On Saturday, ABC’s World News Saturday and the NBC Nightly News each ran a story touting the high number of patients arriving at a free clinic in Los Angeles, operated by Remote Area Medical, as evidence of the need for health care reform. For the NBC Nightly News, it was the third such story on the facility of the week.
While ABC’s World News with Charles Gibson had run one story on Friday that focused on the generous work of the organization and its founder, Stan Brock, Saturday was the first time World News had touted the clinic as evidence of the need for reform, or compared America’s poor to the Third World, as stories on the CBS Evening News and the NBC Nightly News had already done previously. And on Saturday, ABC and NBC again failed to inform viewers that patients who arrived at the free clinic were not required to prove financial need to receive service, but were merely accepted on a first-come, first-serve basis.
On World News Saturday, ABC anchor Dan Harris set up the piece:
In Inglewood, California, tonight, a vivid demonstration of the health care crisis: A clinic that provides free health care has been inundated with patients. Almost 46 million people in this country do not have health insurance, but the problem is a lot bigger than that. Many people who do have insurance still cannot afford the care that they need.
ABC correspondent Mike von Fremd related that Remote Area Medical was founded to help Third World countries, but "is now helping people in America's second largest city," before showing a soundbite of Jamie Court of Consumer Watchdog declaring that the scene at the clinic "is the poster child for everything that's wrong in American health care":
MIKE VON FREMD: This event was sponsored by Remote Access Medical, an organization started to serve Third World countries. It's now helping people in America's second largest city.
JAMIE COURT, CONSUMER WATCHDOG: This is the poster child for everything that's wrong in American health care. When you see working Americans, people with health insurance, coming here because their health insurance isn't good enough-
On Saturday’s NBC Nightly News, correspondent Miguel Almaguer related that the charity was founded to provide help to people in the Third World but is now serving "the world's richest country in the nation's second largest city," before showing a clip of the program’s founder, Brock, declaring that if the clinic operated for three months it would still not serve all those who would show up for free health care:
MIGUEL ALMAGUER: RAM, or Remote Area Medical, first began offering donated health care in Third World countries, but they are running this week's operation in the world's richest country in the nation's second largest city. If you were here all month, could you serve everyone that needed help?
STAN BROCK, REMOTE AREA MEDICAL: Oh, not a chance. No. We could be here three months, and we still wouldn't catch up on the demand for the service.
Almaguer also relayed the story of a woman who was seeing a doctor for the first time in 17 years, and played a clip of her citing her case as an example of why something should be done – presumably by the government – to make health care "affordable":
MIGUEL ALMAGUER: Like thousands of others, they're willing to wait days for a few free hours of care. Mora hasn't seen a doctor in 17 years.
MIKE WALSH: It's very scary, yeah.
MORA WALSH: Yeah, it is frightening. That's why I really feel that we need to do something in this country where it's affordable.
Below is are complete transcripts of the relevant stories from the Saturday, August 15, World News Saturday on ABC, and the same day's NBC Nightly News:
#From ABC's World News Saturday:
DAN HARRIS: In Inglewood, California, tonight, a vivid demonstration of the health care crisis: A clinic that provides free health care has been inundated with patients. Almost 46 million people in this country do not have health insurance, but the problem is a lot bigger than that. Many people who do have insurance still cannot afford the care that they need. Mike von Fremd is at that free clinic tonight. Mike, good evening.
MIKE VON FREMD: Good evening, Dan. Many of the people waiting in line for this free care are what the medical community calls under-insured. They have basic insurance, but it does not cover their most basic needs. Damone Jones, in the dental chair, works for the Edison Power Company. He has medical insurance, but could not afford the $5,000 root canal that he’s getting today for free.
DAMONE JONES, PATIENT: I have insurance, but it's so high, when I go to the dental, it’s outrageous prices, so I can't do it. I can't afford it.
VON FREMD: More than 1,000 volunteers – dentists, doctors and optometrists such as Jayme Chiu – have been working 14-hour days. They are shocked at the number of people desperate for care.
DR. JAYME CHIU, OPTOMETRIST: I'm exhausted. People are continuously coming. People really have very basic needs. And it's so basic that it's sad.
VON FREMD: This event was sponsored by Remote Access Medical, an organization started to serve Third World countries. It's now helping people in America's second largest city.
JAMIE COURT, CONSUMER WATCHDOG: This is the poster child for everything that's wrong in American health care. When you see working Americans, people with health insurance, coming here because their health insurance isn't good enough-
VON FREMD: The care that this free clinic is offering is estimated to be worth $200,000 a day. They expect to treat 8,000 desperate patients. Lindsey Huff has catastrophic health care. It does not cover her dental or vision needs, and she’s not had an eye exam or teeth cleaning in years.
LINDSEY HUFF, PATIENT: It's unbelievable. For me it's like winning the lottery. Seriously, I’m going from here over to dental. And all these little problems that I've been able to slip by and get by are going to be resolved.
VON FREMD: This has been a godsend to these people, but the clinic closes down on Tuesday. Mike von Fremd, ABC News, Inglewood, California.
#From the NBC Nightly News:
LESTER HOLT: Back now with more of a tough scene we've been watching unfold all week. Thousands of people – many without jobs or health insurance – are continuing to overwhelm volunteers at a free health care clinic in Los Angeles. Many needy people who were turned away earlier in the week were told to come back today. But what happened when they got there? NBC’s Miguel Almaguer joins us tonight from Los Angeles. Miguel, good evening.
MIGUEL ALMAGUER: Lester, good evening. The massive medical floor behind me is in full swing 12 hours a day, but the hundreds of volunteers are having a tough time keeping up with the thousands that continue to show up. Turned away earlier this week, they waited three days, even took three buses to get here. Mike and Mora Walsh can't find work, and they don't have health insurance.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Do you have a primary physician?
MORA WALSH, PATIENT: No.
ALMAGUER: Like thousands of others, they're willing to wait days for a few free hours of care. Mora hasn't seen a doctor in 17 years.
MIKE WALSH: It's very scary, yeah.
MORA WALSH: Yeah, it is frightening. That's why I really feel that we need to do something in this country where it's affordable.
ALMAGUER: On Tuesday, the L.A. Forum became a mobile hospital. The bleachers are still packed with people, but center court has become center stage for medical procedures on the fly. Eight days of free health care, but by the third, wrist bands for the entire week were gone.
VITA MARTIN, PATIENT: Please. I deserve it.
ALMAGUER: Vita Martin has a job but no insurance. She found out she'll need more than one day of free care.
MARTIN: My blood pressure is so high, and I can't afford the meds that I need to make it lower. And I'm gonna die.
ALMAGUER: RAM, or Remote Area Medical, first began offering donated health care in Third World countries, but they are running this week's operation in the world's richest country in the nation’s second largest city. If you were here all month, could you serve everyone that needed help?
STAN BROCK, REMOTE AREA MEDICAL: Oh, not a chance. No. We could be here three months, and we still wouldn't catch up on the demand for the service.
ALMAGUER: Doctors know they can't help everyone.
DR. TERESA ROMERO, VOLUNTEER: You almost feel like you're not doing very much, you’re helpless.
ALMAGUER: But today, Mike and Mora Walsh made it through the doors.
MIKE WALSH: This is like a miracle.
MORA WALSH: This is. This is fantastic.
ALMAGUER: Thankful, even though this may not be all the care they need, but it's the only care they can get. The Walshes are among the 8,000 people that organizers say they will be able to help by Tuesday. Lester?
HOLT: Miguel Almaguer tonight. Thank you, Miguel.
—Brad Wilmouth is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.




MIKE VON FREMD: Good evening, Dan. Many of the people waiting in line for this free care are what the medical community calls under-insured. They have basic insurance, but it does not cover their most basic needs. Damone Jones, in the dental chair, works for the Edison Power Company. He has medical insurance, but could not afford the $5,000 root canal that he’s getting today for free.
LESTER HOLT: Back now with more of a tough scene we've been watching unfold all week. Thousands of people – many without jobs or health insurance – are continuing to overwhelm volunteers at a free health care clinic in Los Angeles. Many needy people who were turned away earlier in the week were told to come back today. But what happened when they got there? NBC’s Miguel Almaguer joins us tonight from Los Angeles. Miguel, good evening.
STAN BROCK, REMOTE AREA MEDICAL: Oh, not a chance. No. We could be here three months, and we still wouldn't catch up on the demand for the service.














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Why would you want to pay for anything?
August 16, 2009 - 22:17 ET by karelingWhen if you wait long enough, eventually you might get it for free:
MIGUEL ALMAGUER: Like thousands of others, they're willing to wait days for a few free hours of care. Mora hasn't seen a doctor in 17 years.
IOW, Mora's willing to wait 17 years just to get free health care. Wonder what else she's waiting (and for how long) to get for free?
I looked at the same quote
August 17, 2009 - 06:20 ET by motherbeltI looked at the same quote and thought;
Well, with socialized medical care, she'd wait more than a few days to see a doctor. How about weeks, months?
It just goes to show ya, people will do without things and then line up for it when it's free.
If you give it away, they will come.....
Does "free" affect demand?
August 17, 2009 - 06:46 ET by ThisnThatIt just goes to show ya, people will do without things and then line up for it when it's free.
Right. Like Cash for Clunkers. People get free money to trade in a car they wanted to get rid of anyway. So what if they had to buy a car with better gas mileage? The Gov could take this and claim the following: "See, there was a pent-up demand for fuel efficient cars". Completely ignoring the effect that "free" has on human behavior. Just like NBC saying "See, there is a pent-up demand for affordable health care" -- just as long as you and I pay for someone else, of course.
___________________________________
"Tax the rich" is a basically unstable way of governing - The NYT
And no one is reporting
August 17, 2009 - 07:47 ET by motherbeltAnd no one is reporting that most of the new cars being bought are not Priuses and subcompacts, but SUVs.
"FREE" Health Care
August 16, 2009 - 22:43 ET by ptsonSo people will show up if offered something for "free." What a surprise! Actually Mr. Obama demonstrated this by attracting 100,000 Germans to listen to a boring speech, in a foreign language by offering "free" beer and brats. Ultimately, it demonstrates nothing but what I learned in business school about advertising; the most emotionally effective word that can be used to reach people is "free." Despite the hype, there is nothing free about the health insurance reforms being offered. On the contrary, the cost will increase dramatically.
If Obama care doesn't pass Congress, I guess I will go door to door to collect money to pay for my health care premium. Would THAT be absurd enough to make the point that the only one who should be paying for MY health care is ME.? What a concept. We all pay for our OWN health care. Then we can all do and eat whatever WE decide. No need for health care and food police! Why that could SAVE BILLIONS. Demand that YOUR Congressman stand up for LIBERTY and stop being a TYRANT!
Who paid for the beer and brats, anyway?
August 17, 2009 - 07:32 ET by karelingNow I'm reminded of that old Warner Brothers cartoon about the singing frog and the guy who thought he could make money from it. To get people into the theater to see the frog, the guy put out a sign saying FREE BEER and he got trampled.
well, duh
August 17, 2009 - 00:32 ET by mom_roxCanada and Great Britain provide free health care, and they're not caught up either.
"Almaguer also relayed the
August 17, 2009 - 01:32 ET by ckc1227"Almaguer also relayed the story of a woman who was seeing a doctor for the first time in 17 years"
So, in 17 years, this woman couldn't save enough money to pay for a doctor's visit?
"Lindsey Huff has catastrophic health care. It does not cover her dental
or vision needs, and she’s not had an eye exam or teeth cleaning in
years."
It's not supposed to cover those things. That's like buying a house without a garage, then complaining that there's no garage to park your car in.
Also, if this Lindsey woman hasn't had an eye exam or a teeth cleaning in years, it's because she didn't want to pay for them. You can get an eye exam, or a teeth cleaning for around $100, at least you can around here. If the cost of living is too high, then she needs to move. No one is entitled to live somewhere they can't afford.
I would say it's like
August 17, 2009 - 06:26 ET by motherbeltI would say it's like buying homeowners insurance and expecting it to pay for regulare maintenance, like cleaning out the gutters and snow removal.
Or like expecting your auto insurance to pay for oil changes and tire rotations....after all, they keep your car in good running order, don't they?
It Was a Vivid Demonstration, Alright
August 17, 2009 - 01:53 ET by BondPlainBondA vivid demonstration that California does not know how to handle money.
The Governator stopped all dental care benefits of the Medi-Cal program (to be reinstated soon); many of the people at the Forum were either illegals or Medi-Cal dental patients.
NBC isn't wearing its
August 17, 2009 - 06:44 ET by ThisnThatNBC isn't wearing its agenda on its sleeve again, are they? Sheeesshhh -- I thought they were cured of that. This is really surprising -- and disappointing. Whom am I going to trust from now on? \sarc
___________________________________
"Tax the rich" is a basically unstable way of governing - The NYT
TnT... I had a feeling
August 17, 2009 - 17:36 ET by bigtimerTnT...
I had a feeling that link was going to go where it did once I saw the name Andrea Mitchell...that was agreat zing you got in to make your point...I'm smiling.
Obama's a Community Agitator, a walking, talking destroyer. ~ Rush Limbaugh
An
August 17, 2009 - 10:58 ET by jessieHAnd how many are illegals? I haven't been to a doctor in 30 years. I can't afford it. I can't go to a free clinic because I'm not a child, a woman or an illegal. But there is no way I want the govt. to be in charge of healthcare. They aren't qualified to run a broom, let alone a care system. They are just polititians. They have no common sense. Hell, they have no morals to speak of.
Free health care is bad, if it's not the government providing it
August 17, 2009 - 12:07 ET by CobraManI can't believe the stupidity of this 'report." They're showing how EFFECTIVE charitable health care is, yet they use this FREE, EFFECTIVE heath care as an argument that "free" health care can only be effective if the federal government is paying for it. That's just stupid!
The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution
Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court
Some British newspaper
August 17, 2009 - 14:21 ET by BruzillaSome British newspaper echoed this story as an example of the typical US healthcare system. They pointed out how 8,000 people, who had fallen on hard times, needed to go to this free clinic for their healthcare since we don't have universal healthcare.
They didn't bother to note that even taking the 47 million uninsured number as valid, at the time these 8,000 people were seeking their free healthcare, about 260,000,000 Americans had the freedom to seek out any doctor, have virtually any procedure performed, without the need for long waiting periods, government approvals, or other issues associated with the British NHS.
So, we have 47 million people getting nothing, and 260 million being taken care of, while Britain screws over everyone equally. Hard to see where the Brits have a better deal.
Access to Health Care
August 17, 2009 - 15:51 ET by deerjerkydaveThis report demonstrates that people without health insurance still have access to health care. It may not be as fast or as extensive as paying customers but it works. It demonstrates that the socialists in our political system are only interested in taking over the insurance industry, they don't really care about access to health care.
Whoa!!
August 17, 2009 - 17:30 ET by DoktorFrankenWait a minute. Isn't it the Right that's using Scare Tactics????