Scott McClellan upbraiding the press for being unchallenging certainly doesn't match the record of combative exchanges we recall. Here are a few eyebrow-raising examples of McClellan being pounded by the network stars from our Notable Quotables newsletter:
1. Won't Bush bury Saddam's sons with respect, according to the rites of the religion they held dear?
"Article 17 of the Geneva Conventions requires countries at war to, quote, ‘ensure that the dead are honorably interred, if possible, according to the rites of the religion to which they belong.’ Does the President, as Commander-in-Chief, believe that the United States is bound by that, when it comes to the bodies of Uday and Qusay Hussein?" – ABC’s Terry Moran questioning new White House Press Secretary Scott McClellan at the July 23, 2003 briefing.
2. What would you have the media do? How dare you answer my question by suggesting what you would have the media do?
ABC White House correspondent Terry Moran: "Scott, you said that the retraction by Newsweek magazine of its [phony Koran-in-the-toilet] story is a good first step. What else does the President want this American magazine to do?"
Press Secretary Scott McClellan: "...We would encourage Newsweek to do all that they can to help repair the damage that has been done, particularly in the region. And I think Newsweek can do that by talking about the way they got this wrong, and pointing out what the policies and practices of the United States military are when it comes to the handling of the Holy Koran. The military put in place policies and procedures to make sure that the Koran...is handled with the utmost care and respect...."
Moran: "With respect, who made you the editor of Newsweek? Do you think it’s appropriate for you, at that podium, speaking with the authority of the President...to tell an American magazine what they should print?" — Exchange at the May 17, 2005 White House news briefing.
3. Who told you that you had the right to use discretion as to which parts of a leak prosecution to comment on?
NBC’s David Gregory: "Scott, I mean, just — I mean, this is ridiculous. The notion that you’re going to stand before us after having commented with that level of detail and tell people watching this that somehow you decided not to talk. You’ve got a public record out there. Do you stand by your remarks from that podium, or not?...Why are you choosing when it’s appropriate and when it’s inappropriate [to comment on the leak investigation]?"
Press Secretary Scott McClellan: "If you’ll let me finish-"
Gregory: "No, you’re not finishing — you’re not saying anything!" — Exchange at a July 11, 2005 White House news briefing.
—Tim Graham is Director of Media Analysis at the Media Research Center
Editor at Large
Comments Policy
You forgot to include all
June 1, 2008 - 13:48 ET by fitzfongYou forgot to include all the press conferences where Scotty's response amounted to the old Jackie Gleason "ha-ma-na, ha-ma-na..."
"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan
For the Record
June 1, 2008 - 14:14 ET by usinkoreaI find the current media blitz that it was cowed into "supporting" the build up to the war and the war effort early on a fascinating example of pseudo-revisionist history.
In this day-n-age, with all the undeniable historical documents in the public domain - like film footage ----- it is utterly amazing intelligent people can avoid recognition of basic facts like ---- President Clinton and his crew certainly believed Iraq had WMD, that PM Blair and the rest of Europe thought he had them....and so on....
That was what gave legs to the Bush administration's push to war --- not GE executives and the White House sending out J. Edgar Hoover's corpse to pressure the media.
And even the media's championing of Scott McClellan's book that apparently does nothing but rehash the "lies" idea that can't stand up to historical scrutiny can't erase what President Clinton and other non-conservative people believed before Bush was in office.
Media truth
June 1, 2008 - 17:44 ET by jaywlGo up to the DMZ. Those people you see are our enemies because Bush won't talk to them. If Obamaman becomes President, that week those same people will be our enemies because they won't talk to Obama. History belongs to the victors. As long as the American people tune in or subscribe to liberal/left media more than not, the MSM will set the agenda and write the history.
Only in the Liberal MSM...
June 1, 2008 - 14:50 ET by Tom1969caOnly in America would a member of the MSM get angry and indignant with the President's press secretary for answering the question he asked!
~~~
I admire FDR for not insisting on getting the approval of France and Germany before going to war.
--Anne Coulter
Ridin' dirty with the demedia
June 1, 2008 - 15:20 ET by acumenDon't sweat the past Scotty. You've Moved On.