Obsessing over Sarah Palin's pro-life position on abortion, MSNBC hosts and reporters on Tuesday night repeatedly raised it and painted it as a detriment to Republicans even though last week with Democrats the channel did not similarly pursue how a solidly left view on abortion might hurt Obama and Biden. By the count of the MRC's Geoff Dickens, between 8 PM and midnight EDT, MSNBC raised abortion at least 16 times, twice with an edge that painted the GOP position as extreme by applying a “hard right” label. Chris Matthews declared “they are going hard right on abortion rights” and later David Gregory asserted: “The abortion platform here is pretty hard right.”
Chuck Todd, Political Director for NBC News, fretted over how “this is as stringent of a platform on abortion the Republican Party ever has. And the problem is” that “these delegates are more conservative than even the ones four years ago.” Andrea Mitchell described Palin as “very conservative” and pressed a Republican Congressman: “Now there are a lot of women in that area who are less conservative socially than Sarah Palin. There are a lot of women who believe in choice. So how do you square the circle there?”
Matthews bemoaned to Tom Ridge that “it seems like you got a convention saluting a vice presidential nominee who wants to outlaw abortion, period, across the country. Is this going too far?” To Tim Pawlenty, Matthews demanded:
Do you believe you can win with the cultural statement being made by the selection of Governor Palin? That statement being someone from the very culturally conservative part of your party?
Highlights from MSNBC's Tuesday, September 2 coverage of the Republican convention, as gathered by Geoff:
ANDREA MITCHELL TO PENNSYLVANIA REP. JOE PITTS (8:12 PM EDT):
Now there are a lot of women in that area who are less conservative socially than Sarah Palin. There are a lot of women who believe in choice. So how do you square the circle there?
TOM BROKAW AND CHUCK TODD (8:20 PM EDT):
TOM BROKAW: And the Republican Party platform, which was passed under the direction of Senator Richard Burr of North Carolina, he said they reached out across the country electronically, and otherwise, to put together the platform. When it came to abortion, no exceptions. Rape, incest, didn’t make any difference, they were opposed to abortion. That is Senator, pardon men, Governor Palin’s position as well but it has not been John McCain’s position.
CHUCK TODD: Well what’s interesting is that Gary Bauer, the onetime presidential candidate, was, was John McCain’s representative on the platform trying to, trying to soothe everything. And they made the decision not to fight these delegates here on this issue. Senator McCain, this platform does not represent Senator McCain’s conservatism. He did not make it his party’s platform. He made it the Republican Party platform, that he happens to be representing. Stark contrast to Barack Obama who went ahead, changed the wording on abortion, put in a line in there that made pro-life Democrats a little more comfortable. That was not done here. If anything this is as stringent of a platform on abortion the Republican Party ever has. And the problem is this. These delegates are more conservative -- I had, I had -- than, than even the ones four years ago. Than even the ones eight years ago. I had a state chair tell me that people ran to be John McCain’s delegates in places like Michigan and Ohio, after the process, and they were more conservative than the people they were replacing. He’s like, this guy goes, “They aren’t John McCain Republicans, they just came here."
MITCHELL TO SENATOR ARLEN SPECTER (8:23 PM EDT):
I’m with Arlen Specter of course. Senator you represent a lot of pro-choice women, a lot of liberals, how does Sarah Palin play among your constituents in Pennsylvania?
CHRIS MATTHEWS (8:35 PM EDT):
Bottom line here, they are going hard right on abortion rights.
RACHEL MADDOW: Yes they are bringing back the most divisive social wedge issue that we’ve got and they are going double-down on it.
[PAT BUCHANAN noted Obama is “hard left” on abortion]
MATTHEWS: And then, and then, but Pat it’s further than that. It is further because, not taking any position on this, they are taking a stronger position. Governor Palin supports the abolition of abortion as a right, period! She doesn’t just say, throw it back to the states. She says, “If I got any say in this we’re gonna outlaw it.” Right? Isn’t that true?
DAVID GREGORY TO CHRISTIE TODD WHITMAN (8:49 PM EDT):
Does this convention represent a move to the center?You may be talking about governing, but as a matter of campaigning he’s moved to the right. The abortion platform here is pretty hard right when it comes to the abortion question with which you have some disagreement, I think, with the party still.
CHRIS MATTHEWS TO TOM RIDGE (9:02 PM EDT):
Governor Ridge the moderate wing of the Republican Party is atrophying right now as you watch on television. Sununu’s got a tough race facing him. There’s one Republican left in the entire New England delegation of Congress. You’re under fire, you’re getting smaller and smaller. And tonight it seems like you got a convention saluting a vice presidential nominee who wants to outlaw abortion, period, across the country. Is this going too far?
MITCHELL TO CARLY FIORINA, FORMER CEO OF HEWLETT-PACKARD (9:04 PM EDT):
Now she is more socially conservative than a lot of independent women and a lot of Democratic women, Hillary Clinton women. You were trying to reach out to Hillary Clinton women. And what would be the appeal here of Sarah Palin for someone who believes in choice and who, you know, doesn’t believe in her views on creationism, intelligent design. She is very conservative, socially.
MATTHEWS TO MINNESOTA GOVERNOR TIM PAWLENTY (9:27 PM EDT):
Well let ask you about this, this whole question of the culture of the Republican Party. Both political parties, the Democratic Party and the Republican Party to win the presidency have to win a majority support of the country, something like 50 percent to win. Do you believe you can win with the cultural statement being made by the selection of Governor Palin? That statement being someone from the very culturally conservative part of your party? Is it gonna work?
MATTHEWS ON ABORTION WITH REP. HEATHER WILSON, OLBERMANN REBUTS WILSON (11:46 PM EDT):
MATTHEWS: Let me ask you about the very tricky issue or troubling concern of abortion rights. Did it surprise you, that, that came up a number of times tonight? And do you think that will create enough of a majority, going into the election, this November, for the Republican candidates?REP. HEATHER WILSON: Well the Republican Party is pro-life and, and I think that’s an important issue for a lot of folks in the Republican Party. It’s also a big contrast with Senator Obama, who is not only pro-choice, or, or but has taken some votes including in the Illinois State Senate against, you know, the Born Alive Act, which is, to me, just incomprehensible. And I, so, so there’s a very big difference for folks. And it’s important to Republicans.
MATTHEWS: Tell us about that issue, the Born Alive vote, back in the early part of this century, 2002, 2003. What was that about? Why is that worthy of note tonight and Senator Thompson raised that in his discussion, in his speech tonight.
WILSON: Because what it said was if a child, if someone, if someone tries to abort a child and the child, rather than being aborted and born dead, is born alive, then they should be given medical assistance. And it came out of a case where a nurse held a baby while the baby died and was prohibited from providing any life support to that child. And it was just wrong. And it’s, and it’s, it’s, and Senator Obama said, “No let them die.” And I, I just find that to be deeply troubling. Very, very troubling and I think a lot of people here did tonight. It’s something that really goes to the core of what being pro-life is about.
MATTHEWS: How do you square that deep concern about life and opposition abortion with hosting Joe Lieberman tonight, a very strong supporter of abortion rights, at your convention?
OLBERMANN: To be fair to Senator Obama, Representative Wilson was not complete in that context of what she said. Senator Obama, at no point, said, “Let them die.” What he, his argument was, in voting against that measure in the Illinois state legislature, was that extant law, the laws that were already on the books in Illinois, fully covered that horrific situation. And I believe Representative Wilson knows that.
—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center





TOM BROKAW: And the Republican Party platform, which was passed under the direction of Senator Richard Burr of North Carolina, he said they reached out across the country electronically, and otherwise, to put together the platform. When it came to abortion, no exceptions. Rape, incest, didn’t make any difference, they were opposed to abortion. That is Senator, pardon men, Governor Palin’s position as well but it has not been John McCain’s position.
Bottom line here, they are going hard right on abortion rights.
Now she is more socially conservative than a lot of independent women and a lot of Democratic women, Hillary Clinton women. You were trying to reach out to Hillary Clinton women. And what would be the appeal here of Sarah Palin for someone who believes in choice and who, you know, doesn’t believe in her views on creationism, intelligent design. She is very conservative, socially.













Editor at Large
Comments Policy
And Obama's view that
September 3, 2008 - 05:33 ET by motherbeltAnd Obama's view that abortion should be permitted at any time up to birth, and if the baby happens to survive the procedure, should be left to die, isn't "hard left"?
As for Sen. Obama not saying "Let them die"....they never do. They always have other "technical" reasons for opposing things like the PBA ban and BAIPA.
By his vote Obama said "Let
September 3, 2008 - 08:54 ET by misterbee241By his vote Obama said "Let them die."
Sorry, I cant come up with an expletive adequate enough to apply to Olbermann. Or Obama either for that matter.
Find the memo
September 3, 2008 - 05:49 ET by KC MulvilleObviously, the heads of MSNBC communicated their strategy to their reporters:
Hillary = abortion. Therefore, Hillary voters = pro-abortion. We at MSNBC must not allow the McCain campaign to appeal to women. Therefore, at every opportunity, hammer home the fact that McCain and Palin are pro-life, to make sure that women won't fall for the GOP pitch.
They're not hiding their agenda at all, are they?
This is for Popular Tech......
September 3, 2008 - 06:27 ET by old croI hope you awake and read/respond to this post.....
I have been reading/commenting at this site for the past two years. I come
here to read stories and comments regarding the liberal bias that is evident in
the MSM. It is enjoyable reading this site early in the mornings when I awake,
it keeps me informed and educated but most of all amused at the plethora of
witty comments posted by others (you know who you are). I have responded to
objectionable people in the past with invective not particularly nice. Don't
get me wrong, I enjoy your many lists and most comments, but STFU already with
your personal campaign against Sarah Palin. I am already tired of reading your
derogatory comments when perusing articles posted here. Take a break and let
life get hold of you, for it surely will go on. I am commenting like this
because you are impeding my enjoyment of this site, commenting everywhere on
someone (I don't know this for sure) you know nothing about and can do nothing
about. End
Isn't it interesting that since McCain’s announcement,
the big O's acceptance speech and all the blathering that normally would have
followed has been wiped off the headlines? This pick for VP (IMHO) must be very
strong because she knew what would be coming if she accepted, maybe not the
level of vitriol but the type, and she went for it anyway.
Abortion Has Become The Central Attack Issue for Liberals
September 3, 2008 - 06:28 ET by BrutusThe media are obsessed over Palin's pro-life stand because they no it highlights a key difference between their party and the powerful evangelicals and pro-lifers.
Attacks will only increase as their desparation rises. I blogged about it at The Right Opposition at http://www.rightoppo... .
Thanks for your post
If abortion is so wonderful
September 3, 2008 - 08:06 ET by kgIf abortion is so wonderful then why is it an election issue on every single election for the last 30 years?
Answer: Because it is wrong and they know it. Every woman I have ever known that had an abortion has deeply regretted it and that for decades afterwards.
"Forget change, I want improvement!"
Implicit bias
September 3, 2008 - 09:14 ET by seldumondeNotice how Andrea Mitchell frames her question - "there are a lot of women who believe in choice." That is putting the questions in the terms used by the pro-choicers. It infuriates pro-choicers when you frame the debate in a pro-life manner - describing people as either pro-life, or pro-abortion, pro-death, anti-life, etc. Similarly it irritates me when the debate is framed as she did - as if there is no life involved, just a "choice."
This is the kind of subtle bias you find all over the media. It supports my belief that media bias is more a factor of worldview or mindset than willful actions. People like Andrea are just used to seeing things in a certain way, and they simply cannot understand pro-lifers because they likely don't know any.