Appearing on CNN's Reliable Sources Sunday to mark the 10th anniversary of becoming host of CNN's Late Edition, Wolf Blitzer defended Al Gore's famous statement that he "took the initiative in creating the Internet," as the CNN anchor argued that Gore's words, which came during a March 1999 interview with Blitzer, were "misreported" and "twisted" by the media. Blitzer: "It never dawned on me that that would be exploded and, to a certain degree, misreported on what he said. He never said, 'I invented the Internet,' although that headline was so damaging to him, as a result of that interview."
After host Howard Kurtz asked if the media "kind of twisted the meaning of the words," Blitzer agreed with that assessment, and credited Gore with work in Congress that "resulted in a lot of other people creating the Internet." Blitzer: "Yes, yes. Because if you look precisely at what he said ... when he was a member of the Congress, he did take the initiative in passing the legislation that eventually resulted in a lot of other people creating the Internet, not necessarily him. But all of it, as you correctly point out, was lost because the headline was 'I invented the Internet.' And that really, that really hurt him a lot." (Transcript follows)
Video of Blitzer's question and Gore's response, from a March 9, 1999, primetime edition of Late Edition, can be seen in the March 12, 1999, CyberAlert here.
Below is a complete transcript of the exchange from the Sunday, July 6, Reliable Sources on CNN:
HOWARD KURTZ: I had not realized it until recently, that when you interviewed Al Gore back in the 2000 campaign, that the famous phrase that has always been affixed to him, "inventing the Internet," came in an interview with you. Was it some sort of trick question that you drew this out of him?
WOLF BLITZER: No, it was a simple question: What makes you different than his opponent for the Democratic nomination, Senator Bill Bradley of New Jersey? And I wanted him to give me some examples why he thought he'd be better to be the Democratic nominee than Senator Bradley. And then, at some point, he started talking about, I took the initiative in, to create, I don't remember the exact phrase, to create the Internet. But it never dawned on me that that would be exploded and, to a certain degree, misreported on what he said. He never said, "I invented the Internet," although that headline was so damaging to him, as a result of that interview.
KURTZ: So you think the media kind of twisted the meaning of the words?
BLITZER: Yes, yes. Because if you look precisely at what he said, he was very precise -- and, as you know, Al Gore is a very precise guy -- when he was a member of the Congress, he did take the initiative in passing the legislation that eventually resulted-
KURTZ: Yes, but all that got lost.
BLITZER: -in a lot of other people creating the Internet, not necessarily him. But all of it, as you correctly point out, was lost because the headline was "I invented the Internet." And that really, that really hurt him a lot.
—Brad Wilmouth is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.




HOWARD KURTZ: I had not realized it until recently, that when you interviewed Al Gore back in the 2000 campaign, that the famous phrase that has always been affixed to him, "inventing the Internet," came in an interview with you. Was it some sort of trick question that you drew this out of him?














Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Al's Internet
July 6, 2008 - 13:06 ET by BarrackLike there's such a huge difference between "Inventing the internet" and "Creating the Internet". geeesh
www.benbarrack.com
"Mission Accomplished"
July 6, 2008 - 13:33 ET by TruthMonger"Mission Accomplished" Al
we'll still celebrate every anniversary of your "internet creation" with much glee and fanfare:)
in all 57 states, right obama?
I just looked up "Histories
July 6, 2008 - 14:02 ET by kgI just looked up "Histories of the Internet" by the Internet Society and no where is Gore's name mentioned.
http://www.isoc.org/internet/history/brief.shtml
"Forget change, I want improvement!"
→ kg
July 6, 2008 - 14:08 ET by Cool ArrowAnd how old was this wunderkind when he created the Internet?
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
That vast right wing
July 6, 2008 - 15:56 ET by celatorThat vast right wing conspiracy is at it again!!
Now they're changing history. Those rascals! Someone has to stop them.
It's all in the semantics!
July 7, 2008 - 09:33 ET by goldenthroatBarrack,
You ask if there's a difference between 'inventing the internet' and 'creating the internet'. There is - if you're a liberal!
"Everything you know is wrong!" - Firesign Theatre (and the Democratic Party)
BUT AL GORE IS AN IVENTOR OF RENOWN.....
July 6, 2008 - 13:47 ET by PaarlHE INVENTED GLOBAL WARMING......OUT OF THE VACUUM OF PURE NOTHINGNESS!!!!!!
Paarl of Rhodesia
Paarl... LOL...You beat
July 6, 2008 - 14:00 ET by bigtimerPaarl...
LOL...You beat me to it...those were my thoughts exactly..
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
invented???
July 6, 2008 - 14:41 ET by pagg30They have to 'invent' a problem so they are needed to fix it.
An Inconvienient Dilusion of Fact
He Still Doesn't Make Sense
July 6, 2008 - 14:01 ET by Tyler DurbinAl Gore was 15 years old when the intellectual underpinnings of the Internet were first conceived! Even if we accept his assertion that he never claimed to be its inventor, his influence in the development of the Internet (on any level) is dubious, at best. The D.O.D. had already deployed the system, years before Mr. Gore was ever elected to office. Come on Mr. Blitzer--provide some damned context!
"Virtue is more to be feared than vice, because its excesses are not subject to the regulation of conscience."
Here's Blizter's context in
July 6, 2008 - 15:58 ET by celatorHere's Blizter's context in its entirety: "I said it so it must be true."
Unfortunately M. Thatcher
July 6, 2008 - 15:31 ET by jpm100Unfortunately M. Thatcher invented global warming to undermine the UK's coal miners' union (no pun intended) and force a switch to Nuclear power.
algore and his internet
July 6, 2008 - 14:07 ET by art341I was using the internet when algore thought it was a place for freshly caught trout. In those days it was called the ARPAnet and browsing was still something you did at Macy's when you didn't want to buy anything.
Ya know
July 6, 2008 - 14:33 ET by 10ksnookerI was there when the Internet was created, we were officially site number twelve. And Al Gore didn't create anything. Yes, it all ran on 300 baud Teletype, no graphics :+)
Well "no graphics" is not
July 7, 2008 - 01:41 ET by Dan The Man 2Well "no graphics" is not entirely true. Some of the more enterprising individuals did print out graphics albeit primitive with the limited type available. I was in ninth grade, in a computer logic class and saw the handiwork when we logged onto a site and accessed a program and it printed a picture of Snoopy I think.
Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.
AlGore
July 6, 2008 - 14:53 ET by SharkAlGore did not invent the internet, but he did stay in a Holiday Inn last night.....and sauced the buffet......
Al Gore's childish fantasies
July 6, 2008 - 15:54 ET by lgeubankThe "History of the Internet" site DOES mention Gore:
So Al Gore took the initiative in creating the Internet in 1988! Before that, we were all just playing around, huh Al?
When did Al take the initiative in creating the movie "Love Story"?
You have to wonder about grown-up men who delude themselves with fantasies that they flew rocket ships or killed dragons or shot Billie the Kid.
Al Gore is scientifically illiterate. He knows no more about computer science than he does about meteorology. This charlatan is an insult to everybody who DOES know something about a scientific subject.
What Gore Said
July 6, 2008 - 18:02 ET by allanfARPANET was around well before 1988. Gore did support the technology. I do believe the words "in creating the Internet" reflect the great hubris of this man.
For the record here is what Gore said in front of fellow Democrat Blitzer.
semantically sophisticated sentence = lie
July 6, 2008 - 21:27 ET by needleThank you, Allanf, for researching and supplying exactly what Al said.
It does appear that Al was articulate and spoke precisely as Blitzer alleges. It is not true that he spoke the truth, nor is it true that what he said came even close to what Al’s apologist Blitzer says Al meant to say, or at least should have mean to say.
Notice how Blitzer creates a faux statement that is not verbatim but is very similar to the statement that Al Gore made and then denies that Al Gore made the faux statement, clearly implying that Al did not say what in fact he did say. As far as I am concerned, Blitzer, that is a lie; but for a Liberal it is just a semantically sophisticated sentence, like “I did not have sex with that woman, Monica Lewinski.”
Impunitas semper ad deteriora invitat.
Evidently it's reinvent Al season...
July 6, 2008 - 17:21 ET by ThalpyEvidently it's reinvent Al season. Start watching the sea; Al will be walking out on it at any moment.
He did not even "create" it
July 6, 2008 - 20:30 ET by wdhorningThe only thing Al Gore ever invented/created is "inconvenient lies". His lies inconvenience the rest of us.
Every Computer Science expert in the world, of which there are now millions, will tell you not only about the long history of networking computers (internet) going back to the 1960's, which grew from out of government, educational and private networks, but of how public networks were born in the late 1980s, and bloomed in the early 1990's. None of this had anything to do with the initiatives of Al Gore. As for governmental regulation of the Internet, that also went back to the 1960's, also before Al Gore.
Essentially, from nearly the very beginning of the earliest networks (long before Al Gore was on the scene), there was file transfer protocal (ftp), email protocal (POP), newgroups (USENET), and gopher (to search on other computers on the Internet), plus a number of other useful Internet tools. Then with the Internet already in place, Marc Andressen and Eric Bina, invented Mosaic, the first Web browser. With that invention, and with a decision by several governing bodies, the Internet was open to the public, and backbone nets popped up all over the place, such as PSInet, which was a commercial endeavor, not a govenment plan, and it was open for business in 1989, also long before Al Gore was on the scene as V.P.
Bill Clinton and Al Gore deserve absolutely no credit for the Internet, but they both do deserve a lot of credit for discrediting the office of President and Vice President, respectively. Ironically, they both have discredited these offices through their insidious lies. They were not only "poor excuses" for presidential offices, but "poor excuses" for humans.
People, people, you're all
July 6, 2008 - 20:39 ET by CJK51People, people, you're all missing the point! You're all clearly too stupid to grasp the nuance of what Al was saying to Wolfie way back when. The award-winning Al Gore does not need to say what he means for he is above all that. And furthermore, pay no attention to the black hole of energy expenses that his home, focus on your carbon-spewing lifestyles and leave Al and his nuances alone!
And please do forgive me for getting all that sarcasm on you all :-)
The seeds of what eventually became the internet were planted...
July 6, 2008 - 20:41 ET by R D Helm...well before Al had flunked his first divinity-school exam.
The truth is insensitive. - Neal Boortz
This appears to be a little prep work
July 6, 2008 - 20:56 ET by pbthinkerCNN was be trying to prepare us for the Obamaisms that are going to come. He's already started with the, I passed this legislation, and I proposed that legislation, and I supported this and that. Once we get to the truth, Wolf will be coming out and saying this is how Republicans got Gore and try and back Obama all the way.
Obama is an empty suit and the irony is that, apparently, he's the best the Democrats have to offer. Isn't that funny? Once again, the Democratic nominee is light on substance and they'll be out there straining their credibility, once again, to support him and foist him on an unsuspected public.
Does McCain have what it takes to beat him?
Democrats: Stuck on Stupid since 2000.
The CERN experiment coming up soon...
July 6, 2008 - 21:14 ET by JoggerNotMay make all of this, well, moot...wait and see..hope and pray.
regards...
Meaning...what? They may
July 6, 2008 - 21:20 ET by balboaMeaning...what? They may inadvertently erase reality?
No...I am thinking more along the line of...
July 6, 2008 - 21:35 ET by JoggerNotLittle black holes, giving us about 1 year, to do something.
erase reallity?
You have allready smoked your' reality.
Bummer.
Yea JogNot.;. The Obambatron, particle of change
July 6, 2008 - 21:21 ET by upcountrywaterspinning with hope..
Liberals62%
IranianUranium
Some MRC stuff on algore
July 6, 2008 - 21:02 ET by upcountrywaterwho are those guys; gaffe #2!
Liberals62%
IranianUranium
Al (the sky is falling) Gore
July 6, 2008 - 22:51 ET by I.am.DILLIGAFcouldnt create a fire with two matches and a can of gas. He is the biggest wind bag this side of Bamma
Guns and Violence are not the answer but they are one solution to the problem== SARG
Al Gore's NAPS vs the Commercial Internet
July 6, 2008 - 23:13 ET by redherkey"he did take the initiative in passing the legislation that eventually
resulted in a lot of other people creating the Internet, not
necessarily him"
I co-founded the first commercial provider in the upper Midwest US. Al Gore's claim has been an outright lie that those who helped pioneer the commercial Internet have understood for years.
Gore was instrumental in working with NSFNET and had a proposal to give the administrative control of the network to a partnership between the baby Bells and the IBM/MCI joint venture known as Advanced Network Solution (ANS). ANS operated the NSFNET backbone under contract with the NSF, and provided services to the nonprofit regionals which were prohibited from providing commercial traffic (though they did, while sucking taxpayer funds for bloated retired PhD staffs, including free office and data center facilities colocated at universities, university-paid leased line circuits, university health care benefits, etc.).
Gore intended to give full administrative control to the RBOCs (baby bells) of peering points, charging admission to any commercial service provider to connect, while also being able to sell retail Internet service without the same penalty. This NAP model was also proposed to use a measured rate service, a concept the RBOCs were familiar with from toll networks (long distance). Had they succeeded, the Bells would have likely been the sole providers of Internet, and your usage would have been billed per minute like long distance.
As an early commercial network, we had numerous battles with Gore and NSFNET as the tried to keep anyone not on the RBOC list from having access to NSFNET routes. Back in 1993, most of what people thought of as the Internet was found on NSFNET - things like gophers, WAIS and a plethora of academic domain email users (who were prohibited from using their accounts for commercial purposes, but again, nobody enforced that).
This approach was of particular interest to the RBOCs and they treated Senator Gore very well when it came to time for contributions. Just as Rep. Billy Tauzin used to be called the "Representative from BellSouth," Gore truly was the Senator from the Baby Bells. In the late 1980s, they all saw the writing on the wall from the earlier divestiture and increasing competition. While they were restricted from providing long distance services for some time, they saw this new Internet thing as their chance to get back in charge. At the same time, the failure to control this disruptive technology was considered to be a major risk to the RBOCs. Al Gore was firmly in their camp in working to swing the monopolization of the commercial Internet into the RBOC camp.
Fortunately for everyone here, the Commercial Internet Exchange and aggressive cowboys like Marty Shoffstall at PSI, Rick Adams at UUNET, Bob Collett at Sprint, and Bill Washburn, executive director of the CIX, created a peering platform that invited dozens of networks in and led to other peering facilities like the MSF Datanet MAEs (Metropolitan Area Ethernets). While this topology isn't predominant today, it was instrumental in breaking Al Gore's monopoly dream.
Like global warming, Al Gore has consistently been on the wrong side of change. He's consistently embraced the old boy network (likely because they pay for his immense overhead) and has worked relentlessly to impede the advancement of the right causes for individual liberty and the empowerment of the little guy.
rh... Wow...and thank you
July 6, 2008 - 23:20 ET by bigtimerrh...
Wow...and thank you for all this info.
Btw...it was algore that gave us the universal tax on our phone bills every month under the guise of every school being connected to the internet was it not?
Is this partly what you are talking about...the tax was and is outrageous.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Al Gore's Internet Vision
July 6, 2008 - 23:26 ET by redherkeyJust to give some context to my previous post, place yourself in 1991-1993. Al Gore is proposing transitioning from the NSFNET to a commercial Internet that would be run by the regional Bell operating companies (RBOCs). These regional monopolies would be able to set rates and terms on all access to the Internet, and would bill per minute for access.
One example of this was US West (acquired into Qwest), which was running a pilot program called CommunityLink. US West partnered with a France Telecom subsidiary to use a "Internet terminal" called Minitel, a clunky little monochrome videotext terminal hooked up to your phone line, connecting to various bulletin boards run by your supermarket, local radio stations, movie theater ticket office, school districts, city government, etc. Each paid US West to have their bulletin board hosted, and you paid per minute for access. Eventually they envisioned where you could order movies (US West Interactive) as well as see what specials were on sale at the grocery, request a song on the radio, and see the bus schedule. They called this environment the "Global Village" and it was about as exciting as a Soviet planned city.
If you're curious what Al Gore's Internet would have looked like, here are some links on the CommunityLink project:
http://seattlepi.nws...
http://findarticles....
http://www.aisworld....
I helped bury CommunityLink in its Omaha pilot market, and spent countless hours enlisting our Senators to tell Al Gore to back off on his monopoly aspirations. It's amusing that he's back again, foisting yet another completely worthless concept upon us in a means of transferring trillions of wealth to those he does bidding for.
Woah redherkey, algore industrialist by government fiat
July 7, 2008 - 00:21 ET by upcountrywaterNow his global warming carbon tax...algore ya, sick puppy
thank you for your input.
Liberals62%
IranianUranium
Barack will not be on the ballet in Nov.
July 7, 2008 - 09:46 ET by SemperrightWrite this down.
Barack will not be on the ballet in Nov. He will have a Clinton sized "accident" The MSM knows this so they are picking the next candidate. They want Gore next instead of Hillery.
Semperdamus has made this prediction.
"Some people spend an entire lifetime wondering if they made a difference.
The MARINES don't have that problem."
President Ronald Reagan - 1985
Oh, if members of the MSM
July 7, 2008 - 10:18 ET by Chris NormanOh, if members of the MSM would only occasionally explain what Republicans really meant when they make a controversial or questionable statement - but no, they're the ones that are usually helping fan the flames...