Berman concluded with how the conservative candidate, Douglas Hoffman, “says not all views are welcome” as he suggested “there's always boundaries.” To which Berman intoned: “The question for Republicans is will those boundaries become a burden?”

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Journalists are certainly trying to make them so.

In between, Berman did at least note “that Scozzafava endorsed the Democrat Bill Owens, sparking I-told-you-so's from the right.” Viewers then heard from Rush Limbaugh: “DeDe Scozzafava is illustrating precisely what moderate Republicans will do.”

The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the story on the Monday, November 2 World News with Charles Gibson on ABC:

CHARLES GIBSON: Now, to politics. There are off-year elections tomorrow. In New Jersey and Virginia, governors will be chosen. Maine has a critical vote on gay marriage. New York City chooses a mayor. But there is nothing to compete with the House of Representatives race in upstate New York which has taken bizarre turn after bizarre turn. John Berman ventured up to Watertown, New York.

JOHN BERMAN: Try to follow this: A Republican drops out of a race which might guarantee Republicans keep the seat, which might be bad for the Republican party longterm.

DOUG HOFFMAN, NEW YORK CONGRESSIONAL CANDIDATE: All along I’ve been fighting for the soul of the Republican party.

BERMAN: Thing is, Douglas Hoffman is not the Republican party nominee. He's a third party candidate who entered the race when New York Republican leaders selected moderate DeDe Scozzafava, who supports abortion rights and the President’s stimulus plan, to fill a seat in a district won by President Obama in 2008.

CLIP OF HOFFMAN AD WITH FEMALE NARRATOR: Tired of choosing between two liberals for Congress?

BERMAN: Scozzafava came under withering attack from the likes of Sarah Palin and national conservative groups who flooded the district with money and volunteers. Where are you from?

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: I'm actually from the Denver, Colorado area.

BERMAN: And this weekend, trailing in the polls, Scozzafava, the handpicked Republican nominee, dropped out of the race. This was Republican candidate Scozzafava’s campaign headquarters, now completely shut down. This after the Republican party and its national campaign committees spent $1 million backing her in this race. Stranger still now that Scozzafava endorsed the Democrat Bill Owens, sparking I-told-you-so’s from the right.
                
RUSH LIMBAUGH: DeDe Scozzafava is illustrating precisely what moderate Republicans will do.

BERMAN: The Republican National Committee is now backing Hoffman, and polls show he may be able to ride the wave of conservative dissent to victory.

FORMER REP. TOM DAVIS (R-VA): We need those people. They're going to be a major part of who we are. But they also have to tolerate other points of view.

BERMAN: But Douglas Hoffman says not all views are welcome. The tent can only be so big?

HOFFMAN: Well, isn't that true in life in general? There's always boundaries.

BERMAN: The question for Republicans is will those boundaries become a burden? John Berman, ABC News, Watertown, New York.

GIBSON: And our chief Washington correspondent, George Stephanopoulos, joins us. George, let's talk about the elections tomorrow and let's start with that House race. A liberal Republican gets forced out of the race by a more conservative guy who was actually not a Republican, was running on the Conservative ticket. What happened to the big tent in the Republican Party?

GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS: Well, what Republicans would say, Charles, is that Dede Scozzafava is just stretching those tent poles too far: Pro-gay rights, pro-choice/pro-abortion rights, even had the backing of the Working Families Party, that she really wasn't part of the mainstream of the Republican Party according to those party officials. Democrats say that's a sign that the extremists have taken over the party....

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

→ Liberal Republican Gets Forced Out

Did Gibson finally hear about Arlen Sphincter?

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Big Pup-Tent democrats

forgot about poor Joe Lieberman?

(donkeys may have short memories, but elephants

never forget) 

"When the democrats are finally done

we'll all be living in tents." 

I was thinking the same thing, Mitch

Forget about Scozzafava.  Lieberman was a former Democratic VP candidate, and a few years later, the DNC threw him under the bus.

Gibson is a blithering idiot.  Why should a political party keep members who are diametrically opposed to the party's agenda?  Gibson is such an expert on politics he doesn't understand what parties are for.

" Why should a political

" Why should a political party keep members who are diametrically opposed to the party's agenda?" Spot on, Galvanic. The "big tent" concept as espoused by the libmedia and practiced by the likes of McCain, Specter, Gingrich, Steele, Scuzzfart, et al diluted the Republican brand so badly, that we started losing elections.  It did not help that the Repubs in Congress became as corrupt and spendthrift as the Dems.  If there is no difference between a Dem and a Republican, why vote for the Republican?  Viva la difference! Viva la Reagan Revolution.

"A communist is someone who reads Marx.  An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx."  Ronald Reagan

Don't worry charlie

You can join Katie in exile soon my friend, very soon...

LMAO - Radical Leftist worrying about RINO's being ejected!

I am sure Charlie is sincere, sincerly scared shi.less that the presstitutes are losing any credibilty and that someone other than Marxist radical might end up controlling the country that is!

 

STUPID!

Allowing the left in the media to define "Republican" and pick who gets into the "tent" and who is the party candidate is STUPID! After all it worked so well in 2008, right? Any criticism of the democrat party for having ZERO tollerance for contrary opinions? The media never does that contrast and criticism, do they?

So did Hoffman seek out the

So did Hoffman seek out the Republican parties nomination? Was he the Republican parties nomination? Is he running as a Republican?

No, No and what was that ? No?

So what is this "Big Tent" reference and tieing it to the Republicans.  Oh, is it because Republicans and Independants are planning on voting for the "Conservative" Independant and not the Liberal RINO that had the Republican nomination or the Democrat? When will people wake up and start to realize that the populace has stirred and might actually be begining to vote with principle instead of along party lines.

Watch out Washington if this actually starts to happen!

→ Well, sort of

As I understand it, Hoffman did try to get the Republican nod but Skuzzy got tapped by the big boys down at the pool hall to run as a Republican.

That's when Hoffman decided the Conservatives weren't being given an honest choice.

Maybe a little investigation is in order as to who these queenmakers (in this case) are.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

I did wonder about that, but

I did wonder about that, but the big picture hopefully stands as he did NOT get it and is running as an independant.

→ No doubt about it

I'm thinking the Republican machine up there must be a front for the Dems.

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Time for NY-23 conservatives

Time for NY-23 conservatives to clean out the local Newts.

The fallacy of "big tent" is the chicken-egg argument

It's your message and values, end of story.
Republicans have had a small tent lately because the "show" (message) has been lousy---->Dem Lite

 A politcal party will attract hordes of people if it promotes
a clear, concise, and smart agenda, ie  the Contract with America
was pure genius, but once in power they forgot about tort reform and small govt,etc,  and by 2001 Dems regained the Senate.
People will respond to Conservatism, alas there isnt much on the ballot that one can vote for.......

Meanwhile back at GOP headquarters...

We are out of bubble gum.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wp_K8prLfso

Faith,determination,  and power of the vote can restore our liberty if we can chop off the thousand hands of ACORN, toss the RINOS out on their keisters,and wrench back the judiciary.

We can do this.

YES WE CAN .

 

 

 

 

 

Conservatives don't want a lying two faced traitor.....

Oh the horror.   No mention of how she took all the party's money to run as a Republican only to screw the party  over.  Her whole campaign was a scam and we're supposed to lament over the fact she is gone....?

" if Republicans are able to stop Barack Obama on health care, 'it will be his Waterloo, it will break him....-Sen. Jim DeMint

Just think of all the $$$ Republicans have sent to the RNC

that were wasted on this phony!  She should have to repay the Republican Party since she endorsed her Democrat challenger!

Makes me even more proud of my decision to NOT send one $ to the national party - we give to individual CONSERVATIVE local candidates and also to those across the country.  At least that way I can tell myself my little contribution actually helped.

This comment comes from a proud Tea Party attendee, otherwise designated by Homeland Security as a Domestic Right Wing Terrorist!  And now by our president as a 'swiftboater' - both titles I'll wear proudly!     It is no dishonor to be in a minority in the cause of liberty and virtue ~ Sam Adams

202.224.3121   LET CONGRESS HEAR THE ROAR OF THE SILENT MAJORITY!  

202.456.1111   WHITE HOUSE COMMENT LINE

 

Just say NO to the RNC!

The other day I got a survey from the RNC...of course they also want a donation of $50-$100.....

I skipped filling it out and wrote on it (very large) "Not one dime until you stop supporting RINO's like Scozzafava!!"

and sent it back in their pre-paid envelope.

I encourage everyone to do the same. I will contribute to those Republicans I think are worth my money, but zippo to the national committee!

Good for you.

It's the only way they will learn.

" if Republicans are able to stop Barack Obama on health care, 'it will be his Waterloo, it will break him....-Sen. Jim DeMint

What irritates me is that

What irritates me is that the local REpublican Party keeps calling and starts off reading a script with lipservice about "Keeping Nancy Pelosi in check" and could they please ask me for $100.

I reply that they will not get another penny from me until they run someone in the primary against John McCain.

The kid usually then continues reading the damn script saying "I know times are tough but could you see your way to giving us $50?"

I reply not until they run a primary opponent against John McCain.

Then the kid who is obviously not listening to me says "WOuld you be able to contribute $25?"

At which time I freak out and scream "NOT UNTIL YOU RUN A PRIMARY OPPONENT AGAINST JOHN FRIGGIN MCCAIN."

And the kid keeps reading... "possibly ten dollars..."

And I ask "What did I just say?"

and he follows the script to end the call.

The Republicans are asking for a beating from a third party candidate if they do not get their head out of the third point of contact and listen to their members instead of treating us like chattle.

Come Hell or High Water

This media chose the Republican candidate in 2008 and they very much plan to in 2012.  Where are the stories on the democrat split on what the heck to do in Afghanistan?  Obama is afraid to make a decision because of the moonbat wing?  Some big tent!

Agreed and

We have a big tent, we just dont let pigs in, we leave that up to the democrats who run the "Big Sty"

THE SYSTEM...

 Texndoc,

Yes, the MSM played their part in picking McCain, but the big problem is the open primary system too many states have. You should at least be a registered Republican to vote in a Republican primary. That should be Chairman Steele's 1st priority, kill open primary voting.

 

"...How blind can you be, don't you see...

...that the gambler lost all he does not have..."  

Nightwish

I really wish liberals would

I really wish liberals would stop worrying about the Republican party.  Crocodile tears are meaningless.  It's about time some of these politicians who aren't conservative get the hell out.

Caller on Rush Limbaugh nailed it....

Liberals are only using the rhetoric of 'the big tent' as a weapon to try to bully and threaten wimp RINO leaders into letting Demorats pick GOP candidates.

That's how we wound up with John 'I-Ran-My-Campaign-Like-A-Concession-Speech' McCain.  That's how we wound up with Sphincter the turncoat and Olympia Snow-Job.  That's how we wound up with an army of wimp RINOs who bend over and grab their ankles whenever a Demorat walks by.  They may as well be wearing T-shirts and tattoos on their foreheads that say 'stooge'.

Demorats and their media whores are now scared to death that Republicans with guts who are standing up for smaller government, fiscal responsibility and Christian values are about to take the stage.  And they are letting us know exactly who we SHOULD support by yelling at us and ordering us who we should be against.....

Rush is still in denial

Rush is still in denial that he didn't call the shots on the Republican election. Whether you like him or not, McCain won with a majority of Republicans votes in the overall primary.

While a lot of Bush Republicans like Limbaugh who supported the Big government Republicans complained about those of us who didn't approve of the way they ran things. 

But here is the thing. The key word that Skuzzyflava failed in this phrase is big tent REPUBLICAN. I can vote for someone like McCain who I agree with 85% of the time, but I can't vote for Democrats who I agree with at best 10% of the time.

There was more to it than

There was more to it than that.  We wound up with McCain because Huckabee and McCain conspired to get enough delegate from some key states to force Romney out of the race - because they both wanted someone a little more 'centrist'.

And once that bait-and-switch got Romney out of the race, and the media proclaimed Huckabee 'too polarizing', who did the GOP go with?  McWimp - the guy who 'crossed the aisle'.  The guy who voted with Democrats on every major issue since Bush was elected in 2000.  He was the liberal wet-dream candidate - a guy who was so much like liberals that it was hard to tell them apart.  

And since the only 'choice' was between a hardcore liberal and a liberal who was pretending to be a conservative, people went with the real thing instead of the phoney.

And it'll happen again unless the GOP wakes up and starts nominating REAL conservative leaders.

Is it possible for the next president to demand a mass

resignation from ALL members of Congress?  How else will we ever get those lifers out?  They have sold their souls for a life of great comfort with excellent benefits and a retirement ordinary citizens will never see...and they aren't about to let go without a good fight!  And NEVER once do they consider the concerns of their constituents!!

How can we ever get term limits passed if the ones voting would be affected?  So much for Mr. Smith Goes to Washington...greed takes over quickly and then they are set in concrete!

This comment comes from a proud Tea Party attendee, otherwise designated by Homeland Security as a Domestic Right Wing Terrorist!  And now by our president as a 'swiftboater' - both titles I'll wear proudly!     It is no dishonor to be in a minority in the cause of liberty and virtue ~ Sam Adams

202.224.3121   LET CONGRESS HEAR THE ROAR OF THE SILENT MAJORITY!   

202.456.1111   WHITE HOUSE COMMENT LINE

 

That's why the Founders put in the ammendment process!

We need to elect enough Congress Critters that 'get' the brilliance of our Founders, and yes; vote for their own term limits.  The states can help by 'pre-approving' the ammendment (3/4 of the states) with enough political pressure to vote 'yes' or you're voted out anyway.  A tall task, but still possible.

 

 

To know and not do, is to not yet know

And a lot of us conservative

And a lot of us conservative libertarians were disgusted by the pick of John 'I'm in the middle' McCain by the Republicans. It's time to throw all of them out. BTW, Rush doesn't tell me how to vote either.

And a lot of us

And a lot of us conservative libertarians were disgusted by the pick of
John 'I'm in the middle' McCain by the Republicans. It's time to throw
all of them out. BTW, Rush doesn't tell me how to vote either.

 What are you talking about? Rush was the most vocal opponent against McCain on the conservative side.

“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)

Rush is hardly a

Rush is hardly a libertarian, with either a small or large 'L'. He and I might agree about a lot of things, but that doesn't suggest that he directs my vote.

Several of the above posts make reference to Rush. I agree that the media involvement, such as the NYT's faux support of McCain, and the primary voting structure in various states led to the selection of a poor candiate for Republicans. My comment needs to be read in context.

Hardly.

First of all, there is no such thing as "overall primary".

It's a rigged game.  The early primaries are  mostly are in the ultra liberal states (New Hampshire ring a bell?).  Secondly, many of these primaries are open primaries, where those who are registered as independent, and even democrat, are allowed to vote.

Finally, the republican primaries are mostly winner take all, as opposed to the democrat apportioned delegate allocations.

Unless and until the Republican National Party, and the subsequent state Republican Parties fix this idiocy, we'll end up with more RINO's.

This whole "Big Tent" is just nonsense.  It's democrats stealing elections.  If the indies want to vote with us, fine....they can do it in the general.  But until they get their moderate a***** off the fence, they can stay out of our primaries.  If they're so in love with the democrats, so be it.

NO MORE RINOS.

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

While a lot of Bush

While a lot of Bush Republicans like Limbaugh who supported the Big
government Republicans complained about those of us who didn't approve
of the way they ran things. 

 Since Rush did not support Bush's big government polices (which is fact), I have no idea what you're talking about.

“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)

What's this?!

Charles Gibson is actually up on current events?

Good for you Charlie, even if you are confused as hell about it.

ROFL!! Maybe Charlie will

ROFL!! Maybe Charlie will learn what the acronym ACORN means, before he leaves the ABC anchor desk!!

Facts are like kryptonite to the liberal.

Rocky

Let's hope he gets it down before he follows Wolf Blitzer and Soledad on Jeopardy, as follows:

Oh-oh-oh-oh

I was there to match my intellect on national TV
Against a plumber, oh, and an architect, both with a PhD
I was tense, I was nervous, I guess it just wasn't my night
Art Fleming gave the answers
Oh, but I couldn't get the questions right, -ight, -ight

I lost on Jeopardy, baby (oooh)
I lost on Jeopardy, baby (oooh)

-Weird Al Yankovich

 

 

LOL!!

Could I have "Tyrants Jimmy Carter Loves," for $1000.00 Alex??

Facts are like kryptonite to the liberal.

Ol Charley

Just curious but did Gibson poop in his pants when the more liberal guy beat Joe Leiberman in the Connecticut?

Did I miss something

Since when did the terms "Republican' and "liberal" end up in the same catagory? Did I miss something all those years? This so called Republican was to the left of the Demonrat running. If that is what the Republicans are, well, they will never win anything again. In the end, just more hand wringing by the media elite wanting to pick who they run again like McLaim...oh well.

Stupid

These people are so clueless about rank-and-file Republicans. 

Finally, after all this time.....

the MSM cares about what happens to the GOP!!!

(if only it were remotely sincere..... Usually, they are just giving us advice on how to NOT suck less in the eyes of 'moderates' and liberals) 

Georgie - you got 1/2 correct! She was NOT representative of

the mainstream of the Republican Party...and the sooner Newt and Michael Steele and John McCain and Lindsay Graham and Olympia Snowe wake up to that fact, the better off our party will be.  The Silent Majority will be silent NO longer!  Do you hear us now?????????????????????????????? 

Michele Bachman for PRESIDENT!  SHE is 'representative' of those of us who have sat quietly for too long...we will no longer be silenced! 

"...GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS: Well, what Republicans would say, Charles, is that Dede Scozzafava is just stretching those tent poles too far: Pro-gay rights, pro-choice/pro-abortion rights, even had the backing of the Working Families Party, that she really wasn't part of the mainstream of the Republican Party according to those party officials. Democrats say that's a sign that the extremists have taken over the party..."

This comment comes from a proud Tea Party attendee, otherwise designated by Homeland Security as a Domestic Right Wing Terrorist!  And now by our president as a 'swiftboater' - both titles I'll wear proudly!     It is no dishonor to be in a minority in the cause of liberty and virtue ~ Sam Adams

202.224.3121   LET CONGRESS HEAR THE ROAR OF THE SILENT MAJORITY!   

202.456.1111   WHITE HOUSE COMMENT LINE

 

The Big Tent

The "Big Tent" does not include socialists or communists or democrats disguised as republicans.

The "Big Tent" is for all people who simply would like to be governed by the principles of the US Constitution. If you need a 3-ring circus in your tent (with ringmasters pelosi, reid, and obama) thenyou are in the wrong Big Tent... go find the tent being held up by trial lawyers, SEIU, and confused minorities who think their ringmasters will pay their rent next month.

btw- I do not agree with Rush 95% of the time... instead, Rush agrees with *me* 95% of the time. That's a distinction *with* a difference that the LWP cannot be expected to comprehend. 

Gee, Charlie, What happened to the

post-racial, bipartian, transparent, most ethical, multi-voiced, non-lobbyist presidential administration ever?  Where is the big tent of the Democratic party where the Big Dogs are villified by the lunatic leftist?

Dist 23

My district is right next to the 23rd and I can tell you they are really jazzed for Hoffman up there.  Biden wasted his time. 

Aside: http://hillbuzz.org has a youtube by Palin ripping the obamanocare bill.

 

 

Forty percent of Americans

Forty percent of Americans desribe themselves as conservative.

That's a big ass tent.

Name one.

Can you name one conservative Republican who could run as a Democrat anywhere, without having a lobotomy?  Talk about a purge, it would happen very quickly. 

The Big Tent Democrats are only an illusion.  If you're pro-life, pro-business, low-tax individual, the Democrats aren't going to recruit you, period.  The Democrats idea of diversity is having some color at a rally, that's about it.   

Election 2008-God's way of showing us that elections count.  

Charles Gibson

Charles, you hack. People are not playing that game anymore, if they ever were. Where's the democrats big tent? I don't know many people who will confess to being in it right now. The far far left has taken it over.

I love how journalists make up all the rules you have to follow to be considered for a political office.

Getting creamed in the polls

Getting creamed in the polls and dropping out somehow means you were forced out by the GOP?

I must be going mad ...

.. I actually agree with George Stephanopoulos.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.