The San Diego Union-Tribune published a story last week that typifies the lack of perspective and a refusal to give a more full account of the facts in the illegal immigration debate common from too many media outlets. The Union-Trib was all worried that "22 migrants have died in S.D. sector" but didn't seem too interested in all relevant information, leaving only a vague feeling that sympathy is due these "migrants," as they repeatedly call them, instead of illegal aliens.
First of all, the very title itself of the story by staff writer Norma de la Vega calls these illegal invaders a much more benign "migrants." It's as if they are legal entrants, honest "migrants," instead of those sneaking into the country through the desert back country of San Diego.
To their credit, though, the story does call them illegal at least twice. First here...
The number of people who have died while trying to cross the border illegally in the San Diego area has more than doubled in the past year.
And here...
Zamudio, a Michoacan native who had lived in the United States for 20 years, was deported in May. As far as anyone knows, he crossed illegally over the mountains May 20.
But, there is the problem with the story and it tends to make the reader "feel" badly for these illegals despite the fact that they are breaking laws to get here. There is no perspective of this death rate that the story says has "more than doubled" as if the numbers are cause for great alarm.
Now, of course, no one wants a single person to die just because they want to take advantage of the wonderful opportunities that they might find in these great United States. But, even a quick glance at the numbers of illegals coming in shows that the 22 or so that have died is a tiny number and that it isn't really anything to get too alarmed over in the statistical sense.
Thus far in the 2008 cycle, the San Diego border patrol has apprehended 122,554 illegal immigrants crossing our borders. And that is just San Diego. Add in the other sectors of the Southwest Border Patrol and you get 578,774. And these are only the ones caught. Certainly the estimates of over 1.9 million illegal crossings in the Southwest area can be believed.
So, let's realize the paltry number that is 22 or so deaths that have resulted from this dangerous crossing. With thousands apprehended and over a million not being apprehended, 22 deaths is a statistically insignificant number.
And, as the story does report, the San Diego patrol has rescued 64 people thus far this year. So, we've even saved lives with our border patrol. There is little reason to feel too bad for these people. They took their chances, broke the law, and some paid the ultimate price for that decision. They should feel lucky that even more didn't die from the efforts.
In the end, here, one can only assume that the sort of sensational approach to the story was meant to make Americans feel sorry for these lawbreakers instead of feeling scorn for them.














Editor at Large

Comments Policy
Eastern Europe Cold War Countries
July 18, 2008 - 09:58 ET by YahooWatcherdid a few things right, like protect their borders.
I'm really sick of the
July 18, 2008 - 10:24 ET by Indiana JoeI'm really sick of the media portraying those against illegal immigration as "anti-immigrant." Talk about trying to "frame the debate." Sadly, too many people fall for this semantic double-talk.
A poster here (sorry, don't remember who) has a tag-line that I love to quote on this subject:
"Calling an illegal immigrant an 'undocumented worker' is like calling a street-corner drug dealer an 'unlicensed pharmacist.'"
Beautiful.
Ask a liberal if we should
July 18, 2008 - 10:36 ET by FlashmanAsk a liberal if we should deport all foreign criminals and watch them squirm.
I've talked with
July 18, 2008 - 11:07 ET by NorthCoasterI've talked with some Mexicans who got caught in the U. S. illegally with fake documents or who got caught particpating in attempts to smuggle people across the border. They are embarassed to have done such a thing and vow to do things the right way next time.
It's difficult to get in the right way but they recognize the value of being honest and upright.
The unfortunate thing is that other countries would rather have the U.S. deal with their employment problems and the people get stuck in the middle with loss of lives.
Secure the border and provide programs at home and there's less incentive or need to try to sneak in.
If you get caught here illegally you get sent home!
Of course
July 18, 2008 - 11:07 ET by Eileen Rightthere is no mention of Americans killed by "Migrants".
I live in California where
July 18, 2008 - 12:07 ET by Rush FanI live in California where the largest population of illegal immigrants in the country is having a major impact. The Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) estimated in a 2004 study that illegal immigration was costing California taxpayers more than $10.5 billion a year for education, health care and incarceration. Our school systems are overwhelmed with the children of illegal immigrants, and the effect of this on the dropout rates is dramatic. A recent updated analysis estimates that 25% of high school students quit school each year, and for Latinos it was closer to 30%.
In 2006 the U.S. Census Bureau estimated that California’s Hispanic population was 35.9%, and would grow to 43% of the population by 2025.
The problem is not going to be alleviated until we secure our border. Unfortunately, California’s next governor may be the sanctuary city (San Francisco) mayor Gavin Newsom. And neither Presidential candidate is expected to enforce our current immigration laws.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
"They are actively promoting the decline of America." ~ Rush Limbaugh on liberals and Democrats
MORE THAN ILLEGALS IMPACTED HERE
July 18, 2008 - 14:03 ET by Solrac7Our hometown rag fails to mention the border incursion by the Mexican Army who are protecting the drug runners. Or the increasing violence committed upon our Border Patrol Agents. Or the trash and refuse the Illegals leave behind in the desert and wilderness areas. Or the increase in tuberculois in San Diego and other border regions. Or the clogged hospital emergency rooms full of illegals. Or the car crashes that happen when a Border Patrol Agent lawfully attempts to pull over a suspected load of illegals and they take off at high speed in a crappy vehicle overloaded with illegals. Or the foreign terrorist disguised as Mexicans who are using our borders to cross into our country and waiting to wreck havoc on our home. Or the drug runners.
I could go on but I think you get the point. And then to have a racist group like La Raza in our town last week trying to explain away their bad intentions and being fawned over by our presidential candidates. What the F is going on here?
And don't call me racist. I am married to a Mexican, now American, who came here the legal way!
Why nobody reads the U-T anymore
July 18, 2008 - 14:32 ET by greenfairieAll of the local media in SD is sooooo pro-illegal immigration, it makes Telemundo and Univision look like Tom Tancredo T.V. by comparison. The U-T is no different, with its sob stories about poor schmoes trying to sneak across the desert.
Great points WTH - 25 americans are killed every day by aliens?
July 18, 2008 - 16:10 ET by Dee BunkI thought I'd try to look up the number of Americans killed during the same time but had no luck. I don't know if this is credible or not but I found this article at infowars.com
It says
"Using the GAO report, Representative Steve King of Iowa points out
that 25 Americans, on average, are killed by illegal aliens every day
(about evenly split between motor vehicle accidents and outright
murder).
Do the math: That works out to more than
9,000 deaths per year, or more than 36,000 deaths over the past four
years. That's more than ten times the number of Americans killed in
Iraq over the past four years!"
Interesting
World Net Daily did something similar for 2006 that puts the number at 12 per day