Despite growing into a massive network, National Public Radio still demonstrates signs of being the same countercultural liberal listening post that came of age in the Vietnam era. On Thursday’s Morning Edition, NPR covered war and post-traumatic stress disorder in a trendy liberal way: as an opportunity to sell combat veterans on the mystical healing power of yoga.
Government-subsidized yoga for veterans? NPR reporter Allan Coukell (sounded like "Cockle") suggested it’s the government-funded wave of the future: "So far, most of the veterans have been paying for the sessions themselves, but [Tom] Boyle hopes the Veterans Affairs system will start to offer yoga nationwide. He already sees PTSD and other symptoms of battle stress in troops back from Iraq — and he knows thousands more are still to come."
Scroll down on the NPR webpage and you see NPR also promoted it last July on Morning Edition, at least in a brief and light fashion, as John Ydstie (not a typo) related: "You think you need a dose of energy and tranquility? Well imagine if you were headed to war. That may be why more soldiers are turning to the ancient Hindu practice of yoga. The magazine Fit Yoga's August issue features aviators in full combat gear doing yoga poses on the deck of an aircraft carrier. Drop and give me a downward dog, soldier -- now breathe and exhale."
It’s interesting that NPR never stopped to consider that since yoga is inspired by the Hindu religion, that perhaps government-funded yoga might be considered taking a brick out of that "wall of separation" between church and state.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Government-sponsored Hindui
March 2, 2007 - 06:17 ET by motherbeltGovernment-subsidized Hinduism? Not a problem. That's a mulit-cultural thing, like prayer rooms, halal meals, and reordering the school day for Muslim children during Ramadan. Have a cross at a national monument? Now, them's fightin' words!!!
Yoga huh? No thanks. If I
March 2, 2007 - 06:39 ET by FowlerK9Yoga huh? No thanks. If I want to relax when I get home and relieve stress, I'll turn off the TV, pour a glass of single malt scotch, listen to some George Strait while smoking a cigerette. Oh and my wife has some good ideas for stress relief for her returning husband ;)
FowlerK9
Security Team Echo 7
Tallil Iraq
I've seen one yoga book wri
March 2, 2007 - 07:18 ET by sarcasmoI've seen one yoga book written by a Christian. If anything, it's more like a form of exercise than a form of religion, and yoga's about as related to being a Hindu as Santa Claus & the Easter Bunny are to being a Christian. Maybe post-war yoga's like government-funded chaplains during a war, just one of those things that seems to make human beings tend to function more-effectively...Anyway, far-worse ideas have been promoted on NPR. And yes, I can see how the "pump 'em all full of (legal but expensive-as-hell) drugs" lobby, which owns quite a few politicians in both "major" parties in fee simple, might object to this kind of non-drug competition. Religion's fine, but in this case follow the money.
JMR
I guess if soldiers really ar
March 2, 2007 - 08:28 ET by AtheistRepublicanI guess if soldiers really are doing yoga.. its a.. good idea? I mean, I always support the troops, so yah. What a strange story to start my days.
<sarcasm> what about Go
March 2, 2007 - 09:04 ET by Conservative in the Arts<sarcasm> what about Govt funded ballet classes for our soldiers? After all, if NFL players take it for agility and speed, just think of how it would help them out on the battlefield.
Just think....the left will be all for this to "support the troops" but really be all for it for how it will demoralize a bunch of macho guys for forcing them to take ballet, at the same time teaching "diversity".........</sarcasm>
<sarcasm> what about Go
March 2, 2007 - 09:05 ET by Conservative in the Artswhy did it do a double post? sorry.
Another tax supported liberal
March 2, 2007 - 09:54 ET by jdhawkAnother tax supported liberal mouth piece spouting BS - NPR.
Meanwhile, the Army and our dear congressional representatives are making a big deal out of housing issues at Walter Reed Medical Center in Washington, D.C. When the real issue is that Walter Reed has long ago been in need of tearing down and a new state of the art facility built in its place. It is a travesty that these soldiers are provided care at a third rate facility. Our nation can certainly afford a first rate medical facility for those that have sacrificed much in defense of our country.
Walter Reed was operational some thirty years ago, in 1977. All are well aware of the revolution that has occurred in medical processing, computerization, patient care, etc. in the span of three decades. It is impossible for a plant and facility of this type to accommodate those changes. So, the Army decided to close Walter Reed by 2011 and open a new combined services facility on the grounds of the Navy Medical Center in Bethesda, MD. However, there is one problem with that "story." It is 2007 and ground has not been broken on a new facility. It will take several years to build the new facility and then outfit it with the wherewithal that is needed to have a first class medical facility like that of Womack Army Medical Center, Fort Bragg, NC. When is this going to start? Time is short. Our soldiers deserve better.
WAMC
March 2, 2007 - 18:26 ET by SarahAnnieYou wouldn't think Womack was so hot if you had to have a baby there last September. I was on the list to be induced on the 11th, but couldn't be til LATE on the 13th. Serves me right for getting knocked up as soon as The Man and I got back from Taji, Iraq. Biggest baby boom in history.
If VA wants to offer to pay for yoga, that's cool with me.
I haven't been in the DC area
March 2, 2007 - 22:36 ET by GoldenEagleI haven't been in the DC area for a few months, but it seemed to me that once the decision was made to close Walter Reed, the only thing the Democratic local representation in DC (including their House Delegate, Mayor, and City Council) could talk about was how they were going to save the jobs and, if they could not do that, redevelop. Obviously, their patriotism and concern for the people who protect their freedoms with blood was absent while they focused on selfish needs.
Congress is the enemy of our military, past, present, and future. That is why the Constitution places its power in the hands of the Executive. Our Founding Fathers actually had brains.
Quite simply Yoga SHOULD be a
March 2, 2007 - 18:49 ET by ucQuite simply Yoga SHOULD be allowed and understood and maybe even have such funded for medical purposes. As a discipline that encourages very disciplined breathing and stretching it may be a vital tool towards improving healing especially when it comes to PTSD cases. It can be used as a faith neutral remember your basic human condition technique that wouldn't negate getting back to whichever faith may be held by each possible patient.
Got to disagree Tim. As to the Jesus and Mary tomb it still today can be said maybe "that if the Bible didn't exist it might have to be invented."
Maybe just small "y" yoga though. I remember reading about PTSD before "PTSD" naming.