CBS Touts 'Village' Run By 'Hungry For Change' Wall Street Protesters
CBS's Bigad Shaban filed a puff piece about the "Occupy Wall Street" demonstrators on Tuesday's Early Show, trumpeting their "self-operating mini-community in lower Manhattan" and how they were "hungry for change," all the while ignoring the radical left wing politics of many in attendance. Shaban took more time to note that "this isn't your average protest. Yoga classes are taught in the off-time."
Co-anchors Chris Wragge and Erica Hill played up the "mini-village, complete with a daily newspaper, recycling, a free breakfast buffet, [and] yoga" during their promo for the correspondent's report. Shaban picked up where his colleagues left off with his "not your average protest" line, and added that "a makeshift library has been set up with at least 1500 books...and the grounds even has (sic) its own medical tent and newspaper, 'The Occupied Wall Street Journal.'" [video clips available below the jump]
The CBS journalist then spotlighted two of the protesters, one who coordinated the food distribution, and another who handled trash. Shaban noted how both were unemployed and were "hungry for change." But hiding in plain sight in his footage from the "village" were signs of the far left agenda of those in attendance. As he mentioned the medical tent, a red flag with Cuban communist Che Guevara's image on it flew in the background (visible at the 0:18 mark in the video above). Later, an anonymous demonstrator wrote the slogan, "destroy corporate capitalism" on a poster.
On Monday's Early Show, the correspondent did something similar when he omitted the far-left politics of Daily Kos writer Jesse LaGreca, one of the demonstrators featured during his report that day on "Occupy Wall Street."
Shaban didn't play sound bites from critics of the movement at any point during the segment. He only pointed out at twice that "organizers admit their movement is without long-term direction" and that "some are now criticizing the moment as unorganized."
The full transcript of Bigad Shaban's report from Tuesday's Early Show, which aired 38 minutes into the 7 am Eastern hour:
CHRIS WRAGGE: The 'Occupy Wall Street' protests that started here in New York last month have now spread to more than 60 other cities, including Boston, where police arrested dozens of demonstrators early this morning on trespassing charges.
HILL: Protesters say they are in this for the long haul.
CBS's Bigad Shaban is in New York City's financial district this morning with a closer look for us at the village that has, essentially, popped up there, set up by the demonstrators. Bigad, good morning.
BIGAD SHABAN: Well, guys, good morning. The protesters acknowledge they're still without a long-term vision or plan, saying their focus right now is recruitment. So some are now criticizing the moment as unorganized. But, when it comes to the actual operation of the base here, it seems to have a structure all its own.
[CBS News Graphic: "Protesters In Profile: Inside Look At Men And Women Of Movement"]
UNIDENTIFIED MALE 1: They're going to do more full, deep breaths-
SHABAN (voice-over): This isn't your average protest. Yoga classes are taught in the off-time. A makeshift library has been set up with at least 1500 books.
UNIDENTIFIED MALE 2: Your medic station is on the other side of here-
SHABAN: And the grounds even has (sic) its own medical tent and newspaper, 'The Occupied Wall Street Journal.' What began as protest has morphed into a self-operating mini-community in lower Manhattan, with a complimentary breakfast buffet of fresh fruits and bagels.
AMY HAMBURGER, PROTESTER: Well, we didn't use that too because we have all this food that people that are giving us-
SHABAN: Twenty-nine-year-old Amy Hamburger manages the meals. She's an out-of-work teacher's aide who's been here from the start- 25 days and counting- with food donations from around the world.
HAMBURGER: Pizzas from Mexico, pizzas from Alaska, gifts from Scotland- (laughs) all kinds of stuff.
SHABAN (voice-over): (protesters singing, "I'm going to let it shine") The 1960s feel of music and dance brought her in. But it's the deep frustration over the economy, she says, that's kept her here.
HAMBURGER: It's time to get together and re-evaluate, and not necessarily do away with the system, but just figure out where we went wrong and how we're going to do it right now.
SHABAN: In the process, many protesters have been split into groups to help run this site- everything from the live Web feed, to recycling and trash pick-up.
James Jordan is 26, and nearly one year into his search for a full-time job. He works overnight shifts at a hotel, and now spends his days here.
JAMES JORDAN, PROTESTER: It's not easy. It's not easy. I mean, I've got a college degree. I'm thousands of dollars in debt- tens of thousands of dollars in debt.
SHABAN: (protesters chanting, "Let them go!") He and others hungry for change. (protesters chanting, "Shame!") Amy Hamburger says she'll be there, to make sure they get the food they need to see it through.
HAMBURGER: Right now, this is my life, and it's going to be my life until it's not anymore. (laughs)
SHABAN: Still, organizers admit their movement is without long-term direction, making the day-to-day operation of its headquarters, perhaps, more organized than the protest itself.
SHABAN (on-camera): Meanwhile, the marches continue, including one set here for this afternoon dubbed the 'millionaire's march.' Chris and Erica, they plan to visit some of the city's wealthiest residents.
HILLL Yeah, they're actually planning to march to some of their homes. It will be interesting to see where that takes them. Bigad Shaban, interesting piece- thanks.
- Matthew Balan's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
Ohhhh, It Sounds Like Heaven....
Submitted by bigdaddy on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:42pm.
....can we all go live there??? Maybe the unicorns will return and we can have unicorn rodeos....
60's demonstrators helped Nixon get elected
Submitted by MidAmerica on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:50pm.
I guess these protesters are determined to make sure obama is not reelected.
Agreed. I can't for the life
Submitted by Van Halen on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:55pm.
Agreed. I can't for the life of me see how this is going to play into Obama suddenly turning his plummeting poll numbers around. They can protest all they want but the fact is that too many people are broke, unemployed, or on the battlefield and there is absolutely no fix for this coming out of the White House - not even remotely.
It's the economy, stupid!
They will riot sooner or
Submitted by LAM SON 719 on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 11:17pm.
They will riot sooner or later, obama will turn the police on them and stop the riot. He will be seen as a hero restoring order.Mainstream democrats, independents and the the republicans will flock to him for being strong. He may even suspend the primaries and throw in a little martial law. Do not trust him.
And who's footing the bill
Submitted by motherbelt on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:54pm.
And who's footing the bill for all this "free" stuff? Does it just appear every morning, like the manna in the desert?
They'd best not complain about the homeless, because they're showing just how nice living on the street can be.
They can all move to Cuba or Venezuela and live like this forever, as far as I'm concerned.
Jimmie Kimmel
Submitted by MidAmerica on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:03pm.
Be sure to catch the end of this clip because it's funny (and true)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nd4yfEVaUtg
Too funny!
Submitted by Dave81 on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 9:12pm.
"What do we want??"
"We're not really sure!!"
"When do we want it??"
"NOW!!"
ROFL! Thanks for sharing
OK, let's just say
Submitted by oldmanatee on Wed, 10/12/2011 - 12:52pm.
that I was a supporter of this "grass roots gathering" and wasnt't able to be there...(fights back tears of sorrow), and decided I'd mail these brothers in arms( and sisters in hairy armpits) some food for the buffet... how would one go about getting the street addy to send a care package???
Smelly Hippies
c/o Barry O
1600 Uninhabitable Park
Nastyass NY
All I need is the zip code, right?
Zip Code: 00000
Submitted by stratman on Wed, 10/12/2011 - 2:32pm.
Zip Code: 00000
so good
Submitted by rowdygirl on Thu, 10/13/2011 - 10:48am.
my laugh for the day .. thanks !
Tam
How many days into this are
Submitted by Van Halen on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:53pm.
How many days into this are we and we still have no definition of what it is they are protesting? But we HAVE seen pot smoking, crapping on a cop car, peeing on the ground, drug selling, fighting with the cops, calling for extermination of all the Jews, denunciations of everything American, lying, cheating, stealing, sex in the park, and the destruction of virtually everything that has been touched by this bunch. On top of that, virtually every one of these 'protesters' looks like a throwback to a circus freakshow. This is getting old fast. The cold weather is coming.
This is just Woodstock
Submitted by motherbelt on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:54pm.
without the bands.
great minds
Submitted by rowdygirl on Thu, 10/13/2011 - 10:47am.
I was thinking live action version of "Hair" without the music...
:)
Tam
First time hearing of NYC?
Submitted by Mister Orange on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:00pm.
You've just listed day-to-day activity in NYC proper.
Well then they've managed to Wal-Mart the effect
Submitted by kata on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:03pm.
.
Mister Orange
Submitted by hydrodynDM on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 9:32pm.
So why did CBS feel it necessary to avoid showing any of the things Van Halen mentioned if, as you say, it's just typical day-to-day activity in NYC?
Oh wait - were you being sarcastic?
Is this the same protest:
Submitted by Radical1979 on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:55pm.
*that someone used a police car as a bathroom?
*where fights broke out over the food?
*where the trash is piling up in mounds?
*where the smell is becoming overwhelming?
*where the drugs are flowing?
Great place. By the way, to the guy with all the school loan debt, no one forced you to go to college. You can do two years at a community college and then two of state schools, or you can work and go to school part time and pay as you go. It's not my fault you CHOSE to get into debt.
Bio-Hazard Colony Emits Weapons Grade Odor
Submitted by kata on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 7:56pm.
Bio-Hazard Colony Emits Weapons Grade Odor
the stuff you're not going to see on the MSM. And of course the DailyMail is having far too much fun with this. (it goes without saying that a lot of these pics are NSFW.)
The democratically appointed facilitators have very tenuous control. The only people with any semblance of sanity are the ones that run the livestream (aka "the media crew") but they don't have to deal with the day to day occupations of their occupation. Managing a chat room is one thing - but It's not nearly so easy to clear the park and perma ban people whom have decided they like the free food and clothes.
I AM ONE OF THE 53 percent and pi@@ed off
Submitted by Tomorama on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:04pm.
In Boston, the slob of a Mayor makes every pretzel vendor jump through hoops to get every money grubbing permit on the books, BUT the same slob is not charging these "youts" a dime for ANY permits and they are serving food in a group setting.
NO PERMITS NEEDED at all and someone questioned why he and his family a few weeks ago couldn't camp out there and he actually said "You don't have a cause"........
Free electric, no permits, police protection all on my dime.
I HATE LIBERALS.
By the way, the TEA PARTY WAS REQUIRED TO GET PERMITS for their protests.
You can add Blooming idiot to that
Submitted by Boudin on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 9:02pm.
He gave the morons a free pass for the next 4 months
Hungry for $ change $
Submitted by djwolf12 on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:12pm.
this shoud be Obama's presidential bumper sticker in 2012
It sounds vaguely familiar . . .
Submitted by Galvanic on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:31pm.
Co-anchors Chris Wragge and Erica Hill played up the "mini-village, complete with a daily newspaper, recycling, a free breakfast buffet, [and] yoga"
. . . Now I remember. It was in a brochure about a summer camp for rich kids.
whoa!
Submitted by kata on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:46pm.
You certainly nailed that one.
How 'bout those 'alternate activities'
Submitted by Galvanic on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 10:19pm.
Thai massage? Tarot? Henna tatooing? Ai-YEEE!
If the MSM's support for these communist-inspired "protests"
Submitted by Dave. on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:34pm.
...hasn't yet convinced the American people that the media is infested with freedom and America-hating commie scum, what is it going to take?
-Dave
Vote for the American in November
I wonder if they'll apply for Statehood?
Submitted by CobraMan on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 8:59pm.
So, now these protesters have their own "mini-community," also known as a commune? Does that mean that they'll be applying for Statehood soon?
The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States. The US Constitution
Unless you're a fetus. The US Supreme Court
Or Anwar al-Awlaki.
...complete with a daily
Submitted by PeskyDane on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 9:43pm.
...complete with a daily newspaper, recycling, a free breakfast buffet, [and] yoga"...
Note the complete absence of a shower point. But then is anyone surprised by this apparent aversion to soap and water?
Whenever these rabble rousers
Submitted by celator on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 10:02pm.
Whenever these rabble rousers are shown on TV, I am reminded of "The Lord Of The Flies" novel or even "Fahrenheit 451". There will be no good outcome for these folks, because, eventually, finally, they will have to get actual jobs. Statehood is not in the cards for them. ;+}
Not once
Submitted by dmaley1714 on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 10:20pm.
has the media described the actual numbers of the protest, I have been down there it is very small less than 2500 people. It is amazing the amount of free publicity they are getting
I christen this new town ...
Submitted by Fredy on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 10:27pm.
OBAMAVILLE!
The real challenge for Occupy Wall Street
Submitted by Galvanic on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 10:27pm.
At least two factors bode badly for them.
1. They don't know quite what they want, so they don't know when to go home. As things get colder and wetter in the norther n cities, maintaining numbers will be difficult.
2. Free food, cheap drugs, and sex in the park draws in all kinds of riff raff who are less interested in causes than they are in hand-outs. When they no longer get free stuff, there's no telling what they'll do.
I suspect that the MSM's fascination and blatant admiration for these demonstrations will fade as they did with the Cindy Sheehan and Code Pink stuff. If nothing happens from day to day, the media's attention will be drawn to celebrity divorces, natural disasters, and the 2012 campaign.
Assured Mutual Destruction
Submitted by stratman on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 11:17pm.
If cold weather does not break up this mob, eventually the people working to keep a modicum of essentials available - food, water, trash removal - will surely create a rift between them and their ultra-lazy parasite fellow protesters. It will be a mirror image of the class warfare they all are enjoying at the moment. The close quarters of this psychedelic kibbutz will speed the unraveling as well.
Relying on strangers instead of mommy and daddy to feed and toilet you only lasts so long. The strangers have no long-term compulsion to take care of the users/abusers since they have neither legal obligation nor social imprinting based on birth relation.
Fortunately for many of the
Submitted by jhva on Tue, 10/11/2011 - 11:24pm.
Fortunately for many of the protesters they have a home they can return to when this thing is over. I haven't read or seen anything on TV/Online about the homeless folks and the people that could really use a donated meal. Unions must not give a crap about the invisible folks that they can't recruit. Pizzas flying in from all over the World. Famine in Africa. The protesters should turn their focus to solving a real problem rather than taking and being all greedy-like.
FDNY can solve this problem right quick.
Submitted by johnsonl on Wed, 10/12/2011 - 6:58am.
A couple of 2 inch lines right about sunset should do it. Gettin' cold in Manhattan in the evenings...