CBS: Israeli ‘Hardliner’ Netanyahu is ‘Hitch’ to Pro-Obama Livni Being Prime Minister


On Tuesday’s CBS Evening News, even after Katie Couric introduced a story about Israel’s election which will determine the next prime minister as being "too close to call," correspondent Richard Roth’s report spent more time focusing on the popularity of center-left Kadima party candidate Tzipi Livni – whom the report linked to Barack Obama – and featured positive soundbites of her supporters, but devoted little time to her conservative Likud party rival and former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whom Roth briefly presented as a "hitch" to Livni becoming Israel's leader.

In her introduction, Couric labeled Netanyahu as a "hardline" candidate: "In Israel they're counting votes in an election that remains too close to call. Late tonight, hardline candidate Benjamin Netanyahu claimed victory, but exit polls show Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni in front. Despite that, Richard Roth tells us the process of choosing a new prime minister is far from over."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Roth began by relating that Livni "faces a huge political hurdle" and then gave a positive presentation of her "hope and change" candidacy, including soundbites of Israeli citizens expressing admiration for her.

RICHARD ROTH: A lawyer and former Mossad agent, Livni took a tough line during Israel's offensive in Gaza, then peppered campaign speeches with hope and change. She defied Israel's macho and military tradition in politics and voters liked it.

TAMIR LAZAROV, ISRAELI VOTER: I thought it was the best option that we have right now, so-

REUT GAN, ISRAELI VOTER: And she's a woman.

LAZAROV: Yeah, she's a woman. That's a bonus.

ANAT FELZENWALBE, ISRAELI VOTER: She hasn't failed yet and she's a woman. She deserves a chance. And women are better listeners. They don't work from the ego.

After relaying Livni’s promise to work with the Obama administration toward Middle East peace, Roth presented Netanyahu as an obstacle to Livni’s election, and did not include soundbites of the conservative candidate’s supporters. Roth:

The hitch is, in Israel's fragmented parliamentary politics, former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is still her rival for the job. With fewer votes but a bigger block of potential right-wing allies, Netanyahu also claimed victory, insisting he'll be able to form a coalition government and become Israel's next prime minister. Even at Livni's happy headquarters here, they know that's not just empty rhetoric, and political wrangling now will decide who really won.

On the next morning's The Early Show, as previously documented by NewsBuster Kyle Drennen, Roth fretted that a Netanyahu win would be a "setback" for Obama: "And that could be a setback for the White House, eager to restart a peace process in the Middle East."

Below is a complete transcript of the report from the Tuesday, February 10, CBS Evening News:

KATIE COURIC: In Israel they're counting votes in an election that remains too close to call. Late tonight, hardline candidate Benjamin Netanyahu claimed victory, but exit polls show Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni in front. Despite that, Richard Roth tells us the process of choosing a new prime minister is far from over.

RICHARD ROTH: Her election night headquarters erupted in cheers, but Tzipi Livni faces a huge political hurdle to becoming prime minister, even if the vote count confirms exit poll predictions. A lawyer and former Mossad agent, Livni took a tough line during Israel's offensive in Gaza, then peppered campaign speeches with hope and change. She defied Israel's macho and military tradition in politics and voters liked it.

REUT GAN, ISRAELI VOTER: I thought it was the best option that we have right now, so-

TAMIR LAZAROV, ISRAELI VOTER: And she's a woman.

GAN: Yeah, she's a woman. That's a bonus.

ANAT FELZENWALBE, ISRAELI VOTER: She hasn't failed yet and she's a woman. She deserves a chance. And women are better listeners. They don't work from the ego.

ROTH: Livni's been Israel's chief negotiator with the Palestinians and says as prime minister she'd work with the Obama administration to try to reach a peace deal. The hitch is, in Israel's fragmented parliamentary politics, former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is still her rival for the job. With fewer votes but a bigger block of potential right wing allies, Netanyahu also claimed victory, insisting he'll be able to form a coalition government and become Israel's next prime minister. Even at Livni's happy headquarters here, they know that's not just empty rhetoric, and political wrangling now will decide who really won. Richard Roth, CBS News, Tel Aviv.

—Brad Wilmouth is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I can see it now...

Between Obama and Hillary, peace in the middle east basically means Israel making ridiculous concessions; like giving up Jerusalem.

It's the Chamberlain peacenik leadup to WWIII, 21st century style.

Conservatism you can believe in.

Bibi is the " MAN " he will take nothing from the Muslims , including  Barry. Great news for moral clarity in a troubled regieon. Finally, they have someone to protect the people of Israel.

Rightward shift

Although the election was close, Kadima did not really gain.Rather, Yisrael Beiteinu took away Likud votes.

This is a harder shift to the right than a Likud win. Yisrael Beiteinu stepped
over Labor as the number 3 party in the polls. Its not over till its
over, but it looks like Israel is going to have a hard right wing
government coming out of this.

easygoer... That's what I

easygoer...

That's what I am hearing too!

YAHOO!

BT The AP used the adjective "hard liner"

In the Israeli election coverage blurb in my local rag. So I guess all the robots, including Katie, were parroting the verbiage from the AP. I was unsure what the the opponent of Netanyahu (sp?) is in the politco-meter left or 'centrist' as the article claimed. But I figure anyone who wants to kick palestinian ass in general and hamas ass specifically is going to be labeled as a "hard liner" in leftistworld. Israel is seeing the US leftist writing on the wall and are 'girding' their loins for the coming conflict w/o the aid of the U.S. The Israelis as I have posted before are not going to give up with out a large fight and Damascus and Tehran better beware. BTW I think it is time for some bylines for AP (AP= associalated propaganda) articles since all the jerks who write these bs lefty articles get to hide behind the AP appelation.   

"Somehow, I told you so, just doesn't quite say it." Will Smith in 'I, Robot.'

Good Points Everyone

I too have been reading the AP articles yesterday and today.  I think they called Netanyahu a "hard liner" about three or four times in every article, just in case the reader didn't catch it the first or second time.  He's clearly the villian in these articles.

Yesterday the AP did its best to portray the election as a clear victory for Livni when their only source for data was exit polling which showed a tight race.  Exit polling that shows a tight race is never a strong indicator of how it will end.  I am not surprised to see today the actual results coming in and seeing an overall shift to the right.

Here's an example of the AP coverage:

"The two offer vastly different approaches when it comes to peacemaking with the Palestinians: Livni supports giving up territory to make room for a Palestinian state, while Netanyahu has said he considers current U.S.-backed Mideast peace talks a waste of time."

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090211/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_politics 

Can you believe this garbage?  Livni has a plan for coexisting peace, but the evil Netanyahu is just a naysayer without any plan of his own.

Livni's been Israel's chief

Livni's been Israel's chief negotiator with the Palestinians

Ya and how has that been working lately? 

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Notice that the MSM makes

Notice that the MSM makes only a feeble attempt at educating the viewers on how all Parliamentary elections work and coalition governments are produced. A redux of 'but Gore got the most votes' and total ignorance of the Electoral College in 2000.

Obama And The Middle East Challenge

It does look like Netanyahu will play a major role in the new government and the man has a backbone! This doesn't look good for our kissy-face president. Hillary will be caught between a rock and a bowl of Jello. The Palestinian pretenders may have their way with Obama but Netanyahu has history on his side along with our support--for now, anyway.  He knows the ultimate goal is the complete obliteration of Israel and this must not happen! However, I don't have much confidence in a leader (?) who has to go begging with scare tactics to gain support for his outrageous stimulus plan.

http://www.chalktalk-talk.blogspot.com

She hasn't failed yet, what

She hasn't failed yet, what about Lebanon? What about continuing missles from Gaza? What about stopping the Gaza War before success was achieved? What about the surrender of Gaza in the first place? Not a big success record there. Funny how the reporters couldn't find any Bibi supporters in the crowd?

At least now when Herr Obamafuhrer

At least now when Herr Obamafuhrer and his hench-person Joachim von Clintontrop decide its time to sell Israel down the river in order to appease their Iranian dictator friend, at least Israel will be in a better position to stand on its own.

On a historical note, no nation that has ever turned its back on Israel has ever thrived again.

-Dave

Our clueless political leaders are about to drive us all over a cliff. The time to HITM is now-before we go over.

lololololololol!

"Herr Obamafuhrer and his hench-person Joachim von Clintontrop"

lol! 

I haven't laughed that hard in a couple of days.

I'm with you

Baseballmaven

 Well stated, Dave...

  Does Couric even understand how the elections work in Israel--just because "exit polls" showed Livni "ahead" by 1 or 2 pts is meaningless in terms of who becomes prime minister--the majority will be a conservative coalition--thank goodness!