Nets Lead w/ 'Awful' Economic News, Not So Excited About Job Gains

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

When the Labor Department on Friday announced a strong gain of 166,000 jobs during October, double expectations, ABC and CBS gave it a few seconds while NBC ignored the good news, but on Wednesday night NBC, as well as ABC and CBS, led with a bad day on Wall Street they painted as a harbinger of impending economic doom. NBC anchor Brian Williams piled on the bad news as he insisted he took “no pleasure” in highlighting it. With “DANGER SIGNS” on screen, Williams announced: “Good evening. The following sounds pretty awful -- and we take no pleasure in reporting it -- but today Wall Street fell, the U.S. dollar fell, GM is in bad shape and the housing market continues to be in big trouble.”

CBS displayed “MARKET TURMOIL” on screen as Katie Couric opened with how “investors were carrying a world of worries on their shoulders today” because of “the falling dollar, record high oil prices, the mortgage mess, the housing slump, and a possible economic slowdown. And they responded by dumping stocks. That sent the Dow plummeting more than 300 points for the second time in a week.” Over on ABC, Charles Gibson teased his top story: “Tonight, oil gushes and Wall Street plunges.” Gibson cutely led: “Wall Street today took a nose dive sharp enough to make investors' ears pop.”

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

On Friday, November 2, however, the CBS Evening News gave the good news on unemployment less than ten seconds as Couric reported: “The markets got a boost today from the unemployment report. It held steady in October at 4.7 percent and job creation was strong with 166,00 jobs.” The positive news earned only a few more seconds from ABC's Gibson on World News: “Wall Street ended a volatile week with stocks recovering a little, after yesterday's big losses, thanks to a strong jobs report that cooled fears of a recession. 166,000 new jobs were added last month, twice what was expected and unemployment held steady.”

NBC Nightly News didn't consider the jobs gain newsworthy at all.

Downplaying good news and hyping the bad is nothing new in recent months.

The CBS Evening News last week ignored, and NBC barely noted, the 3.9 percent GDP growth in the third quarter. For details, check this posting by the MRC's Business & Media Institute: “GDP Growth Missed by CBS, Downplayed by NBC.”

My October 5 NewsBusters item recounted how the network evening newscasts, in early September, showcased a loss of jobs in August but, in early October, when that number was revised to a big gain and even more jobs were created in September, CBS didn't bother with the upbeat developments while NBC failed to correct the earlier misinformation:

When the Labor Department reported a net loss of 4,000 jobs for August, the September 7 ABC, CBS and NBC evening newscasts highlighted the bad news as evidence of an impending recession, but on Friday, when the Bureau of Labor Statistics revised the August number to a gain of 89,000 jobs and reported 110,000 new jobs for September, only ABC bothered to mention the revision while CBS didn't utter a syllable about either jobs gain. The CBS Evening News anchored by Harry Smith, however, found time to note the Postal Service's decision to honor two CBS journalists -- Eric Sevareid and George Polk -- with stamps.

A month ago, Katie Couric plugged an upcoming look at “new worries about the U.S. economy following a disappointing jobs report.” Harry Smith then cited “new concern about the economy tonight following a report which showed the number of jobs in the U.S. dropped by 4,000 in August, the first monthly decline in four years.” Anthony Mason asserted “it had a lot of economists uttering the 'r' word today, recession,” and fretted: “These job numbers are the most worrisome sign yet, Harry, that the housing slump and the mortgage crisis could take the entire economy down with them.” ABC anchor Charles Gibson teased: “The economy loses jobs for the first time in years as the housing crisis raises the risk of recession.” Betsy Stark declared: “The risks of a serious slowdown, even a recession, are rising. Today's jobs report was shockingly bleak.”...

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

In the case of the dollar

Awful needs no scare-quotes. It's inflation. I've warned that "inflation's coming" right here on NB ever since I arrived, and it's about time the news media noticed the obvious, even if they WON'T notice massive central bank intervention in an ostensibly "free" gold market...
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

Well Sarc,

I've warned that "inflation's coming" right here on NB ever since I arrived,

Assuming the doomsday scenareo you are pridicting is in fact coming, You arrived at NB's 2 years and 1 week ago.  Maybe I should start warning that the sun will fail to rise.  I'm sure I'll be right... eventually.

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

Jimbo, perhaps you should

Jimbo, perhaps you should start portending the doom of the disappearing of the sun. Eventually your prediction will come true. Come August 1, 2008, the sun will disappear! You will be a prophet, and will be able to thump your chest and pat yourself on the back. The end is nigh! The end is nigh!

I'm not "pridicting" doomsday

I already predicted inflation. It happened, I told you so beforehand, so why not just deal with the facts??
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

I'm not "predicting" either.

I already predicted the demise of the sham Cult of "Dr." Paul. It happened, I told you so beforehand, so why not just deal with the facts??

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

You can't even mock!

Some "demise." Some "cult." Same excuse for an "argument."
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

When “Dr.” Paul finally

When “Dr.” Paul finally does whatever it is he intends to do, Sarcasmo is going to be like Bill Mahr after President Bush is out of office – looking for another cause.

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

Nope, wrong-again.

I'll be exactly like I was before he ever ran. Making fools here look foolish (see above). And why not take "Unsane's" advice and wait for the primaries? The instinct to whine is very strong...
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

These libs are besides

These libs are besides themselves with their wishful thinking. If the economy takes a downturn (which it can do), this only "proves" that capitalism doesn't "work". Thus, they can haul out their old chestnuts of wealth re-distribution and New Deals.

The economy is like the climate. Ups and downs, with an overall pattern of stability. Only the libs are dishonest/stupid enough to isolate a segment of performance, and screech that it is something in of itself, ignoring the bigger picture.

Interesting.. since they are the ones who accuse conservatives of being small-minded and have tunnel vision.

I don't think they are

I don't think they are really hoping for a downturn, or are trying to create one via their reporting...I just think they are trying to present the image of a hurting economy because it helps their political agenda. 

This is why a falling economic growth rate of 3.8% under Clinton is considered a "roaring economy" whereas as a growing rate of 4.2% under Bush portends doom.

Because of the normal ups and downs of the economy, the media can cherry pick and portray whatever image they want.  They do this with "climate change" and other issues as well....

liberal illusions

if all this bad economy news is fake and just puffed up by liberals, why did ben b cut rates? because the economy was so strong he needed to make it stronger?

clearly there is a risk of recession right now, but i think we all hope that it's just a mid cycle slow down(which is probably is) and nothing more serious.

i don't think there is some huge conspiracy against bush/republicans, the economy could go either way right now, and being overly bullish would be quite illogical.

Why should they care...

Why should liberals care about our economy considering we will all be dead soon from AGW? 

Get Email updates from Fred http://socialnet.imwithfred.com/email_alert_july_26.html

"...and we take no pleasure

"...and we take no pleasure in reporting it..."

Methinks the liberal doth protest too much.

Forget 911, I dial 9MM.

What does a net loss of

What does a net loss of 4,000 jobs for August mean?  Is that supposed to mean that there were actually NO NEW jobs at all, and that the economy as a whole actually lost 4,000 jobs, or does it mean that there were 4,000 less NEW jobs in September than in August, i.e., if August's new jobs were 170,000 then September's were 166,000, or 4,000 less? 

Actually, there was a 4,000

Actually, there was a 4,000 job loss in August. The main factor in those lost jobs was the 60,000 GOVERNMENT jobs that were cut. That is 60,000 less jobs paid by taxpayers, and, to me, that is actually a good thing.

Actually..

"That is 60,000 less jobs paid by taxpayers"

This only means that they contract the jobs out. This actually costs more, since there are middle-men, and there are less benefits to the person actually working.

This also fuels corruption by sweetheart deals and kick-backs. Both parties engage in this.

I believe you are ASSUMING

I believe you are ASSUMING the jobs were contracted out.
I need to see some proof before believing you.

Government workers have less benefits? Really?

I guess "It's the economy

I guess "It's the economy stupid" only applies when the market is up AND there is a Democrat in the White House.

Come to think of it, where was all the press coverage on the Dow's run up to a record high? Oh never mind...

Leon says "By the way, I'm not afraid of fat people, I'm repulsed"

Truth Monger Says - "Both are religions [Christianity & Islam], yes - with the same percentage of terrorists."

the economy isn't great

all signs point to a bear market coming, 

"but  no i love bush this can't be"

the market isn't partisan.  you can explain away the shrinking dollar that we will be using as tp pretty soon, 

you can try to explain why we raise our debt ceiling rather then try to slow down spending, 

oil 100

inflation rising.

jobs may have been added but americans are getting poorer cause of our plumetting currency. 

if tax cuts (which i'm all for) work so well then why are we printing off money like fools and borrowing money like never before?

the economy isn't great, 

weak dollar means more

weak dollar means more people buy our stuff - econ 101 - non-partisan

biz is booming where i live 

Partner with Islam and the NB respect police:)

True liberal view in the late 90's

The true liberal view in the late 90's, of the shape of the economy was clearly and loudly expressed by economists and others whom the MSM has a lot of respect for. Predictions were loud and clear prior to the economic turmoil, and the history of the event was well documented after the crash.

 However during that period of time, in spite of the overwhelming evidence of an impending doom and gloom, with a Democrat [Clinton - but it doesn't matter who], the MSM pounded ahead all through the elecltion cycle of 2000 as if nothing had happened (the historic stock market crash of March, and all of the fallout from it), the MSM pushed ahead with blinders on. Nothing would get in the way of the agenda to elect Al Gore. 

The MSM continued to push Al Gore and the Democrats on their economic record. The end of the decade was also marked heavily by the CA energy crisis, the Intafada, one of the world's most deadly wars and genocides unfolding in the DR Congo. Sierra Leone was the location of another. Afghanistan had been violently been taken over by the Taliban (w/Pakistan's assistance). Chechnya was all over the news. Clinton's much touted genocide in Kosovo? No evidence had been found of the claims he had hyped. N. Korea was cheating on the Clinton/Carter deal. Iraq was unraveling; US bombing had escalated immensely for 2 straight years, and Clinton was loosing support for the Sanctions Regime.

But perhaps none described the fear better of how the economy would play out, and from the MSM's point of view [citizens would suffer], than the adored by the left liberal (socialist) economist Dean Baker (often on the news since 2001 to bash Bush economics).

Everything he, and so many more, wrote about and warned about, these same economic collapse mania media figures today, were silent about back then -- had to put the Democrats in power. Misc. excerpts, Dean Baker of CEPR:

March, 2000) The main feature of the 'new economy' is a stock market bubble of unprecedented magnitude. When the bubble bursts, the new economy will just be a bad memory. The inflated stock market has created enormous distortions in the economy, the ramifications of which will only be apparent when stock prices return to more normal levels.

(March, 2001) The nation's political leaders chose to ignore the stock market bubble and instead focused their attention on distant and relatively minor problems like potential shortfalls in the Social Security trust fund in 30 or 40 years or the reappearance of budget deficits in a decade or two.

As a result, millions of families have seen their dreams of a secure retirement or their children's college education vanish with the stock market bubble. The level of negligence of the nation's political leaders in ignoring the stock bubble exceeds anything since the days of Herbert Hoover."...

[..]

(Oct, 2001) "The first step in dealing with the current recession is to recognize clearly its cause. On this point, there can be little ambiguity. The cause of the recession was the collapse of the stock market bubble."

"The decision by the Federal Reserve Board and the Clinton Administration not to take any actions to try to limit the run-up of the stock bubble was a mistake that the nation will suffer from for many years to come."

"Even the most cursory review of the data shows that the "new economy" was mostly hype..

[..]

..At the individual level, millions of households now find themselves with insufficient savings to pay for their retirement or their children's education."

"The stock market bubble created a huge amount of unpredicted wealth, which has quickly dissipated. Millions of families have been hurt as a result."..

[..]

(Nov. 2000) The Costs of the Stock Market Bubble"

"This pushed the savings rate almost to zero. It also led to an enormous buildup of household debt."..."this paper shows the extent of the over-valuation to be in the range of $8-13 trillion. An over-valuation in the stock market of this magnitude is going to have very serious consequences for the rest of the economy."

For a very interesting read which clearly explains, from a liberal, that Bush inherited a disaster - not a booming economy with surpluses as far as the eye could see, Bursting Bubbles -Why the economy will go from bad to worse.

It's interesting to note, although one can share a few of Baker's long term concerns, how poorly he predicted how the Bush economy

why are you saying this is

why are you saying this is 'liberal bias'?  these people are reporting the economic news  - what are they supposed to say - 'don't worry, everything will be alright'? our dollar is dropping in value, so much so that some of our biggest overseas investors - China, for one, are beginning to shift some of their enormous investments(we're talking trillions here) into other currencies for a better return,  I'm sorry, but this just isn't good news