ABC's World News on Tuesday night bemoaned the impact of conservatives and citizen journalists in derailing President Barack Obama's agenda. Pivoting from the reaction to Obama's address to students, anchor Charles Gibson observed “today's speech was really the latest target of some conservative groups taking on the President” and “their tactics are having an impact.”
Reporter Dan Harris asserted “the conservative echo chamber is not new, but,” he fretted, “this White House is operating in a vastly accelerated media environment where you no longer need to be in the presence of reporters to make news, as we saw with the health care furor at those town hall meetings.” Journalistic veteran Tom Rosenstiel marveled: “Today you can arrange that protest yourself, photograph it with a hand-held cell phone, and if you can then generate enough views of that video on YouTube, you can make something into national news.” That's because, Harris insisted, “the mainstream media love a good fight, even if the charges are unfounded.”
Though Harris acknowledged “some of the conservative complaints do play into larger concerns” about Obama, he relayed how “critics say the White House has been simply unprepared to deal with the ferocity of the conservative push-back.”
Gibson next cued up how in an interview with Good Morning America's Robin Roberts, to air Wednesday, President Obama regretted “more moderate Republican voices are not being heard.” In the single soundbite, Obama expressed “frustration” that the voices of “the traditional leaders, the Bob Doles of the world” have been “shouted down on that side.”
The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the story on the Tuesday, September 8 World News on ABC, following the lead item on Obaam's presentation to school students:
CHARLES GIBSON: And today's speech was really the latest target of some conservative groups taking on the President -- whether the subject is health care reform, his economic plan, or something as seemingly noncontroversial as staying in school. And as Dan Harris reports, their tactics are having an impact.
DAN HARRIS: If you want to get a sense of how quickly a controversy can ignite, check out this play by play. On August 26th, the White House officially announces that President Obama will be addressing students. The next day, a conservative Web site [Ron Paul's Daily Paul] criticizes the speech without even knowing what the President will say exactly. Just days later on September 1st, the Chairman of the Florida Republican Party slams the speech as “indoctrination.” By September 2nd, Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck are all over it.
KEVIN MADDEN, REPUBLICAN STRATEGIST: A lot of that opposition begins to feed itself. One person becomes 100 people. 100 people become 1,000.
HARRIS: The conservative echo chamber is not new, but this White House is operating in a vastly accelerated media environment where you no longer need to be in the presence of reporters to make news, as we saw with the health care furor at those town hall meetings.
TOM ROSENSTIEL, PROJECT FOR EXCELLENCE IN JOURNALISM AND FORMER LA TIMES REPORTER: Today you can arrange that protest yourself, photograph it with a hand-held cell phone, and if you can then generate enough views of that video on YouTube, you can make something into national news.
HARRIS: And that's because the mainstream media love a good fight, even if the charges are unfounded. But there's something else going on here as well. Some of the conservative complaints do play into larger concerns about this President, concerns that show up in his slipping poll numbers on health care reform and big government spending.
DAVID CHALIAN, ABC NEWS POLITICAL DIRECTOR: Even unfounded criticism is finding a home because there's a resonance on the larger issue for many Americans of too much government in their lives – auto bailouts, bank bailouts, government-run health insurance.
HARRIS: Even though Team Obama ran such a successful presidential campaign, critics say the White House has been simply unprepared to deal with the ferocity of the conservative push-back.
MADDEN: You have to be aware of the opposition that is going to arise, and have a plan to deal with it.
HARRIS: The White House is clearly hoping that tomorrow's big speech to Congress will create a new narrative, the comeback. Dan Harris, ABC News, New York.
GIBSON: The President, in an interview with Robin Roberts of Good Morning America to be broadcast tomorrow morning, made reference to all this in the context of health care, saying more moderate Republican voices are not being heard.
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA, IN GMA INTERVIEW: Part of the frustration I have is that, on the Republican side, there are wonderful people whose voices, I think, are tamped down, and, you know, the traditional leaders, the Bob Doles of the world, those voices have been, I think, shouted down on that side, and I hope that the Republican Party can rediscover that voice.
GIBSON: George Stephanopoulos is joining us now. George, the President may yearn for more moderate Republican voices, but it seems less and less likely he's going to get much Republican support on health care reform.
GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS: It does, Charlie. The last bipartisan negotiations are just about at an endpoint, likely to break down tomorrow finally, and the Democrats in the Finance Committee will have to try to come up with a majority on their own. But what the President, I think, was trying to do in that interview with Robin Roberts, what I think he will do tomorrow night, is reach out to the voters who are attracted to that kind of sensibility. Independent and moderate Republican voters who either voted for President Obama last year or were open to him at the beginning of this year, but are starting to pull away, he wants to get them back tomorrow night by convincing them that he's going the extra mile on bipartisanship.
GIBSON: But he keeps saying we have to do something, the status quo is unsustainable. The problem becomes what you do when you get into details. And he has to come up with a bill and they still haven't, that they know can get enough Senate votes and more than half the House votes.
STEPHANOPOULOS: That's exactly right, Charlie. And to do that, he is going to have to, again, move more to the middle. Tomorrow, I think he will be more specific than he's ever been in the past. I think he will actually identify many of the ideas that he's talking about that are Republican ideas and may even come up with some new ideas that have been supported largely by Republicans, like malpractice reform, again, to try to show that he is working hard to make this system work, and if he ends up having to go with Democrats alone, he had tried his best to get Republicans on board.
GIBSON: Alright, George Stephanopoulos in Washington, thanks.
—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center





DAN HARRIS: If you want to get a sense of how quickly a controversy can ignite, check out this play by play. On August 26th, the White House officially announces that President Obama will be addressing students. The next day, a conservative Web site [Ron Paul's
TOM ROSENSTIEL, PROJECT FOR EXCELLENCE IN JOURNALISM AND FORMER LA TIMES REPORTER: Today you can arrange that protest yourself, photograph it with a hand-held cell phone, and if you can then generate enough views of that video on YouTube, you can make something into national news.
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA, IN GMA INTERVIEW: Part of the frustration I have is that, on the Republican side, there are wonderful people whose voices, I think, are tamped down, and, you know, the traditional leaders, the Bob Doles of the world, those voices have been, I think, shouted down on that side, and I hope that the Republican Party can rediscover that voice.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
We're just doing the job...
September 8, 2009 - 20:20 ET by P. Aaron...that ABC and their buddies refuse to do:
READ THE DAMN BILL!
MY PREDICTIONS...MARK IT
September 8, 2009 - 21:03 ET by reelman46MY POLITICAL PREDICTIONS…MARK IT
Sadly
(and terrifyingly) the radical kook Obama surrounded by secular
socialist kooks Reid and Pelosi will soon affect America in ALL the
ways we (with any sense and sense of history) fear.
The moonbats and loony left know their stars will never be better
aligned…heck, even Chavez wants to help Obama. The kook secular
socialist angry haters of American values must strike with all force
before the 2010 elections. They know voters are terrified of all this
kook secular socialism…and madder by the week as the lies pile up, the
excuses pile us, the denials pile up, the gov-meant hiring piles up and
the debt piles up…while nearly a sixth of the country is jobless and
retirement plans are still far from regaining that 30% hit.
That means a monster Health Care bill with over 50 new panels,
boards and commissions (HB 3200 has them now) plus more triggers for
takeovers than a pistol factory. Did I mention trillions more in debt?
History teaches us the “gov-meant selling price” is always 3-9x the
true cost in just a couple years. The Cap and Tax will be the next
toxic enema for Uncle Sam. Talk Radio and The Net will lose freedoms.
ALL their major bills will be rammed thru…even if special rule changes or taking the 51 vote path are needed.
These radicals are not the compromising kind but the angry arrogant
clueless breed that never learns or displays any common sense.
They just want the power and to heck with the results down the road.
Its all rainbow dust and happy unicorns to the modern lefty.
You just don’t really really understand how wonderful their secular
socialist society will be. Ask the Castro and Chavez praisers.
Voters got a sample of the congressional arrogance of the modern
democrat this summer. Its only the beginning. There will be weeping and
gnashing of teeth.
The rage will rise to heights not seen in generations as the biased
media struggles to change the constant dirty diapers from this group of
political thugs. That is the same media that looked the other way in
2008 as a known marxist surrounded by same was allowed a free pass.
That stain is permanent.
Just as the economy starts struggling to its wobbly feet the nation will be hammered with many new taxes in 2010.
By next summer all this major mischief will come to pass and set the stage for the greatest voter turnout in history.
J. Carter Obama and his fellow travelers will have the omnipresent “ghost of economy past” haunting them for Halloween 2010.
(These are my instincts, I hope to be very wrong)
Doug Schexnayder, Ph.D. (theconservativecrawfish)
More toxic legislation will
September 8, 2009 - 22:34 ET by Dan The Man 2More toxic legislation will only be passed under marshall law.
What they rue
September 8, 2009 - 20:22 ET by jdlybrandThey really rue the fact that 'citizen journalists' are putting them out of business.
"What a revoltin' development this is!"
Chester Riley
Good Riddance
September 8, 2009 - 21:31 ET by evilcontractorTo quote Roy Clark, "Thank God and Greyhounds you're gone." If these so called journalist would just do their damn jobs, real people would still be watching...
www.btreasures.com
Yeah, they would...
September 8, 2009 - 20:24 ET by SlyrrGiven that all the 'big 3' networks are nothing but Obama's media puppets....
Pathetic - and to think they used to be respectable. Look at them now - oh how the mighty have fallen...
Conservative Groups?
September 8, 2009 - 20:26 ET by obageegeeThese idiots think we are that organized? LOL
OBAGEEGEE...
September 8, 2009 - 21:08 ET by danybhoyOf course they think we are organized. They are leftists, everything leftists do require central planning. It's all top down, follow the leader. The right does'nt need to be told what to do, we just do it. No central planning needed. They think there must be an organized effort because that's how they do things.
I really laugh at the term "citizen journalist", it sucks. My question is this, what are you a citizen of? The "citizen journalists" they are pissed off at consider themselves AMERICAN citizens. Many in the MSM consider themselves to be a citizen of THE WORLD. Screw those "citizens of the world", leave America & join the world.
"...How blind can you be, don't you see...
...that the gambler lost all he does not have..."
Nightwish
Slyrr
September 9, 2009 - 16:34 ET by ahusserThe only reason they were respectable was they had no opposition. Their golden age is gone. We had no choice but to watch their stuff as skewed as it was there was nothing to compare it with. Looking back I don't think they have changed all that much (this perspective is from a Vietnam Veteran who witnessed and felt the pervasive bias that was and is the MSM) there was no internet to shine a spotlight on their leftist ways (maybe they were more subtle back then) and since their statist/socialist/fascist candidate won the presidency they feel they have a mandate to be less subtle or maybe they are just less competent.
"Somehow, I told you so, just doesn't quite say it." Will Smith in 'I, Robot.'
critics say the White House
September 8, 2009 - 20:27 ET by motherbeltcritics say the White House has been simply unprepared to deal with the ferocity of the conservative push-back.”
That's because they never expect conservatives to push back!
Just like they were floored in 2000 when a bunch of guys in Dockers and golf shirts pushed back when they tried to lock the doors and count votes in private, now they are caught flat-footed at the situation that "everyday people" might not agree with them and actually want their voices heard!!
Conservatives are supposed to just mumble under their breaths and "suck it up."
chucklin' charlie gibson
September 8, 2009 - 20:26 ET by NotFondOfLibsWell, boo hoo, charlie gibson. Really tough to hear you don't like disagreement with barack obama's policies and speeches. Got a suggestion for you, crybaby: Go sit on a pinecone and see how that treats you. Glad to hear abc news is finally getting rid of you, you condescending, arrogant oaf. Too bad Sarah Palin didn't knock your teeth out when you tried to submarine her last year. Suck wind and good riddance, gibson.
WAIT! They actually
September 8, 2009 - 20:31 ET by Free StinkerWAIT!
They actually admit that citizens are involved? What next? Actually reporting on Obama?
Nah! That's crazy talk.
→ Hey Charlie Gibson
September 8, 2009 - 20:32 ET by Cool ArrowIs this the "Gibson Doctrine" as you understand it?
Don't you have some vacation coming before you retire?
Start on your memoir.
Van Jones is a Quitter - FS
Bob Dole???? This is who
September 8, 2009 - 20:38 ET by motherbeltBob Dole????
This is who the President thinks should have the voice and speak for Republicans??? Holy Cow!!
If he's not available, I'm sure the President will settle for John McCain!
he wants to get them back tomorrow night by convincing them that he's going the extra mile on bipartisanship.
This, when the headline says Pelosi and Reid Tell President "We Have the Votes" ???
Then why the big speech?
I think Rush nailed it today when he said the President has to shore up support in his own party!
But as Stephanopolous says, he wants to make it look like he's trying to get Republicans on board.
Yeah, Georgie, he'll talk about "malpractice reform"....he'll agree to consider looking into the possiblity of evaluating the idea......
Well, what does Bol Dole think?
September 8, 2009 - 22:22 ET by CobraManBob Dole thinks Obama's a doofus!
The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution
Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court
That explains it!
September 8, 2009 - 20:43 ET by Red Jeep"...you no longer need to be in the presence of reporters to make news..."Ah ha! That explains why with tea parties or anything else, if a reporter, professional journalist, is not there...there's no news to report!
And to think all this time I thought the SRM was censoring the news by leaving out stories, but there is no news there if a reporter didn't see something happen...if reporters stick there head in the sand...OK...well, until now when they can be forced to see.
New Issues...Same Old Response
September 8, 2009 - 20:49 ET by txradioguyI imagine King George and the pro English writers of the time felt the same way about the Silence Dogood letters and Federalist Papers that the MSM and the Libs feel about news sources such as NB...Drudge and Fox.
Those that don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
"I May Be Changed By War, But I Will Not Be Defeated By It" - Audie Murphy
The MSM have betrayed the people of the United States.
September 8, 2009 - 21:27 ET by Army BratFoxnews would appear to be the only ones left doing any reporting. If not for them and our radio hosts like Mark Levin, Sean Hannity, Rush Limbaugh and all the rest of the Patriots doing what the traitors of the MSM have failed and are failing to do, we would know nothing of the storm that has descended upon us...for they continue to deny it's existence as the water clearly rises.
I and many others saw it on the horizon, but we were ignored, told that the storm was in our minds when we could clearly hear and see the damned thing coming.
And the boot licking crowds at NBC, CBS, MSLSD, ABC continue to ignore any sign of imperfection in the Won and continue to advance his agenda unread and unconsidered.
Is it any surprise that we have been betrayed? Not to me. The Press long ago elevated themselves far above the mere citizen. They became the judge of what is best for us decades ago. Elitists gauging what is best for the masses.
Knowledge is power. If we have less knowledge, we have less power. Keeping intelligence from us controls intelligence, controls us. That's why they're pissed about losing control of the Truth. They have lost control of us and they don't like it one bit.
Now really...if the American people had known that both of his parents were Communists, do ya think maybe it would have influenced their decision on who to vote for? If they had full knowledge of what kind of people he would place in positions of power, if they had heard him say, I'll Bankrupt the Coal Industry; Your Energy Prices Will Skyrocket. What then?
Thanks to the treasonous acts, and I believe the term is accurate, of the members of the Obama Ministry of Propaganda and Misinformation, we shall never know what a truly and properly informed America would have sought in a President.
My local paper made zero mention of the "resignation" of Jones...same with our local lib TV station. Pathetic.
islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.
"National News"
September 8, 2009 - 20:54 ET by Forbus"The mainstream media love a good fight"....uh, no! The mainstream media love a good fight when a Republican is in power. If they were loving a good fight, now, they would have been all over the Van Jones debacle.
This is all just pure frustration over the fact that Conservatives have found a way around the MSM.
Forbus... Bulls-Eye! Fox
September 8, 2009 - 20:59 ET by bigtimerForbus...
Bulls-Eye!
Fox, internet...radio.
They will do their best to silence us..soon.
'Go Green...Recycle Congress'
"Critics say the White
September 8, 2009 - 20:55 ET by jdhawk"Critics say the White House has been simply unprepared to deal with the ferocity of the conservative push-back” - this is a load of crap.
Look at the videos of the Town Hall meetings and other protests of obama, it will make you sick or kill you, care. The pro obama, it will make you sick or kill you, care had machine printed signs, they were targeted in their messages, they were organized. The con, obama, it will make you sick or kill you, care were scattershot in their messages, had hand painted signs, and unorganized.
Also, note that ABC got this lie in, “the mainstream media love a good fight, even if the charges are unfounded.” The charges were indeed founded. This bill will socialize medicine. It will cause death panels to be formed. It will cause the wonderful drugs that our drug companies have created to cease to be created. It will cause bright, intelligent, highly motivated college students to do anything but go into the practice of medicine. It will cause even the most basic of care to be beyond the average America.
Call, write, or e-mail your elected representatives and tell them you do not want obamacare. Tell them that if they vote in favor of it, that you will do everything within your power to get them out of office in the next election. Just say no to socialism.
This week is the critical week to make those calls, write those letters, or simply send an e-mail off to protest this asinine legislation.
Did Gibson have his little
September 8, 2009 - 21:07 ET by d1carterDid Gibson have his little nose glasses on looking down on the commoners?
I'm so glad these people
September 8, 2009 - 21:11 ET by ThisnThatI'm so glad these people weren't around during the revolution.
"And who is this Paul Revere person? It's up to the town cryers to announce the news, not unsophisticated people who don't have the skills necessary to know what to report. We have learned that Mr. Revere doesn't have any experience in light-house readings, especially at night at long distances. This was simply a wrong-headed attempt at stirring up trouble."
"There is no rational reason to have Minutemen. These people are terroists and need to be watched. Only the Government should be allowed to own guns, and only the Government can take care of us in times of danger. Here at Ye Ol' ABC, we are calling on these radical people to lay down their arms before they cause an incident."
"There was a report today that some racists destroyed a shipment of tea. And why? Because they didn't want to pay their fair share of taxes, that's why! This is just another example of how wealthy individuals are placing the burden of supporting our country directly on the backs of the poor. And to dress up like Native Americans -- that's racism to the core!"
___________________________________
"Tax the rich" is a basically unstable way of governing - The NYT
TnT,
September 8, 2009 - 21:22 ET by R D Helm"I'm so glad these people weren't around during the revolution."
Actually, had they been around then, most of them would have been thrown up against a post and shot.
-Dave
Even when the government tries to kiss you, it is just a prelude to a good screwing. -Neal Boortz
Hey Dave, ya never know
September 8, 2009 - 22:13 ET by Scuba DudeHey Dave, ya never know what might happen if there is another revolution.
"That whenever any form of government becomes destructive to these ends,
it is the right of the people to alter or to abolish it, and to
institute new government, laying its foundation on such principles and
organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely
to effect their safety and happiness."
The Obama Administration: THE most fiscally irresponsible Administration EVER
brings to mind.....
September 8, 2009 - 21:19 ET by jon_torlinYou know, I see crap like this and I keep thinking about Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton.....now that's how you settled things!
Wishful thinking sometimes....
-Jon
O' Reilly showed the first
September 8, 2009 - 21:23 ET by JAJTO' Reilly showed the first interview Gibson had with Sarah Palin. i am reminded of his hubris and all i can think of when i see is picture is "good riddance"
I couldnt care less what ABC shows, i refuse to watch. JAJT
Strange Things are Amiss at the Circle K
September 8, 2009 - 21:29 ET by pbthinkerWhen I saw Pelosi and Reid come out, after their meeting, they seemed to have huge smiles on their faces. They scrupulously avoided a question about a bi-partisan bill with Republicans having input. I wonder if Obama has said he's willing to let them go with reconciliation and push this thing through?
Election 2008-God's way of showing us that elections count.
I heard somewhere that the
September 8, 2009 - 21:35 ET by Free StinkerI heard somewhere that the Senate GOP leadership had a threat should the Democrats use "reconcilliation" to get around the 60 vote requirement to end deabte.
They were going to invoke some sort of "every bill must read aloud" rule, effectively shutting down the Senate. I hope they do. We're safest when (regardless of who runs the show) Congress is not "working".
Doesn't this sound like
September 8, 2009 - 22:17 ET by Scuba DudeDoesn't this sound like something that is happening now?
"He has erected a multitude of new offices, and sent hither swarms of officers to harass our people, and eat out their substance." Can you say czar?
"He has obstructed the administration of justice, by refusing his assent to laws for establishing judiciary powers." Kinda sounds like the Black Panthers case being dropped.
The Obama Administration: THE most fiscally irresponsible Administration EVER
tired of liberal
September 8, 2009 - 22:17 ET by stunnedtired of liberal lies
Bob Dole did not wimp out as he wrote the following in his editorial,
"Many of us were taught that the president proposes and Congress disposes. Today, Congress is doing both -- with the president relegated to the role of cheerleader in chief as he campaigns for various House committees' efforts. Certainly, Obama supports much in these proposals -- but Barack Obama is our president, not a commentator."
Obama voting present again.
Aw, poor guys. It's all
September 8, 2009 - 23:13 ET by AlanaAw, poor guys.
It's all that darned free speech!
Not to worry though. There are those in the administration working on that.
Why would anyone listen to Charles Gibson regarding anything?
September 9, 2009 - 00:07 ET by Rush FanI lost complete respect for this liberal "journalist" when he didn't know the definition of the Bush Doctrine.
Thank goodness he will be gone soon. What a dummie!
------------------------------------------------------------
“Nobody believes what the mainstream media says now anyway. Except the uneducated, the illiterate, and the uninformed -- which, sadly, is a fairly large number” ~ Rush Limbaugh
This country is going to
September 9, 2009 - 00:18 ET by mostlymoderateThis country is going to have a bright future with politics completely out of the hands of the mainstream media.
They still dont get it
September 9, 2009 - 02:39 ET by well99This isnt about conservatives or republicans.It is about Americans wanting to control their own lives.Doesnt matter if you are Repub,Dem or Indep.The goverment is suppose to work for us not control us.The msm doesnt get it because they have the comprehension of a rock.People are not sheep that they can herd down the road to socialism.The media needs to pull their collective heads out of Obama's a$$ and do their frelling job.Their job isnt being cheer leaders for The messiah.
Doing the work that no one else wants to do.
September 9, 2009 - 07:21 ET by KarmaCitizen journalists and the likes of Glenn Beck are the illegal aliens of the media.
Healthcare...Food...Education...Housing... - What sprouted as free for some is maturing into a free-for-all.
G-d forbid that the will of the people might be considered...
September 9, 2009 - 08:20 ET by ThalpyG-d forbid that the will of the people might be considered in any decisions. Obama did get a lot of votes, but he failed to get a lot of votes as well. He was not given a mandate to re-invent the United States of America. He was simply elected President.
September 9, 2009 - 09:05 ET by jessieHABC doesn't have a clue or any reporters. The people they hire to report don't report. They act like union workers. Too lazy to do their jobs. Too lazy to look up any facts. They sold their self respect to obama. CBS, NBC, ect. are the same. I wonder what they see when they look in the mirror.
You betcha. America isn't
September 9, 2009 - 09:48 ET by anonymous621You betcha. America isn't as idiotic and passive as Obama had hoped. Bloggers everywhere are in this fight. Conservatives on the radio are raking in the ratings and letting people know the real deal. The MSM is confused and scared as their strangle-hold on America seems to be slipping away from them. I have heard it said that some people want a revolution. Well, to me, it has already started on the Internet. God bless free speech!
-Eric
ABC News' tries to pull a fast one
September 9, 2009 - 10:47 ET by ArminiusI caught the Dan Harris segment on Nightline last night and did not realize that it played earlier on World News Tonight. I noticed something very peculiar about Harris' claim about Rush Limbaugh and posted a blog item here:
http://cjonline.com/interact/blog/groenhagen/2009-09-09/why_its_difficult_to_trust_the_mainstream_media
“critics say the White
September 9, 2009 - 11:05 ET by G. May“critics say the White House has been simply unprepared to deal with free speech in a democratic society.”
Fixed.