“There is a noticeable trend under way. A growing stream of Iraqis who left to escape the killing, many of them going to Syria, now reversing their migration,” anchor Brian Williams highlighted Tuesday evening as the NBC Nightly News became the first broadcast network evening newscast to air a full report on the trend.
From Baghdad, reporter Tom Aspell showcased a mother who exclaimed: “I'm so excited” and “I can't wait to get back.” Aspell explained: “Though safer, life in Syria turned out to be hard. $300 a month rent and food for the family of seven wiped out their savings. So when the Iraqi government offered free bus tickets to Baghdad, today's opportunity was too good to miss.” Adding the caveat that a safer Iraq is not the main motivator, Aspell noted: “A recent UN survey at registration centers found most Iraqi refugees are returning home not because Iraq is any safer, but because they're running out of money, and Syria is clamping down on visas.” Aspell, however, acknowledged upbeat trends: “Refugees coming back to Baghdad are going to see a lot of changes. There are more people in the streets, shops are open and traffic everywhere.” Though Aspell pointed out how “it is still a dangerous city. There are kidnappings, shootings and bomb blasts every day,” another mother, nonetheless, decided: “Thank God we returned and found the situation better than when we left.”
Before NBC's Tuesday night story, broadcast network evening show coverage of returning refugees was limited to part of a sentence by fill-in CBS Evening News anchor Russ Mitchell, who noted the night before Thanksgiving (November 21) that “the Baghdad government said today some 1600 refugees are now returning to Iraq each day” (see link below to the Nov. 26 NB post for the full story Mitchell was introducing), and this short update the same night from ABC anchor Charles Gibson:
We turn next to Iraq, and the story of a reverse exodus. The interior ministry in Iraq says that about 1,000 Iraqis are returning to their country every day. These are Iraqis who had fled to other nations -- Syria, mostly -- to escape the violence. And many of those returning believe it is safer now.
ABC's World News leads with four full reports since late October on improving conditions in Iraq, followed by two before tonight on the NBC Nightly News and just one on the CBS Evening News. My November 26 NewsBusters item, “CBS Grudgingly Acknowledges Progress in Iraq, But...,” provides a rundown of all the positive stories on all three networks.
The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the November 27 NBC Nightly News story:
BRIAN WILLIAMS: In Iraq, two American soldiers were killed today north of Baghdad. And violence across the country today has killed at least 30 Iraqis. There is a noticeable trend under way. A growing stream of Iraqis who left to escape the killing, many of them going to Syria, now reversing their migration. NBC's Tom Aspell reports tonight from Baghdad.
TOM ASPELL: Time to go home. Four months ago, the Balabas family left Iraq after Sunni militiamen forced them out of their house. In Damascus this morning, with plastic suitcases, a tattered soccer ball and their precious pet pigeons, the family said goodbye. "I'm so excited," said Fatimah. "I can't wait to get back." Though safer, life in Syria turned out to be hard. $300 a month rent and food for the family of seven wiped out their savings. So when the Iraqi government offered free bus tickets to Baghdad, today's opportunity was too good to miss. The Iraqi government has even launched a satellite TV commercial to get the one million Iraqi refugees in Syria to return home. It shows a family returning to clean and quiet streets. But a recent U.N. survey at registration centers found most Iraqi refugees are returning home not because Iraq is any safer, but because they're running out of money, and Syria is clamping down on visas. The U.N. says it's not ready to say it's safe for Iraqis to go back.
SYBELLA WILKES, UNHCR Spokesperson: The question is, is it a lottery? Is it safe for you to go back? And that's the question that refugees themselves have to make up their own minds.
ASPELL: Refugees coming back to Baghdad are going to see a lot of changes. There are more people in the streets, shops are open and traffic everywhere. But it is still a dangerous city. There are kidnappings, shootings and bomb blasts every day. Hosham Abdul Rahman, a goldsmith, took his family to Syria for a month before returning to Baghdad. He ran out of money, too. His wife Hallah at home says it was the right choice. "Thank God we returned and found the situation better than when we left," she says. That's all the Balabas family was hoping for when their bus, one of 14 carrying 500 Iraqis, left Damascus for Baghdad this afternoon, enough security to enable them to restart their lives in their own country. Tom Aspell, NBC News, Baghdad.
—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center





TOM ASPELL: Time to go home. Four months ago, the Balabas family left Iraq after Sunni militiamen forced them out of their house. In Damascus this morning, with plastic suitcases, a tattered soccer ball and their precious pet pigeons, the family said goodbye. "I'm so excited," said Fatimah. "I can't wait to get back." Though safer, life in Syria turned out to be hard. $300 a month rent and food for the family of seven wiped out their savings. So when the Iraqi government offered free bus tickets to Baghdad, today's opportunity was too good to miss. The Iraqi government has even launched a satellite TV commercial to get the one million Iraqi refugees in Syria to return home. It shows a family returning to clean and quiet streets. But a recent U.N. survey at registration centers found most Iraqi refugees are returning home not because Iraq is any safer, but because they're running out of money, and Syria is clamping down on visas. The U.N. says it's not ready to say it's safe for Iraqis to go back.
ASPELL: Refugees coming back to Baghdad are going to see a lot of changes. There are more people in the streets, shops are open and traffic everywhere. But it is still a dangerous city. There are kidnappings, shootings and bomb blasts every day. Hosham Abdul Rahman, a goldsmith, took his family to Syria for a month before returning to Baghdad. He ran out of money, too. His wife Hallah at home says it was the right choice. "Thank God we returned and found the situation better than when we left," she says. That's all the Balabas family was hoping for when their bus, one of 14 carrying 500 Iraqis, left Damascus for Baghdad this afternoon, enough security to enable them to restart their lives in their own country. Tom Aspell, NBC News, Baghdad.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Praise God
November 28, 2007 - 00:44 ET by Lame CherryI sincerely believe one of the biggest mistakes President Bush and his administration undertook was asking for God to give America the victories in Afghanistan and Iraq.......and then when the victories came by His Son, the Lord of all Battles, Jesus the Christ, not one public thanks nor praise was given His Name and the credit was taken by people.
In that to correct now the Iraqi's returning, yes thanks be to thee Living God Whom most there deny in His Elohim or Family of the Father of us all, His Son or Thought Who created all of us and His Holy Spirit Who makes all of us in One Spirit for humbling the Iraqi and American peoples, so that the knowing will give all glory, honor and praise to God, to Jesus the Christ of Them, the True Prince of Peace.
*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS
It might be...
November 28, 2007 - 07:27 ET by heldmyw...a tad premature to claim victory.
A good solid claim for 'improvement'? Sure! And for that I'm sure we all give thanks.
Where's the "liberal media
November 28, 2007 - 00:59 ET by sanskritgWhere's the "liberal media bias"? Besides the reference to a throw-away one-liner from another network?
Uh, the bias comes in that
November 28, 2007 - 01:09 ET by RESTLESS 1Uh, the bias comes in that the other networks have yet to cover this story adequately. Not to mention the usual caveats:
"Adding the caveat that a safer Iraq is not the main motivator, Aspell
noted: “A recent UN survey at registration centers found most Iraqi
refugees are returning home not because Iraq is any safer, but because
they're running out of money, and Syria is clamping down on visas.”"
"Though Aspell pointed out how “it is still a dangerous city. There are
kidnappings, shootings and bomb blasts every day,” another mother,
nonetheless, decided: “Thank God we returned and found the situation
better than when we left.”"
See, the good old leftwing media continues it's bias. Not to worry.
maybe some intrepid NB reporters can report
November 28, 2007 - 12:14 ET by professor truththe truth about Baghdad. They might want to readthis stroy before they get too optimistic:
http://www.commondre...
hahaha! What a shock. A "progressive" site whines
November 28, 2007 - 12:25 ET by RJabout how "dangerous" the left-wing journalists think Baghdad is. hahaha!
RJ...too true
November 28, 2007 - 12:29 ET by LionKingNow the alphabet networks (ABC,CBS, NBC) are lying about progress in Iraq.
the phrase 'left wing journalists'
November 28, 2007 - 12:51 ET by professor truthis not in the article.
haha, Perfesser Plagarist...no kidding?
November 28, 2007 - 13:00 ET by RJThink they're going to call themselves left wing journalists? hahaha.
but you added it anyway, in all
November 28, 2007 - 13:15 ET by professor truthyour infinite wisdom. By the way, regarding my plagiarism, yes, technically I plagiarized by not crediting my source of the cut and paste. Did I deliberately intend to do this or COULD this have been an oversight??? Go back and find the evidence and present your case.
HINT:normally, a deliberate plagiarist NEVER cites a word for word quote, since this is a dead giveaway. Having been a teacher for 25 years, I understand a little bit abut plagiarism and ow people try to cover it up. Someone who deliberately would plagiarize would try to use his personal syntax along with changing up a few words(by substitution or rephrasing) or other possible strategies in an effort to cover up the stolen ideas. So, yes, I plagiarized. It was inadvertent,
and will never occur again.
Now, about your overdue apology to AF . . .
November 28, 2007 - 13:22 ET by Free StinkerIf you had just said this yesterday, you might have more credibility right now.
Now, about your overdue apology to AF . . .
Yes it is -
November 28, 2007 - 17:12 ET by pbanks7the phrase 'left wing journalists' is not in the article.
Yes it is - It's right here:
But most journalists said they believe violence and the threat of violence have increased during their tenures.
The real numbers are going down but they feeeeeel that the violence is up. Maybe it's because they can actually leave the green zone, but it feeeeeels more dangerous outside the green zone.
Left wing journalists: feelings over facts every time.
Ignorance is bliss. It's easier to repeat a mindless slogan than to do some actual research.
Prof, seems to me I read
November 28, 2007 - 12:40 ET by bassndudeProf, seems to me I read that story a few years back. But instead of Bagdad, they were talking about New Orleans.
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
the linked article from reuters
November 28, 2007 - 12:48 ET by professor truthdescribed how dangerous Baghdad is based on statistics and interviews from veteran war correspondents. Considering that a far higher % of journalists casualties have occurred vs soldier casualties, the' whiny 'word seems a bit misplaced.
bass, the causualties of journalists after Katrina
November 28, 2007 - 12:54 ET by professor truthwas nil. Compare against the casualties of journalists in Baghdad.
Veteran war reporters were stating this is the worst they've seen(Baghdad). That is not good news. I believe these guys far more than the pentagon.
I'd be leary...
November 28, 2007 - 13:03 ET by Sua Sponte 75Since most of these clowns don't even leave the GZ and get there notes from stringers. Why wouldn't they want you to believe it's the worse? Well things going good and progressing don't sell newspapers for one, and inate hatred for the administration the other. Want to know what's going on, and not from some hack hanging out in the coffee shop either, Michael Yon has been on the forefront for quite some time and imbedded.
"You're either part of the solution or part of the problem"
Maybe...
November 28, 2007 - 12:46 ET by Sua Sponte 75that the truth is people are clawing their eyes out because it's working. Honestly don't require reading by some progressive writer, most likely written on the balcony in the GZ with notes from a stringer. Or better yet, cowboy up and come on over to see for yourself.
"You're either part of the solution or part of the problem"
Got more than that???
November 28, 2007 - 13:29 ET by Airforce_5_OGot more than that??? Rueters is your source? Professor how many reporters have died in Iraq this year?
The only thing you should feel when shooting insurgents is the rifle recoil.
"Proffesor"
November 28, 2007 - 19:07 ET by RESTLESS 1Seems every time I post lately, there you are sniffing my ass. Cut it out, I know you like me, but I don't go that way.
Now, about your inane arguments, first that Iraqis don't want us there, I offer this as rebuttal. Read it and weep, for it is from arguably the MOST liberal site on the planet.
Second, from the same very liberal site, comes confirmation of this thread. I think I will believe the Iraqi people over the liberal reporters over there suffering from BDS.
Oh, and tell Leon that the ass kissing he is giving you lately is highly inappropriate on this site. Simply vulgar actually.
Failure to Give Bush credit
November 28, 2007 - 09:01 ET by ThisnThatThe MSM chooses to highlight every single Democratic criticism of President Bush, and fails to give Bush credit for some remarkable turn-arounds -- not only historically, but for those situations created during his term. To wit:
Korea's nukes
Deposing Sadam, after his 10+ years of shooting at our planes, funding suicide bombers, corrupting nations, etc.
Zero (count them, ZERO) attacks on U.S. soil following 9-11
Booming economy following Clinton's recession
Lybia
Turn-around in French, German relations
Uniting Arab countries against Iran (this is little talked about, but is very significant)
And now, the Palenstein/Israel talks (supported by the United Arab countries who are witnessing these talks!)
All of this in the face of constant, overwhelming opposition everywhere, from the Dims, the MSM, the UN, and other countries. He's had to put up with lies, mis-information, and revisionist history throughout his two terms as President. He's done this without complaint, and with a focus on our shared goal -- a prosperous and safe America. Contrast this with the Dim's goal -- an America that kow-tows to foreign interests and control; that promotes class warfare; that punishes those people who work hard (and become wealthy as a result); and that wants power for the sake of controlling every aspect of your life.
The contrast is startling -- and the MSM is hiding this every single moment of every single day. That's the MSM bias.
By the way, think about the very real possibility of having a free Iraq and Afghanistan linked to the U.S. in the near future -- how will that affect our long-term interests in the Middle East? This possiblity has never existed before, and it's Bush's perseverence that has made this possible.
___________________________________
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber
Let's not forget Afghanistan..
November 28, 2007 - 02:33 ET by mastersofdeceitnot that everything is perfect, nowhere is.
"A sense of pre-Taliban normalcy is returning not only to the
law-enforcement arena but also is seeping into other aspects of life.."
Ouch Brian!
November 28, 2007 - 08:18 ET by fossten“Thank God we returned and found the situation better than when we left.”
Oooooohhhhh you know that's got to stick in his craw that he HAS to report good news from Iraq. Somebody's gonna pay for this later.
Right now I wish I were Williams' bartender...
Forget 911, I dial 10MM.
What??!!!
November 28, 2007 - 11:19 ET by c5thenIs the "civil war" over already?
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Fred08.com