NBC: Everybody Should be Mad About Miers Nomination

Photo of Noel Sheppard.
  • Bookmark and Share

On this evening’s “NBC Nightly News,” Andrea Mitchell seemed to be advancing a position that would make both Republicans and Democrats angry about the president’s nomination of Harriet Miers to replace Supreme Court justice Sandra Day O’Connor.

Mitchell starts her segment with a statement from Texas Supreme Court justice Nathan Hecht that is clearly designed to raise the ire of pro-choice Americans: “She is pro-life. Harriet and I have attended pro-life dinners in Dallas years ago. She attends evangelical church in Dallas when she's there and has for 25 years that takes a very strong pro-life position.”

Then, Mitchell has a clip from Rush Limbaugh’s radio program today that should inflame conservatives: “The idea that we now have to roll the dice and wait a number of years to find out if this one works out, when it isn't necessary, is I guess the big bugaboo with me.”

What follows is a full-transcript of this report, along with a video link.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Mitchell: The president says he doesn't know what Harriet Miers thinks about abortion.

Bush: I never ask their personal opinion on the subject of abortion.

Mitchell: But Texas Supreme Court justice Nathan Hecht, a longtime friend who says he talked to Miers this morning, says she is definitely against abortion.

Hecht: She is pro-life. Harriet and I have attended pro-life dinners in Dallas years ago. She attends evangelical church in Dallas when she's there and has for 25 years that takes a very strong pro-life position.

Mitchell: Still, to many conservatives, Miers is a blank slate. The chief complaint again today on talk radio --

Limbaugh: The idea that we now have to roll the dice and wait a number of years to find out if this one works out, when it isn't necessary, is I guess the big bugaboo with me.

Mitchell: Conservatives also worry about her answers on this 1989 questionnaire from gay activists when Miers supported civil rights for gays. However she also opposed repealing Texas's anti-sodomy law which the Supreme Court later overturned. Still, conservatives ask why pick Miers over proven conservative judges? In fact, many Conservatives say that the president is missing a golden opportunity to change the direction of the high court, exactly what he promised when he was re-elected.

Bush: I earned capital in the campaign, political capital, and now I intend to spend it.

Mitchell: The Miers nomination critics on the right say leaves them depressed and disappointed.

Conservative Activist: We spent our entire political life waiting for this moment, and the president ran from the fight.

Mitchell: But their opposition may not matter for Miers’ confirmation. So far, no republican senator has joined the chorus of critics.

Video Link

—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.