Guv's Daughter Gets Unearned College Degree... Guess Which Party?

Photo of Warner Todd Huston.
By Warner Todd Huston | April 24, 2008 - 14:04 ET

Looks like the daughter of the West Virginia's Democratic governor has gotten herself into a bit of a scandal with an unearned, politically awarded college degree from West Virginia University. A panel to review allegations that the woman didn't really earn that degree was convened and it was determined that she just does not qualify to get that degree that was awarded her by "High-ranking academic officers" at the school. Naturally, no report mentions that Gov. Joe Manchin is a member of the Democratic Party and that HE was the one that appointed the school's officials.

It seems that at the school, highly placed friends of the Democratic governor were trying to cover for the Guv's daughter who claimed for several years that she had a degree when she did not. Heather Bresch was suddenly awarded an MBA from WVU nearly a decade after she left the school and after the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette called the University to check on the woman's degree.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Back in December of 2007, the Post-Gazette broke the story of the politically awarded degree.

Top officials took the action nearly a decade after she was a student. The revision was sparked by a routine call from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette to confirm the academic credentials of Ms. Bresch, daughter of West Virginia Gov. Joe Manchin, following her Oct. 2 promotion to chief operating officer at Mylan. The Cecil-based company is chaired by Milan Puskar, WVU's largest benefactor.

The paper then recounted all the appointments that the Governor made to the school's board and hinted that the MBA was awarded because of politics and not completed class work.

Since then, a board had been looking into the awarding of the degree and now it has been concluded that the Governor's daughter really didn't earn the degree she was awarded.

Now, the news today is that the board is announcing their findings that Bresch does not deserve her MBA. As usual, the stories are filled with all sorts of details about the situation and about the woman's father, Governor Joe Manchin. Well, all sorts of details but the fact that the Governor and all his appointees to the school are Democrats, that is.

So here we go again with a story that easily fits the subject of government corruption, a "culture of corruption," because the Governor's sycophants at the school were the ones that gave out a degree for political reasons and yet, the Guv's party just isn't "relevant" to these news folks.

Who can doubt the were West Virginia's Gov. a Republican that old "Republican culture of corruption" would have been the meme of the day?

So, the AP forgot Governor Manchin was a Democrat just as the local papers and state wide news sources and TV stations did.

But, the funniest example of absurdity with this issue is the reactions at the Democratic Underground. You'll never guess who's fault the Demmies there blamed for the Democrat daughter of a Democrat Governor getting a fake degree?

Yeah.... you guessed it.

George W, Bush!

Hilarious for it's utter stupidity. BDS shall never die.

(h/t Newsbusters reader capav)

(Photo credit: YMSWWCblog)

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I guess her degree was

I guess her degree was worth exacly what she paid for it.  Funny that she was not mentioned as a Demorat.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

The major was "Political Science"...

the minor was "corruption of public trust by unworthy elected imbeciles".

WV MOUNTAINEERS...

 So Heather Bresch attended WVU, so did Adam "Pacman" Jones, neither one earned a degree. Makes sense to me.

Dan The Man 2, your right, it's worth what she paid for it.

 

"Some of us are wise, some of us are otherwise"  Mark Levin

I'm ROFL regarding the

I'm ROFL regarding the comments on DU...these pathetic critters...they really need to get a life...talk about a culture of corruption.

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Expect lies that Bush didn't earn his MBA

Don't forget, Mr. Bush EARNED an MBA.

I expect stories claiming he too didn't deserve it. Somebody somewhere will find a way to make the accusation.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

They already have

On the DUMMIES comments thread above referenced.

Even More Interesting @ Demoncrassic Underworld

The last post in the reply chain about Ms. Bresch is the most interesting:

Fact: she's been with the company since 1992, has steadily worked her way up the ladder ever since.
Worst case scenario speculation: she may have been "kicked upstairs where she can do less damage."

Fact: Sometime last fall, when she became COO, it became important that she have record of a bona fide MBA.
Speculation: She may or may not have misled Mylan to believe she had previously earned it.

Personally, you know what I think? If she didn't lie on her resumé, WV should have
awarded her an honorary MBA the day she got that big office. People get
honorary degrees - people get PhDs all the damn time, for their life's
experience outside of the classroom."

Whoever the poster Crisco is in real life, he or she has some real serious issues:

  • May or may not have misled? Just as one cannot be a little dead, one cannot dissemble about a degree. You have it or you don't. She either lied about having an MBA or not. It's black and white. Even if you have completed all the coursework but haven't received your degree yet, you can't be counted as having that degree.
  • The state should devalue all other MBA's just because one person got a "big office"? C'mon, she's COO of a company not Mother Theresa. What would you feel if you had an earned degree from the same institution and they just willy-nilly handed them out to anyone who got promoted to a "big office"? Bet you wouldn't be very happy.
  • People do get honorary PhD's, that's true. But there's a big difference between a PhD and an MBA. PhD's in most schools, require a published research paper that has been defended in front of a committee of peers. MBA's rarely have such stringent requirements.
  • I know from years in executive HR - honorary degrees never count to fulfill a bona fide occupational qualification. Imagine the problems that would occur in medicine, education and the hard sciences if honorary degrees were accepted as real. Would you want your doctor to have an honorary MD/DO? Would you want your dentist to have an honorary DDS? Would you want your pharmacist to have an honorary PharmD? Would you want the chief civil engineer in you city/county/state to have an honorary degree? Would you want the head chemist at your local water processing plant to have an honorary degree? State licensing departments do not recognise honorary degrees for any license or certification that requires a particular degree. Additionally, if a job description makes no allowance for honorary degrees and/or equivalent experience, the company is on the hook to every other person who applied for the same job, met the minimum qualifications and was denied the job. Can you say lawsuit? I thought you could.

This tool, Crisco, has chosen an apt screen name - his/her brain is deep fried. Definitely not the sharpest knife in the drawer.


"All that is necessary for the trimuph of evil is that good men do nothing."

- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)

www.conservativeboot...

I wonder

I wonder if dipsco... er, I mean crassco... oopsie, Crisco... ever said that Bush "may or may not have misled" anyone?

It May Have...

It's posted a lot, so that's entirely possible. I noticed that a lot of posters over there have a gold star next to the screen name and the designation 1000+ posts. Goody - cesspool, er crapo, er crisco is a kiloposter! Insert all the jokes about quanity v quality here...


"All that is necessary for the trimuph of evil is that good men do nothing."

- Edmund Burke (1729 - 1797)

www.conservativeboot...

As a West Virginian I can

As a West Virginian I can say that this has been swept under the rug here in the local news, as pointed out. In fact one of the rumors that I've heard was that the local news was "ordered" to hammer the "Rich Rod" problem. As with my screen name, I do work in the industry and no one at my radio station knew about this. Hell, the only way I found out about it was from a Pittsburgh paper. Two months ago.