Four Times More Journalists Identify as Liberal Than Conservative

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

A survey conducted late last year and released Monday, by the Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, confirmed the obvious -- that compared to the views of the public, conservatives are under-represented in national journalism while liberals are over-represented. Jennifer Harper of the Washington Times discovered the nugget buried deep in the annual “State of the Media” report from Pew's Project for Excellence in Journalism and FNC's Brit Hume on Tuesday night highlighted the findings from the survey of 222 journalists and news executives at national outlets:

Only six percent said they considered themselves conservatives and only two percent said they were very conservative. This compares with 36 percent of the overall population that describes itself as conservative. Most journalists, 53 percent, said they're moderate. 24 percent said they were liberal and eight percent very liberal.

Only 19 percent of the public consider themselves liberal. And it's not much of a leap to presume many of the 53 percent who describe themselves as “moderate” are really quite liberal.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Hume's item on the March 18 Special Report with Brit Hume on FNC:

A newly released survey indicates that conservatives in the national press corps are a lonely lot. 585 [the total of national, local and Internet] journalists were polled by the Project for Excellence in Journalism. Only six percent said they considered themselves conservatives and only two percent said they were very conservative. This compares with 36 percent of the overall population that describes itself as conservative.

Most journalists, 53 percent, said they're moderate. 24 percent said they were liberal and eight percent very liberal. The Washington Times quotes project deputy director Amy Mitchell as saying that the findings are about the same as in a similar survey done four years ago.

The MRC's “Media Bias Basics” has a section with the numbers from 2004, which are indeed very similar.

Harper's March 18 Washington Times article: “Right underrepresented in press's diversity.”

The political ideology question is #36 on page 55 of the PDF with the results for the survey conducted September 17 to December 3, 2007. For national broadcast journalists (97 polled), zero percent call themselves “very conservative” while 6 percent said they are “very liberal.”

Overall, only 8 percent of those at national outlets attend church or synagogue weekly.

The political ideology results were summarized in “Section III” of the report released on March 17 by the Pew Research Center for the People and the Press, “Financial Woes Now Overshadow All Other Concerns for Journalists The Web: Alarming, Appealing and a Challenge to Journalistic Values.” The relevant portion:

Journalists' Ideology

As was the case in 2004, majorities of the national and local journalists surveyed describe themselves as political moderates; 53% of national journalists and 58% of local journalists say they are moderates. About a third of national journalists (32%), and 23% of local journalists, describe themselves as liberals. Relatively small minorities of national and local journalists call themselves conservatives (8% national, 14% local).

Internet journalists as a group tend to be more liberal than either national or local journalists. Fewer than half (46%) call themselves moderates, while 39% are self-described liberals and just 9% are conservatives.

Among the population as a whole, 36% call themselves conservatives -- more than triple the percentage of national and internet journalists, and more than double the percentage of local journalists. About four-in-ten (39%) characterize their political views as moderate, while 19% are self-described liberals, based on surveys conducted in 2007 by the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press.

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

There is no such thing as moderate

moderate only means you don't have the courage to admit what you are or are too stupid to know.

If you took moderate away as a choice and made them pick one or the other, 90% of the so called moderates would probably break to the liberal side.

Dee, what would I be?

I spend all day mocking liberals AND conservatives. If they're not going to mention the evil L-word, and apparently they're not, where else would I fit on their political line if the "moderate" choice vanished???
JMR

A corruption-story the TV media will-not cover.

Sarc - do you really think you are moderate?

You seem to have very strong convictions and I'd never call you a moderate. I'd call you a conservative. Being conservative doesn't mean that you have to agree with Republican politicians. There are libertarians who are very liberal and some are very conservative and from the things you say I'd definitely put you in the conservative camp.

Some may consider you liberal on social issues, but I don't. I see the libertarian view on social issues completely differently than liberal's views. I think you would favor judges like Scalia, Alito and Roberts over Ginsberg and Suetor. I think the judges someone prefers and the Supreme court rulings that the agree disagree with are a better indicator of their conservative or liberal slant than what politicians they support.

I doubt you agree with the liberal Kelo vs New London or even Roe V Wade and would agree with the conservative judges much more often.

There is no moderate in politics. There is moderate in personality and I don't think either you or I posses that either ; )

I don't consider myself a moderate

But, especially these days, I don't think I fit in with "liberal" or "conservative" either, unless I'm among the politically literate and can get away with "classical liberal," which probably best describes my views. My main point is the lack of an L-word choice on such surveys, especially in view of the decades of success of the quiz, seems not too bright if Pew is trying to honestly measure human (or journalist) political diversity. Antilibertarian bias -- it's a media accuracy problem even beyond goring my ox.
JMR

A corruption-story the TV media will-not cover.

Numbers scewed even further

The "moderate" label is subjective. Most liberal journalists consider themselves "moderates," as they associate mostly with like-minded people. I would bet if the "moderates" started explaining their political views, you'd find the overwhelming majority of them are decidedly liberal. 

You are correct

The left do believe they are the mainstream of the U.S.

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

As fast as circulation

As fast as circulation numbers are sinking for newspapers and national magazines there's fixin' to be a bunch of unemployed liberal writers.

"Moderate" is the mask that

"Moderate" is the mask that Liberalism wears to get in and be accepted.

fair and say what?

This would explain the gnashing of teeth and rending of garments displayed by the media at the mere mention of fair and balanced.

No question, in the context

No question, in the context of this survey, Moderate = Liberal.