In another swipe at the U.S. Military, the website of the Isthmus, a weekly alternative paper from Madison, Wisconsin, published a short piece called, “Army Aims at Schoolkids,” in which the paper quotes an anti-military activist as saying that the ad banners for the U.S. Army posted in Madison’s High Schools is “extremely inappropriate.” Of course, we should expect one of these anti-military nuts to call out against the U.S. Army for advertising in our schools, but what we shouldn’t expect is the subtle bias from the paper that helps those who hate our troops attack the Army.
The hallmarks of an editorial board that is against the military is evident throughout this report.
From the title of the piece, “Army Aims at Schoolkids,” to the tag line under the picture of the Army ads, “Extremely Inappropriate,” the paper seems bent on loading the story with negative connotations against the Military. Let’s look at that headline, by the way. “Army Aims at Schoolkids.” That is unduly negative right there. After all, these ads for the U.S. Army are displayed in Madison’s High Schools, not the lower grades. Isn’t it misleading to call High School aged teens “schoolkids”? The term “schoolkids” seems to bring 10-year-olds to mind far quicker than it does 18-year-olds.
Then the two lead paragraphs, the second of which gives a protester against the Military the first chance to get his point across, further stacks the deck against the American Military in this piece. That second paragraph reads:
"I think it's extremely inappropriate," says David Hoppe, a member of the Madison Area Peace Coalition and a former career counselor at East High. "Schoolchildren play on these fields, and every time they look up, they'll see 'Army.'"
But at least the piece does go on to explain that there is no violation of the school board’s practices to have taken payment from the Army for the ads, just as they have taken fees from other groups for displaying ads in the schools. School board president Arlene Silveira told the paper that there was nothing wrong with the ads. “It isn't forcing anyone to do anything,” she’s quoted as saying in one of the only two paragraphs that give support to the ads. And, isn’t that just a fact, after all? These ads are not compulsive, at least not any more so than any ad is, naturally. Still, this report has far more negative things in it describing this ginned up “controversy” than it does exculpatory items in favor of the military and its right to place these ads in the schools. And, one other thing is of interest here. The paper is obviously trying to make this story seem a raging controversy. But, a look at the facts as presented and giving them some thought seems to show just two people up in arms against the Army while no one else seems to be offended. The Isthmus highlights the faux outrage of only two anti-military activists. That’s it. Two. Now, consider this, if this story was a great community involving issue, one where many people were upset, you’d think that more than just two guys would be highlighted by the paper here. If this was a real controversy, the paper wouldn’t fail to report the many numbers of people in protest against this school’s policy. But we get quotes from only two guys who are upset over the lawful and moral ads for our Military placed where teens can see it. Do two activists mouthing off make a controversy now a days? So, what can we derive from the fact that there doesn’t seem to be very many people upset? Certainly we can see that only two guys are mad and everyone else has no problem. But, perhaps we can spy one other possibility? That the Daily Isthmus wants to make this seem more than it really is to draw more people into the conflict against the military to help these two lonely nuts in their quest to defeat our troops. After all, two whiners is not a story. But if the paper can alert others to the issue, maybe more will join the effort against the Military?














Editor at Large

Comments Policy
"Extremely inappropriate"
October 16, 2007 - 08:42 ET by Hero Squad"Extremely inappropriate" would be putting an Army ad at the local Senior Citizen Center.
Putting it at a high school football field - a location filled with juniors and seniors who are starting to think about their future and where some of them may wish to proudly serve their country upon graduation - is merely "appropriate."
Just because Mr. Peace Coalition isn't "Army Strong," doesn't mean he should attempt to thwart the desire of others who are.
Good. Let's not try to pretend we don't have one.
*****
Hero Squad's Daughter at the World War II Memorial in Washington, D.C.
Hmm... Putting and
October 16, 2007 - 09:19 ET by Six String SpiffHmm... Putting and advertisement for the military in a school (Where the student can make that career choice himself) is 'inappropriate', but it's PERRRRFECTLY alright to hold an anti-war rally.
Liberals hate freedom of choice. No. Liberals just hate freedom, evidently.
The American Revolution Continued
It's probably even
October 16, 2007 - 09:29 ET by lnthompIt's probably even perfectly all right to drag whole class-rooms full of kids out to hold up anti-war signs without regard to what any of their parents, much less the kids themselves, think about the war or the military.
Lee T.
U.S. Navy (ret.) / Vancouver, Washington
The history of the race, and each individual's experience, are thick with evidence that a truth is not hard to kill and that a lie told well is immortal.-- Mark Twain
Or passing out condoms in
October 16, 2007 - 09:58 ET by HypocriteHaterOr passing out condoms in school is perfectly alright for liberals.
Their updated motto should be "make love (and catch diseases because condoms are only 75% effective), not war (to protect our country and freedom from terrorists who want us dead or converted to Islam).
Concur: This is the
October 16, 2007 - 10:47 ET by BDConcur:
This is the classic case of "Let someone elses child do the hard work." And over the years it has had an effect. When I go through the young officers in my classes, the vast majority of them are military brats or kids who grew up in military towns such as Sierra Vista AZ, Killeen Tx, Rapid City SD, Fayetteville NC, and Omaha NE. You know, towns that are not afraid to show the flag anymore.
WHere do I get virtually no troops from? Las Angeles and Manhatten.
Nothing makes a Dad/mom more proud....
October 16, 2007 - 08:57 ET by JayTeeNothing makes a Dad/Mom more proud than watching the HS equivalent Graduate from Boot Camp, and all the character, discipline, and Endurance associated with that accomplishment.
The United States of America has every right, obligation, and authority to set up shop in public Schools and provide advertisement for the greatest Military on the face of the Planet.
Living to old age, requires an Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines defending your right to live to an old age. The Survival of the strongest is still the law of the Planet, regardless of the last 40 years of your life and your kids..... get some Vision, dude.
This is straight off CODE PINK's book on pg 19
October 16, 2007 - 09:07 ET by blackrain4xmasCode Pink put out a book called STOP THE NEXT WAR NOW. In it, they detail their tactics and strategies at disarming the US. Pg19 is targeting military recruitment centers. There's repeated sections that talk about inundating newspapers with letters to the editor-even small town ones.
Code Pinkers live in a
October 16, 2007 - 12:13 ET by PeskyDaneCode Pinkers live in a world inside their own minds. In the real world, unprotected women are routinely raped, pillaged, and their children are slaughtered in front of them except when they are "lucky" enough to be merely taken into slavery. They only thing standing between them and being treated like property are the strong moral men willing to defend their persons.
Yes, a banner promoting the
October 16, 2007 - 09:08 ET by drillanwrYes, a banner promoting the single most important organization (in the history of civilization) in bringing about this nation's independence, liberty, and freedom ... and continues to protect and preserve such independence, liberty, and freedom not only for this nation but for other countries in the world is so offensive and detrimental to high school kids that it far out-weighs those highly informative ads that run 24/7 on commercial TV about erectile dysfunction ...
Yes, replace the ARMY banner with a VIAGRA banner ... (NO /sarc button here ... I'm frakking dead serious ... Were I a parent at that school THIS would be MY retort to this idiot ...)
You mentioned "the single
October 16, 2007 - 10:17 ET by BruzillaYou mentioned "the single most important organization (in the history of civilization) in bringing about this nation's independence, liberty, and freedom ... and continues to protect and preserve such independence, liberty, and freedom not only for this nation but for other countries in the world." What does the Navy have to do with this? I thought the guy wanted to ban Army ads. :)
You know where I'm coming
October 16, 2007 - 10:34 ET by drillanwrYou know where I'm coming from ... ;^ )
Wouldn't matter if it were Army, Navy, Air Force or Marines ... The ignorant dolt would be pushing the same agenda.
The parents of this school need to counter this guy.
Sad, but not Suprising
October 16, 2007 - 09:09 ET by kdoliverWhat makes this really sad is that with the military, he would not have the freedoms to say moronic things.
One of my favorite rants is "Peace Activist". I can respect a person who truly believes in peace. I think we all do. But if you are stronger enough to allow yourself, your family, or your country to get the crap kicked out them and turn the other cheek--I may disagree, but I can respect you. These guys are just anti-American.
http://thelazytriathlete.blogspot.com/
Bite the hand that protects
October 16, 2007 - 09:13 ET by Six String SpiffIt amazes me how much these pacifists crap all over our military, but then shiver in a corner a pee like scared puppies when a threat is presented. Don't worry pacifists. You just keep watching PBS, and we will continue to protect you. Fools
Of course, by "We" I mean all the rest of us freedom loving, Patriotic, rational American citizens for those of you in Rio Linda, or Leon.
The American Revolution Continued
Out of Whack
October 16, 2007 - 09:25 ET by mattmIt's perfectly OK for the homos and the abortionists to go after the school kids...but the Army? No way.
God bless the U.S. Military!
Good point, Warner. By flacking what is currently a non-story
October 16, 2007 - 09:27 ET by RJbefore you know it, they have a real "controversy" to report.
Who knows....maybe get national coverage as the paper that's been reporting the story "from the beginning."
"That the Daily Isthmus wants to make this seem more than it really is to draw more people into the conflict against the military to help these two lonely nuts in their quest to defeat our troops. After all, two whiners is not a story. But if the paper can alert others to the issue, maybe more will join the effort against the Military?"
It simply repeating...
October 16, 2007 - 10:18 ET by Ole_SargeDuring MY high school years (1974-78) there WAS a REAL anti-military bias, from many of the High School teaching staff and administrators. My own High School Counseler whom is supposed to "assist" students, actually hindered me. I had paperwork to her for applying for an Air Force ROTC scholarship that she screwed-up, ON PURPOSE!!
The military recruiters COULD NOT come into the school buildings in those days. So they parked vehicles outside, just during lunch hours and stood on the sidewalk.This is Northeast Ohio, in the winter... just a "little" cold and snowy. No, they could NOT come inside, nor could they have information left inside the building either.
It did change, but sounds like the old time anti-military hacks are back one last time...
Ah, the more things change...
BTW we had a fair number of guys enter military service between 1977 and 1983 from my hometown, and more than a dozen gals. This a suburban community where it is almost "automatic" to go to college.
Ridiculous
October 16, 2007 - 10:38 ET by XJ.JonThis is absolutely absurd. There is no real worry for the students. This is ONLY a strike against our treasured Military Forces. This retard is an idiot.
Even my dog knows not to bite the hand that feeds and protects him.
Oh, God, what happened to common sense in America?
It's alive and well with
October 16, 2007 - 10:43 ET by JimboIt's alive and well with Conservatives.
Jimbo says - "There is a fine line between freedom of speech and treason"
Isthmus is a weekly rag
October 16, 2007 - 11:06 ET by CyberNorrisFYI, the Isthmus is a weekly free rag one can pick up at the grocery store. The Daily Page is their web site.
This rag is known for its viewpoint catering to the ultra regressives and hippies who largely inhabit the central parts of Madison.
Don't confuse this publication with a real newspaper... not that the real newspapers in town are that much different.
The Isthmus
October 16, 2007 - 11:15 ET by tmfCyberNorris made the point that I was about to make. This is not a real newspaper. For SF Bay residents, I think it is roughly the equivalent of the Berkeley Daily Planet here. Appalling but to be expected from this kind of rag in a crazed liberal town like Madison or Berkeley.
what's funny...
October 16, 2007 - 13:08 ET by CyberNorrisYa know what's funny is I clicked on the headline fully expecting it to be about Madison.
How perfect would it be if
October 16, 2007 - 11:58 ET by Hero SquadHow perfect would it be if the military's response was to buy that open advertising space above the Army ad and put a Navy ad there?
**Hero Squad's Daughter at the WWII Memorial
So the schools can push a
October 16, 2007 - 14:17 ET by rbosqueSo the schools can push a gay / leftist agenda but not give kids a choice to serve their country? Treason.
Oh, yeah, here ya go...
October 16, 2007 - 16:50 ET by drillanwrIf it wasn't so twisted and dangerous it'd be frakking hilarious :
Prescribe 'the pill' at middle school?
Student health officials say a broad contraceptive program is 'totally needed.'
http://pressherald.mainetoday.com/story.php?id=140910&ac=PHnws
And then there's this:
October 16, 2007 - 17:11 ET by drillanwrChicago Public Schools to open Marine-run academy
http://abclocal.go.com/wls/story?section=local&id=5707549
Yeah and the peas activists
October 16, 2007 - 18:01 ET by terrigYeah and the peas activists in Chi-town are up in arms. They now have one for every service and the lefties are po'd. However, I heard (I believe on Fox) that only 17% ever wind up joining the military. Daley was yapping to the anti-war kooks about this. I guess now he takes this stuff personal because I believe his son enlisted last year. However, if his son was not in the service I have to wonder if he would be so agitated about this.
He couldn't be, after all,
October 16, 2007 - 18:08 ET by BDHe couldn't be, after all, he is a liberal.....