CBS's Greenfield Recalls Clinton Scandals Long-forgotten by Media

Photo of Brent Baker.
  • Bookmark and Share

Prompted by Hillary Clinton's dissembling answer during Tuesday's Democratic presidential debate about why her White House records have not been released, CBS political correspondent Jeff Greenfield uniquely reminded "CBS Evening News" viewers on Wednesday night of her scandals not mentioned by the media in years. Greenfield outlined why Hillary Clinton, contrary to her claim the National Archives is delaying the release when, in fact, President Clinton asked communication between him and the First Lady be withheld until 2012, wants to keep secret her papers from the White House years:

The notion that there's stuff that's being restricted potentially opens the door to asking questions about, well, the travel office where the independent counsel said she had been factually false. How did her brothers get pardons for two felons after being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars? How did she raise $100,000 trading cattle futures? This stuff hasn't come up in the campaign...

And it hasn't come up in the mainstream media which, until Tim Russert's question at the debate about the suppression of her records, has so far shown little interest in “asking questions” about the 1990s Clinton era scandals.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

ABC, CBS and NBC on Wednesday night all ran stories on how other candidates at the MSNBC debate took on Mrs. Clinton over her stands on Iraq and Iran and the inconsistency of her position on New York's plan to give driver's licenses to illegal aliens. ABC's David Wright didn't touch on the hidden records and NBC's Andrea Mitchell gave the subject just a brief mention as she noted how Clinton was “blaming the National Archives for sealing her White House papers when this letter from Bill Clinton shows he asked that they be sealed for 12 years.”

The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video for the exchange, between Greenfield and anchor Katie Couric, which followed a debate report from Jim Axelrod on the October 31 "CBS Evening News:"

KATIE COURIC: Jeff, as we saw, Senator Clinton hit some rough patches last night. Let's talk about what happened when she was asked about immigration.

JEFF GREENFIELD: She began by dealing with a complex substantive matter, one that former Florida Governor Jeb Bush thought, you know, maybe we should have driver's licenses for illegals, maybe it makes us all safer. And I think she, I think what happened was her radar said "Whoops, general election mine field. Republicans, immigration, hot button." And those two clashed.

COURIC: But she is in a bit of a conundrum, is she not, because she doesn't want to stake out positions that may haunt her later on if, in fact, she gets the nomination, you know? And at the same time, she risks coming across as if she has no core values or beliefs.

GREENFIELD: And we have learned that if you are labeled a waffler or a flip-flopper in a campaign, that can prove to be very, very damaging.

COURIC: There was another mine field when she was asked about records of the Clinton presidency being kept by the National Archives.

GREENFIELD: Well, there's a mountain of stuff from those eight Clinton years, and the President, President Clinton, told the National Archives, look, any material relating to communications between the First Lady and the President, restrict them until 2012, well after this election. The problem, of course, is this is no ordinary First Lady. She was a key policy advisor, office in the West Wing, ran the health care initiative. And historians, and, yes, political opponents, would love to look through that to see if there are any contradictions or interesting political issues to raise.

COURIC: All right, let's look at what happened when she was asked about these records.

GREENFIELD: Absolutely. Very uncomfortable for her. Let's take a look.

TIM RUSSERT, DEBATE MODERATOR, MSNBC DEBATE: But there was a letter written by President Clinton specifically asking that any communication between you and the President not be made available to the public until 2012. Would you lift that ban?

HILLARY CLINTON: Well, that's not my decision to make, and I don't believe that any President or First Lady ever has. But certainly we'll move as quickly as our circumstances and the processes of the National Archives permits.

BARACK OBAMA: I'm glad that Hillary took the phrase "turn the page." It's a good one. But this is an example of not turning the page.

GREENFIELD: And here's the problem, Katie. The Clinton campaign has been very successful in not going back to any of that turmoil of the '90s. The notion that there's stuff that's being restricted potentially opens the door to asking questions about, well, the travel office where the independent counsel said she had been factually false. How did her brothers get pardons for two felons after being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars? How did she raise $100,000 trading cattle futures? This stuff hasn't come up in the campaign, but you could almost hear the opponents beginning to chomp at the bit, waiting to ask, "What is she hiding?" There's the potential problem, I think.

—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

If I was Greenfield, I'd

If I was Greenfield, I'd hire a body guard, or two!

And..... stay away from

And..... stay away from Marcy Park..!

These are the boys of Pointe du Hoc.
Ronald Reagan- 40th Anniversary of D-Day

Well, bravo for Jeff

Well, bravo for Jeff Greenfield! But this is not going to amount to a hill of beans unless it is repeated elsewhere.

Nevermind if it were a Republican...if it were any of the other Democrat candidates....we would be hearing the media's lines that "The questions continue to dog so-and-so" and "The questions are not going away." Something tells me we are not going to get this drumbeat with HRC.

BTW they need to keep after her on her so-called "stand" on driver's licenses for illegals, because Judicial Watch is already suing Spitzer and the NY DMV over it. And they may have given her just the"out" she needs:


"If Governor Spitzer wants to change the rules, he has to follow the
rules – which means going through the New York State Legislature and
otherwise following New York law."

So now she can say that's not her decision to make, it's up to the state Legislature.

mb, I'd add a bravo of my

mb,

I'd add a bravo of my own, but I suspect this may be the height and maximum coverage CBS will ever offer of Hillary's past. They got it out of the way early and it can now be put to bed. Am I being too cynical?

Hillary won't be alone in the White House...

Well, it's refreshing to hear that Greenfield has a bit of memory recall, but it's worthwhile to remember that Hillary won't be alone in the White House... "we could have two presidents at one time."

In the light of how the press is always comfortable in bringing up past Republican scandals and unfortunate events, etc., there is a long list of issues that, if the press were true to its own cause, would be up front in every discussion of Bill and Hillary Clinton.

First, there might be the thousands of follow up queries to: "So.. what became of all of the old crooks who were friends of you two, to wit: JAMES RIADY PLEADS GUILTY WILL PAY LARGEST FINE IN CAMPAIGN FINANCE HISTORY FOR VIOLATING FEDERAL ELECTION LAW." Follow up question being, "By the way, did President Clinton ever apologize for putting the justice department through all of that - I'd say ‘putting the American voting public through all of that,' but we in the media did our damn best to play it quiet?"

Secondly, the left side of the isle is actually really pissed off about the Clinton leadership during the 90's on NAFTA, WTO, China's Free Trading "Favorite" status, and their view (and the press's view) of how this has hurt the American worker. "Any defense here Hillary? After all, the press just keeps getting away with blaming it all on the Bush administration."

Thirdly. The story goes, Hillary, that when the Clinton's left office, they left a surplus as far as a ... well -- the term was actually "projected surplus" was it not? The bubble burst before you left office, Hillary, and over the next 3-4 years the country was saddled with some $1.8 trillion in lost tax revenue (almost all from the reversal you left us with). Now, now, now - Bush Tax cuts did not hit the books until after the reversal. Besides, since the Bush tax cuts hit the books in 2003, Federal tax revenues have recovered from the Clinton crash, and have soared 44%. And don't forget, millions of American workers lost their jobs, their life savings and their health insurance in the mess that you two left behind.

Fourth. The HIV/Aids pandemic in Africa. You see, the media has no fear in going back in time and blaming Ronald Reagan for not talking publicly about Aids, back when it was first becoming understood, however, you and Bill knew damn good and well about it -- and did next to nothing to keep tens of millions of folks from contracting the disease, especially in Africa and Indonesia. Yea, Bill Clinton (Johnny come later to the party) has finally followed in the footsteps of that great leader on the issue, President Bush, who stepped up to the plate and got the entire congress behind him in taking historic steps - and the results are in the books now, but perhaps none expressed it better than David Corn of the Nation, when he wrote back in 2002, "How many times is Bill Clinton going to apologize to Africa." Or, as he answered his own question as to why Clinton did so little, he offered,

The prevailing view was, these people should die quietly.

And:

A cynical guess at Clinton's motivations: AIDS in Africa, it doesn't poll well.

I note that when the left pounds on George Bush, the mainstream media likes to pile on, however, in the Clinton's case they simple crawl in to a hole and act like it didn't occur.

Hillary, how can it be that the press does not ask you and your husband each time you are in front of them to comment on your lack of effort and on how historic the humanitarian effort by President Bush's leadership has been? Oh, and on the fight on malaria, also.

Speaking of Africa, Hillary; after Bill Clinton's complacency over the Rwandan genocide, he said "never again." Next door, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, estimates are that beginning in 1996-1998 some 4 1/2 to 6 million died in the civil war and genocide there - the largest loss of life in a single conflict since WW II.

So Mrs. Clinton let's get this straight. The press continues to hate and pound on Reagan, (any Republican, for that matter) for not doing enough for HIV/Aids, back in the 1980's, while at the same time, they consider the absence of effort by Bill Clinton in two, or three, of the greatest tragedies to befall mankind during the modern era, the stuff that humanitarianism and "it's takes a village" is made of, to be off limits for discussion?

Someone help me out here.

ABC's David Wright didn't

ABC's David Wright didn't touch on the hidden records and NBC's Andrea Mitchell gave the subject just a brief mention as she noted how Clinton was “blaming the National Archives for sealing her White House papers when this letter from Bill Clinton shows he asked that they be sealed for 12 years.”

Blaming the National Archives....

Now isn't that rich?!

Sandy Burger anyone...why those National Archives worked wonders for her little pudgy thief and the records they stole before the 9/11 Commission got them...and he just got a slap on the hand by the law...just like her and her partner in crime Bill have for decades...

Things are coming back to bite them in the arse...I love it I have waited for so many years to say....

Pay Backs are hell Hillary...you sow what you reap!

LMAO!

The media's just acting on

The media's just acting on the Clinton's policy of "don't ask, don't tell".

Thankfully we have other news outlets to get this information from.

Darth Dutch

Michael Isikoff

I'm rereading his book on the Clintons during the Monica scandal -- "the more things change, the more they remain the same"