ABC's Claire Shipman Uses No Liberal Label for Stewart Rally, Worried About 'Right-Wing' Beck's Protest
Good Morning America's Claire Shipman on Friday used no liberal labels in a friendly piece to promote Jon Stewart's rally in Washington, Saturday. Yet, on August 28, she warned viewers about the "right-wing" Glenn Beck and his protest in the nation's capital.
Shipman credulously asserted of Stewart and fellow comedian Stephen Colbert: "But what are we to make of a couple of comedians who say they have no political agenda drawing huge crowds to Washington a few days before elections?"
The ABC journalist simply parroted Stewart's claims: "[Stewart] insists he's not the answer to Glenn Beck. He's been talking about a different message." Even though Shipman reported that liberals such as singer Sheryl Crow and actor Sam Waterston will be attending, she never used ideological labels.
The only sources cited were White House spokesman Robert Gibbs and media critic Howard Kurtz, who noted how "strongly" Stewart feels about bipartisanship. No mention was made by Shipman of the fact that Arianna Huffington and other liberals will be paying to bus in liberals.
Yet, on August 28, when Beck was leading a protest of hundreds of thousands in Washington, Shipman worried that it was on the same date as Martin Luther King's famous 1963 rally. She informed, "The right-wing radio show host insists the timing was an oversight. But he seized on the King legacy as compatible with his message." The reporter even dug up an old quote of Beck calling Barack Obama a racist.
In contrast to the talking heads featured on Friday, Shipman in August included Al Sharpton to complain, "They're having an anti-government march on a day that King came to appeal to government. You can't have it both ways."
Apparently, Glenn Beck is a "right-winger," but Jon Stewart "has no political agenda"?
A transcript of the October 29 segment, which aired at 8:02am EDT, follows:
GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS: Fresh off his interview with President Obama, Jon Stewart is heading to Washington with his Comedy Central sidekick Stephen Colbert for tomorrow's Rally to Restore Sanity and Fear. So far, the Daily Show's Facebook page shows 200,000 people saying they will come but Stewart and Colbert put a tight lid on what those fans can expect to see until now. Claire Shipman is on the case starting to crack that open. Claire?
ABC GRAPHIC: Comedy or Sanity? Stewart and Colbert Rally in D.C.
SHIPMAN: George, they have been secretive but leaking out Sheryl Crow, Sam Waterston, part of the country band Wilco will be here. But is this a political rally or big piece of performance art? Unclear.
JON STEWART: We are going to do this! The forms have been filled out! The checks have been written!
STEPHEN COLBERT: People, people can definitely book their hotel rooms now!
SHIPMAN: Whatever it is, it's clearly going to be big.
STEWART: For tonight I announce the rally to restore sanity. It is happening, people!
SHIPMAN: But what are we to make of a couple of comedians who say they have no political agenda drawing huge crowds to Washington a few days before elections? One of them able to snag a coveted pre-election interview with the president.
BARACK OBAMA: Jon, I love your show, but-
ROBERT GIBBS: I think Jon Stewart is about as good an interviewer as there is in the public domain right now.
SHIPMAN: He insists he's not the answer to Glenn Beck. He's been talking about a different message.
STEWART: A million moderate march where we take to the streets to send a message to our leaders and our national media that says we are here. We're only here. We're only here, though, until 6:00 because we have a sitter.
HOWARD KURTZ (Media critic, Daily Beast): He is looking for a bigger megaphone. I mean, this message that the country is not really convulsed by partisanship, it's just the extremes we see reflected in the media, is one that he feels so strongly about.
SHIPMAN: But Jon Stewart the comedian will never admit it.
STEWART: What we are doing is we are using the rally format to do the same thing we do with our shows.
SHIPMAN: Now, look, a lot of people coming we talked with, George, think this is much more than satire and looking at that Facebook page it will be a big under 30 crowd.
STEPHANOPOULOS: If those 200,000, if show up.
- Scott Whitlock's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
To MSM liberal is the norm
Submitted by T Walt on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 7:27pm.
This is because to the MSM "liberal" is the norm. No need to label those who they perceive as "the norm".
Hello, anybody here?
Submitted by cajun2 on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 7:37pm.
After having read numerous articles about Stewart's planned rally, I have yet to figure out what is the purpose or the message for this rally.
Anybody out there willing to enlighten me?
I'm not sure, cajun2,
Submitted by 26CX on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 7:43pm.
but I think it's a cluster something-or-other.
Bill Press said it best.
Submitted by SnapTie on Sat, 10/30/2010 - 2:08pm.
Liberal radio host Bill Press calls the event. "A big masturbation festival on the National Mall."
Thanks 26CX*
Submitted by cajun2 on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 7:48pm.
Finally, clarity.
You're welcome, cajun2
Submitted by 26CX on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 7:50pm.
I'm often told I have a gift for pointing out the obvious.... ;)
eee
Submitted by giatn on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 9:03pm.
eee
the right wing believes in freedom of speech
Submitted by giatn on Fri, 10/29/2010 - 9:03pm.
The assumption that the right wastes as much time tracking
the left as they do the right is not valid. The left is obsessed
with Fox, Beck etc. but the obsession is simply not reciprocal.
Besides many on the right are big fans of Stewart also,
especially after his epic interview with the first "Dude".
Swimming in Liberal water
Submitted by needle on Sun, 10/31/2010 - 8:16pm.
"But what are we to make of a couple of comedians who say they have no political agenda drawing huge crowds to Washington a few days before elections? One of them able to snag a coveted pre-election interview with the president." WHAT?!? Jon Stewart has no political agenda? But Obama chooses to have an interview with him in the last week of a desperate election? I think Claire Shipman is pretty desperate.
Answer to the first question above: Arianna Huffington’s and Oprah’s bus service is pretty important.
“Even though Shipman reported that liberals such as singer Sheryl Crow and actor Sam Waterston will be attending, she never used ideological labels.” If one swims in Liberal water, as is the case with Claire Shipman and the liberal media in general, it’s just water; there is only one distinction that matters to them, and that is conservative air.
- Looking forward to the self-annihilation of the Manipulated Stories Machine.
Gosh
Submitted by StarAZ on Sat, 10/30/2010 - 12:22pm.
A bunch of moderates milling. Sorry I have to miss this.
NFL Jerseys *Bears
Submitted by Fans Jerseys on Tue, 12/28/2010 - 11:03pm.
NFL Jerseys *Bears Jerseys*
Brian Urlacher Jersey Dick Butkus Jersey Mike Ditka Jersey Walter Payton Jersey*steeler sonline Jerseys*
Ben Roethlisberger Jersey Hines Ward Jersey James Harrison Jersey Troy Polamalu Jersey Willie Parker JerseyNHL Jerseys *Penguins Jerseys*
Andre Fleury Jersey Sidney Crosby Jersey Evgeni Malkin Jersey Mario Lemieux Jersey*Fans Jerseys*
Antti Niemi Jersey Brent Seabrook Jersey Patrick Kane Jersey Bobby Hull Jersey Jonathan Toews Jersey