On Sunday's NBC Nightly News, correspondent Chris Jansing filed an unusual report which took a sympathetic look at California taxpayers who are having trouble affording a recent increase in the amount of taxes withheld from their paychecks, as she described the situation as taxpayers "footing the government an interest-free loan, and a lot of people aren't happy about it."
The NBC correspondent used several soundbites of average Californians -- one man even earning minimum wage -- who complained about the situation, with one man comparing the government to a "mafia," and another seeing the government as being like children who think their parents are an endless source of money.
Anchor Lester Holt relayed the "unwelcome surprise" from the government as he set up the story:
Money is tight in these challenging economic times, perhaps nowhere more so than in California where a crushing deficit has prompted something new – a 10 percent increase in that state's withholding tax. And it has been an unwelcome surprise to millions of taxpayers.
After two soundbites of women who were shocked by the news, Jansing filled in viewers on how the plan works, as the government would withhold more money which would be returned when taxes are filed. Jansing: "The plan is to give the money back at tax return time. In other words, taxpayers are footing the government an interest-free loan, and a lot of people aren't happy about it."
Then came a soundbite of minimum wage worker Brian Foster as he slammed the government as being like a "mafia." Foster: "It's the government. They're like the mafia. They can do whatever they want. I mean, you know, I only make minimum wage."
After devoting a moment to the opposing view, including a soundbite from State Assembly Speaker Karen Bass as she argued that "we needed the extra money right now so that, frankly, the situation wouldn't even be worse," Jansing concluded her report with another man expressing an unflattering view of the government:
CHRIS JANSING: With many businesses already feeling as if they’ve got a case of pneumonia, Robert Smith has a message for politicians: Grow up.
ROBERT SMITH, CALIFORNIA RESIDENT: Your kids don’t think there’s an end to your pockets, that you can just reach in and pull the money out. And the government seems to be the same way.
Below is a complete transcript of the report from the Sunday, November 8, NBC Nightly News:
LESTER HOLT: Money is tight in these challenging economic times, perhaps nowhere more so than in California where a crushing deficit has prompted something new – a 10 percent increase in that state's withholding tax. And it has been an unwelcome surprise to millions of taxpayers. Our report from NBC's Chris Jansing.
CHRIS JANSING: At McDonald’s Hearing Aid Center in Sacramento, employees can't believe their ears-
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #1: No, I had no idea.
JANSING: -or their paychecks.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #2: I was definitely surprised.
JANSING: During the legislative battle over California's huge deficit, lawmakers quietly added a new provision, withholding 10 percent more state taxes -- and it's just now kicking in. For a typical family of four making $90,000, taxes would go up as much as $368 a year. For a single person, about $211. The plan is to give the money back at tax return time. In other words, taxpayers are footing the government an interest-free loan, and a lot of people aren't happy about it.
BRIAN FOSTER, BARTENDER: It's the government. They're like the mafia. They can do whatever they want. I mean, you know, I only make minimum wage.
JANSING: Like restaurants across the country, business has been down at J.J. Brewky 's in Camarillo, and, like other businesses, the upcoming holiday season will be key to turning a profit this year.
JEFF WALKER, J.J. BREWSKY’S: I think it's the wrong time to be doing this. There's two things that affect the restaurant business. It’s disposable income and consumer confidence, and I think clearly this is a detriment to both.
JANSING: And critics argue the impact will be felt well beyond California by offsetting any possible benefit from the federal economic stimulus plan, and California is by far the largest state economy in the U.S. Already lawmakers are getting an earful from taxpayers.
STATE SENATOR TONY STRICKLAND (R-CA): They're just frustrated. They’re angry.
JANSING: Here's what the Democrats are saying. The supporters are saying it's a few bucks.
STRICKLAND: Well, tell that to my constituents who are having a tough time making ends meet. They don't have the dollars already.
JANSING: But, facing the biggest loss of revenue in California history, supporters say there was little choice.
KAREN BASS, CALIFORNIA STATE ASSEMBLY SPEAKER: And so, we needed the extra money right now so that, frankly, the situation wouldn't even be worse.
JANSING: There's an old saying that when California sneezes, the country catches a cold. With many businesses already feeling as if they’ve got a case of pneumonia, Robert Smith has a message for politicians: Grow up.
ROBERT SMITH, CALIFORNIA RESIDENT: Your kids don’t think there’s an end to your pockets, that you can just reach in and pull the money out. And the government seems to be the same way.
JANSING: Chris Jansing, NBC News, Camarillo, California.
—Brad Wilmouth is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.




LESTER HOLT: Money is tight in these challenging economic times, perhaps nowhere more so than in California where a crushing deficit has prompted something new – a 10 percent increase in that state's withholding tax. And it has been an unwelcome surprise to millions of taxpayers. Our report from NBC's Chris Jansing.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Well...surprize, surprize.
November 9, 2009 - 12:15 ET by c5thenCalifornia has a right to all the money that it's citizens make and just decides how much to let them keep, right?
What happens when everybody requests the money back on the tax returns but CA still doesn't have any money?
And the best question...Where were the news media when the politicians were creating this protection racket? Why was this such a surprize to CA residents?
Just imagine what will happen when the Federal Government is running the health care system and it needs 10% more $$ to "tie it over" until the next year...
Throw 'da bums out!!!
Before it's too late.
www.loyaltoliberty.com
We don't give no stinking refunds
November 9, 2009 - 12:49 ET by slickwillie2001The outcome here is obvious, those claiming state refunds next year will be paid in California vouchers, a currency soon to be less useful than grocery store coupons.
Californians should be changing the state version of the W-4 doublequick.
Under with held
November 9, 2009 - 12:52 ET by sevenOver state dependents and send in as little as possible. The state will fight against tax refunds. They just don't learn.
All of those greedy
November 9, 2009 - 13:04 ET by Aryehpeople in CA. How dare they want to be selfish and keep their own money to take care of their families. Don't they know that they should happily sacrifice their money for the greater good...
Hehehe...
"The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny
individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities" Ayn Rand
No sympathy
November 9, 2009 - 13:04 ET by Cranky GordonHaving escaped CA 10 years ago, I can only shake my head at these enlightened Californians. There isn't a cause they wouldn't spend other people's money on.
Now it's time to pay the bills.
Call me when you come to your senses and vote fiscally conservative.
X
November 9, 2009 - 13:09 ET by serfer62And of course CA voters will reelect these people...
CT tax increase
November 9, 2009 - 16:47 ET by sarge329" It's just a few bucks " . Right. And later, it'll just be a few bucks more. Sounds like incrementalism, or a lobster in the pot. And then what happens come refund time when the " promised " payback comes, and the coffers are empty? Oops. " Well, we'll pay you back later " , and later never comes. Isn't this where Frau Pelosi and her " take the insurance or you'll face fines/jail time " came from?