ABC's "Good Morning America" isn't afraid to call 'em like they see 'em.
On health care, Chris Cuomo set up his resident health expert to deliver an outright insult to the American people. Republican Sen. John McCain (Ariz.) advocates more patient choice and flexibility in buying health insurance, but ABC’s medical editor, Dr. Tim Johnson, scoffed at that notion in a September 5 story.
“The idea that individuals are going to have enough knowledge and enough savvy and enough insight and, frankly, enough guts to make choices all by themselves is pretty much a pipe dream,” Johnson said.
ABC’s Web site touts Johnson as “one of the nation's leading medical communicators of health care information.”
Cuomo also misled viewers about McCain's plan for tax credits, yet his coverage of Obama's plan wasn't very illuminating, either.
But Cuomo showed he, like Johnson, is worried about people making decisions: “Is there a risk in putting the Joneses in control of their own health care?”
Amy Menefee is director of communications for the Galen Institute.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
insidious
September 9, 2008 - 17:02 ET by mbuelThese collectivists are absolutely insidious.
And the fact that the republican polls are surging is great proof that at least a small majority sees through them (thankfully.)
Palin has accomplished great things, while Obama has continued to make empty promises that the world owes you a living.
Well Dr. Johnson, I don't know about the people in your circles
September 9, 2008 - 17:08 ET by JTPbut the people in my circle make decisions "all by themselves" quite often. And suprisingly we don't need a community organizer to tell us what to think or help us fill out forms. No, for real, there are capable human beings beyond the Potomac out here.
"I need more cowbell!" SNL
Oh man...that's bad.
September 9, 2008 - 17:10 ET by supercon“The idea that individuals are going to have enough knowledge and
enough savvy and enough insight and, frankly, enough guts to make
choices all by themselves is pretty much a pipe dream,” Johnson said.
Is he sure?I managed to pick out my sox this morning all by myself.That makes it three days in a row.
I thought that lefties were all about choice.It is astonishing how illiterate they think the middle America rubes are.
I' m surprised that they still allow us to vote.They allow it but you know they don't like it.Liberals don't like it when people "make
choices all by themselves" as it takes away their power.They know that if people are allowed to decide things on their own they almost always go against what the left would like to see.
That's why lefties hate ballot initiatives because the little people actually get to have a say in their lives and bypass the will of the left.
Victory in Iraq.
Liberals suck.
McCain for Preznint.
"I thought that lefties
September 9, 2008 - 17:29 ET by ckc1227"I thought that lefties were all about choice.It is astonishing how illiterate they think the middle America rubes are."
They are all about choice, as long as they can make it for you.
This from the folks,
September 9, 2008 - 18:27 ET by IamTinmanThat think a 13 year old child can make the decision to murder her own unborn baby without even discussing it with her parents?
Why do we even bother to listen to these people? They have an agenda based on having an unelected elite make life or death decisions for people they don't even know or care about.
Look at how the Insurance companies treat some medical procedures and visualize how they would be treated by a faceless government bureaucrat. You don't even have to visualize it, just ask a canadian who has to leave his or her country to get medical care.
National health programs in Europe are falling apart and taxes are being raised to support failing healthcare systems. We americans are capable of making our own healthcare decisions and living with the result if we make bad ones.
I am not some ant whose every moment of existance is controlled by some self designated health dictator and I don't think most americans are either.
I may be wrong and you all want transfat police, cigarette cops, and calorie counting neighbors turning you in for two donuts in the morning, but I don't think so.
Great point, t-man!
September 9, 2008 - 22:18 ET by Galvanic"This from the folks that think a 13 year old child can make the decision to murder her own unborn baby without even discussing it with her parents?"
Spot on, t-man! They don't even see the hypocrisy in their policies.
"Why do we even bother to listen to these people? They have an agenda based on having an unelected elite make life or death decisions for people they don't even know or care about."
Dr. Johnson may have a point. Afterall, inmates in the gulag don't have the liberty to make mistakes about their health care choices; why should we? ;-)
Well, shoot.
September 9, 2008 - 17:18 ET by Chris NormanWell, shoot. The self-appointed elite intelligensia think that we dumb hicks ain't smart enough to eat right, choose not to smoke, drive where we want, shop where we want, handle firearms, raise our kids, or pick the school we want. Thank the good Lord we got them smart people ready and willin' to make these choices for us, 'cause I don't think I could move an inch without their help and di-rection...
McNotObama '08
The idea that individuals
September 9, 2008 - 18:12 ET by TruthMongerThe idea that individuals are going to have enough knowledge and enough savvy and enough insight and, frankly, enough guts to make choices all by themselves is pretty much a pipe dream,”
love it!
frame-worthy:)
Journalism is the opium of the liberals
Oh yeah? Insurance is a no-brainer compared to telephone bills
September 9, 2008 - 17:20 ET by attorneygirlThis guy clearly has never read a telephone bill, or had to choose between the myriad of telephone carriers--both land lines and cel phone providers.
Now there's a tough contract or bill to wade through. These phone bills make choosing a health insurance carrier as simple as ordering off a fast food menu.
Really. It's not that hard. (Maybe it is for him....)
By the way, when I was in college, I didn't have health insurance--and it was MY CHOICE. I was young, young, and, yup, YOUNG. Then, when I got a real job, I got health insurance.
Now that I'm older, we chose our own health insurance, and shopped around, and it was NOT HARD TO READ OR FIGURE OUT.
But you'd hate to hear me gripe and grumble whenever I pay telephone bills--they're rip-offs and hard to understand. Hate em. And I leave it to my ever-so-patient husband to shop around for new telephone carriers, fax-line telephone carriers, and new cel phone carriers--because of the jargon, fees, and obligations.
Health care insurance is a breeze after that.
Anyone else agree? (Or am I the only simpleton out here?)
Liberals don't even allow you to vote
September 9, 2008 - 17:25 ET by attorneygirlPardon me, but I read another poster's comment, and he (or she) wrote that the he or she was surprised that the liberals even allowed people to vote.
Hummmm..
Let's examine this statement. Didn't the Democratic Party not allow thousands (or millions) of people's votes to count? Isn't this what happened in the Democratic primaries this year with Michigan and Florida? Were not all those voters' votes stolen or ripped off? Didn't the Democrats used to call this "voter disenfranchisement?"
This year, the Democrats (their national party, that is), SELECTED, APPOINTED, DECLARED, AND THEN ANNOINTED their CHOSEN ONE to be their nominee.
So, no, the Democrats don't want you to even vote. They pretend such is the case, but in reality it is not so.
Therefore, this idiot who thinks that folks can't choose their own health insurance coverage is just following the party (socialist party, that is) line of ORDERING folks what to do and THINKING for them.
It's all bad.
the following is from the Democrat party convention platform
September 9, 2008 - 17:28 ET by jkwtradingDemocrat
platform "For decades, Americans have been told to
act for ourselves, by ourselves, on our own. Democrats reject this recipe for
division and failure."
the good doctor is abiding by the socialists preachings.
Heal thyself doc
September 9, 2008 - 17:30 ET by acumen“The idea that individuals are going to have enough knowledge and enough savvy and enough insight and, frankly, enough guts to make choices all by themselves is pretty much a pipe dream,” Johnson said.
Is Johnson actually suggesting that the government would do a better job? Especially after the Feds did such a wonderful job helping everyone get homes by setting up Fannie and Freddy. Yeah, that worked out swell. /Sarc
Healthcare Intelligence
September 9, 2008 - 17:31 ET by GothampcEverywhere I've worked, we've always had to make choices regarding healthcare. Usually the company offers three or four different choices and I would pick. I've had to learn terms like HMO and PPO, but I think if I can do it 99.999999% of the population can do it.
Watch for the Dems to confuse the issue like they did privatizing Social Security. "You don't want choice in healthcare, you want what Congress wants".
"You don't want choice in
September 9, 2008 - 18:12 ET by Eileen Right"You don't want choice in healthcare, you want what Congress wants". What Congress wants for us is not what Congress has given themselves.
Of course not. It would
September 9, 2008 - 18:18 ET by dmntd1Of course not. It would cost too much for us lowly peons.
Fascism is a religious conception in which man is seen in his imminent relationship with a superior law and with an objective will that transcends the particular individual - Mussolini
Who then?
September 9, 2008 - 17:41 ET by Kevin HalpernIf "individuals" aren't smart enough and don't have the guts to make the decisions, who will make them? A machine?
They'll use an computer
September 9, 2008 - 18:14 ET by Eileen RightThey'll use an computer modeling program, like the one they rely on for AGW.
A Year ago
September 9, 2008 - 18:16 ET by dmntd1A year ago I realized that I was too smart NOT to have health insurance, and started shopping for it. Imagine my surprise when my AGENT was willing to help me shop for it!!!
There are a lot of people that need help purchasing such things as insurance (car, home, life, health). That's why insurance was generally sold through agents. People taught what the difference between policies are.
Granted, some of the agents will rip you off, but if you're shopping for ANY big ticket item, why would you settle for a single quote?!?
Fascism is a religious conception in which man is seen in his imminent relationship with a superior law and with an objective will that transcends the particular individual - Mussolini
Yep, we Americans sure are
September 9, 2008 - 18:21 ET by Clear thinkerYep, we Americans sure are dumb. Just look at who the Dems have as their nominee!
Moron’s On Parade
Making Fun of AGW http://giovanniworld.wordpress.com/
I have commented on my
September 9, 2008 - 18:24 ET by stratmanI have commented on my dislike for this Socialist in a suit previously. His type, and worse, are the reason I am not a member of the AMA - they stopped talking for me a long time ago. Amazingly, Johnson will not receive the deserved rebuke from the Left for this patronizing, bigoted, patrician schtick. It is more important to elect His Hopelessness: The Obama and further secure Socialism in America.
As others have commented here, many people make decisions on their selection of healthcare when they start a job. Yes, the employer has pared down the number of choices prior to the employee choosing. But, this is a key reason why employee's feel dissatisfied when dealing with their healthcare company. It is the EMPLOYER that the healthcare industry considers the CUSTOMER, not the employee that utilizes the services.
Since the employer pays for the service, the Healthcare Industrial Complex is only interested in keeping the employer happy, and only marginally so to begin with. The employee is more like a servant that uses the master's credit card to purchase groceries, never getting quite the respect the one paying for the goods/services would/does recieve.
Healthcare companies can present a menu of service plans just like Human Resources does currently to the individual. The huge difference is John and Jane Doe will be the ones paying the HealthCo. the bucks, resulting in the Healthcare now catering more to the specific needs of the individual/employee instead of the basic, overriding financial considerations of the employer. and competition will increase by HealthCo. resulting in improved value for the individual.
One issue not discussed yet is that Hospitals and medical offices will not welcome the increased complexity and money-draining time killing aspect of even more numbers of health plans. Keeping track of what is or is not available when treating/diagnosing a patient is already disgusting, and will worsen when people go ala carte on healthcare. So, more needs to be done to streamline insurance interaction inefficiencies. That will probably require legislation since Healthcare has rarely done anything without a force applied.
For those of you that may find contempt with that last statement, understand that the Healthcare Industrial Complex was granted immunity from federal anti-trust laws following WWII in an effort to spur medical coverage for all the veterans and their families. This decision has culminated in the Charlie Foxtrot of HealthCo.'s today. Grifters like John Edwards have also been instrumental in the healthcare mess. Of course their are always a few bad apples in every profession, and physician's need to prune those incompetent doctors of their licensure.
What is not needed is LESS choice by the American public when it comes to their health. I suggest Cuomo and Johnson move to Cuba where the weather's warm and Socialism will tell them how to breathe and for how long... since that is what they want done to us.
RRAM Tough!
Paging Dr. Stalin...Dr.
September 9, 2008 - 18:27 ET by fitzfongPaging Dr. Stalin...Dr. Stalin, please report to GMA. Paging Dr. Stalin...
"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan
fitzfong.blogspot.com
Condescension
September 9, 2008 - 19:23 ET by iveseenitallOne of the most sickening things about "liberals" is their condescension. They exist in their own bubble, "knowing" that their point of view on anything is the ONLY point of view on anything. And like Fonzi on Happy Days, they can never admit that they are, or have ever been, "Wr,Wr,Wr, Wrong"! Witness Barry Obama concerning the Surge. Ironic that the "expert" on this show was being questioned by a Cuomo. His father, Mario, has always been one of the most condescending popinjays of all. Really, don't "liberals" just make you sick? They do me.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
I need a second opinion, doctor
September 9, 2008 - 18:41 ET by CobraManI need a second opinion before accepting your diagnosis of the reasoning abilities of the American people, doctor.
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
paging liberals
September 9, 2008 - 19:14 ET by candanceCome on lefties, come here and defend this. Explain why I'm too stupid to choose my own health care plan.
Next we'll be too stupid to choose car insurance plans, so the government should step in and decide that for me as well. Heck, why don't I just let them control the food stupply so I don't waste my own time choosing between chicken or steak.
Don't worry
September 9, 2008 - 19:30 ET by CobraMan"why don't I just let them control the food stupply so I don't waste my own time choosing between chicken or steak."
Don't worry, liberals like Obama wouldn't be able to make that choice for you as any answer they could give, with specificity, would be above their pay grade.
BTW, just don't ask them about Chicken Fried Steak as that would REALLY confuse them!
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
BTW, just don't ask them
September 9, 2008 - 19:51 ET by general companyBTW, just don't ask them about Chicken Fried Steak as that would REALLY confuse them!
No wonder it is my favorite
"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg
Do that and you'll get
September 10, 2008 - 01:31 ET by IamTinmanSoylent Green!
Why Watch Offensive News?
September 9, 2008 - 19:25 ET by deerjerkydaveWhy would any American watch a news program that insults them like this? "You're too dumb and weak to make choices about health care...but not sex or abortions!"
This is precisely the kind of tripe I just refuse to take in from the liberal media. Good luck ABC with your "news" programs because they are not watched in my household.
Actually, I agree. I am
September 9, 2008 - 19:52 ET by clarkfkActually, I agree. I am not smart enough to buy my own health insurance. But this is only because the insurance companies have gone out of their ways to make their plans cryptic and difficult to understand and choose which is best for you.
I don't know about that
September 9, 2008 - 20:52 ET by CobraMan"But this is only because the insurance companies have gone out of their ways to make their plans cryptic and difficult to understand and choose which is best for you."
I don't know about that. I bought my own health insurance and I didn't have much of a problem. The hardest choice I had was choosing which clinic would be my primary, everything else was pretty much self-explanatory, including the coverage amounts, the premiums I would pay, the deductibles I am charged, and how emergency visits to a hospital in which my insurance company is not affiliated would be covered.
Obama: My job is above my pay grade
Certainly then I must
September 9, 2008 - 22:20 ET by clarkfkCertainly then I must applaud your particular carrier. As for me, I have had nothing but grief trying to choose particular plans, etc.
Hey Dr. Tim....I don't
September 9, 2008 - 22:18 ET by FirmwormHey Dr. Tim....I don't believe this takes much savvy, insight, or guts.
https://www.ehealthinsurance.com/
Pleeze help
September 9, 2008 - 23:27 ET by thebobboI ain't me no smart enuff to get nunne of that helth inshurance. Shure do hope the gummint giv it too me. My gutz is all a-twitter watin for it.
lol!
September 10, 2008 - 10:17 ET by deerjerkydavelol!
This IS the Democrat Party!
September 10, 2008 - 07:35 ET by ChasvsThey are the one's who know enough to RULE the little peole of America!
You know, the people who brought forth the richest and mightiest Nation in the World WITHOUT the leadership of the Democrats.
Surest way to break this Country is to put it in the hands of the Leftist that want to make you their SLAVE.
Here is the comment I just sent off to ABC
September 10, 2008 - 08:09 ET by danhat... ABC’s medical editor, Dr. Tim Johnson, scoffed at that notion in a September 5 story.
“The idea that individuals are going to have enough knowledge and enough savvy and enough insight and, frankly, enough guts to make choices all by themselves is pretty much a pipe dream,” Johnson said. This man insulted EVERYONE in America. That ABC would entertain someone this ignorant is laughable. Typical elitist liberal. Drag the majority down instead of pulling the minority up. ABC;shame on u!
I would encourage everyone here to do the same.
here is the link:
http://abc.go.com/si...
Beware of the 500 character limit.
++++++++++++++++
Normally I don't root for the disease. But in your case I am willing to make and exception.
Dan, you'll have to forgive
September 10, 2008 - 08:22 ET by MassConservDan, you'll have to forgive Dr. Tim. He's from Boston (started out on the ABC affiliate) and doesn't know any better.
One would hope that someone that age would have developed some common sense in their advancing years, but it can be hard to break the liberal yoke up here.
I just grab the duct tape...
September 10, 2008 - 08:47 ET by danhat...when I hear crap like this. Crap like the "good" doctor is spewing.
++++++++++++++++
Normally I don't root for the disease. But in your case I am willing to make and exception.
Dan, can't say I blame you.
September 10, 2008 - 10:36 ET by MassConservDan, can't say I blame you. Having grown up in the environment I think the conservative locals develop certain immunity to that kind of excrement in that our heads have built-in anti-explosion protection.
That’s not to say we’ve got preternaturally thick skulls or anything. ;-)
Geeze, the cluelessness, the arrogance!
September 10, 2008 - 09:28 ET by JohnMcGrewHey, does this boob do his own taxes? Does he understand the tax code? Or does he hire someone to figure it out for him?
Has he ever figured out all of the forms and regulations for Medicare? That was far more difficult to understand than my health insurance was. Does he honestly think that the government can do better than that?
I spend far more time working on my taxes than I have on my health insurance.