The Seattle Post-Intelligencer is refusing to run the photos of two men the FBI is seeking to question in connection with suspicious behavior aboard a Puget Sound ferry - behavior that could be a precursor to a terror plot, or could be nothing nefarious at all.
The Seattle PI reports the story here and explains its rationalization for not publishing the photos here. And - in a steller example of complete touchy-feely uselessness - the paper is holding a haiku-writing contest for readers to write about how they feel about the FBI alert and the way the paper handled it.
From the report:
The FBI is asking the public for help in identifying two men who were seen behaving unusually aboard several Washington state ferries. About four weeks ago, the FBI fielded several reports from passengers and ferry workers about the men, who seemed "overly interested in the workings and layouts of the ferries," Special Agent Robbie Burroughs said Monday.
The FBI also publicized photos of the men, which were taken by a ferry employee, Burroughs said. The Seattle P-I is not publishing the photos because neither man is considered a suspect nor has either been charged with a crime.
From the excuse, er, rationalization, er, explanation by Seattle P-I Managing Editor David McCumber:
Ferry security is hugely important. So are civil liberties and privacy.
The P-I last year reported that according to a Justice Department inspector general's assessment, Puget Sound's ferries were the nation's No. 1 target for maritime terrorism.
This may well be a case of alert citizens spotting a very real threat. But running a photograph of two men who may as easily be tourists from Texas as terrorists from the Mideast with a story that makes them out to be persons of interest in a terrorism investigation seems problematic, to say the least.
Yeah. Of course it would be easier to find out which is the case if the FBI could find the guys. And it would be easier to find the guys if the Seattle P-I would publish the photos, so that Seattle-area residents would know what the men look like whom the FBI has asked the public to help them find. As it stands now, in the name of being politically correct, the Seattle P-I has decided to alarm the people of Seattle and leave them looking suspiciously at just about anyone who fits the general description of male and looking like they might be from the Middle East.
Besides, while McCumber raises the flag of "civil liberties and privacy," the men in the photo were photographed in public while on a public ferry.
There is no invasion of their privacy, nor of their civil liberties, by publishing the photos so that the authorities can locate and speak with the men.
Disagree with me on that? Consider this: If Managing Editor McCumber needed art to illustrate a story on the region's ferry system, he could and likely would dispatch a Seattle P-I photographer to one of the ferries, and publish a shot of random ferry passengers on the deck of the boat. The paper might not even bother to identify the people in the photo.
Newspapers publish crowd shots taken in public all the time without identifying the people in the photo or asking if they mind having their photo published - or knowing if they are or are not involved in some sort of criminal activity.
McCumber's excuse for not running the photos is ... beyond weak. It is a figleaf for political correctness run amok, political correctness that may compromise the security of the people of the Seattle area that the Seattle Post-Intelligencer ostensibly exists to serve.
Politeness causes me to refrain from suggesting the editors of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer must be smoking something.
The good news: The P-I's decision to not run the photos is fueling widespread distribution of the photos in the blogosphere.
No word yet on how the Seattle Times is going to handle the FBI's request - the most recent story in the Seattle Times that seems relevant was this story published August 3.
Here's more from the Jawa Report. Also, the blogger at The View From Out Here, comments, "If we don’t know what they look like then how can we identify them? If you think they are just tourists, did you ever, on vacation, take pictures of a restricted area on a boat and tried to measure the size of the boat?"
No.
The P-I should put the security of its community ahead of the desire to not hurt some folks' feelings.
Update: Michelle Malkin's excellent post on the Seattle ferry story reminds us of the the Seattle Times' investigation in 2004 on reports on jihadi probing of the ferry system.
Update: A commenter at the Seattle Post-Intelligencer's website notes how out of touch with reality the editors of that paper are about the new media world in which they now operate.
It's amazing to me to think that, in this internet era, the [paper] is arrogant enough to think that they can 'hide' something from the public. By not publishing the pictures, they are making themselves less relevant - additionally, through the controversy, they are making the story bigger than it would be otherwise. This is a perfect example of why newspapers, and big media in general, is losing readers by the thousands.
Neither the Seattle Post-Intelligencer nor the rival Seattle Times is the gatekeeper of information in the greater Seattle area anymore, if they ever were. Neither are any of the local TV news stations. There are just so many news outlets and distributors now - cable networks, websites of out-of-town papers, and blogs - that no matter what the Seattle Post-Intelligencer did, the people of Seattle were going to see these photos.
Thus, their decision to not publish the photos does not in any way accomplish the goal that drove that decision, while simultaneously showing the people of Seattle that the paper will put political correctness ahead of the security of thousands of Seattle-area ferry commuters - and demonstrating its increasing irrelevance in the broad and varied new-media landscape.
A dumb and dangerous decision all around.
—Bill Hobbs is author of Who Is Fred Thompson, a blog-centric look at the presidential candidate.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Figures! Btw...I know
August 21, 2007 - 20:24 ET by bigtimerFigures!
Btw...I know about this and have seen these men along with their pictures....this should be a National Alert everywhere.
Washington State along with Oregon have done nothing but aid and abet the enemy...for years now.
Washington and Oregon aiding and abeting? More so Oregon...
August 22, 2007 - 00:22 ET by MrCameramanHey bigtimer...Greetings from the NW. I would agree with your statement about aiding and abeting, but, WA is the place where our customs/border folks nabbed Ahmed Ressam back in 2000, and the place where the suspected Oregon training camp was broken up...the FBI has done well in WA, it's Oregon and Portland where the problem is, their police force decided not to help the JTTF in Portland...so there you've got a point...anyway, have pity on those of us that live here in liberal land...and btw, KOMO, the ABC affiliate in Seattle is running the photos.
Dorothy
August 21, 2007 - 20:29 ET by CaringwhiteguyDorothy Parvaz must not take the ferry
Parvaz
August 21, 2007 - 21:36 ET by pocomocoThe ferri is too gauche for the likes of Parvaz. She's definately a Prius kind of gal.
What the P.I. needs is a decrease in subscriptions...
August 21, 2007 - 20:32 ET by JayTeeGee, Sounds like people need to recognize what the Paper represents.......and it isn't the citizens who read it. I think a large draw down in subscriptions, or mass cancellations would help put Intelligence back into the Post Intelligencer.
I would find another Read.......and wait for them to fold and be replaced by another concerned publication....more concerned for it's citizens, less concerned for criminals, more support for the Police, etc...
What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ? David Foote GoE
"neither man is a suspect
August 21, 2007 - 20:43 ET by Blazer"neither man is a suspect nor has been charged with a crime"
Hmmmm,.........with out doing too much research here, I'll go out on a limb, and say that didn't stop them from posting the pictures of the Duke Lacrosse players, or drumming up criminal conspiracies about Bush, Cheney, and Rove, with pictures included. Just a hunch though.
from Wiki
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer is one of two daily newspapers in Seattle, Washington, United States, the other being the Seattle Times. The P-I is widely perceived to be more liberal than the Times.[citation needed] It is well-known nationally for its editorial page, especially its editorials and political cartoons.[citation needed]
"The P-I is widely perceived to be more liberal than the Times."
Hard to believe, but I guess that pretty much sums it up right there folks.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious. "
- Ben Kenobi on Liberals, and the MSM.
Mr. Hobb's... I want to
August 21, 2007 - 21:01 ET by bigtimerMr. Hobb's...
I want to say one more thing to you....I hope you keep posting/blogging here...if nobody pays attention to what you are have been saying...well isn't that how life goes?
I just want to thank you.
My Hiaku
August 21, 2007 - 21:13 ET by SarahAnnieWho are these 'masked' men?
Michelle Malkin has pictures
Go check out her site.
Hey, this is pretty fun! Let me get some more booze in me and I'll try again. Maybe.
Nebraskans for War: Peace through Strength
*Blink Blink Blink*
August 21, 2007 - 21:15 ET by BondPlainBond...
Good haiku
August 21, 2007 - 22:30 ET by muh-oonHere is the one I just posted:
The Seattle Post
takes threat seriously, prints
floating edition
This is almost as fun as a captionfest.
Seattle Post
August 21, 2007 - 22:48 ET by Felicity RandI'm going out on a limb here--not really--that if the FBI wanted them to print pictures of two suspects behaving strangely outside an abortion clinic. . .
Front Page
August 21, 2007 - 22:54 ET by Free StinkerFront Page
My Haiku...
August 21, 2007 - 23:41 ET by m4ster chiefThe haiku I just submitted:
Hold Liberal Convention
Aboard the ferry; then
Sink that sucker!
FWIW: May be considered by some as lo-ku...
Sunrise at sea; a breeze across the deck, salty spray tickles the face, the aroma of fresh coffee, stack gas, and haze-gray paint is in the air. Another Navy day aboard ship as a Navy Chief...the perfect life!
Here's a question: does the
August 21, 2007 - 23:03 ET by balboaHere's a question: does the FBI ever do this for American criminals or non terrorist situations? Do the police?
Bal, here's the answer:
August 22, 2007 - 14:26 ET by MikeBBal, here's the answer: YES. There have been many instances when a photo or photos are shown on tv and newspapers because they are "persons of interest". Notice they are not described as suspects, but persons of interest that the police or FBI want to talk to.
"A communist is someone who reads Marx. An anti-communist is someone who understands Marx." Ronald Reagan
Crapola
August 21, 2007 - 23:15 ET by JoePMore crapola, fakery and ooogah, boogah!! Be afraid, all of ye! Bad guys, aaaayrabs for cryin' out loud, are comin' to take .....I don't know, but to take somethin' away from us. We haven't figured out yet what it is, but it's be repeated over and over, so it must be true.
Past your bed-time, Joey.
August 21, 2007 - 23:19 ET by RJPast your bed-time, Joey.
Do you think that if the
August 21, 2007 - 23:44 ET by BlondeDo you think that if the Seattle P-I Managing Editor David McCumber's daughter had been raped, and the cops had a composite drawing of the perp....that that would be printed on the front page?
Anyone?
David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive
Ah, but there you're
August 21, 2007 - 23:49 ET by balboaAh, but there you're talking about a crime that's been committed, someone is actually wanted for committing a crime.
Would They Publish Photos of Two White Guys Who Were...
August 22, 2007 - 00:11 ET by Bill HobbsWould they publish photos of two white men seen repeatedly and suspiciously hanging around outside the fences of elementary school playgrounds, talking to young girls, and taking pictures of the fences and locked gates?
You know they would.
No difference here - except, in this case the men sought by law enforcement for questioning are men thought to look "Middle Eastern," rather than white.
Good article, great
August 22, 2007 - 08:12 ET by Ruths husband BenGood article, great links. I had quite a bit of fun reading the haikus. I wonder if the passengers on the Titanic wrote haikus about not needing lifeboats?
I particularly liked this comment by "retep":
"So who cares who these guys are. Tourists or terroists. If they are planning something on the ferry system and you're not blown up in the blast, you have a much better chance of treading water in Puget Sound waiting for a pick up than the choice to burn to death or jump 90+ stories to your death like many of those in the world trade centers. We need to all forgive more. We need to all love each other more and then the fear will start to disapate and we won't have to worry about this type of stuff.
Think about it!
Peace!"
Ack! My cut and paste feature on my computer just laughed so hard it threw up. Gotta get out the handiwipes again.
how 'bout these?
August 22, 2007 - 17:25 ET by sixlbs9ozhaiku contest done...
glad to be writing that I
didn't finish mine
Or...
brown-skinned Arab men
cause overwhelming white guilt;
foolish liberals
Just Like the Others
August 22, 2007 - 19:10 ET by JoePThis fake "ooogah boogah" is no different than the 'scare' a few months ago with the east-coast airports. Big news, headlines for a couple days.
What came of it? Arrests, indictments, convications, death penalties?
You'd only know if you read the small paragraph on page 7 or so of just a small handful of newspapers.
The 'terror scare' was a test only. Yipper, just a test by DHS, but it took 3-4 months to come out with that information and scant was mentioned, so most folks probably still think "geez, I'm so scared....whatever happened there?"
Few are probably aware of that on this board, being a circular atmosphere, since most were probably too busy answering the poll at this link about Americans not knowing anything about what's going on in the world, right fellers?!?!
http://www.breitbart...