Update: Israeli Paper Denies Saying Obama Spread 'Secret' Prayer

Photo of Tim Graham.
  • Bookmark and Share

James Taranto provided an update on his item about Barack Obama releasing the contents of his Wailing Wall prayer to media outlets. The New Republic Plank blog ran an "Obama Vindicated" item reporting that the newspaper Ma'ariv is denying it:

I just got off the phone with a Ma'ariv spokesman who says that the accusation is "completely false," and that he has no idea who these papers were quoting from Ma'ariv. "No official spokesman for Ma'ariv told this to any of the papers." I've got some calls in to these papers to find out where they got the quote. (I'll update here when I hear back.) He told me definitively that "the Obama campaign did not give us a copy of the letter or approve it for printing."

UPDATE 1: I just spoke with an editor at one of the four publications [that] quoted the alleged "Ma'ariv spokesman." This editor broached the possibility that Ma'ariv was trying to deflect criticims [sic] of it by releasing these spurious rumors about the Obama campaign, but upon realizing that they'll have to back up those accusations, is now disavowing them. This editor is going to look into this alleged "Ma'ariv spokesman" they quoted in his publication so we can try to ascertain if this is a Ma'ariv cover-up. I'll update here when I hear back from him and if I get anything interesting from the other publications who also quoted this alleged spokesman.

Clearly, as a liberal Democratic magazine, the New Republic has its own suspicions about how its hero Obama must be getting railroaded. But Taranto added: "Neither Haaretz's English-language version nor the Jerusalem Post, both of which quoted the purported Maariv spokesman, seem to have backed away from or otherwise updated their earlier reporting." He also links to Israel Insider, which notes how the Obama campaign tried to handle the story:

If Maariv is now contradicting itself, the Obama campaign, characteristically has been acting coy, refusing to confirm of deny that the prayer note even comes from the hand of Barack Obama. An AP report notes: "Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs would neither confirm nor deny the note was Obama's [but] The handwriting appeared to match a message Obama inscribed Wednesday in the guest book at Yad Vashem, Israel's official Holocaust memorial, and was written on stationery from the King David Hotel, where Obama stayed while in Israel. Obama signed the Yad Vashem message. The note from the Western Wall was unsigned."

An Obama spokesman Bill Burton flatly denied the contention that Obama's prayer, in the form of a note slipped into the Wailing Wall, was "approved for publication," adding: "That didn't happen," he said in an email cited in Ben Smith's Politico blog. "We have neither confirmed nor denied the prayer to anyone."

The candidate himself should be questioned about this on TV to put an end to the "coy" refusals to confirm or deny. It's not that there's anything offensive in the prayer to deny. It's a perfectly good prayer, a credit to whoever prays it -- as long as it's a prayer and not a campaign ploy.

—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

On to rumor two ->

"Seconds after Obama left the stones, some of his entourage stepped up to the wall (dressed in suits) and I recorded a young man gathering notes in his hands in what appeared to be the search for Obama's freshly placed personal note. He is joined by others who unwrap notes and read them."
— David Cohen, freelance photographer/videographer, Jerusalem

 Pictures posted at Black and Right

 When nothing is as it seems and the history is murky then it becomes to easy to believe the worst.  I keep trying to think that Sen. Obama is a decent man who is out to accomplish good (at least in his own opinion) but it is getting difficult to hold onto optimism when there seems to be spin on everything - even things that don't need spin.

 

 

"but it is getting

"but it is getting difficult to hold onto optimism when there seems to be spin on everything"

It's because Obama is such a fool. Did you see his speech yesterday? He said we could replace all the offshore oil just by properly inflating our tires and getting tuneups.

This guy is a real moron. The only things he has going for him are teleprompter charism and the MSM. Else, there is no substance there, and a real lack of real-world experience and intelligence.

___________________________________ 

If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber

Right, TnT, he says "We

Right, TnT, he says "We can't drill our way out of this" but apparently he believes we can "conserve" our way out of it. It's as simple as proper tire inflation and tuneups.

And since his plan seems to mean dividing up existing supplies among more and more people, why not ration gasoline?

Agnostic is right...everything is spin.

And euphemism, and code words.

Check out this IBD Editorial for a rundown of his pie-in-the-sky promises, cleverly couched in code words..

Obama's theme song

ThisnThat,

I missed it but that is the exact statement that I expect from a politician today.  A politicians thoughts: Facts?  Who needs them when what really matters is what the press is going to tell the ignorant masses.

I can't even believe in entertaining conspiracy theories anymore because I have a hard believing any politician gives a damn about in of the 'little people' to plot against them.  The media covers for the Democrats a lot more than they do for Republicans but there is no lack of coruption and arrogance there either.

For the first time in my life I will probably vote for the lesser of two evils for many offices and part of the reason I have resigned myself to this reality is because unless things change the best we can hope for is to stall until a better informed, educated and involved class of voter comes along.  Where this mystical wave of voters are going to come from I am not sure.

Just

Blow up your tires and go to lunch.

It's Obama right? His word is no good, his character is no good, his judgement is no good, why would you think his story was to be taken as fact?

The black helicopter, tinfoil prayer & photo-op.

He probably put a blank piece of paper in the wall, or dictated a demand to god. Remember this is a candidate who just told the MSM how to do their job, "You need to ask John McCain what he's for, not what he's against!" Huh? Notice that the MSM didn't say, "What the F**K kind of answer is that?" 

In McCain's defense ... at least he doesn't ask answers. 

Obama and his crew

 
understood this note would be read and spread.

Look at it's content.

SOB-ama, is a media created sensation, ie: celebrity

In the note he prays for humility?

This is the same guy who told the prego reporter he never has doubts!

The note is an attempt to make it seem as though he, the celebrity, were praying for the wisdom..

NOT TO BE EXACTLY WHAT HE IS!

"This is the same guy who

"This is the same guy who told the prego reporter he never has doubts!"

The same guy who said "it's always a bad idea to use always or never", lol.

ckc1227

Yea that's the guy. The very same one. lol

How many notes

belonging to high profile visitors have been "stolen" and printed???

I'll wait for a brilliant answer.

My guess? ZERO, ZIP, NADA

But as I say, I'll wait for an answer

Toe tapping and not under the stall