CBS Trumpets 'Groundbreaking' Report Linking 'Extreme' Weather to Climate Change
Wednesday's CBS This Morning hyped a "groundbreaking" new report from federal government scientists that claims "the first-ever statistical connection between extreme weather and man-made climate change." Correspondent Wyatt Andrews spotlighted how the study "found that man-made heat made the Texas drought roughly 20 times more likely."
Andrews also hinted a connection between climate change and a recent heat wave, even as he explained that "the biggest reason for the record heat is the transition...from the La Nina weather pattern...to this year's warmer pattern, El Nino."
Anchor Erica Hill introduced the correspondent's report by noting how "the first six months of 2012 were the hottest ever recorded. Well, this morning, much of the country is now facing a severe drought." Fill-in anchor Lee Cowan added that "it's leaving crops withered and farmers worried. Now, in a groundbreaking report, though, government scientists say that climate change explains at least some of the weather changes."
Andrews led the segment by highlighting the plight of Jeff Fisher, a farmer in Illinois whose crops are threatened due the recent heat. After outlining the La Nina/El Nino connection to the high temperatures, the CBS journalist turned to the results of the recent study from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration:
ANDREWS: Scientists at NOAA have also announced the first scientific connection between extreme weather events, like last year's drought in Texas, and man-made climate change. A new study found that man-made heat made the Texas drought roughly 20 times more likely.
Moments later, the correspondent added that "every day in this record-setting heat takes more of Jeff Fisher's crop and his livelihood away."
Even as he tried to tie the Midwest drought to the climate change apparently pointed to in the government study, Andrews strangely concluded his report by stating that "NOAA scientists, meanwhile, are not saying that climate change causes any one specific drought, like the one in Illinois. They are saying the science is good enough now, they can lay odds on the connection."
The CBS correspondent also hyped the NOAA study during a report on Tuesday's CBS Evening News. Both times, Andrews omitted mentioning another recent study published in Nature that indicated a cooling trend during the past centuries.
The full transcript of the report from Wyatt Andrews on Wednesday's CBS This Morning, which aired 13 minutes into the 7 am Eastern hour:
ERICA HILL: We told you yesterday how the first six months of 2012 were the hottest ever recorded. Well, this morning, much of the country is now facing a severe drought.
LEE COWAN: It's leaving crops withered and farmers worried. Now, in a groundbreaking report, though, government scientists say that climate change explains at least some of the weather changes.
Wyatt Andrews has the story now from Washington. Good morning, Wyatt.
[CBS News Graphic: "Going To Extremes: Report: Global Warming Factor In Severe Weather"]
WYATT ANDREWS: Lee, good morning. Good morning, Erica. The official report on this is due out any day now. But already, 2012 is shaping up as a record year for heat. Government scientists have also made the first-ever statistical connection between extreme weather and man-made climate change.
ANDREWS: Jeff Fisher was expecting his corn crop to yield more than 150,000 bushels of corn this year. But he was also expecting more rain and a lot loss heat. Central Illinois, instead, is in a serious drought, and the state set more than 200 records for high temperatures just in June and July.
JEFF FISHER, FARMER: We've had temperatures in the 90s for as many days as I can remember.
ANDREWS: The biggest reason for the record heat is the transition in the Pacific from the La Nina weather pattern, which is typically cooler, to this year's warmer pattern, El Nino.
Tom Karl is the chief of the climate office at NOAA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
TOM KARL, NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION: Now, this year, we have a growing El Nino, the warm phase, and we're already seeing all-time temperature records being broken for global temperatures. That's because the Pacific waters now are warming.
ANDREWS: Scientists at NOAA have also announced the first scientific connection between extreme weather events, like last year's drought in Texas, and man-made climate change. A new study found that man-made heat made the Texas drought roughly 20 times more likely.
KARL: There definitely is a connection between greenhouse gases and extreme weather. We're seeing very strong evidence to suggest that not all, but many of the extremes that we're seeing around the planet are being enhanced by greenhouse gases.
ANDREWS: And every day in this record-setting heat takes more of Jeff Fisher's crop and his livelihood away.
FISHER: It's stressful. It's stressful on myself and my family - my father and I. This is a family farm, and we've watched it go down and down and down.
ANDREWS: NOAA scientists, meanwhile, are not saying that climate change causes any one specific drought, like the one in Illinois. They are saying the science is good enough now, they can lay odds on the connection. Lee and Erica?
HILL: Wyatt Andrews, thank you.
- Matthew Balan's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
First ever statisticial link?
Submitted by Blonde on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 6:33pm.
WAIT......I thought there was consensus already.
Sheesh. Bloody twits.
Handy Reference Guide to Obama's Gaffes and Goofs ~ Currently Numbering 200 (and Counting)
Its true! Its gotten MUCH hotter the last 2 months!
Submitted by NJRightWinger12 on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 7:26pm.
And I think it will stay hot for about another 2 months, then slowly get cooler, and then a few months later, get even COLDER! Wow, its like we have global warming AND cooling in the same year, and it does this EVERY year! OMG, what will become of us and the earth? Good think Im renting!
ever since January the sun
Submitted by Dan The Man 2 on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 9:16pm.
ever since January the sun has bee rising earlier and setting later. I have been taking notes and using the data I have I extrapolate the sun will in a matter of a year always be in the sky 24/7. I guess this is what the Global Warming is all about.
"Groundbreaking" report?
Submitted by CO2Maker on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 7:37pm.
What other kind of report about climate change could there be? "Earth-shattering"? That's pretty much the same thing. "It'll blow the deniers away." Now we're on to meteorology.
Maybe we need a new group: Accuracy in Metaphors. When you need to use the exact word to sway the audience. Or, when bad synonyms happen to good alarmists.
Weren't those cold/snowy spells "weather"?
Submitted by deadeyedan on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 7:43pm.
The report in Nature, which has been on the alarmists' side from the get-go, cited in the article has to be a shocker to those suckered into this sleazy AGM scam.
As usual, there is no sign that double blind experimentation is used here.
CLIMATEGATE - the revelation that the pseudo-scientists at East Anglia University know just as much about the atmosphere as Harvard law professors know about the Constitution
Well, I'm confused.
Submitted by UpNorth on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 8:18pm.
OK, "settled science" means something is " more likely."? They can't prove anything but "they can lay odds on the connection"?
OK, I'm convinced that they don't know their rear ends from their elbows.
In Michigan in 1896, the average yearly temp was 46.3 degrees F, in 2011 the average yearly temp was 44.9 degrees F. Someone explain how that's globull warming?
That's from my Disqus side, I'm getting confused on where to post now.
How can man-made heat in Texas cause drought, if . . .
Submitted by Gary Hall on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 8:39pm.
How can man-made heat in Texas cause drought, if . . .according to NOAA the official 116 year long temperature record in Texas, statewide, shows absolutely no warming trend, and the precipitation record shows a very slight increase in precipitation.
Color me droughtless and warmless,
(;~/ gary
And how did US temps in June, 2012 rate?
Submitted by Gary Hall on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 8:53pm.
How about the 14th warmest June on record.
Go fry that egg on your sidewalk - every 7.5 years.
(;~/ gary
round breaking reports......
Submitted by GregE on Wed, 07/11/2012 - 9:04pm.
...........on extreme weather, are called weather forecasts.
Get On With Life!
Submitted by rammingspeed on Thu, 07/12/2012 - 12:40am.
Aw, here comes some real science to kick your dumb punk asses
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2171973/Tree-ring-study-p...
Warming?
Submitted by Jersey Girl on Thu, 07/12/2012 - 6:09am.
Never mind the weather reports coming from Europe.
Never mind the record rainfalls in Florida.
Never mind the cool weather in California.
It's only the hottest year on
Submitted by Kenny Bunkport on Thu, 07/12/2012 - 9:12am.
It's only the hottest year on record if you use Hansen's dumbed-down temperature revisionism for the dust bowl days. Which of course the MSM does.