It appears that Washington Post columnist Dana Milbank has dumped his appearances on MSNBC's "Countdown with Keith Olbermann." Host Olbermann issued a DailyKos diary explaining the dust up on Monday, August 4. According to Olbermann, the problem came in when Milbank violated Keith Olbermann's well-known journalistic standards. Of course, I jest about that... not that there was a disagreement but that there are any journalistic standards in the Olbermann camp.
Now, for a man that is supposed to make his mark with words and for a man the left constantly claims is eloquent, Olbermann's diary explanation is quite badly written. But, the gist of the matter is that Olbermann has supposedly been asking Milbank for "nearly a week" if an Obama quote in one of his Washington Post stories was sourced and reported accurately. Apparently Milbank took exception to having his own journalistic integrity questioned by a sports guy.
(Milbank's original column was headlined: President Obama Continues Hectic Victory Tour)
Dana Milbank of The Washington Post, who notified us today that after four years appearing with us, he had accepted another television offer.
This saved your crack Countdown staff an increasingly difficult decision.
For nearly a week we'd been waiting for him to offer a correction or an explanation for his column from last week in which he apparently reported an Obama quote without a full context turned the meaning of the quote inside-out.
Then he called criticisms of his column "whines" even though the dispute was over whether Obama said the self-deprecating: "It has become increasingly clear in my travel, the campaign -- that the crowds, the enthusiasm, 200,000 people in Berlin, is not about me at all. It's about America. I have just become a symbol of the possibility of America returning to our best traditions" -- or only the part about "I have just become a symbol..."
We had decided not to have Dana on this news-hour again until this was cleared up, and, sadly after some very happy years, he's apparently chosen to make that cloud permanent.
Of course, I don't claim to be the best grammarian, but this thing is a mess.
Anyway, on his DailyKos diary after the main announcement, the MSNBC mouth also added some obsequious, meely-mouthing apparently trying to making sure his fans don't imagine he is too harsh on a fellow traveller. Not a very brave stance to take. After all, a man with conviction would stand up for his standards whether violators come from his side of the ideological divide or not.
Anybody who would come on television to talk about the Dick Cheney shoot-up, wearing an orange safety vest and a hunter's cap automatically gets my benefit of the doubt. But even that had a shelf-life, which was nearing, when he took any further decision-making out of our hands. It was quite a surprise conclusion, obviously, and I'll take it (before anybody tries to take it back).
I'm sure that wasn't his intention, but often one's best work is inadvertent. I'm just as sure his version of the provenance of the original version of the quote the Post's source provided was accurate. What happened thereafter was the problem.
This is one thing that definitely stands out in this situation. Olbermann's feigned deference to Milbank is so hypocritical it elicits outright laughter. Too obviously Olbermann is bending over backwards not to call Milbank a liar over his earlier column about Obama and he falls all over himself to give Milbank every benefit of the doubt, deserved or no. But there is no mistaking the fact that Olbermann is calling Milbank a liar, regardless.
But, in contrast to his absurdist rants on the air about how he hates those he normally finds less than forthcoming, despite his posing as the brave, stalwart standing up for what is right, in spite of his excoriation of those that don't live up to his supposedly high standards, Milbank is treated with kid gloves here. One might call Olbie quite a hypocrite for his soft touch with someone on his own ideological side of the line... and I think I shall, if you don't mind too terribly.
A big question is, if Keith Olbermann was so upset at Milbank, if he felt Milbank was not telling the truth, why did Olbermann not call him out on the air like he does his ideological enemies? Was he really so afraid that the fans would be upset? Is Olbermann's dedication to his "principles" so shallow? Shouldn't one hold to principle no matter who gets mad over it? That's what Bush does, doesn't he? He holds to his principles no matter who gets mad. Is Olbermann made of of less moral fiber than Bush? (I know you can answer that question) False bravado does not speak well from the so-called champion of the people.
Of course, there is the other thing that smacks of a playground taunt. Olbie said that he had "decided not to have Dana on this news-hour again" until Milbank addressed Olbie's questions. But, since Olbie never said any of this on the air and since the question was never aired in public so everyone knew what was going on, it seems more like Olbie is acting the part of the beaten up third grader yelling to the school yard bully, "Yeah, you better run," after the bully was long gone from the playground. How do we know that Olbie made any such principled decision? The truth is we don't.
I also find it amusing that Olbermann keeps referring to his little circus as a "news hour." His is obviously an analysis and opinion show, whether you agree with his politics or not, and not "news."
So, the man who prides himself on standing up and speaking truth to power gives one of those on his own side a pass, and grovels while he does it.
Quite hypocritical, indeed. And very unseemly.
(Photo credit: Huffingtonpost.com)



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
WTH
August 5, 2008 - 03:32 ET by Cool ArrowCan you link Milbank's article so I can read it?
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Here you go: President Obama
August 5, 2008 - 03:49 ET by Warner Todd HustonHere you go: President Obama Continues Hectic Victory Tour.
And I'll add this to the story in case someone else forgot what a web search engine is.
;)
Thanks WTH
August 5, 2008 - 04:08 ET by Cool ArrowI know what a Serach Engine is, but I guess I assumed this wasn't Milbank's first column. Silly me.
I'm used to being coddled here.
PS. I know it's probably not in your spellchecker, but I think it's Olbermann, not Oblermann. Just in case "somebody else" doesn't know how to spell it.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Olber, Obler... who
August 5, 2008 - 04:11 ET by Warner Todd HustonOlber, Obler... who cares?
Ha, ha.
I'll fix it if you insist.
Ed Zackaly
August 5, 2008 - 04:24 ET by Cool ArrowAnd please don't change it on my account. I've got a computer at home that skips letters while I type. Only happens when I'm in NewsBusters. It's like I got a Dem virus or something.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Naw, I better change it to
August 5, 2008 - 04:37 ET by Warner Todd HustonNaw, I better change it to read correctly. I don't want the head cheese(s) coming down on me like a ton of bricks. I give them enough reason to scold me. At least I can spell this clown's name right!
(look at how you spelled "search" up above, by the way)
LOL
Serach
August 5, 2008 - 04:42 ET by Cool ArrowSerach: Isn't that a book in the Bible?
Never mind, that's Sirach, and it doesn't exist outside Catholic Bibles so we cannot discuss it.
Never mind.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Hmmm...
August 5, 2008 - 05:04 ET by Warner Todd HustonThe way I heard it Serach was going to be the name of Spock's father once upon a time.
Interesting
August 5, 2008 - 05:10 ET by Cool ArrowThey do things differently on Vulcan, I guess.
I don't remember what my dad's name was going to be. . .I only remember what it is.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Me neither
August 5, 2008 - 05:28 ET by Warner Todd HustonBut I am sure that my dad thought my name was "what the hell do you think you're doing?"
Bummer WTH
August 5, 2008 - 05:34 ET by Cool ArrowDat blamit na mal was my last name. He speaks a lot of German.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
You're both wrong
August 5, 2008 - 08:36 ET by ArcherBThe proper spelling is Obambermann. He changed shortly after Hillary dropped out. Otherwise, he would have been Hillbermann.
"To send men to the firing squad, judicial proof is unnecessary." Ernesto "Che" Guevara
Close, But...
August 5, 2008 - 16:54 ET by geoff.gale...no joy. You're all forgetting that very important 'Herr Oberleutnant' that precedes all mentions of the great man's name.
/sarcasm
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."
- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)
www.conservativeboot...
OK, I read it
August 5, 2008 - 04:05 ET by Cool ArrowI don't see anything in the column that might be offensive to his majesty, king Obama, or to his jester, lord Olbermann.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Exactly... the thing is
August 5, 2008 - 04:23 ET by Warner Todd HustonExactly... the thing is Milbank quoted the quote exactly correct. He didn't expand on the quote, but his point wasn't the news about that quote alone. It was the cumulative arrogance coming from the Obama campaign, that quote just adding to the din. So, Milbank did not quote Obama incorrectly at all (or quote what was being reported that he said).
Obviously Oblermann
August 5, 2008 - 04:40 ET by Cool ArrowOblermann couldn't find fault with the report so he picked nits where he could.
LYDSEXICS UNTIE
Not his job
August 5, 2008 - 15:11 ET by addeigloriamMr Milbank has been a member of the MSM long enough to know that his job is not to quote Obama accurately, but rather to alter, massage, or use any other damage control method necessary whenever Obama says something arrogant and stupid.
Thanx for the report with background
August 5, 2008 - 04:54 ET by timrfrench61First time I've seen anybody put the right perspective Keithy O: that he's a commentator and a sports guy (not a real anchor).
People take him too seriously here. He's just a non-stop OpEd with editorial oversite by Beavus and Butthead that couldn't get his dream job on MTV doing real news.
Don't get me wrong: he's highly entertaining here as a swinging pinata ("Whoopy! Catch the candy!"). It relaxes me after a day at work (our counter people insist on having him on the screens in our show room)
Keep up the good work!
Thanks for the chuckle this
August 5, 2008 - 06:13 ET by motherbeltThanks for the chuckle this morning, Warner.
KO's claim that he would have gotten rid of Milbank because he trimmed a quote is, as Malkin says, "snortworthy." Milbank's real sin was blashphemy. KO wouldn't have cared if it were a Republican who Milbank quoted without the entire context.
Olbermann's show is a "news hour"????
Who'da thunk it?
Well, after all, he says what he does is "really journalism."
I wish this font were 8 feet high
August 5, 2008 - 06:47 ET by theduck6WHY DOES ANYONE GIVE A RODENT'S RUMP WHAT A WASHED UP HEADCASE OF A FAILED SPORTS YAKKER THINKS ABOUT POLITICS????
Apparently a couple of dozen
August 5, 2008 - 07:27 ET by motherbeltApparently a couple of dozen people do, because he still has an audience.
Keith Goobermann moves further and further into insanity.
August 5, 2008 - 09:41 ET by Guy Arthur ThomasKeith Goobermann, whose extremes usually fall within the expected range of LEFTY LIB ranting, has been pushing himself beyond even LEFTY boundaries. While it is true they will throw each other under the bus and eat their own when they perceive such victims as having no use within LEFTY LIB circles anymore, in this case Dana Milbank has QUITE a bit of LEFTY LIB shelf life left (no pun intended). While eating their own isn't FOREIGN TERRITORY for LEFTIES, eating them before their "useful until date" is.
Goobermann is engaging in self-destruction. He is obviously a fraud in the first place. But this goes beyond his fraudulent posturing and pronounced double standards. He is ignoring RATIONAL boundaries, even for socially accepted LEFTY LIBS. This reminds me of the course Dan Rather took.
Apparently, Rather believed the notion he was invincible. He believed he could violate rules, any rules, with immunity. His being insulated from any honest criticism and having his ego stroked constantly by lessers and envious peers resulted in Rather's demise from the now famous case of forged National Guard documents. And to this day he is still shocked by it all.
Goobermann is on this course (of course on a lesser plane at MSNBC but one we will all observe nonetheless). His egomaniacal lust for preeminence doesn't have the normal checks and balances that keep people from going over the edge. And probably it is due to a severe flaw in his character, but that is another issue for another day. The point is, Goobermann is not just at the edge but is repeatedly over the edge, even in the world of the LEFTIES.
Goobie, be warned! When you fall it will be your own LEFTY LIB brethren waiting at the bottom with a pot of boiling stew in which to cook and eat you.
The answer to terrorism IS war. Next Please!
Milbank finally wised up
August 5, 2008 - 09:43 ET by oopsIsaiditagainWarner "Great Thanks" for watching KObama so I don't have to!! News Hour? BathtubBoy is delusional, and that is being kind. What a pompous ass. Are the only people watching that dribble institutionalized??
Video
August 5, 2008 - 09:47 ET by Rush FanHere is the video of Olbermann’s “World’s Best Person” segment regarding Milbank.
That ‘accepted another television offer’ Olbermann was referring to was Dana Milbank’s appearance on CNN's Election Central with Campbell Brown that same evening.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
John McCain - more liberal than conservative, more Democrat than Republican, more anti-Bush than pro-Bush.
Hey RF... That was going
August 5, 2008 - 11:56 ET by bigtimerHey RF...
That was going to be my question...what network did wittle Dana go to...
Thanks for the info.
Will watch the link with the video in a bit...
I find all this amusing...Keithy got dissed by one of his own in my eyes...attempting to make it look like he was the one doing the dissing regarding where Dana went or if he stayed with msnbc...
One thing about it...Keith can't handle the truth...he has to live in his own made up la-la land leftist world.
Personally, I can't stand either one..but this is humorous.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
Olbermann's lack of class
August 5, 2008 - 09:58 ET by KC MulvilleYou know, a professional organization (one with class) usually announces that a person won't be participating anymore, but they leave it at that. Olbermann, lacking class, couldn't let it go. He had to add in his version of the tale, which accuses Milbank of not following the Obama spin. Not only did Milbank fail to swoon at Obama, he also failed to join the conspiracy of spin.
Notice, of course, that since Olbermann didn't have the decency to keep his mouth shut, and since he couldn't (or wouldn't) include Milbank's side of the story ... he's forcing Milbank to respond elsewhere. (Howard Kurtz, check your voice mail.)
It's also probably not a good idea for Olbermann to use the words "shelf life" too often.
KO is mentally ill...I don't
August 5, 2008 - 11:03 ET by marpelKO is mentally ill...I don't understand how the truly crazy (besides Ted Turner) could be so popular as to keep a hideous show like Countdown.
This is too rich.....KO
August 5, 2008 - 14:25 ET by mlongThis is too rich.....KO hasn't come clean and admitted he misquoted (lied about)Bill O'Reilly(again) even though there's clear video evidence and now he's kicking Milbank off Countdown because he thinks he didn't probably quote Lord Obama?..man this just show's KO knows he can do and say anything on MSNBC and get away with it...but like always KO is making more enemies of people who are on his side of the isle and that might hopefully come back to bite him in his ever growing a**. LOL!!!
"I want to cut his b*lls off" Jesse Jackson on Lord Obama