AP National Story Criticizes Walker's Jobs Website For Out-of-State Jobs Which Would Increase Wis. Tax Collections
UPDATE: BizzyBlog commenter "Rich in Iowa" notes that what the AP is criticizing is "a clearinghouse for employers and job seekers hosted by the State of Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development and this site pre-dates Walker’s Governorship by, oh, maybe a decade."
Boy, Scott Bauer and the Associated Press have really, really nailed Scott Walker this time -- not.
Bauer found that some of the jobs listed in Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker's "Job Center of Wisconsin" website are located in Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota, Michigan). Imagine that: The Badger State's governor is including jobs in neighboring states because he apparently believes that his state would be better off if some of its unemployed workers found jobs across the border. Oh the humanity.
Bauer seems not to have figured out that Wisconsin residents working in Illinois, Michigan, and Minnesota (Iowa is not clear) pay Wisconsin state income tax (which is based on the state of residence), and that the state would be better off collecting income taxes from such workers instead of continuing to pay out unemployment and other government benefits.
The AP apparently thought that the matter is such a big potential scandal that it put Bauer's story on the national wire. Here goes (bolded text demonstrates how Bauer really doesn't get the income tax point raised in the previous paragraph):
APNewsBreak: 6,000 jobs touted by gov outside Wis.
Nearly one in five of the jobs listed on a state website touted by Gov. Scott Walker as a resource for unemployed Wisconsin residents are actually located in neighboring states, according to an analysis by The Associated Press.
More than 32,000 job openings were posted on the Job Center of Wisconsin's website as of Tuesday, but about 18 percent of them were in Illinois, Minnesota, Iowa and Michigan. It was unclear how many of those roughly 6,000 jobs could be filled through telecommuting, though many appeared to require on-site work.
Walker ran on a promise to add 250,000 private sector jobs in the state by 2015, and the Republican repeatedly referenced the website - the state's official jobs site - in his radio address last week as a place for Wisconsin's unemployed to find jobs and quickly connect with employers.
A search of the website Tuesday afternoon showed 32,253 job listings. Of those, 3,014 were in Illinois, 2,078 were in Minnesota, 737 were in Iowa and 136 were in Michigan.
It wasn't clear how many of the out-of-state jobs would allow someone to work from home, although a spot check showed many required on-site work, including multiple hotel housekeeper jobs just across the state border in Rockford, Ill., and farther south in the Chicago suburbs. It also was unclear how many would require workers to move out of Wisconsin.
But it's not unusual for people living near the Wisconsin border to work outside the state. The Twin Cities are only about 30 miles from Hudson, Wis., and downtown Chicago is about 50 miles from the state line and just a 90-minute train ride from Milwaukee. Dubuque, Iowa, is just across the Mississippi River and attracts workers from many rural Wisconsin communities.
Bauer also fails to entertain the possibility that residents of other states, particularly Illinois, which has lost 25,000 seasonally adjusted jobs in the past three months, might be interested in moving to Wisconsin (which has picked up 30,000 this year) if they manage to land jobs there. That would also enable the state to increase its income tax base and collect sales taxes when new residents buy things.
Seriously, the ignorance on display here should be embarrassing, but nobody at the AP appears to even know enough to be embarrassed.
Scott Bauer, the AP in Wisconsin, and the wire service nationally all seem to have come down with a serious, long-term case of Walker Derangement Syndrome. The only cure would appear to be finding reporters who know what they're doing and don't have what appear to be huge statist chips on their shoulders.
Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.
- Tom Blumer's blog
- Login to post comments
Comments
That's because Democrats
Submitted by dscott on Thu, 09/22/2011 - 4:29am.
That's because Democrats don't like the idea of losing voters, I mean dependents who keep them in power. Detroit is only a faillure because people moved away when Democrats ran the city into the ground. California is undergoing Detroitification as we speak, unfortunately for them, the middle class is moving out and the unskilled illegals are moving in to collect welfare benefits.
Is North Dakota on Wisconsin's list? Unemployment is less than 4% in ND, you are virtually guaranteed a job in less than 30 days of looking. Bismark, ND = 3% unemployment, employers are practically begging you to take their job. Pack your bags and move, it's the American way, after all our forefathers came to America by voting with their feet, it's a tradition.
http://www.bls.gov/web/metro/laummtrk.htm
what an idiot
Submitted by dubuqueman on Thu, 09/22/2011 - 11:21am.
I used to be one of those who lived across the river from Iowa in Wisconsin and worked in Iowa--hence my handle. I paid plenty of nice taxes to Wisconsin.
Here in Minneapolis
Submitted by CobraMan on Thu, 09/22/2011 - 1:07pm.
Here in Minneapolis, I know more than a few people who work Downtown and live across the border in Wisconsin. It's about a 35 minute commute, shorter than most commutes around the Metro area. They live in one state and work in another, which is a win/win for both states. So, what's the big deal?
By the way, Wisconsin isn't the only state where employers from other states advertise on state "job center" employment services websites/databases. It's done here in Minnesota. I would hazard a guess that it's also done in most, if not all, of the states employment centers. You can, occasionally, find over-sea jobs in our employment center's databases! Oh, the horror!
Also, the AP failed to note that employers, even those from out-state, pay a FEE to be listed on a job center's employment database, just like they pay a fee to be listed in a newspaper's "help wanted" section, which, by the way, also lists numerous jobs out-state. So, once again, what's the big deal?
The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States. The US Constitution
Unless you're a fetus. The US Supreme Court
Or Anwar al-Awlaki.
embarrassingly ignorant
Submitted by ohio granny on Thu, 09/22/2011 - 1:09pm.
AP is an embarrassingly ignorant organization on display for the whole world to see.
The word of the day for AP.....
Submitted by TheAngryConservative on Thu, 09/22/2011 - 6:48pm.
....is reciprocity. All states have arrangements with all others as it relates to who gets the tax revenues if a person lives and works in a different state. In some states, such as Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Alabama, and Pennsylvania, you can actually end up paying two different local taxes because you don't work and live in the same locality. As far as the states go, the reciprocity can be to the worked state, the lived state, or it can be shared (in whole or in part) between both states.
It's blisteringly obvious that the AP has an axe to grind against Mr. Walker and they're so blinded by their agenda that they failed to consult at least one payroll professional before writing their insipid little story.
Not all journos are this amateurish, but it speaks to the stereotype that people that go to J-school probably can't cut it in a real job. If I was half this careless in my job, my job security would be....lacking.
We have, I fear, confused power with greatness. ~ Stewart Udall