On Holiday, Gibson Trumpets How France 'Requires 31 Vacation Days'

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

Fretting over how “Americans give back 438 million vacation days a year” when they could be “sitting on a beach,” ABC anchor Charles Gibson concluded the Presidents’ Day World News by channeling envy of European socialist rules as he complained that “America is the only major country in the world that has no government-mandated time off.” Citing how “psychologists say people are better workers, less stressed, if they take their time,” he helpfully suggested “you might consider moving to France. There, the government requires 31 vacation days plus holidays.” No mention, of course, of how that (plus a 35-hour work week) hurts French productivity and job creation, to say nothing of requiring significant immigration.

The anchor of the newscast on the network owned by Disney showed a picture of smiling vacationers with Mickey Mouse before he ended by noting: “And someone asked me today, ‘Why are you making a big deal of this? You're at work today.’ Good point.”

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Yearning for European time-off mandates is nothing new for the networks, particularly NBC’s Today show. A few examples I quickly found in the MRC’s archive, and these don’t include the more common calls to follow Europe’s lead in mandating paid maternity and family leave:

CNN contributor Polly LaBarre on In the Money, June 9, 2007:

"We work longer hours, we work harder, we work with fewer breaks than any other industrialized nation on Earth....To put this in perspective, we work more than medieval peasants used to work....We’re a country that has no mandated paid vacation whereas the European Union has a floor of 20 days and vacation champs like France and Sweden offer 39, 40 paid days."

Katie Couric, April 4, 2005 Today show:

"So many Americans feel overworked, and I have a statistic — 30 percent do not take their full vacation. I mean, is there something wrong with this picture? Are we too obsessed with work, because the Europeans sure have a very different attitude don’t they?"

NBC’s Today, August 1, 2001:

Keith Miller: "Break out the band, bring on the drinks. The French are calling it a miracle. A government-mandated 35-hour work week is changing the French way of life. Two years ago, in an effort to create more jobs, the government imposed a shorter work week on large companies, forcing them to hire more workers....These American women, all working in France, have time for lunch and a life."
Avivah Wittenberg-Cox: "More Americans should be more aware that an economy as successful as the French one managed to be successful without giving up everything else in life."
Katie Couric, following the end of Miller’s taped piece: "So great that young mother being able to come home at three every day and spend that time with her child. Isn’t that nice? The French, they’ve got it right, don’t they?"

Matt Lauer to Escape magazine’s Joe Robinson, a proponent of mandated vacation, June 12, 2000 Today show:

"Americans are working more and getting less vacation time than people in any other industrialized nation....I feel strange saying, I never stopped to think about the fact there is no official U.S. policy on vacation time."

The MRC’s Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript from the end of the Monday, February 18 World News on ABC:

CHARLES GIBSON: Finally tonight, did you work today? It is, after all, a federal holiday, Washington's birthday. It's a holiday in many states, as well. But we learned today Americans are apparently uncomfortable taking days away from work. Consider this number: It is estimated Americans give back 438 million vacation days a year, 438 million. People could be sitting on a beach, taking pictures of themselves in front of famous landmarks, playing golf, just kicking back reading a book. But no, they work. America is the only major country in the world that has no government-mandated time off. 75 percent of Americans do get paid vacation, 14 days the average. But then the average worker gives back three of those days. Why do we do this to ourselves?

SUSAN GINSBERG, WORK AND FAMILY LIFE NEWSLETTER: People are scared that if they leave and if they're away for a few weeks that something is going to happen, and that they're not going to, that somebody's going take their job.

GIBSON: And when Americans do take time off, 60 percent of us are checking office e-mails. IBM might as well stand for "Infernal Beach Machine." But the thing is, psychologists say people are better workers, less stressed, if they take their time. So you might consider moving to France. There, the government requires 31 vacation days plus holidays. And someone asked me today, "Why are you making a big deal of this? You're at work today." Good point. That's World News for this holiday. I'm Charlie Gibson. I hope you had a good day. For all of us at ABC News, have a good night.

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I seriously doubt that

I seriously doubt that katie or charles got to where they are by working 35 hours a week and taking 31 days off a year

 

"give me a break!" - John Stossel

Wow with all of these great

Wow with all of these great countries out there, I shocked that there is anyone in the news rooms at all..

All I can say is...  GO,we will not keep a light on for you.

 

 

 

Ronald Reagan, 1962: I did not leave the Democratic party, the party left me.

Insert: your name, 2008, and the Republican party.

"No mention, of course, of

"No mention, of course, of how that (plus a 35-hour work week) hurts
French productivity and job creation, to say nothing of requiring
significant immigration."

He also failed to mention how that "luxury" is paid for by high taxes.

"An armed society is a polite society. Manners are good when one may have to back up his acts with his life." --Robert A. Heinlein, "Beyond This Horizon", 1942

So how come I work with a

So how come I work with a French woman who left France to come here to work so she could get ahead? hmmm? If France was so great.

WhatAMaroon

Is he really so ignorant?

He mentions France...where their work related policies are strangling the economy and with which, most of the French employers at least, have had their fill and are trying to get changed.

Moron? Or does he have a bias?

Happy Trails...

Moron? Or does he have a


Moron? Or does he have a bias?

All of the above?

And yes, those wacky socialist vacationers a couple of years ago took off for the beaches and left their elderly parents sweltering (and dying) in over 100 degree heat in their apartments. But hey, they're entitled to their month-long vacations, dammit!

Not to mention the fact that the laziness of the Frence is the reason they haven't even bothered with air conditioning, for crying out loud!

Ah, yes, the French Utopia. Money for not working...oh, wait, they don't need money. The government gives them everything!

This is why France allows massive immigration of Muslims: they need workers to pay taxes. And it's also why they are afraid to annoy those "youths" who will rampage at the drop of a hat.

Check out this article from City Journal. This is how bad it was in 2002.

Oh, you think it must have gotten better since then? Then check out this story from 2005.

Anyone heard or seen any stories since then, that say the situation is improving?

"Anyone heard or seen any

"Anyone heard or seen any stories since then, that say the situation is improving?"

Nope. Read Mark Steyn's "America Alone." If anything, it's getting worse, and not just in France, but all across Europia.

Wonderful France

Of course Charlie Gibson is going to extol the
virtues of France as he is a rich 7 figure salary elitist. Any rich person would love mandatory vacations and only working a few hours a week.

First that means money does not change hands so you are in power like a monarchy. Second it means the poor stay POOR so they don't infest your rich private beaches. Third it means only your family has opportunity for any position in life as it is heridtary.

Look at ole heart condition Charlie Rose. He had his ticker operation in France, because he could afford and he had position. All that matters is social order in France and most Frogs are about where the Nazi's left them in poverty.

This is why Sarkozy is attempting to Reaganize France like eastern Europe is Reaganized so French people will have the opportunity to prosper.

Gibson is just a self centered jerk.

 

*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS

Libs

Ask any "liberal" and he will tell you how ANY country is "better" than America. Ask the Obamas and they'll tell you how America needs to "change". Michelle Obama will tell you there's nothing to be proud of here, except her husband. Yet the libs live in America and will stay living in America until the end of their lives. And the most vocal of them will be financially better off than most other Americans. Logic, rationality, and love of country are not their strong suits. Sad.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"

 

America is the BEST place on the planet to start your own

business..

If you do REALLY REALLY well you will be able to take off 365.24 days a year.

delegate man delegate.

A new and improved "rifleman" 37 sec.

Iranian uranium; Iranian ICBM's; Iranian satellites..CHANGE is comming BELIEVE in that!

 

U.S. policy on vacation time?

What?  Obamanation , Hellry, have yet to weigh in on this issue?  I want to roll up my sleeves, go to work, and demand that my success be compensated , With all the great virtues of the wonderful example of france...sarc tag /  needed...

Hot flash for katie

katie, I ACTUALLY STAYED HOME WITH MY SON. Shocking isn't it-and that was here in the good old USA. Not just four days a week, but the WHOLE week. I have been back at work for a few years now in an ER, but the best days of my life were spent with my son as he grew up. Not only that, but I (gasp) home-schooled him from age 8 on.

I will also cross post with another topic here in NB; I am way older than michelle obama, but I have been proud and grateful to be an American my whole life. AND my one visit to France many years ago was more than enough.

“America is the only

“America is the only major country in the world that has no government-mandated time off.”

And we're the world's only superpower; wonder if there's some sort of relationship there?

“America is the only

“America is the only major country in the world that has no government-mandated time off.”

And we're the world's only superpower; wonder if there's some sort of relationship there?

"That's warm, friendly

"That's warm, friendly France for you..."

-- Grace Kelly, TO CATCH A THIEF

 

We bid a fond farewell to Professor Talking Points & Cheetos

Why should they care how

Why should they care how many hours we work? The French pay for those "vacations" through their taxes. This is nothing more than drive-bys trying to sell socialism to to the stupid and ignorant!

French loafers.

Last time I checked, France had an unemployment rate hovering a tick over eight percent.

If we had a similar rate here, Charlie and his minions would be screaming imminent depression!

The best part is

The best part is that they have averaged 10% unemployment for decades. In France, you have a one in ten chance of not having to go to work at all, those lucky dogs!

 In fact, the economy is so great that the youth get together regularly around cheery bonfires to let the government know how much they appreciate France's economic policy.

 My problem is trying to decide which country's citizens to eny more: France or Denmark.

Guessing...

I didn't see this story, but I am guessing that in Charlie's haste to gush over French Socialism, he didn't mention the fact that unemployment has hovered between 8-10% over the past 25 years.  Nor did he mention the confiscatory rates of taxation.  Nor their debt.  Nor the fact that in a poll taken two years ago, 75% of French 15-24 year olds identified their dream job as working for the government.

I'll take the dynamic United States over going absolutely nowhere France. 

Res tantum valet quantum vendi potest.

Envying France: media-clowns are pathetic

Yes, the folks whose sole ambitions are driven by self-entitlement and milking the cows for zilch, usually socialists, consider numerous vacation days a divine right.

Ironic, how these media clowns love, loathsome, France; a nation founded on superciliousness and haughtiness.

This is where America is heading if Obama or Hillary takes over the White House: God help us!

As of January, 2008, the

As of January, 2008, the unemployment rate in France was 8.3%.

France

If Charlie thinks things are so wonderful in France------? Simple, Charlie.  Pack your bags, renounce your American citizenship, and head for your Eden of Europe.  I'm sure you'll be sooooo happy!

Capitalists and a free-market!!!!

Essentially, the only people who work on Christmas and Thanksgiving are some healthcare workers. Since we live in the best free-market society in the world, the market actually took care of our holidays. Enough people wanting vacation on these two holidays plus enough companies getting no business on these two holidays equals two national holidays.

Most companies give employees about twenty days of vacation/sick leave plus nine or ten holidays, and that is at entry level. The higher you go, the more vacation you get. If you don't get vacation, read a book, take a test, and move your career out of McDonald's.

Also, we have more drive to succeed in this country.

I don't want the government interfering with my work or life any more than they already have.

What a joke

The top of the t.v. news business is full of hardcore, workaholic careerists who make Japanese workers look like the French by comparison.  Not only do these people give up vacations, they also give up having normal relationships.  Divorces are common and their kids are strangers.  Give me a break.