A Billion Here, A Billion There: Dem-Backed Firms Get Speculative Energy Dept. Loans

Photo of Tom Blumer.
  • Bookmark and Share

GlobalWarmingThe headline and the first paragraph from this Friday Wall Street Journal report by Josh Mitchell and Stephen Power reads like a bad joke Jay Leno's writers would have discarded, because no one would believe it. The second paragraph isn't much better:

Gore-Backed Car Firm Gets Large U.S. Loan

A tiny car company backed by former Vice President Al Gore has just gotten a $529 million U.S. government loan to help build a hybrid sports car in Finland that will sell for about $89,000.

The award this week to California startup Fisker Automotive Inc. follows a $465 million government loan to Tesla Motors Inc., purveyors of a $109,000 British-built electric Roadster. Tesla is a California startup focusing on all-electric vehicles, with a number of celebrity endorsements that is backed by investors that have contributed to Democratic campaigns.

That's a combined total of just shy of a billion dollars going to two companies currently making toys for the wealthy under circumstantially suspect conditions.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Tesla may have legitimate prospects; at least it is selling something. The company claims in an August 7 press release to have posted a profit of $1 million on sales of $20 million during the month of July. Fisker, on the other hand, is still working on a dealer network.

But in each case, based on where the companies stand, the funding for development would ordinarily come from venture capital or corporate investors who would take significant ownership stakes. No lender in the private sector, even a bank laboring under the Treasury Department's Troubled Assets Relief Program, would dare make these loans except under externally-induced duress, on the justifiable concern that, well, they would be creating more troubled assets.

But the Department of Energy (DOE) has no problem putting taxpayers on the hook for these speculative ventures. As the late Illinois Senator Ev Dirksen said (in essence), "A billion here, a billion there, and pretty soon you're talking real money."

The story should have received more attention than it has, especially because of the circumstantial evidence of favoritism, which apparently included a of taxpayer-financed loan application consulting:

DOE officials spent months working with Fisker on its application, touring its Irvine, Calif., and Pontiac, Mich., facilities and test-driving prototypes.

.... Henrik Fisker, who designed cars for BMW, Aston Martin and Tesla before starting his Fisker Automotive in 2007, said his goal is to build the first plug-in electric hybrids that won't sacrifice the luxury, performance and looks of traditional gas-powered luxury cars.

.... He said he pitched the Karma to Mr. Gore at an event hosted by KPCB last year, and that the former vice president almost immediately submitted a down payment for the car.

Kalee Kreider, a spokeswoman for Mr. Gore, confirmed that the former vice president backs Fisker and purchased a Karma. "He believes that a global shift of the automobile fleet toward electric vehicles, accompanying a shift toward renewable-energy generation, represents an important part of a sensible strategy for solving the climate crisis," she said in a statement.

Fisker's top investors include Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, a veteran Silicon Valley venture-capital firm of which Gore is a partner. Employees of KPCB have donated more than $2.2 million to political campaigns, mostly for Democrats, including President Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, according to the Center for Responsive Politics, a nonpartisan group that tracks campaign contributions.

.... Fisker's government loans will come from a $25 billion program established by Congress in 2007 to help auto makers invest in the technology to meet a new congressional mandate to improve fuel efficiency. In June, the DOE awarded the first $8 billion from the program to Ford Motor Co., Nissan Motor Co., and Tesla, which are all developing electric cars.

It's reasonable to ask whether Congress in 2007 expected that the program would take on the self-evident default risks of lending to a start-up and a very early-stage company, respectively, or if it expected that the funds would be accessed by already well-capitalized companies.

It's also reasonable to ask whether the Fisker deal is worth it, based on the DOE's September 22 press release (bolds are mine):

US Energy Secretary Chu Announces $528 Million Loan for Advanced Vehicle Technology for Fisker Automotive
Investment will save or create at least 5,000 jobs

Washington, DC – Energy Secretary Steven Chu today announced a $528.7 million conditional loan for Fisker Automotive for the development of two lines of plug-in hybrids that will save hundreds of millions gallons of gasoline and offset millions of tons of greenhouse gas emissions by 2016. The project will result in approximately 5,000 jobs created or saved for domestic parts suppliers and thousands more to manufacture a plug-in hybrid in the U.S.

“This investment will create thousands of new American jobs and is another critical step in making sure we are positioned to compete for the clean energy jobs of the future,” said Secretary Chu. “Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles could revolutionize personal transportation and cut our dependence on foreign oil, not to mention give us cleaner air and less carbon pollution.”

.... While the final assembly of the Karma will be done overseas, more than 65 percent (based on cost) of the parts required for Karma will come from U.S. suppliers. The four-door Karma is scheduled to appear in showrooms in summer 2010.

All of this for 5,000 jobs? What's more, DOE itself acknowledges that many of the jobs will probably not be "created," only "saved," using the preposterous "created or saved" language the administration has used since shortly after the November election. Before the election, candidate Obama, without any exception I could find, referred only to "creating jobs."

If there were so many conflicts of interest in appearance in a financial arrangement in any other administration, I daresay the press as a whole would be paying a lot more attention to this, and asking a lot more questions. But in the Obama administration, under the environmental mantra, apparently anything goes, even if, as noted yesterday (covered at NewsBusters; at BizzyBlog), much of the underlying data supporting the very idea of global warming as a valid concept may have disappeared.

Cross-posted at BizzyBlog.com.

—Tom Blumer is president of a training and development company in Mason, Ohio, and is a contributing editor to NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

$89,000 dollars for an Electric Sports Car?

I can get a house on Wheels for $89 K!!!  And you guys can come help me take them off when I get it on the blocks.

Liberalism: The haunting feeling that someone, somewhere, can help themselves.

Good one, AF

I know someone who will lend you an old dog and a cooler for your beer.  I bet he'd even help you build a porch for that thang.

 

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

Oh Blonde

You say the sweetest thangs...It makes my old thumpin gizzard skip a beat!!! 

Liberalism: The haunting feeling that someone, somewhere, can help themselves.

Hee hee, AF

I bet I can get him to throw in a lizard to assist the gizzard (and a pair of overalls, too).  Only if you agree not to barbeque it, tho.  You need an iguana ranch to accompany that thar trailer.

Off Topic:  We saw HUGE iguanas in Costa Rica....the suckers are everywhere.  We even ran over one that ran across the road, but of course, I didn't tell the driver man that.  He'd have wrecked us, for sure.

I hope he fails, too.

 

 

yea AF-50, It ain't home till you take the wheels off...

Trailer Park Troubadours, Double Wide and Dangerous..

sample below

http://www.unhitched.com/demos/DNDainthome.mp3

Oh yea it takes 30 hours to charge a Tesla roadster.

Ok an hour charge time; if you pay another $100,000.00 for a 250 KW charger!

Exactly what our founders

Exactly what our founders warned against, preached against and wrote our founding documents toward.

Like the misguided Kelo decision, gubment becoming too big and awarding favors, unfairly, to people that support those in office. 

If this continues, we are done.

Al Gore & Pals strike

Al Gore & Pals strike again...he doesn't need to wait for Cap-and Trade,he's being paid off handsomely with this little deal...aren't the tax-payers lucky....no outrage from what I've heard about this dirty-rotten scam of his...as he runs all the way to the bank...with a smile on his face.

Sickening...all of this.

'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart

There must be some type of

There must be some type of legal action that could be taken.

More questions...

Will any of this money go off-shore? Are these companies unionized? I know the column mentioned Irvine and Pontiac sites, but are they testing facilities, distribution facilities or manufacturing facilities? What is the expected turn-around for repayment? (This is a loan, correct?)

Now for my ultimate this really confuses my simple mind question: Isn't one of the major issues with the environmental crowd the use of coal to generate electricity? And a follow up: With no real viable technology on tap to replace (not augment, replace)the use of coal for electricity generation (I know nuclear is viable scientifically, but not politically- so it's not currently on the table), why are we creating vehicles that will run on scale and infrastructure that currently doesn't exist, and will at best replace the non-existent man-made elements of the non-existent global warming catastrophe with another dirty fuel?

sure is

they're going to build it in Europe, so tell me, how does that save or create American jobs...???

One More Question

Why would anyone doubt the motives of this crooked administration?  They gave us unicorns didn't they?  Guess this is two questions.

Racists!

Hmm...Al Gore as the new 

Hmm...Al Gore as the new  John DeLorean?

Seems like this is yet another scam to bilk the taxpayers.

Al Gore

 Come on, we all know what Al  does for a living, now we know the price.

Come On Guys

We need to stop giving grants and loans to Americans for their overseas companies.

Seeing GM is a big fat failure why doesn't Al Gore make his company a local one giving the well needed jobs to American's.

you see Big Al doesn't care for America he cares only for himself and how he can manipulate the system Obama says he wants to change and break the national economy by giving money to foreign car makers.

"The ultimate result of shielding men from the effect of folly is to fill the world with fools."

Herbert Spencer's "State Tamperings with Money Banks"

A scenario I don't rule out ....

.... if the technology proves itself (or even pretends to prove itself), Obama's car czars force GM to buy it at a premium price, enriching Gore and his pals beyond their wildest dreams.

It could be worse

We could be financing cars that run on compressed air, goodwill or fairy dust. Someday electric cars will be cheap and efficient but we're a decade or longer away from that. Unless the subsidy/tax credit is $20k or so, this is nothing more than the middle-class helping wealthy Greens to buy a new car. Maybe we should follow Germany's model and subsidize solar panels and then...well, pay for that subsidy with taxes on homeowners. Make sense to them.

I think they named the car the Karma to attract empty-headed new-age Hollywood and O likes to keep them saying nice things about him. I also suppose someone close to him will profit greatly from this little deal, just like they always seem to do, despite the MSM turning a blind eye.

 

E. Burke "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."

UAW

I can see the now flush with cash UAW investing.  It would be a natural.  They now sell, design and assemble cars.  Why aren't they in it with the store? 

Power Plants Needed

Who is going to build all of the electric generation facilities to power these cars?

I wonder if these morons realize you still have to plug the car into the outlet at your home or office to charge the batteries.

How do they help the environment if they run off of power plants that burn coal or natural gas?