Ed Asner on PBS: Why Excrete Money in Iraq When You Can Waste It Here at Home?

Photo of Tim Graham.

This interview is a little old, but worth sharing. Socialist actor Ed Asner appeared on PBS’s Tavis Smiley show on May 21 to promote his new Pixar film "Up." Asner typically kvetched about the wasteful disaster of Iraq and blundered into an odd quote when he lamented "The crime is you can convince all those Congressional people and the people through the media to piss away all that money overseas and it becomes socialism to convince them to piss away the money here at home."

He also suggested illegal Mexicans are taking some of the racist hate off black people, which Smiley protested, since he didn’t want anyone thinking we were living in "post-racial" (or post-racist) America. Asner also patted himself on the back for having the political courage to play a slave-ship captain on the 1977 ABC miniseries "Roots."

SMILEY: I only know that because I saw you in "Roots" when I was a kid. You played that villain pretty good.

ASNER: I regard that villain as, let's call him, a guy who was trying to be a good Nazi and he failed.

SMILEY: Sounds oxymoronic, but I hear your point. As you look back on that now, 30 or 35 years later, what do you make of the opportunity you had to be a part of - I mean, you've been a part of some of these seminal projects, but talk to me about "Roots" and the character that you had a chance to play in it.

ASNER: Well, I had succeeded well with "Rich Man, Poor Man" the year before. I didn't know that the director would ever have me back again, but amazingly to his credit, he did, but they wanted me for the captain. I mean, for the first mate. I felt I had done that role before and, much as I'd like to be on "Roots," I preferred to do the captain and betray some literary aspect to the character, so they said yeah and I was amazed.

I did it and Ralph Waite was a wonderful first mate. One of the reasons I did it was because I'm sure that the white actors in Hollywood, racist

Hollywood, will avoid this movie about black people, so I have got to put myself up as the great good soul that I am. [Smiley is smiling, since there is a little bit of sarcasm here.] You knew that, yeah. Put myself out there for the Black people of this country. I was lucky I didn't have broken legs from the white actors who wanted to be in "Roots" and they got some beauties.

So I did it and I also thought it would be a loss leader. I didn't think it would run away the way it did and it scored phenomenally and I'm delighted. I think it changed radically this country and a lot of this country's attitude by its people to black people.

SMILEY: I think you're right. I think we owe a debt to Alex Haley that we can never repay.

ASNER: He should be up there in the list of gods.

Smiley later turned to how Asner became a "progressive," and whether his experience growing up Jewish in Kansas City sensitized him to discrimination:

ASNER: I think before I was born, there was a country club that had a lake there, the only lake in the area, and supposedly they had a sign at their box office that said, "No Jews or dogs admitted." You know, I've done a lot of research on Boss Prendergast of that era. He was Irish and they used to have signs up that said, "No dogs or Irish need apply."

So it's applied everywhere. Nowadays they're probably saying, "No dogs or Mexicans need apply." I think, you know, the Mexicans take a tremendous - the immigration, the illegals take a tremendous, what would you call it, burden off Blacks by their illegality and by their lessened American capabilities.

SMILEY: Take a burden off Black people in what way?

ASNER: Prejudice. I think some of these people are so busy hating Mexicans, they don't have time to hate Blacks.

SMILEY: You can't believe that.

ASNER: I can't believe that?

SMILEY: You believe that?

ASNER: Oh, of course. How much room can they have to hate?

SMILEY: I don't know that that hate has to be categorized that way.

ASNER: They don't like to blur their focus. Let's put it that way.

SMILEY: I hear that point. But I think that anybody who is a bigot is a bigot.

ASNER: Oh, sure, yeah, yeah. The Archie Bunkers of the world who did that - there's another good Nazi who was humorous. Yeah, I probably am overstating my case, but as Freud said, you always need someone – you need a scapegoat.

SMILEY: I only raise that -- I think Freud's right about that. I only raise that because I think - and I know you weren't suggesting this -- but I think it's dangerous particularly now that we have an African American who's president and we celebrate that. I certainly do.

But I don't want us to buy into this notion that we live in a post racial America nor do I want us to buy into the notion that, because people are hating on Mexicans, that does not mean that African Americans are still catching hell in certain circumstances.

ASNER: Oh, no. I'm not going to remove that. The skin color will always be a brand.

SMILEY: Exactly. That's the point.

ASNER: The Mexicans have a lighter brand. I know that and I know that I think that, if this country spent more time on trying to benefit all of its citizens no matter what color, there would be less time for hatred and discrimination.

The crime for me in this country is to spend trillions in Middle Eastern adventures with the incumbent loss of life while our country goes into the toilet at home in terms of education, in terms of jobs, in terms of health. I think that's the biggest crime of all.

SMILEY: I don't think it needs it necessarily, but I want to ask just to make sure I'm on the same page. You want to qualify what you mean by Middle Eastern adventures? You want to define that for us?

ASNER: Iraq. I even question Afghanistan and the persistence by this present president of planning to stay in Afghanistan, I think, is foolhardy and a quagmire. You know, the Western world should finally realize, I think, to stay away from this place called Afghanistan because you cannot win. They're gonna try to make themselves the first winners. We were gonna try to improve over the French in Vietnam, weren't we? We got surprised, didn't we?

How nice if we could – the crime is you can convince all those Congressional people and the people through the media to piss away all that money overseas and it becomes socialism to convince them to piss away the money here at home.

SMILEY: If those members of Congress were sitting in my chair and debating you on this, they would say that these aren't really adventures. This is about spreading democracy, Ed Asner. We've got to spread democracy around the world, and to that, you'd say?

ASNER: How many years do you think it'll take? When can we first hope to see those democratic springs arising? And we also see that trouble is beginning to erupt again in Iraq as time moves on and the sects are beginning to fall apart again. I don't trust any of it. I think we have disgraced ourselves as this great democracy and it would be nice if we could do something for the folks at home for a change and uplift ourselves.

I mean, too many times in the past, in my opinion, when things have been going too bad, America somehow found itself in a foreign engagement and the military industrial complex got a chance to work and sell and make profits. I'm really tired of those profit makers. I really am.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

my beloved Lou Grant :(

Mary Tyler Moore is still great. Lou Grant is still amazing.

But what a bunch of kookie nonsense he's yapping on about, especially that "illegal Mexicans are taking some of the racist hate off black people" stuff. Ouch... that really was out-there and uncomfortable.

His liberalism is getting loonier and loonier with age, apparently. 

 

You're the next contestant on...
THE MESSIAH IS... LEFT !!

 

Red Ed

So is Ansner  also opposed to the increase in overseas abortion funding Obama is implementing or the Administrations billino dollar aide package to Hamas?

Learn how to play Guitar,,,,,,moron

Example Music is the only thing, is that an SG he is playing?

 

My Gov. thinks I am dangerous, so be careful

"Television is a freak show" Bernie Goldberg

Ed's saving grace

Asner shines in "Up," easily the best movie of the year and what is probably going to usher in a new era of wholesome, positive movies due to all the money's it's making.

Hollywood's leftism can only stand so much poverty before the bottom line begins to take over. How ironic for Ed.

dont you just wonder?

I would bet Ed has a boatload of lawyers and tax accountants to ensure he doesn't pay a dime in taxes to support his steal-from-the-rich philosophy. I bet he doesn't give a penny to charity and I bet he doesn't live in squalor so others might have a better life. Au contraire... he thinks that YOU should be supporting all of his racist policies with YOUR tax dollars. The loonie left strikes again.  Thanks, Ed. You're an idiot.

No doubt

The real reason that liberals and democrats do not want a simple flat tax is because it means that the majority of the elites running the Dem Party would actually have to start paying taxes.

I learned a long time ago from my personal injury attorney brother-in-law, (who of course votes nothing but Dem), all about how these guys pay zero in income tax by using every loophole imaginable in our tax codes.  He asked me once how I was going to vote on a ballot measure that would raise the state sales tax.  I told him I thought it was unfair to poor people, and that I wouldn't vote for anything that raised taxes anyways.  He tried to convince me that we needed this regressive tax so as to keep taxes lower for upper and middle class taxpayers, I kid you not.

Now, what's all the chatter lately about a "Value Added Tax"? 

"I've sentenced boys younger then you to the gas chamber.  Didn't want to do it, but I felt I owed it to them."  Judge Smails 

I'm just glad I enjoyed Up

I'm just glad I enjoyed Up before I learned it was Ed Asner in it.

ASNER: So I did it and I

ASNER: So I did it and I also thought it would be a loss leader. I didn't think it would run away the way it did and it scored phenomenally and I'm delighted. I think it changed radically this country and a lot of this country's attitude by its people to black people.

   Hollywood types are always so full of themselves.  Asner thinks Roots changed peoples attitudes towards race, that the movie was an important moment in the 'education' of Americans about the treatment of blacks.  Well I clearly remember life before Roots and I already knew how and why blacks were brought to this hemisphere.  Everybody did.

    The attitude changes he sees are not the result of Hollywood but the generational shift that started in the fifties.  The Greatest Generation all the way up to FDR was very racist towards blacks but my generation, the boomers, had a much less racist attitude.

  The reason a black can now be elected President is because enough of the older generation is gone.  There is nothing historic about obama himself.  What is historic is the shift in attitudes of whites towards blacks.  White people are the ones who made history not obama.  He's not the first black to run for President.  He's the first to get enough whites votes to put him in the Whitehouse.

Ya see Jer, it' the left that are racist

Both of these imbeciles talking about skin color being a "brand", and Mexicans being a "lighter brand". Who thinks like that? Not the right. 

"This
liberal would be all about socialize -- uh, uh, would be about
basically taking over and the government running all of your companies."-Maxine Waters 2008

I have always liked this

I have always liked this old-toots ability to entertain on TV but his politics are embarrassingly moronic.

"played the villain pretty good..."

This guy is a journalist?  How about, "played the villain pretty well".   I make mistakes in punctuation and some spelling mistakes occasionally...but I remember that from...2nd grade?

Is it for career advancement purposes that so many Thespians at least appear to be Hollyweirded out?  I find it difficult to believe that there is a relationship between...oh...wait....

"Just when liberals thought it was safe to start identifying
themselves as such, an acclaimed, veteran psychiatrist is making the
case that the ideology motivating them is actually a mental disorder."Based on strikingly irrational beliefs and emotions, modern
liberals relentlessly undermine the most important principles on which
our freedoms were founded," says Dr. Lyle Rossiter, author of the new
book, "The Liberal Mind: The Psychological Causes of Political Madness." "Like spoiled, angry children, they rebel against the normal responsibilities of adulthood and demand that a parental government meet their needs from cradle to grave."

So...the child part fits.  Great actors with genius are rare.  Children love to "pretend".  Pretending is at the heart of acting...yes?  So do more childlike personalities excel at acting.  Thus the "angry children" part of the above makes some sense.   Just sayin'...

islam is a lie and Truth is killing it.

Ed Assner is so full of himself.............

"I didn't know that the director would ever have me back again, but
amazingly to his credit
, he did, but they wanted me for the captain."

Good grief!

Excuse me while I go throw up.

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows.  -Bart Simpson

 

Sticking With The Lie.

SMILEY: I think you're right. I think we owe a debt to Alex Haley that we can never repay.

ASNER: He should be up there in the list of gods.

See, this is the problem with liberals. I'm sure that Mr. Asner is well aware of the fact that Alex Haley settled quietly out of court for $650,000.00 for plagiarizing the book, "The African" written by Hal Courlander. "Roots" also won a Pulitzer for best non-fiction novel though the Village Voice, in a 1993 cover piece, stated that the history of the book was a near total invention. But Mr. Asner still insists that, "He should be up there in the list of gods."

Why do so many liberal gods wind up being false idols?

Once a liberal loon, always a liberal loon!!!

Google Alex Haley Plagiarized Roots for full story.

Really. I had no idea Asner

Really. I had no idea Asner was still alive. I thought this because I hadn't heard any kookiness reported from him in years. Reading about the things he believes, I do think he's unhinged.

 

Alive indeed.

Alive, but brain dead.

"I've sentenced boys younger then you to the gas chamber.  Didn't want to do it, but I felt I owed it to them."  Judge Smails 

Mr. Asner?

I have just one question for you.  How much money per year have you paid to live in this country, enjoy its freedoms and securities, and pay for the cradle-to-grave giveaways you seem to espouse. 

Please break down your answer into both taxes paid as a percentage of earnings and charitable gifts.

I await your answer.

Good grief... where to

Good grief... where to start?

I didn't know that the director would ever have me back again, but amazingly to his credit, he did
If only the rest of the world understood your brilliance, your greatness.... all we see is a bitter, old, self-important, holier-than-thou butt.

I preferred to do the captain and betray some literary aspect to the character
Typical liberal actor.  Seeking to inject his personal agenda into the portrayal of a character.


a guy who was trying to be a good Nazi
Liberals love that "N" word.


Put myself out there for the Black people of this country
You are such a saint.   Well, self-appointed, self-proclaimed, self-celebrated saint.

I think it changed radically this country and a lot of this country's attitude by its people to black people
That's putting the cart before the Ox.  If people were racist, they just would not have watched the show Ed, and it would have FLOPPED.


He should be up there in the list of gods.
gods are pretty cheap in your world, Ed.


supposedly they had a sign at their box office that said, "No Jews or dogs admitted."
Supposedly?   Did you hear this from "un-named sources"?   What poor Ed doesn't understand, it is the liberals who are the true anti-semitics, always running to side with Hamas.


the immigration, the illegals take a tremendous, what would you call it, burden off Blacks by their illegality and by their lessened American capabilities.
What is this "lessened capabilities" of which you speak Ed?  Sounds racist to me.  


I think some of these people are so busy hating Mexicans, they don't have time to hate Blacks.
Typical.  In a liberal's mind, anyone who does not think like me, is full of hate.


there's another good Nazi who was humorous.
Liberals love to toss about the "Nazi" moniker.


The skin color will always be a brand.
Only to the liberals, Ed.


The Mexicans have a lighter brand.
Once again, racist "branding".


if this country spent more time on trying to benefit all of its citizens no matter what color, there would be less time for hatred and discrimination.
And exactly WHAT GOVERNMENT BENEFITS are minorities excluded from Ed?  In fact Ed, who are the primary beneficiaries of most government benefits?


The crime for me in this country is to spend trillions in Middle Eastern adventures with the incumbent loss of life
I guess it was also a crime to spend trillions in our "European adventures" in the 40's.


while our country goes into the toilet at home in terms of education
Do you honestly believe we are not spending ENOUGH money on education?


[somehow] it becomes socialism to convince them to piss away the money here at home.
Yes, taking the earnings of one to give to another is SOCIALISM, Ed.  Using that money to support our troops is PATRIOTISM.


How many years do you think it'll take (democratization of other nations)?
So, I guess we shouldn't have tried to fight the battle against racism, because it would "take too long".


I'm really tired of those profit makers. I really am.
Well, by all means, donate your salary to charity Ed.  Tell the movie industry to quit gouging the public with $10 ticket prices.

When asked if he went to war with Iraq  to derail the impeachment vote:  “I don’t think any serious person would believe that any President would do such a thing." - President Clinton (Dec 1998).

Nice

Very good breakdown and analysis, Jerry.

Have you ever noticed?

Have you ever noticed that Liberals love to denounce America for it's supposed racism and discrimination, and the supposed atrocities or government inflicts on others, and do so ad nauseum, and they scream that this must be stopped even though such discrimination and racism is actually quite rare amongst the population here yet when America tries to stop actual racism and discrimination abroad, as well as actual atrocities like the mass slaughter of innocents (like what happened in Iraq under Saddam), the liberals all stand up and yell STOP?

It's obvious that Liberals don't really care if people are oppressed and/or slaughtered. Unless, of course, they can gain some type of political advantage over their opponents in Government. Typical of the liberals, they're always fighting the wrong war.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

Muslim Women

I got disgusted when Obama gave his speach in Egypt and called for more tolerance when it came to the United States letting Muslim women wear their head scarfs or burkahs or whatever.  When did we ever NOT let a woman wear whatever she wants on her head, unless she is getting her drivers license or passport photo taken, or she needs other form of positive identification.

And then he started to say how they need to "ease up" a little bit on how they treat their women.  When did we call for an "easing up" of apartheid in South Africa?

I've often wondered, if we came across a lost civilization that practiced ritual sacrifice, would be just be passive spectators, because we wouldn't want to interfere with their "culture"? 

"I've sentenced boys younger then you to the gas chamber.  Didn't want to do it, but I felt I owed it to them."  Judge Smails 

Bend, untill we break.

That's the problem with most liberals, they want us to bend our morals to accommodate the immoralities found in other cultures, like the sexism practiced in the Middle East.

Liberals think that morals are flexible, that they can be bent without breaking. They never seem to realize that morals are inflexible, that they break when you try to bend them. A broken moral is useless and society never benefits from useless morals. Hence the "Pro-Choice" movement.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

a guy who was trying to be

a guy who was trying to be a good Nazi
Liberals love that "N" word.


there's another good Nazi who was humorous.
Liberals love to toss about the "Nazi" moniker.

That grated on me as well. The phrase is “good German” not “good Nazi”. Liberals do love the n-word.

 

If stupidity got us into this mess,
then why can't it get us out?
--Will Rogers

I can't help it, but I like

I can't help it, but I like every thing I have seen Ed Asner do, maybe his politics are kept out of his work? 

Anyway, the new movie "UP" is great in my opinion. It is very heartbreaking and very renewing- and a great, great movie in my opinion.  I did not get any sense of a hidden political message like in the Algore inspired Wall-e. 

Actors and Politics

Asner is a perfect example of why I'd rather not ever know an actors politics.  I will go out of my way to never watch anything that Asner appears in.  Sure, I may be missing a very good movie or television show.  But, to exagerate to make my point, suppose David Duke took up an acting career and he was absolutely brilliant as an actor.  I wouldn't go see his work either.

Shut up and act.

"I've sentenced boys younger then you to the gas chamber.  Didn't want to do it, but I felt I owed it to them."  Judge Smails 

Don't throw out the baby

If you miss "Up," you will be missing out on the very kind of movie leftists love to hate and which they've spent the last several decades preventing being made. It's a conservative, Christian movie, even if Asner's the voice of the main character. If you stand on that principle, you will, in this case, actually be hurting your own cause.

Why in the world is it

Why in the world is it "kvetching" to mention, even to argue with passion, that Iraq was a massive waste of money and resources?  if there is anything liberals are right about, it is this.

  Except that by now the

  Except that by now the world would have gotten really lax on Sadaam Hussein who would have immediately restarted his nuclear program to compete with his rival Iran.  The whole Mideast could be a nuclear powder keg right now with two nuclear armed counties friendly to terrorists. 

   The most devastating aspect of the Iraq war is that it gave a political opening for a pretender to become President.

Critical what?

I would hardly call rescuing millions of people from despotism and ternary a waste of money and resources. But, then again, I believe in liberty and justice for all, not just Americans. Do you?

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

and you think liberals drink

and you think liberals drink the cool aid!!!!

So, ending depotism is useless?

So, you believe that ending despotism is useless? Just who's drinking the koolaid here? It sure isn't me.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

BTW

BTW, Liberals do drink that koolaid, and you're one of them.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

Tell me, critically mistaken

Tell me, critically mistaken, is this koolaid?

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

This video and the legal

This video and the legal murder of babies just goes to show you why liberals only act like they care about "social injustice" when it is politically expedient.  The fact that they can even sleep it at night sickens me.

 

When the people fear the government it's called tyranny, when the government fears the people it's called liberty!

So Obama vehemently stated

So Obama vehemently stated during his campaign that he would be willing to take military action against any one or regime that had serious huma rights violations.  Now he was refering to Afghanistan but Sadam Hussein condoned rape, murder, and even geoncide to his own people.  So who's drinking the "Kool Aid?"  You liberals are experts at that.  Try again smartass.

 

When the people fear the government it's called tyranny, when the government fears the people it's called liberty!

that Iraq was a massive

that Iraq was a massive waste of money and resources? 

Quite simply because it hasnot been and will continue to not be a waste of resources.

The US involvement in Iraq will lead to a better outcome than if similar resources and efforts were committed to Afghanistan and elsewhere.

And comparatively did you know we are spending the LEAST on the US military and its operations in both Iraq and Afghanistan than we have hsitorically as part of GDP?

 if there is anything liberals are right about, it is this.

Except liberals are NEVER right.

What do you view as the center of gravity on the Global War on Terror?  In other words, what is the one thing that if the US "Pushes" will topple our enemies?

Excuse the liberals

You'll have to excuse the Liberals. They never met a tyrant they didn't like.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

Tyrants

They never met a tyrant they didn't like.

 

They *love* tyrants!  Liberals want to wield power just like the tyrants do.  For our own good, of course.  ;-)

 

"Gov. Palin has been subjected to one of the most massive and dishonest pile-on smear attacks in the history of liberal media."  -- Lowell Ponte

That's right.

"Liberals want to wield power just like the tyrants do."

That's right. That's why they applaud Obama when he extends federal administrative control over the civilian sector. As much as liberals pretend to hate Imperialism, they are doing their best to make sure America is run like an Empire, will the majority of the power concentrated in a single controlling body, the Federal Government, led by single leader, the President.

The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.
The US Constitution

Unless you're a fetus.
The US Supreme Court

Reply to criticalthinking

Liberals would rather wait until it's too late to avert a large scale war that results in millions of casualties.  So you get events like WWII and over 50 million deaths, and we call it "a good war".

"I've sentenced boys younger then you to the gas chamber.  Didn't want to do it, but I felt I owed it to them."  Judge Smails 

I agree with you, critical

It's perfectly possible to oppose the war without being at the same time a leftist loon. I opposed it from the beginning and still do (Iraq, I'm talking about, not Afghanistan), but once we became entangled in it I never supported the idiotic calls for immediate withdrawal and all that other garbage the anti-American left has been spewing out over the last seven or eight years.

So yeah, if the question is simply whether we should have gone in or not, liberals have a case. But when they accompany that with all the other leftist baggage they typically tack onto it, I think that's what gets most conservatives' panties in a bunch.

Was WWII and the money

Was WWII and the money thrown into it a waste of money?

Assner a real hairball

Apparently Assner has been licking himself again and has a giant hairball lodged in his cartoid artery, preventing logical speech and clear logic.

WWII slaughtered millions of men in combat to eliminate Stalin's fellow Marxist and competitor, Adolph Hitler, which then allowed Stalin to conquer not only Eastern Europe but China as well after his accomplice FDR had made certain Japan would no longer be a threat.

The Soviets entered the war in the Far East three days after Hiroshima was bombed. There weren't needed at all. (And this was six months after the end of the war in Europe.) Stalin had troops amassed near Manchuria so the Marxists could rush in and seize the Japanese military supplies and attack the Nationalist, who had helped the Allies.

Massive propaganda stateside blamed Chaing Kai-shek and praised Mao Tse-tung as the true liberator. What hateful rotgut. Horrible battles in Okinawa, Iwo Jima and the bombs themselves were unnecessary, according to many U.S. military commanders. Not to mention the prolonged suffering in Japanese POW camps.

But Assner is a useful idiot obsessed with another Big Lie about war profiteers that blames the free enterprise. Assner is a small-minded moron and useful idiot.

 

I agree, he''s

a hairball but, I take exception to your statement: "Horrible battles in Okinawa, Iwo Jima and the bombs themselves were unnecessary, according to many U.S. military commanders". Please name a "commander" who said that, at the time.  I believe the terms laid down for the cessation of hostilites against Japan were unconditional surrender.  Until the second A-bomb was dropped on Nagasaki, the Japanese hadn't even considered talking, much less surrender.  The planned, and necessary, invasion would have caused at least a million causualties, according to conservative estimates made at the time.  And without the two atomic bombs, an invasion would have been necessary. 

Brilliant post j17

Amen.

Hey Lou..oops I mean

Hey Lou..oops I mean Ed...

I'm tired of double-talking, hypocritical, leftist looney profit makers like you from la-la-land spewing your BS.

...and to think, he was head of SAG for years...typical Union head eh...he fit the bill perfectly. 

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

The only thing more

The only thing more pathetic than an aging Communist is an aging rock star.

One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 61% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory (yep...approval for Congress now at 39%...do you believe that!?).