All of the attention in the media in recent days over reports of cheers in the Seattle Times newsroom over Karl Rove leaving the White House, and boos in the MSNBC newsroom during a George W. Bush State of the Union speech, don't surprise me. I've seen this kind of naked and unprofessional expression of political bias against Republicans in a newsroom before.
My first job in a newspaper newsroom was in Abilene, Texas. I could not have told you what any one of my co-workers there thought about politics. Ditto for my second daily newspaper job, at the newspaper in Lubbock, Texas, and my third, at the newspaper in Clarksville, Tennessee.
Political bias was a little more on display at my fourth job, at a business weekly in Nashville, but nothing like what happened at the Tennessean on election night in 1994.
You'll recall that in 1994 the Republican Party swept to big gains nationally in House and Senate races and gubernatorial elections. In Tennessee, the GOP took the governor's chair held by a retiring Democrat, defeated a three-term Democratic incumbent U.S. Senator with a political novice named Bill Frist, and gave the highest statewide vote total in history to that point to one Fred Thompson to fill the last two years of the term of Al Gore Jr., who had had resigned his Senate seat to become Bill Clinton's vice president.
I was one of four people in the newsroom that night - just four! - who were happy about the election results. I knew how the other three felt because we communicated via the newsroom computer system our pleasure with each new bit of good news for the GOP.
The other three dozen or so reporters and editors working that night were very obviously crestfallen, upset, downcast and just plain not happy as CNN reported on GOP victory after another.
However, when CNN reported that Sen. Ted Kennedy had survived a tough challenge (from Mitt Romney, who went on to run the successful Salt Lake City Winter Olympics, and then was elected as Massachusetts' governor, and now is running for the GOP presidential nomination), a loud and boisterous cheer went up in the newsroom.
The primary political leaning of the newsroom was evident: Democrat. Liberal, anti-Republican. No big deal, that - as long as they kept the bias out of the paper. But the tone for the paper's coverage had already been set in the last weeks of the campaign, when the paper ran the results of a poll in the Senate race between Bill Frist and 18-year-incumbent Sen. Jim Sasser, a poll that found some 18 percent of voters "undecided" with election day just two weeks away.
The paper described the race as "too close to call," - when an honest analysis of the poll would have said that high percentage of "undecided" voters indicated trouble for the incumbent. Almost nobody is undecided about a three-term incumbent that close to election day.
Was the race described as "too close to call," to depress the challengers' supporters and buck up the incumbent's? If so, it didn't work - Sasser lost in a landslide as virtually all of the late undecideds went for the challenger.
In hindsight, the paper should have seen that coming - big Republican gains were expected nationally, but The Tennessean circa 1994 simply didn't want to see it happen - and so they worked hard to try to prevent it.
In the waning days of the campaign, the paper printed a story implying that Frist was racist because a reporter on the campaign bus heard Frist say he didn't want to hand out pre-sharpened pencils out at a campaign stop in an inner city neighborhood because he might, as he put it, get "stuck." His fear: If the pencils are sharpened, I might jab myself on one.. The paper's spin: Frist was suggesting the African-American kids might use the pencils as weapons.
The paper's anti-Republican tone was on display again at the afternoon staff meeting on election day, when one of the paper's top editors - now retired - walked into the meeting with exit polling data and said this:
"It's worse than we feared."
Not, "It's a bigger landslide than was expected."
"It's worse than we feared."
Translation: the evil GOP is winning everything in sight.
And notice the all-inclusive "we," as if the editor believed his entire staff agreed with him that it was bad thing that the Republicans were winning. In truth, he was mostly right as most of them did.
(Full disclosure: I was not at that staff meeting but have confirmed with three newsroom staffers who were there, one of them a Democrat, that the statement was made. That's enough to pass the journalistic credibility test.)
A few days later, as the magnitude of the Republican sweep set in, one of the assistant editorial page editors told me they had decided to add a local conservative columnist to their staff. Up to then, their only conservative political columns were from nationally syndicated columnists.
And indeed they did add that new local conservative columnist to the staff - seven years later, in 2001. By then I had long since left the Tennessean and gone on to a successful freelance career and also had written more than 100 conservative political columns for two different local papers - a start-up weekly and a start-up daily.
While the Tennessean's editorial page editor did discuss with me the possibility of having me write a conservative political column for the paper - as I had experience writing conservative political commentary and had the connections and contacts and credibility in conservative circles to write it - they eventually gave the task to a columnist already on staff who admitted - in print - that he agreed with Republicans on only a few issues (fiscal conservatism, educational choice, to name two) but still agreed with Democrats 70 percent of the time.
They called the new column "Equal Time," an astonishing admission that the paper had not been giving conservative opinion equal coverage up to that point. But then they ghettoized the conservative opinions in a special once-a-week section, rather than feature them on the main op-ed page.
To Nashville's biggest daily newspaper in 2001, that was considered ideological balance in the opinion pages.
Me? I started a blog in 2001.
Fast-forward to 2007. The "Equal Time" column long ago ceased to exist. Most of the editors and reporters who were in the newsroom in 1994 and 2001 are no longer at the paper, so the political bias evident in 1994 and 2001 can't be assigned to the new regime.
And yet, the Tennessean currently does not employ a local conservative political columnist.
Should they ever decide to do so, the local conservative blogosphere has many good writers.
—Bill Hobbs is author of Who Is Fred Thompson, a blog-centric look at the presidential candidate.














Editor at Large

Comments Policy
Shame
August 19, 2007 - 10:52 ET by iveseenitallAs I read this I get a twinge of sadness. From the mid-nineties on the Republicans had such a great chance to make a change. But they blew it by abandoning conservative principles and embracing compromise. Bill Frist turned out to be a twit. Now we have the likes of Mel Martinez leading the GOP. The left-wing media has done its job again. When will conservatives ever learn? Shame on them.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Republicans no longer Conservative
August 19, 2007 - 11:46 ET by mawendtyour comment on compromise is the key. in my observation, the tolerance of liberalism within the Repub party is what is costing conservatism.
i understand about acceptance, big-tent, understanding, blah-blah-blah. i think if you look hard, it is the tolerance of liberalism and compromise through the Guliani-Romney-Chaffee philosophy that is killing the strength of this political club we call Republicans. the desire to win succumbs to weak decisions in order to maintain political power. the RNC is a big guilty contributor to this.
our leadership does need to learn. until there is a house cleaning and a litnus test defined by conservative principles that are enforced, the Republican party will continue to be watered down to become a politer version of the Democrats. Conservatives can learn, its those compromising leaders that won't; they need to be replaced. maw
I couldn't agree more. I
August 19, 2007 - 16:46 ET by mostlymoderateI couldn't agree more. I would be in favor of abandoning the G.O.P. and starting an entirely new party called the "Conservative" party. Ofcourse, we know that getting anyone besides a Republican or Democrat elected is next to impossible :-(
Even worse I have detected
August 19, 2007 - 12:27 ET by Right2thePointEven worse I have detected bunches of Canadians hitting US blogs tyring to shove their ideas of how the world should work down our throat. Man these people need to get a life.
Clearly they screwed the pooch up there and they want to export it.
At least Mike Vick used a rape bench and knew what it was for.
But these clueless MF's aint got no shame and still cast their swill like it is something good we all need to partake in.
I have more than one read my lips phrases to send them but they wouldn't understand them even though kids here in kindergarten could.
Why am I not surprised.
They are probably upset
August 19, 2007 - 16:49 ET by mostlymoderateThey are probably upset because our border security is so weak that illegal Mexican immigrants et. Al. are traveling right up the Coast of California and into Canada.
Hey I just had our usual
August 19, 2007 - 12:52 ET by Right2thePointHey I just had our usual Sunday power outage when they switched generators.
It's almost like clockwork here you can time eggs on and have sure bet Sunday funnies.
Those toads cant parallel a generator to shift the load they believe the first step is to open the breaker on the suplying generator before the new one coming on line is shut to do the deed.
Lights went out , this computer went down , video tapes in the vcr got that whole blured speech thing that is almost comical.
After that I had to read about hundreds of nude protestors putting their butts on cold ass granite near a glacier in a global warming protest.
Talk about the anti viagra moment. What did they get together the GLBT local union?
It's ideology over everything
August 19, 2007 - 13:32 ET by mattmBill,
What you're saying adds to a point made long ago by Michael Medved about Hollywood - they're ideologically driven. It's not money or artistic achievement - it's about pushing Liberalism.
It's the same for the news-media. If they were interested in informing the public or even something as mundane as making money, they'd recruit all the conservative/libertarians they could find. There has always been plenty of them around, and there writing is usually more interesting, more entertaining and more enlightened than anything the MSM has to offer. I mean, who'd you rather read, P.J. O'Rourke or E.J. Dionne Jr.?
Excellent read...........
August 19, 2007 - 13:38 ET by LukeEnjoyed this Bill. I lived in Memphis '94 and traveled quite a bit in the state.
I was between Nashville and Memphis election night, listening to the results via radio, and thinking the landslide could not be that great.
I was pleasantly surprised. Sad that thee conservative politicians did not take full advantage of that year and just became a shadow of their old selves.
Need more moles
August 19, 2007 - 15:04 ET by regimeofterrorBill,
Thanks for this. I expect this kind of stuff to come up again in the 08 elections. A few more utter anti GOP stories that turn out to be false and hardly any criticism of Democrats or their claims on anything.
I think NEWSBUSTERS ought to set up a tip line for journalists to anonymously report this stuff. It might be hard to substantiate unless they could give specifics. Would make for a great way to continue exposing these people.
Saddam Hussein and terrorism. The rest of the story...
http://www.regimeofterror.com
The local paper lefty columns
August 19, 2007 - 14:55 ET by SportPoliticsHere they have that nationaly syndicated bald headed glasses wearing sourpussed lefty who rages on and on about Bush every single week. They also added the now blatantly liberal lefty psycho Walter Cronkite several years ago.
The first guy looks like Les from WKRP in Cincinnati, in fact just imagine Les as a raving angry left wing loon and it fits perfectly. I've never seen such a sourpussed freak before in my entire life, I'm not sure where these people come from. I can't even imagine meeting one of them. No, I've never attended a left wing loon protest or march.
If you ask me the left has come out of their closet, they are so deranged and foaming at the mouth that they can't stop themselves anymore. Between the old guard LIARS who tried to fool all in the USA for decades getting outed in their lies or exposing themselves happily trying to get some credit or notice before they croak for their own lovely lib legacy, and the new young loud mouthed smart alecks proud of their anti- GWB/GOP stances, the left machine is all out there, for all to see.
I guess it's people like david flapjaw gregory who somehow think their agenda is still hidden, or maybe kieth the deformed olbermann who feels he is merely stating the obvious. lol
The left mind speaks out in all it's glorious certainty: " now we see how gwb has destroyed the USA, all it's allies around the world, the clean air and water, the chance for humanity to survive global warming, the children's education, national healthcare, the manufacturing sector, and given us a never ending war that he and his oil buddies can rob the planet with while the middle class is further exterminated and the children starve."
Yes, that's what the loonball lefties say each and every time they open their yapper. Even their demo leaders say it, over and over and over again. They're insano. They've been playing BS far too long, and can't get a handle on how ridiculous their yapping piehole sounds.
Thanks for recounting your
August 19, 2007 - 21:39 ET by Ken ShepherdThanks for recounting your personal experience with newsroom bias, Bill.
It's a shame that your newsroom couldn't put aside its political feelings to be psyched about what was a bona fide exciting political story: the first time in 40 years there would be a change in who held the gavel in the House of Representatives. That's always an exciting political story begging for balanced journalists to recount it for interested news consumers.
Plus, we see how excited the media got in 2006 with the Dems taking back Congress after a mere 12-year sojourn in the minority wilderness.
I remember the crestfallen
August 19, 2007 - 21:50 ET by bigtimerI remember the crestfallen almost in tears Judy Judy Judy Woodruff and I think Bernard Shaw in total shock reporting, just almost paralyzed, in almost stunned belief that this could be happening on then number one CNN....
I was ecstatic...although I can remember that someone was going to pull a rabbit out of a hat or wake me up from a dream that this wasn't really real...
I cannot even imagine what it must be like to be a conservative working now in any of the msm of any kind.
Thanks Bill for all you have done in your life to help counter some of this bias.... that is for sure....
It reminds ME of 1984
August 20, 2007 - 08:47 ET by smitty031the book, and the 2 minutes hate...
This is probably therapy for the libs in that newsroom...a daily hate filled steam letting so that they may go on about their progressive day.