**Video Below the Fold**
In the Words-Mean-Things category, yesterday we got both the Associated Press and CNN distorting the words Laura Bush used to describe Sarah Palin on foreign policy. Worse, the video interview of the First Lady was right on CNN yet on its own Political Ticker blog, CNN still distorted what Laura Bush said about Palin. It makes you wonder if the folks at CNN even watch CNN?
On September 24, Political Ticker posted a story by "CNN Ticker Producer Alexander Mooney" headlined "Laura Bush says Palin lacks foreign policy experience" and started the posting out with these first lines: (bold mine)
First Lady Laura Bush told CNN Wednesday Sarah Palin lacks experience in foreign policy, but quickly added the Alaska governor is "a very quick study."
Notice my bolded emphasis of the "but quickly added"? This is a distortion. When someone says "but quickly added" it is meant to imply that the speaker thought better of their initial words and thought to quickly add something in clarification. However, the actual video does not show Laura Bush "quickly" adding anything, but going forward in an even, measured tone. She did not "quickly add" a thing.
But, even the headline is a distortion. The headline makes it seem as if this "Palin lacks foreign policy experience" topic was something that Laura Bush focused on. But it was not. In fact, she dismissed it as unimportant. Not only that, but Bush wasn’t even the one that brought it up.
The Associated Press also went with this distortion of a headline: “Laura Bush: Palin lacks foreign policy experience.”
First lady Laura Bush says Republican vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin lacks sufficient foreign policy experience but is a very quick study.
In an interview Wednesday with CNN, the first lady remarked that it's fortunate that Republican presidential nominee John McCain has foreign policy experience himself.
Again, this at the top of each story of what Laura Bush said about Palin we see a focus on the least stressed point that Laura Bush made about the VP pick. And, unlike what the AP story says, Laura Bush did not say “lacks sufficient foreign policy experience.” Bush didn’t use the word “sufficient” nor did she allude to any “insufficiency.”
Here is what really was said by the First Lady…
Transcript
Zain Verjee: Today Laura Bush talked to me about a Washington outsider and the question of Sarah Palin's experience.
I spoke to you a while back and you said at the time that Condeleezza Rice the Secretary of State...
Laura Bush: (laughs) Was my choice. For the female...
Zain Verjee: ... your choice for the female ticket, the vice presidential nominee or...
Laura Bush: Our presidential, sure.
Zain Verjee: ... exactly, or presidential or on the presidential ticket. Sarah Palin has now emerged as the choice...
Laura Bush: That's right.
Zain Verjee: Do you have as much confidence in her as you did then in Secretary Rice?
Laura Bush: I have a lot of confidence in Sarah Palin. She's got a lot of really good common sense and I think that's very important. She also has executive experience from being a governor and a mayor and I'm thrilled to have the chance to vote for Sarah Palin on the Republican ticket.
Zain Verjee: (laughs) But do you think she has the kind of foreign policy experience that everyone's (crosstalk)...
Laura Bush: Of course she doesn't have that. You know, that's not been her role. But I think she is a very quick study, and fortunately John McCain does have that sort of experience.
Obviously the foreign policy question was not Bush's point, but was interjected by the reporter. And when the foreign policy point was asked of her, she basically said that Palin's lack of experience was not so important. So, for the Political Ticker and the AP to focus on a point that wasn't Bush's is a distortion of the First Lady's position on Sarah Palin.
But, who can say they are surprised?
(Photo Credit: CNN)




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
no bias, no bull
September 25, 2008 - 12:06 ET by sawing battariiiiigghtt.
"Hillary Clinton says Obama
September 25, 2008 - 13:43 ET by TruthMonger"Hillary Clinton says Obama lacks any kind of experience whatsoever!"
Journalism is the opium of the liberals
She also modified the "no"
September 25, 2008 - 12:11 ET by motherbeltShe also modified it with "that's not been her role...."
They just hear what they want and understand what they want...facts be damned!
Most of our Presidents for a long time have come from the ranks of Governor....none of them had that "foreign policy experience." If that is so important, then why have Governors consistently won against Senators in Presidential elections?
Well hey, they covered it,
September 25, 2008 - 12:10 ET by mattmWell hey, they covered it, right? They have Laura's words in the story, and the headline isn't a direct lie, so all their bases are covered.
I guess this is why Broder says there is no such thing as media bias.
Laura Bush Knows Better
September 25, 2008 - 13:22 ET by BaxterJWhile I agree that this is cherrypicking, Laura Bush should know better than to give the media a soundbite like that after eight years in office.
Talk about cherry-picking a
September 25, 2008 - 12:17 ET by Indiana JoeTalk about cherry-picking a quote. And what kind of question is that, anyway? Saying Palin doesn't have foreign policy experience is like saying she's a brunette. It can't be denied. The only real question is, how much does it matter?
This brings to mind the age-old conundrum of the first-time job seeker. You can't get a job without experience, and you can't get experience without a job.
Would one of these people please ask Obama about his foreign policy "experience?" Or any experience, for that matter?
"... smells like... victory." - Robert Duvall
»→ I take exception IJ
September 25, 2008 - 12:24 ET by Cool ArrowObama did have some education and religious training in Indonesia.
"Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall!" - Joe Biden 6/12/87
and don't forget, he
September 25, 2008 - 21:30 ET by Cape Conservativetraveled to Kenya, too!!! Therefore, he's "worldly" - NOT!
What about Obama Jr.?
September 25, 2008 - 12:25 ET by Old Europeit never ceases to amaze me how daft and predictable the drive-bys are: What about Obama'S field trip to Europe where he explored several countries? Where is his experience and he's running for president. When did they ever question his lack of experience? He's just the affirmative action doofus who doesn't have any executive experience whatsoever. Also, his grades at Harvard were so bad he still has to disclose them and he couldn't even get an internship at a judge's because of that. And as president of Harvard Law Review he didn't publish a single article! He only became president thanks to affirmative action doofus laws. So where is Obama's experience, let alone intelligence to tackle these issues, CNN?!
Obama's travels
September 25, 2008 - 13:13 ET by LionKingHas he made it to all 58 states, yet?
CNN...Communist News
September 25, 2008 - 13:08 ET by bigtimerCNN...Communist News Network...
All Bias...All Bull... All the time.
Btw...I am glad you brought this up WTH...I saw this crap..I was infuriated.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Experience
September 25, 2008 - 13:12 ET by LionKingWell ...
integrity and journalism
September 25, 2008 - 21:32 ET by Cape Conservativedo not go together very well - in fact, RARELY do we see the two associated with each other. Krauthammer & Will are a couple of exceptions right off the bat.
Sarah's carbon footprint
September 25, 2008 - 13:29 ET by Mica the MagnificentSo she's not a world traveler. So she stayed in Alaska.
Shouldn't the MSM be praising her for not having a huge carbon footprint from all that traveling?
You know, 'save the planet' crap.
Economy collapsing? We may enter a depression? Got it! Call me if you need me, I can't multi-task. You know, practice for a debate and save the economy at the same time - - - - What Obama reeaallly meant.
Laura Bush
September 25, 2008 - 13:59 ET by AvitarWhat seems to be overlooked is that the Governor of Alaska gets more Foreign policy experience than is normal for a Governor. This is because of where Alaska is and its shear size. You get to Canada, Russia and Japan from Alaska by traveling less than it takes to get to the state nearest Alaska.
In addition, Sarah Palin in her short time in office got the natural gas pipeline under construction. BRILLIANT! This makes her America's most successful diplomat of the last couple of years.
Indeed, Sarah is
September 25, 2008 - 21:34 ET by Cape ConservativeBRILLIANT! She will be right at home in her new office in Washington - I can't wait to witness the fresh air that will blow through the town when she arrives!
What kind of foreign policy
September 25, 2008 - 21:37 ET by balboaWhat kind of foreign policy experience?
AP made another misleading comment
September 25, 2008 - 14:21 ET by KimnotaThe AP also went on to say Laura Bush said Palin has also got a lot of good common sense. Never mentioned her comments about executive experience being a mayor and governor.
Shut up
September 25, 2008 - 14:37 ET by rick007When will the Republicans ever learn???????
Any thing they say will be used against them after careful editing.
The best thing to do is say if you do not use the whole answer than do not expect any more interviews.
The Democrats are the best at smears and lies. Even better than the Germans were.
Boycot Chinese products for one month and watch them crawl back.
B Frank is a C---------. Literaly
Debate
September 25, 2008 - 14:40 ET by rick007The only reason "O" Dumby wants to go ahead with the debate is so they can change the format to the Economy where he thinks he's stronger.
The only economy hes good at is sucking off the Goverment.
This is really getting old.
September 25, 2008 - 15:12 ET by marvlThis is really getting old. It is very typical for govenors to lack foreign policy experience. I suspect Sarah has more experience in this department than most. Why does everyone keep harping on this relatively irrelevant point?
But how does this situation compare with the foreign policy experience of an inexperienced state legislator from Illinois? And a very, very junior senator who has barely spent any time in the senate? Hmmmm?
You would think people would be screaming about BHO's lack of any kind of experience: foreign, domestic, executive, financial, economic, military, etc., etc., ad nauseam. Why is no one concerned about this?
I am really, really tired of the Sarah bashing. Get real, people. The real fool here is that egocentric, arrogant, and ignorant fool, Barack Obama.
For the sake of this great country I pray to God that John McCain and Sarah Palin are elected. I don't think this country can survive an Obama presidency.
First Lady on Palin's Experience
September 25, 2008 - 17:51 ET by arley08Once again, hate wins over the truth in CNN's coverage. Thankfully, Fox News is mostly fair and balanced, with only a slight lean to the left when they feel it's necessary!
WTH
September 25, 2008 - 18:02 ET by MrShyWow... after seeing what Laura Bush *actually* said, and only because that Demo-shilling reporter was tweaking her with the question, it's absolutely disgraceful how they went and twisted it -- AND, had the additional balls to make it the headline, no less!
F***ING Liberally-Biased Mainstream Media.
A bunch of f***s. (Sorry.)
NOW PLAYING:
Governor Palin Get Your Gun