Black Group Condemns Krugman Race Comments

Photo of Amy Ridenour.
  • Bookmark and Share

Members of the Project 21 black leadership group have come out swinging against New York Times columnist Paul Krugman for "scurrilously pinning racist motives on critics of President Obama's health care proposals."

(Earlier today, Clay Waters covered Krugman's column for NewsBusters here.)

The group (full disclosure: I work for the National Center for Public Policy Research, which sponsors Project 21) has also called on President Obama to condemn "this effort to stifle debate with race-baiting tactics" as well as "all efforts to derail legitimate public debate."

Krugman's column drew the following specific comments from Project 21 members:

Mychal Massie (Pennsylvania):

"Paul Krugman is the one with race on the brain.  Specifically, he is using race in the lowest and most repulsive declinations.  He is using it because every other argument to stem the growing tide of condemnation for the proposed health care reform bill has failed.  Ergo, when all else fails, parade out the race card and attempt to incite blacks into becoming the useful idiots.

"Opposition to the proposed health care bill isn't based on race.  It is based on a people who are tired of Congress and the President spitting in their faces.  It is the collective resolve of a people who are tired of being tread upon.  One would think a Nobel prize-winner such as Krugman could figure that out."

Mychal Massie is chairman of Project 21.

Joe Hicks (Los Angeles, California):

"I must have somehow missed the articles from Krugman and other liberal and leftist members of the mainstream media that were critical of the activities of ACORN - the radical, leftist group Barack Obama once represented.  Somehow, their heavy-handed activities - that many argue bent the boundaries of legality - were just considered to be the organized expression of disadvantaged communities.

"Now the same shameless, clueless writers are trying to convince us that those Americans who rightfully feel threatened by government-run health care and confront Obama's noxious scheme at public forums are somehow the acts of a 'mob.'  Krugman reveals his bias by admitting that people are genuinely angry without bringing himself to understand exactly why they are mad.  Smearing the rightful anger and concern of everyday Americans as collections of angry, old white folks - or part of the 'birthers' movement - shows the elitist disdain that liberal journalists such as Krugman have for democracy in action."

Joe Hicks is a Pajamas Television commentator and vice president of Community Advocates, Inc. of Los Angeles.  He is a former executive director of the Los Angeles City Human Relations Commission and former executive director of the Greater Los Angeles chapter of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference.   

Deneen Borelli (East Chester, New York):

"Krugman's commentary shows he is as out of touch as many of our elected officials are with real Americans.  What's happening at town hall meetings has nothing to do with race and everything to do with concern over the rapid expansion of government.

"Americans are frustrated that letters, phone calls and e-mails to their elected representatives have had no impact on significant pieces of legislation such as cap-and-trade and stimulus spending.  Americans are taking the next logical step by directly voicing their opinions to their representatives at town hall meetings."

Deneen Borelli is a full-time fellow with Project 21.  She serves on the board of trustees of The Opportunity Charter School in Harlem, New York and previously served as Manager of Media Relations with the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE).

Bishop Council Nedd II (Harrisburg, Pennsylvania):

"I have nothing to do with the 'birther' issue, but I do have concerns about health care.  So do the people in my parishes and in the local diner where I eat every day.  Living in central Pennsylvania, these truly are the people portrayed in the Norman Rockwell painting about freedom of speech that Krugman reference in his column.  To imply these people are now racists is racist in itself.

"Approximately half of the U.S. population didn't vote for Obama in the first place.  Why is Krugman shocked that there is opposition to the Obama health care plan, and that people dare to voice their concern at public meetings?  The Obama plan inserts government officials into end-of-life decisions for seniors and those among us with the least.  That is not a race issue, that is a privacy issue.  The Obama plan has given a whole new meaning to the idea of government for the people.  This health plan is a bitter pill shoved down people's throat against their will."

Council Nedd is an Anglican bishop, serving the Diocese of the Chesapeake.

Bob Parks (Athol, Massachusetts):

"Why is it when liberals want to make their points, their knee-jerk reaction is to go racial?  Paul Krugman is supposedly a journalist.  Before throwing out the race card while speculating, he should give us some attributed quotes.  Minus that, what he thinks is irrelevant."

Bob Parks is a Project 21 member and media commentator, and operator of the Black and Right web site.

Jimmie Hollis (Millville, New Jersey):

"I knew the moment Obama became a presidential candidate that anyone disagreeing with him would be called a racist, and that any opposition to his political views would be seen as racism.  The left has always played the race card because it works.

"But I am nonetheless happy to see that people on the right and many in the middle are now beginning to speaking out firmly and with passion against policies they oppose.  President Obama should speak out and condemn Paul Krugman racial commentary."

Jimmie L. Hollis is a Project 21 member and is retired from the U.S. Air Force, in which he served from 1962-1987.

Geoffrey Moore (Chicago, Illinois):

"This is not about race.  It is about government control.  The system is not perfect, but there is no need to have the government take over control of the entire health care system.  The government has not demonstrated the ability to efficiently control costs and provide good service.

"Believe it or not, there are a lot of people who are not up in arms about their insurance.  There are people who are somewhat pleased with the coverage they have.  The government getting involved will create enormous expense and waste, while creating more problems than they intend to solve."

Geoffrey Moore is a Project 21 member and a marketing analyst in Chicago.

Project 21's entire statement can be read here.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

well-said, all.

well-said, all.

race card 101

Obama and his party have been playing the race card from day one. Why is anyone shocked?

 

 

It's all they have. 

It's all they have.  Hopefully they're running out of ammo, and their demonization tactics will finally become a laughingstock.

They have run out of

They have run out of ammo.

If they had anything better, they'd use it.

 

"Gov. Palin has been subjected to one of the most massive and dishonest pile-on smear attacks in the history of liberal media.-- Lowell Ponte

Wolf! Wolf! Wolf!

As the Gates affair proved, you can only go to the racial well just so often before the charge of racism looses its sting.  Maybe one day soon people of color will start seeing the liberal racial pandering for what it is.

"Our liberties we prize and our rights we will maintain." Official Motto of the State of Iowa

I think these accusations of

I think these accusations of racism are going to end up hurting people who may actually encounter racism.  I don't think it happens as often as the media portrays, and it ends up being a "boy who cried wolf" situation. 

Your absolutly right

To diminish real bigotry, is a problem. Great read Amy, thanks. 

 

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

Wonder if ACORN and the

Wonder if ACORN and the SEIU will mail these folks Oreo cookies?

I thought Carter and Clinton (both) really sucked and damaged this country and they were white.  Being a Communist and hurting the American people is what matters-race is only a factor because the Libtards and the minority racists make it an issue.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).

Thanks, Amy

At least these comments on Krugman’s badly biased perspective got published … here.   I have a very hard time imagining these comments ever appearing in the NYC High School newspaper “of record.”

- Relying upon the State Run Media for your information is like relying upon an embezzler to manage your portfolio.

Jeez, I hope no one tells Senator Boxer!

Jeez, I hope no one tells Senator Boxer.

She will come back with a couple of black organizations who think the opposition IS racist! (I'll see your one black group and raise you two more!)

Well this just goes to show that Project 21 is not a real  black organization.  They are a bunch of Uncle Toms! Oreos!  House slaves doing the masters' bidding!

mb... Hehee...I love the

mb...

Hehee...I love the Boxer mention.

Couldn't agree more with your sentiments in your last paragraph either...why they just have to be Uncle Toms...Michael Steele knows all about those oreo cookies too...the leftists true colors are coming more and more to the forefront...the likes of which I've nevver seen.

Obama's a Community Agitator, a walking, talking destroyer. ~ Rush Limbaugh

→ Money Quote


Ergo, when all else fails, parade out the race card and attempt to incite blacks into becoming the useful idiots.

Dang, Krugman!  That's gonna leave a mark.

So now you're the voice of black America?

LYDSEXICS UNTIE!

Thank you Amy

This assortment of statements has iterated the feelings of many of us much better than I could. 

If they are not NB readers or members, please pass along my sincere thanks for their standing against the liberal race baiting machine. 

"This
liberal would be all about socialize -- uh, uh, would be about
basically taking over and the government running all of your companies."-Maxine Waters 2008

Obama is in danger of

Obama is in danger of loosing a few percentage points of the black, jewish votes. And ALOT of the so called indy vote. I think Palin and Especially Romney can beat his ass by enough votes to cancel out the 5%vote acorn always steals. Acorn are the new Sturmabteillung, the S.A. the Brownshirts running the streets, along with seiu and AFL/CIO thugs, beating down protesters

Re black voters

In 2012 I don't see a lot of black voters changing their vote, but if any of those that voted for him were first-time voters that voted for him because they thought he would "pay their mortgages and buy gas for their cars", those folks might go back to never voting. Anyone that dumb should not vote anyway so that's a good thing.

Re the Jewish vote, those American Jews that voted for the Bamster in 2008 were not too bright to begin with, so to think they will change in 2012 is a stretch.

              

                          The protests are not about healthcare. It does involve it, though. It is about our elected officials passing bills without reading them. To me that is a traitor. Everyone who put their "John Hancock" on the bill without reading it MUST be replaced. By the way, let's stop calling them elected officials. They are elected servants. They are there to serve the will of the people. Seems they forgot that.                Angry Mobster