NPR Explores How Rapper Jay-Z Is the USA, and He Can't Get Bogged Down In Hip-Hop Iraq

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

Last Wednesday, NPR's Morning Edition ran a strange story picking up on how George Washington University professor Mark Lynch blogged for Foreign Policy magazine on how rapper "beefs" are a metaphor for foreign policy. Jay-Z, on top of the rapper heap, is the U.S., whereby a challenging rapper like The Game could be Iran. It prompted this funny letter, read on the air the next day:

LINDA WERTHEIMER: One NPR listener wrote on our Web site: Jay-Z and The Game are like foreign policy? I can't wait to see how Britney Spears and the Pussycat Dolls are like cancer research, or how the reunion of New Kids on the Block parallels how Russia is again consolidating power. Can I search your archives for a story about how Bobby Sherman mirrored the Tet Offensive?

Here's a part of Morning Edition anchor Steve Inskeep's interview with Professor Lynch:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

INSKEEP: And then he goes on to say a bunch of other things we can't repeat on the radio. But basically The Game is hammering Jay-Z as old and irrelevant, the flipside of the argument that Jay-Z is making that some of these new guys are not authentic.

LYNCH: So why is he doing this? And here is where international relations theory becomes relevant. All of a sudden there's opportunities to peel off some of Jay-Z's key alliance partners and form a broad-based coalition against Jay- Z. Maybe he thinks that Jay-Z is getting old, he's irrelevant. The Game says, hey, maybe I can peel off a number of people and undermine the foundations of Jay-Z's hegemony.

INSKEEP: And if the Game manages to fight, stand and fight with Jay-Z, even if he loses that fight, it raises his stature because...

LYNCH: Exactly.

INSKEEP: ...he's in there with the big guy.

LYNCH: Exactly. And you know, so there's this idea that a lot of times in beefs, there the idea that someone's going to be totally destroyed, but actually not so much. All he has to do is survive.

In an earlier beef, 50 Cent spun one of Jay-Z's own lines. He says, if I shoot you I'm famous, if you shoot me you're brainless. Because a hegemon can't get into these little battles all over the place. It drains your resources, it alienates people, it makes you look like a bully.

And so Jay-Z, like the United States after the war in Iraq, has got a really tough decision to make. You know, do you ignore these provocations? But then they might spread, then people might think that you're weak. Do you hit down really hard? You could maybe destroy The Game, but you're going to be exhausted in the process.

And so this like the U.S. now suddenly having to go and fight counterinsurgency campaigns all over the world. And do we have the resources for that? Is that really what we want to be doing with our foreign policy? How do you respond to that?

INSKEEP: So Jay-Z is discovering that even the most powerful superpower has limits to what he can do.

LYNCH: And in fact, the more powerful you are, the more limits there are on your ability to use that power.

INSKEEP: Oh, because you could put yourself at risk anywhere in the world.

LYNCH: Exactly. And if you start alienating other powerful states, or in this case other powerful rappers, who might feel that they're next, they might not want to cooperate with you. So you think The Game is Iran and Jay-Z is the U.S., and what this is really about is not The Game, it's about Europe, right? It's about Kanye West.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

This is perfect.

It illustrates the insanity of "University Profesors" and NPR in the same story.

Throw 'da bums out!

no one re-elected who voted for socialism or debt

www.loyaltoliberty.com

Our tax dollars pay for

Our tax dollars pay for this.

My Thoughts Exactly

Next week they will discuss how Gomer Pyle and Oliver Stone mirror the modern Army and the changes being made.  huh?

"For a people who are free, and who mean to remain so, a well-organized and armed militia is their best security."

So you think The Game is Iran and Jay-Z is the U.S., ???

how about this, Professor Lynch is a representation of all that is bad in this country,

This is a question for Professor Lynch - You don't actually think rap music has a deeper meaning then promoting thugs and violence do you?

If you can see that far into rap music, why is it that you can not understand the basic concept of conservatism and the basic ideas behind the Constitution of the United States?????

...how about we have a recall vote on Senator/Congressperson so and so....

I wonder where The Roots

I wonder where The Roots would fall into his parallels?  Now there's a hip-hop group I can respect.  Musically, The Game is better than Jay-Z.  However, they are childish and stupid when they "beef" on eachother. 

As with most musicians, I would like to tell them "shut up and play."  Same goes with actors and nearly every other entertainer.  Unless they do something worthwhile, I don't care and simply wish to be entertained.

Still, how this man found a parallel here baffles me.  There's essentially no connection and he makes up excuses for what the conflict is.  

Here's a parallel for them.  The US is the biggest kid on the playground.  For the most part he gets his way.  If you're on friendly terms you get treated well and protected.  If you aren't, you can expect an unfavorable reaction.  Iraq would be the kid who throws a rock at the back of the first kid's head.  I know my parallel is stupid, but it's a little more coherent.

Liberalism

Always "meaning well", always looking for "meaning" where there is none, never "meaning" what they say, always being treated, "meanly" and trying to simulataneously ignore and re-invent the "mean old world"

I suppose there is something quiet homoerotic in the liberal brain when "Feelings" is played.

Blacks rape 35,000 white women a year

USDOJ says Blacks rape 35,000 white women a year and whites rape 0.0 black women a year.

Maybe this rapper can fight his sexual lyrics

What a meaningless statistic

What is your point, Daniel?   Rape is about the greatest evil that can be foisted on someone, short of murder.  Period.

And that is regardless of race, color, creed, ethnicity, whatever.   

"CONSUMED DEMOCRACY RETURNS A SOCIALIST REGIME" - Slayer, "Fictional Reality", from Divine Intervention (1994)

meaningful

Daniel Baker,your statistic is meaningful anytime, but esp during these discussions of "police profiling." You cannot have a meaningful dialogue, with accusations of so-called racism of the police and courts without including the such pertinent information. Thank you.

It's especially important when studying the culture of crime and the common use of misogynistic female imagry that is considered mainstream and no longer stigmatizing because of the MSM's unflinching acceptance of rap's denigration of women that would never be accepted if it was popular culture ( esp aimed at teen-agers,) that denigrated black males.