“The problem for Republicans right now is the party doesn't seem big enough for conservatives like [Rush] Limbaugh and moderates like Colin Powell and Senator Arlen Specter,” ABC's Jonathan Karl contended in a Wednesday night World News story on the plight of the GOP which, though framed by anchor Charles Gibson as exploring “whether it can attract new voters by becoming more conservative or more moderate,” came down, no surprise, on the side of those who think the party is already too conservative. Gibson pointed out: “The number of voters who have left the party is growing. In 2003, 31 percent of Americans identified themselves as Republican, 31 percent as Democrat. Now, only one in five say they are a Republican.”
Instead of considering the possibility the party lost support by moving too far to the left by being identified with President Bush's big spending policies or that the congressional leadership is hardly inspiring to conservatives, Karl presumed it's a problem that Dick Cheney, “the most visible Republican in the country these days,” has declared “his preference for Rush Limbaugh over Colin Powell.” Karl featured “Republican strategist” Mark McKinnon who ridiculed Dick Cheney and Rush Limbaugh: “If the Republican party does not expand its tent, it's going to turn into a circus, and it's going to become a minority freak show that sort of features Rush Limbaugh and Dick Cheney.” Karl followed up with how “Senator Lindsey Graham says more moderates is exactly what the party needs.”
Karl failed to inform viewers that “Republican strategist” McKinnon left John McCain's campaign so he wouldn't be part of an effort to oppose Barack Obama's election. “Senator John McCain’s chief advertising strategist, Mark McKinnon, announced Tuesday that he was resigning, following through on a vow he had made months ago not to work against the candidacy of Senator Barack Obama.,” the New York Times reported in May of 2008. “In telling the Cox News Service last June that he would not work against an Obama candidacy, Mr. McKinnon had said that Mr. Obama’s election to the presidency 'would send a great message to the country and the world.'”
The NBC Nightly News also decided to run a piece on Cheney visibility that used him to argue the party must accept non-conservatives. “Cheney's exposure has revealed a new fault line in Republican politics, leaving some to argue that he makes it more difficult for the GOP to re-create itself,” David Gregory relayed, leading into this admonition from former Congressman Tom Davis of Virginia: “Right now, we are at the lowest level of approval that we have had in a generation. So we need to attract converts. We don't need to chase out heretics at this point.”
ABC's Karl concluded with a warning for Democrats: “Democrats shouldn't get overconfident. The last time Republicans were in this big a hole was the late 1970s. Jimmy Carter was in the White House, and Republicans came roaring back just a couple years later with the Reagan Revolution.”
The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the story on the Wednesday, May 13 World News:
CHARLES GIBSON: We're going to take "A Closer Look" at an intense debate in the Republican party – whether it can attract new voters by becoming more conservative or more moderate. The number of voters who have left the party is growing. In 2003, 31 percent of Americans identified themselves as Republican, 31 percent as Democrat. Now, only one in five say they are a Republican. So how does the party stem that tide? Here's Jonathan Karl.JONATHAN KARL: Dick Cheney seems to be everywhere.
JOHN KING, CNN ANCHOR: Former Vice President Dick Cheney here in his first television interview.
BOB SCHIEFFER, ON CBS's FACE THE NATION: Former Vice President is in the studio with us this morning.
NEIL CAVUTO, FNC ANCHOR: Mr. Vice President, welcome. Always good to have you.
KARL: The most visible Republican in the country these days, declaring his preference for Rush Limbaugh over Colin Powell.
DICK CHENEY, ON FACE THE NATION: Well, if I had to choose, in terms of being a Republican, I'd go with Rush Limbaugh, I think.
KARL: And Rush is returning the favor.
RUSH LIMBAUGH CLIP #1: The left is out to destroy Dick Cheney.
LIMBAUGH CLIP #2: They're afraid of Dick Cheney. They are afraid of me.
KARL: The problem for Republicans right now is the party doesn't seem big enough for conservatives like Limbaugh and moderates like Colin Powell and Senator Arlen Specter, who just bolted the party.
MARK MCKINNON, REPUBLICAN PARTY STRATEGIST: If the Republican party does not expand its tent, it's going to turn into a circus, and it’s going to become a minority freak show that sort of features Rush Limbaugh and Dick Cheney.
KARL: One of the few recent bright spots for Republicans is in Florida, where popular Governor Charlie Crist just announced he's running for Senate.
GOVERNOR CHARLIE CRIST (R-FL): And I think that regardless of party, we have to work together to get things done.
KARL: Crist is facing stiff opposition from conservatives who are outraged he supported President Obama's stimulus plan. But Senator Lindsey Graham says more moderates is exactly what the party needs.
SENATOR LINDSEY GRAHAM (R-SC): I don't want to be a party of angry white guys sitting over the, in the corner that nobody listens to and we can't change the nation's policies or be relevant to the future of our nation.
KARL: For his part, Cheney, like Limbaugh, rejects the idea that the party needs to be more moderate to win.
CHENEY ON FNC: I think we will. But I think we'll do it by being true to our principles, not becoming more like the Democrats.
KARL: But Democrats shouldn't get overconfident. The last time Republicans were in this big a hole was the late 1970s. Jimmy Carter was in the White House, and Republicans came roaring back just a couple years later with the Reagan Revolution. Jonathan Karl, ABC News, Capitol Hill.
—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center





MARK MCKINNON, REPUBLICAN PARTY STRATEGIST: If the Republican party does not expand its tent, it's going to turn into a circus, and it’s going to become a minority freak show that sort of features Rush Limbaugh and Dick Cheney.
KARL: For his part, Cheney, like Limbaugh, rejects the idea that the party needs to be more moderate to win.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Inclusion my bare behind
May 14, 2009 - 10:52 ET by DontFeedTheTrollsAnd tell us about the party of inclusion that threw Joe Lieberman under the bus because he disagreed with the party on one, ONE, JUST ONE, issue.
D
Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.
I thik the premise is
May 14, 2009 - 10:56 ET by Chris NormanI thik the premise is "Cheney and Limbaugh bad" and then, in a concerted effort, they find anything and everything they can apply the premise towards - no matter how rickety. If one rightly rejects the premise, all their efforts fall apart.
By the way, why don't they show earlier breakdowns of party identification, when Republicans were at the same point as now? Are they going to lie and say that the upswing was due to the GOP's efforts to recruit "moderate" candidates pre-2003, like who exactly?
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
You're right, Chris. They
May 14, 2009 - 11:14 ET by motherbeltYou're right, Chris. They will move from one target to another, always attempting to paint someone as the "face" of the Republican Party. And always in a bad way. Except for Meghan McCain; then it was what they hoped for ; just another episode of telling Republicans what they "should" do.
Dick Cheney dared to disrespect the liberals' Untouchable...Colin Powell. Cheney said he would prefer Rush in the Republican Party over Powell. Not as a person. And he emphasized his point by asking "Is Colin Powell still a Republican?" Ouch.
Nothing wrong with that.
They might say "Wow, that sucks!" But at least they'll say "Wow!" -Duff Goldman, the Ace of Cakes
Don't Moderates go to the Winner
May 14, 2009 - 11:26 ET by allanfBy their nature don't moderates flock to the party that is most likely to get them elected. Joe Scarborough comes to mind. He was a Repblican but he can play a "moderate" Democrat on MSNBC.
Mother Belt, Tanya
May 14, 2009 - 11:40 ET by Chris NormanMother Belt,
Tanya Reitman, Bill O'Reilly's "body language expert" (and a more worthless feature doesn't exist on his show) tried to show that Cheny was "uncomfortable" when he made the statement that he'd rather have Limbaugh in the party than Powell. She said his shoulders indicated that he wish he hadn't said it. I've noticed that Ms. Reitman has a propensity for confirming Democrats comfort with (the truth of) what they're saying and "observing" Republicans "discomfort". Personally, overall, I think her field of study is little above voodoo and numerology.
The "Mainstream" Media: By liberals. For liberals.
Has anyone seen the sampling
May 14, 2009 - 11:04 ET by Tom PaineHas anyone seen the sampling methodology used to arrive at the conclusions about party identification. I'm sure it was a completely unbiased sample consisting of New York City, Chicago and Los Angeles
Pathological
May 14, 2009 - 13:56 ET by ZuccoZoidHow do you spend your way to prosperity? ANSWER: use taxpayer's money - under the guise of "environment" or "health care" or whatever; gov't produces nothing; they simply take; and the KING PIG rules the trough;
Dissent? Sic the IRS on those Tea Party kooks who actually don't want to pay MORE taxes (even if it's "patriotic" according to Joe Biden); that war being led by Tim Geithner, the purest of all Treasury Sec's (who didn't pay $34k in taxes himself and waited for the statute of limitations to expire - THAT'S how you get WEALTHY in the USA!);
More dissent? You'll be branded a RACIST - code word for destroying life and career; this is DA BOMB as they used to call it; guys like Sharpton et al can rally an army of monsters to stalk, harass and maybe even kill you; and your boss will dump you because naturally that don't want that stuff around;
Yet more dissent? The homo underground is out and running like groundhogs; anal intercourse between men is perfectly normal, and we'll f--k you up the a-- if you disagree; and there are clearly a LOT of homos in gov't; this is one level below the "Racist" tag; not as effective but can still hurt (bend over either way, shmuck!); our so-called friends in the MSM clearly enjoy it on the receiving end;
We have another Janet - this time in charge of Homeland - telling the whole world that Vets and "right wingers" are the real threats; not Islamists;
We get "jokes" about Rush dying, Clarence Thomas dying, Henry Hyde stoned to death, ad nauseum - funny stuff!
Using international media venues to wish death upon anyone who disagrees with the Collective - is funny! it's not "hate speech" of course - never mind the brutal invectives launched against the "evil" Bush/Cheney cabal - so, so evil! Yet it's perfectly ok to BUZZ NYC WITH PHONY JETS and TERRIFY the populace for a goddamn PHOTO OP they decided not to use after all... !
Nope, just another mistake they "inherited" - right?
Funny how they impose their own FATWAs on anyone who disagrees with them; yet WE are branded as "threats" - Orwell would be very, very impressed, or chagrined.
Goodbye America - you're gleefully marching over the cliff like good little lemmings; if you survive the drowning, you'll be charged with waterboarding.
Give up! Give in - be a good servant of the State, and be happy - whatever that is...
http://thepeoplescub...
I am trying to
May 14, 2009 - 11:29 ET by gopsteveI am trying to remember...after the dems lost in 2000, 2002, and 2004, were the msm running the constant drumbeat of "what's wrong with the Democrats?"
Or was it "They just need to get their message out past the GOP attack machine."
In 2004....
May 14, 2009 - 12:07 ET by Prester John....AFTER Bush won and AFTER the GOP picked up 4 Senate seats and AFTER the GOP won 3 more House seats, the networks were all atwitter about how Bush had to "reach out" to the Dems.
And unfortunatly
May 14, 2009 - 12:33 ET by general companyBush did,
My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
Somewhere...
May 14, 2009 - 12:45 ET by Prester John....in all of this there is a lesson, but not one the Beltway GOP is capable of grasping.
"The truth is treason in the Empire of Lies"
www.campaignforliberty.com
No, they reduced their
May 14, 2009 - 12:34 ET by fitzfongNo, they reduced their humiliating loss to a failure to attract "values voters". Their post-election "analysis" consisted of accusing Karl Rove of exploiting the kind of market segmentation approach they're accustomed to using. Rove's "evil strategy" to win large margins of "NASCAR Dads" and "Evangelical Christians" apparently accounted for the entirety of Bush's victory in 2004. In assessing their failure, some Democrat strategists made token references to better appealing to these segments the next time around...but their strategy amounted to slandering the soldiers in an effort to humiliate the Administration, woefully misrepresenting the Katrina disaster as a failure of the Republican President (not the Democrat Governor or Mayor actually responsible) and manufacturing and manipulating a handful of "scandals" (Scooter Libby, Abramoff, Blackwater, Enron, Tom DeLay) to create the "culture of corruption" theme. Unfortunately, the RINOs (concerned more with self-preservation than with principle) played right into their hands by joining in on the Democrat attacks against the Adminstration. Oh, and the Democrat "strategy" to appeal to "values voters" turned into a plan to indoctrinate Christian youth over "stewardship over God's Planet" (read: eco-Marxism for Dummies) and isolate the Christian Evangelicals/NASCAR Dads as fringe kooks who re-elected Bush and, therefore, destroyed the planet, raised gas prices, peddled influence, "outed" a "covert" CIA "Agent" (as opposed to a bimbo desk jockey), failed to protect black people from the ravages of a natural disaster and somehow got rich doing so.
"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery." -Winston Churchill
They just keep pounding the
May 14, 2009 - 11:31 ET by mattmThey just keep pounding the lie, over and over and over and over and over...........puke!
The Dems are the ones with the litmus tests. If your're not pro-gay, pro-abortion, pro-socialism, pro-appeasement, etc. you're not welcome - Oh, they'll allow you to vote for their candidates, but you can't be a candidate with those views - unless you keep your mouth shut and vote with them on legislation.
98 San Jacinto Blvd. Suite
May 14, 2009 - 11:35 ET by Dan The Man 298 San Jacinto Blvd.
Suite 1200
Austin, TX, 78701
Is all we need to know about MARK MCKINNON, REPUBLICAN PARTY STRATEGIST. Austin is full of liberals, and emulates California with fruits and nuts lifestyle. Austin's "Keep Austin Wierd" campaign is proof enough. He is nothing more than a mercenary selling out to teh highest bidder and he sold out to Obama.
I think we should watch what the MSM is telling us, but I imagine it confuses some of the fence sitters. We should define our party and look to scripture to know what to do. As steel sharpens steeel we should do for each other. We should not hide our light under a bushel but shine light into darkness because the darkness cannot abide the light.
Last I checked, these
May 14, 2009 - 11:43 ET by freecitizenLast I checked, these establishment Republicans have already turned us into a minority freak show. Or do they have some some hidden majority voting bloc that we are unaware of? Sorry fella, all the damage that you fear those fringe conservatives are going to do has already been done by you and your squishy ilk.
McCain was the "moderate" poster-child. If he's not moderate enough such that you still voted for Obama, then you have to face the fact that you are in the wrong party. Or admit that you cast your vote based on race. Powell doesn't speak for me and I'd appreciate it if he'd stop speaking at me.
Liberal: remove all that's Right, and this is what's Left.
"... and moderates like
May 14, 2009 - 11:49 ET by IgnatzJFahrquar"... and moderates like Colin Powell and Senator Arlen Specter"
Saw that and did not read another word of the story.
"You should always tell the truth, because if you tell the truth you make it the other person's problem." Sean Connery
I don't buy an eighteen
May 14, 2009 - 11:57 ET by eaglewingz08I don't buy an eighteen point gap. Rasmussen has the gap much less than this fraudulent poll. However if there has been any shrinkage it is because you can't beat a real democrap with a democrap lite. If both are in favor of big spending and big government, then the public will go to the real thing rather than the RINO.
Stories like these simply
May 14, 2009 - 12:04 ET by fitzfongStories like these simply illustrate what ignorant, shallow individuals Mark McKinnon and Lindsey Graham are. One need only look to the example of Arnold Schwarzenegger to see what RINO "governance" is like...half-hearted rhetoric about preserving business, lowering taxes and slashing irresponsible government spending; followed by bluster about "bringing Republicans and Democrats together" (as if that was an inherent virtue); followed by a limp campaign to address the spending issues; followed by a cowardly surrender to the thugs in the State Unions; followed by the annexation of a trendy junk science-based policy in image makeover campaign designed to win support from the socialists who defeated his weak campaign for passage of some responsible ballot initiatives; followed by a complete surrender to the budget desires of the pinkos in the State Legislature; followed by a campaign of arm twisting and threats at Republican legislators who refused to surrender with him; followed by the surrender of a handful of Lindsey Graham/Mark McKinnon/John McCain/David Frum/David Brooks/Spray Tan Crist "Republicans" in the State Legislature, endorsing the largest tax increase in the history of the State; followed by grass roots voter revolt in the face of a heavy-handed tactics designed to force taxpayers to ratify these obnoxious tax increases; followed by desperate and disingenuous attempts by the Governor to secure last-minute support by threatening to cut off police, fire and other essential services (and to open the prisons) rather than standing up to the fat, lazy, incompetent and greedy SEIU GOONS; followed by...if the State is lucky...bankruptcy. Sorry, but Graham, McCain, Snowe, Collins, Crist and Schwarzenegger are cancers on the Republican Party...and either they're going to stand down/leave the Party or those of us who refuse to tolerate their mismanagement are simply going to stop supporting the Republican Party altogether. This is not some minor "dust up" from which both wings of the Party will emerge united. This is a war for the soul of the Party...and if they win, they can have it. It's damaged goods.
By the way, I am so sick and tired of this clash being defined by the media and the RINOs. They always misrepresent this battle as a fight between "moderates" and "social conservatives". Strictly speaking, this is not about abortion, the 2nd Ammendment and gay marriage (though people who have strong opinions on these issues are on the right side of this debate)...this is about a bloated and self-serving government refusing to address the real issues at the root of the economic crisis: entitlement spending, union payoffs and failure to address the consequences of unfettered illegal immigration. RINOs are ignorant of and/or afraid to address these subjects, so they punt, turn on their base and wag their fingers about "big tents" and "intolerance". They change the subject to abortion, guns and gay marriage (because there's no math nor economics involved) in an attempt to shame base conservatives and win support from intellectually incoherent "moderates". Sorry, but the line is drawn in the sand now. I will never support a RINO candidate...if a Republican candidate earns a David Frum/Ross Douthat/Colin Powell endorsement, I will support the Democrat.
"Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery." -Winston Churchill
The deep concern shown by
May 14, 2009 - 12:07 ET by snaggletoothieThe deep concern shown by the Democrats and their apparatchiks for the health of the Republican party is heart warming. The true spirit of nonpartisanship is at work here.
the death of the GOP
May 14, 2009 - 13:03 ET by east tennessee johnFirst, why should the Dems care as long as they're winning elections and controlling the government? The public are generalky front runners and the next election is not going t be based on the cult of personality as this one was. As taxes rise so will prices in order to pay for them. You don't expect the people being taxed to eat them do you? If they do, instead of them being inflationary, they will be deflationary and where will the growth come from to generate the tax revenues we'll need to pay the deficits we know we're going to have? What about the increase in intrest rates, in order to get our creditors to buy our debt, what economic impact will that have? Higher borrowing costs for sure, economy wide. How will that contribute to economic growth and increased tax revenues? It won't. How about additional inflation caused by the expansion of the money supply by the FED? Think that might have an impact that transcends the cult of the personality? Then there are the wars. Comrade O can "finesse" his way around Iraq, maybe, but as a supporter of the Afghan war he has no such option. All these beltway RINO strategists aren't worth a bucket of spit. The Great Obama may find himself in a LBJ box on the one hand and a Carter box on the other, simutaneously. Even the most ignorant of RINO "statgerists" and MSM who can read an actual history book knows either 1 of these 2 boxes led to 2 elections of Nixon and 2 of Reagan. Just keep the faith and don't buy into their bullshit.
Specter is not an DEM!!!!
May 14, 2009 - 15:08 ET by NortoDid they miss that fact. I loved Cheney's retort when asked about Powell, "Is he still a Republican?" Schieffer almost choked, I guess, don't watch Tv.
As Usual
May 14, 2009 - 15:41 ET by DoktorFrankenAs usual, the Left attempts to define us. And fails.
'' . . . moderates like Colin Powell and Senator Arlen Specter, who just bolted the party.''
Colin and Arlen were not Moderates. But they are traitors to the Conservative way of living.
Every time you hear the Left talking about what the GOP or Republicans or Conservatives are, or should be, they are framing the situation or argument in their terms and by their rules. It is so Alinsky motivated and transparent that I am surprised that they think they can affect us. And since the Left gets most of their news from Jon Stewart and Colbert I wonder why they bother.
Expanding the tent=shutting conservatives up
May 14, 2009 - 18:15 ET by nkviking75I guess "expanding the tent" means chasing the conservatives out, or at least shutting them up.
Also, when a Republican bails out of the party, their decision is the conservatives fault.
Makes sense to me.
Not.
When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.