CNN’s Bash to McCain: Are You ‘Heartless’ When It Comes to the Economy?

Photo of Matthew Balan.
  • Bookmark and Share

CNN correspondent Dana Bash, during an interview of Senator John McCain which aired on Tuesday’s "The Situation Room," raised the issue of whether the Republican presidential candidate felt voters’ pain on the economy. "[I]n this time of uncertainty, when there are so many people hurting, are you concerned that there are voters out there who hear that who say, John McCain is heartless when it comes to this issue?" The thought that McCain might be "heartless" was reenforced by inclusion of the chyron, "McCain & Voters’ Pain: Against Big Economic Bailouts." [Audio available here.]

Following her "heartless" question on the economy, Bash followed up by asking a particularly blunt question about whether the current economy would hurt him if it continued into the time immediately before the election. "If the headlines that are on the front page of the newspapers today are the same headlines on the front pages in late October, early November, does John McCain lose?"

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Bash, who is following the Arizona senator during his bus tour to key sites from his past, also pressed McCain on the issue of his age, asking him three questions on the issue. "[I]n terms of your approach, do you, in all candor -- straight talk -- think about your age when you -- and the fact that you are 71 -- will be 72 when you are deciding who would be a potential president?"

Bash’s questions on McCain’s age were based on a recent Wall Street Journal poll that found that voters are more likely to vote for a woman or a black person than a person over 70, and on a self-deprecating remark he made that the role of a Vice President to check on the health of a President "would be especially important" in his case. Bash tried to take the remark more seriously. "[Y]ou say that there are two real roles for the Vice President, and one is to check on the health of the president. And you joked a couple of weeks ago in Pennsylvania that that would be especially important in your case.... What did you mean by that?"

Even though McCain responded that he "will continue to use humor, and if any commentator chooses to take a humorous remark and turn it into something serious, they are free to do that," Bash still pressed him on the age issue. "But it -- but, understanding that completely, in all seriousness, when you're approaching who you're picking for the Vice President, do you think about your age as a factor?"

The full transcript of the interview, which aired 15 minutes into the 5 pm Eastern hour of Tuesday’s "The Situation Room:"

JOHN KING: Now, does John McCain feel voters' pains when it comes to the economy? The Republican candidate on what his campaign calls its biography tour. He visited his old high school in northern Virginia today. CNN's Dana Bash accompanied the senator and sat down with him for a one-on-one interview.

NewsBusters.org - Media Research CenterDANA BASH, CNN CONGRESSIONAL CORRESPONDENT: Senator, thank you for sitting down with us.

MCCAIN: Thanks, Dana.

BASH: The first question is about the issue that Americans do seem to care about the most -- and that's the economy. You've been very clear that because of your principle and because of your Republican philosophy, that you think that the government really should be limited and really should stay out, for the most part, of bailing out both homeowners and what you call irresponsible lenders. But my question is, in this time of uncertainty, when there are so many people hurting, are you concerned that there are voters out there who hear that who say, John McCain is heartless when it comes to this issue?

MCCAIN: Well, actually, I think the government should facilitate a lot of things, and there have been numerous proposals, many of which I have supported and some that I will be coming forward with. What we really need to do is -- fundamentally -- is make sure that we take every action to have the lender and the borrower sit down together so that the millions of Americans who are facing terrible challenges will be able to afford to keep their home.

We don't want greedy speculators, obviously, to profit. We don't want unscrupulous lenders to gain from this and spend taxpayers' dollars on it. But we should devote all our efforts -- and I will be, as I say, encouraging and trying to provide ways for incentivizing that process to happen and, if necessary, give the homeowners who are sitting around the kitchen table today saying, well, I have to get another job, will we stay in our home -- be able to do that. That does mean government helps out. What I worry about, of course, are massive bailouts that will then reward people who didn't behave well. But my efforts and my proposals will to be help that homeowner who is now experiencing a great trauma of losing the American dream.

BASH: If the headlines that are on the front page of the newspapers today are the same headlines on the front pages in late October, early November, does John McCain lose?

MCCAIN: I have no idea. I think that John McCain's experience, knowledge, background, and judgment on both national security and economic issues -- I've been involved in economic issues for the last 20 some years. I was chairman of the Commerce Committee that oversights all sectors, practically, of our economy. So I'm strong on the economy. I'm strong on national security. And the important thing will be my envision -- my vision for the future of this country.

BASH: You're on this bio tour, this service tour that you're on. You're talking, obviously, a lot about your past and your experience. But by talking about the fact that you remember vividly -- at least your first vivid memory was the beginning of World War II, you're also maybe subtly reminding voters of your age. And I want to just read you some numbers from a recent 'Wall Street Journal' poll. Sixty-one percent said that they would elect somebody over 70, but 71 percent said they would elect a woman and 72 percent said a black. So it looks like voters are much more eager -- or at least able to elect a black or a woman than somebody of your age.

MCCAIN: Well, that's interesting, because we are either tied or slightly ahead of both Senator Obama and Senator Clinton. So overall in the polls, I'm very satisfied, where we are, particularly since the generic ballot has Republicans trailing Democrats rather badly. So I'm very happy with where we are. And I'm very happy...

BASH: Specifically on the age issue...

MCCAIN: ...to talk about the past and my values. But all of that is a prelude to the future. If you have experience and knowledge and background and judgment, that's what -- and vision for the future -- that's what the American people will, I believe, the factor that will decide whether they support me or not, and I'm very confident.

BASH: One more question on this. You, when you're asked about who your vice president would be, you say that there are two real roles for the Vice President, and one is to check on the health of the president. And you joked a couple of weeks ago in Pennsylvania that that would be especially important in your case.

MCCAIN: Sure.

BASH: What did you mean by that? And I know you don't want to talk about the process of picking a Vice President, but in terms of your approach, do you, in all candor -- straight talk -- think about your age when you -- and the fact that you are 71 -- will be 72 when you are deciding who would be a potential president?

MCCAIN: No. And in all candor, I will continue to use humor, and if any commentator chooses to take a humorous remark and turn it into something serious, they are free to do that. But I will continue to use humor, and I think the American people like to have a little humor from time to time.

BASH: Absolutely.

MCCAIN: And that was what that whole line was about.

BASH: Absolutely. But it -- but, understanding that completely, in all seriousness, when you're approaching who you're picking for the Vice President, do you think about your age as a factor? And --

MCCAIN: Not particularly, no. I think -- I think about whether that person who I select would be most prepared to take my place, and that would be the key criteria.

KING: Senator John McCain earlier today.

—Matthew Balan is a news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

And they talk about hitting Obama below the belt

Haven't these people heard of age discrimination? And the laws against it? My grandmother lived to 99, and up until the day she died she was one of the smartest and sharpest people I will ever know. Unless there is some evidence of declining health or mental faculties, who cares about Sen. McCain's age? Let's look at his record and his plans for the future, not try to instill some fear that he'll keel over dead of a heart attack the day after he's sworn in.

McCain's mom is 97 I think

Another Sin of Omission by the MSM. . . McCain being age is news, but don't mention any contradictory evidence.

Other cultures value the wisdom of their elders....

In this country, a high proportion of the populace gets their wisdom from Comedy Central and MTV.   Thus, we get empty suits like Barack "We Are The Ones We've Been Waiting For" Obama.

And thus Believes the MSM - - Headlines Rule

Management by Headlines, a shallow view of the Voting populace.  The Question should have been - - "If the MSM keeps talking up the "Recession" angle, how many Americans will think the Economy is really worse than it is ?"

Dow jumps 400 points, and it gets low profiled on the News - - I saw one alphabet news channel put up the DOW numbers, did NOT quote them, went to a station break hoping you wouldn't notice the Graphic.

Americans are getting pissed about being managed by "Omission", and Congress doesn't realize people are Screaming at their TV's when someone pops out of a Congressional hearing to push Wind power . . .literally....

The more interviews McCain

The more interviews McCain conducts the deeper hole he digs himself into.  Seriously, I think it's his age.  He's not thinking rationally and he's not able to think strategicall.

Take Letterman last night for instance.  A regular BS talking point from the Bush Admin and the Newsbusters is that the estimates of Iraqi deaths in the hundreds of thousands are way off base and nothing more than liberal lies. 

Apparently, McCain doesn't feel the same way as many of his constituents.   From the show:

Letterman: 4,000 American men and women soldiers dead since we went into Iraq. Another 30,000 wounded. Untold Iraqis dead. We rarely hear that number. What would that number be? A quarter of a million? Half a million?

McCain: It’s hard to make these estimates, but it’s in the hundreds of thousands, obviously.

Obviously?  Not around here it isn't. 

Of course any rational human being knows that the number is certainly in the hundreds of thousands if not more, but I'm surprised his handlers are letting him say this kind of stuff considering the fact that the people voting for him pretend this isn't the case.

Interesting strategy.

Is Heartless Better than Clueless?

First MSM says McCain is clueless about economic matters. Now they're accusing him of being heartless. My sense is this is a step in the right direction. At least MSM now hints he knows enough to be cruel.

By the way, what is the personal relationship between Dana Bash and John King? Is it like Regis & Kelly, Sonny & Cher or Ren & Stimpie?

Do they ever disclose their relationship when reporting?

Don't forget Obama is

Don't forget Obama is wonderful because he will raise taxes to 'help' the economy.

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

Bash and King getting married

Dana Bash and John King are getting married this summer.

Whew! *THAT* King...

For a moment, I was worried Larry had done it again! ;)
JMR

A corruption-story the TV media will-not cover.

John McCain and Hillary

John McCain and Hillary Clinton , campaigning in the same town, were walking down the street when they came to a homeless person.

The Republican, John McCain, gave the homeless person his business card and told him to come to his office for a job. He then took $20 out of his pocket and gave it to the homeless person.

Hillary was very impressed, so when they came to another homeless person, she decided to help. She walked over to the homeless person and gave him directions to the welfare office. She then reached into McCain's pocket and got out $20. She kept $15 for her administrative fees and gave the homeless person $5. (from an e-mail I got)

Toooo funny Mattm

Tooo funny Mattm.

Barack (redacted) Obama was not to be outdone.  When he came across a homeless person Obama told the homeless person he would never find a job because the MAN kept holding him down.  Obama then asked his grandmother to give the homeless person $20 so Obama could get material for his next book.

Obama

When Obama throws his white mother, grandmother, grandfather (the same gmom & gdad who actually cared enough about him to RAISE HIM) under the perverbial bus he also does that to his daughters who by definition are 1/4 white. What a piece of $%^&!

Gettin' old

"So it looks like voters are much more eager -- or at least able to elect a black or a woman than somebody of your age."

Psssst....Bash...er....Reagan?

Acumen, Reagan is exactly

Acumen,

Reagan is exactly why nobody wants another old president.

He spent his last three years in the White House in an advanced state of dementia.  They hid it well, but I see no reason to repeat that potential disaster.

Nancy

And I would take Nancy Reagan in those years (referencing the oft repeated joke of Nancy running things at the time) over any of the three we have running now.

Perhaps (I guess).  Seems

Perhaps (I guess).  Seems like a nice enough woman.  Not the sharpest too in the shed, but the past 8 years have shown us that intelligence is no longer a prerequisite to the highest office in the country.

I feel ya bro!!!

Think about it:

Al Gore was almost President! He failed out of Vanderbilt's Divinty School AND their Law School!! What a doofus!

Good thing our current President has an undergraduate degree from Yale and an MBA from Harvard.

 

Leon, it's not a big deal,

Leon, it's not a big deal, and we all misspell words now and then, but when typing "Not the sharpest too in the shed,...", you may want to be very, very careful in your spelling of "toool".

No reply necessary.

It just burns you lefties to

It just burns you lefties to know that history has shown Reagan to be amongst the greatest presidents ever doesn't it?  I would even argue that most BDS stems from the fact that history will vindicate W. from his modern day critics.  Three years of dementia???  That is a first I have ever heard that one I must say. 

Free, I have nothing

Free,

I have nothing against Reagan.  I think he was a great leader and was instrumental in the ending of the Cold War.

However, that doesn't change the fact that he was severely mentally handicapped during his second term.

Reagan's last three years....

All Reagan did during his last three years in office was...

 sign the historic Tax Reform Code of 1986

 negotiate the 1988 SALT treaty that lead to the Cold War's biggest reduction of nuclear weapons on BOTH sides. 

 His historic "Tear Down This Wall" speech - which he wrote himself.

 

 

 

Leon , your a uninformed

Leon , your a uninformed fool.

obxray, So Reagan wasn't

obxray,

So Reagan wasn't mentally handicapped in his second term? Weird. I thought that was common knowledge. You must have just missed the memo.

Pssst, by the way, I missed your joke b/c your link doesn't work.

So what disaster are you

So what disaster are you talking about? Im very, very, very informed about the Regan years little one.

Speaking of dementia...

Don't waste your time guys. Leon doesn't do reality.

Leon cite your proof of the last 3 years of Reagan presidency

Time to put up Leon.  Cite your proof of your allegation.

Paw, Simple

Paw,

Simple mathematics.  Alzheimers develops over many, many years.  Ravaging the brain as it goes.

In 1993, it was confirmed that Reagan had full-blown Alzheimers. 

Thus, he was certainly suffering from dementia during his second term.

Call it educated speculation based on an understanding of the pathology of Alzheimers.

His tight lipped inner circle certainly isn't going to let anything out.

 

 

So Reagan proved he could do

So Reagan proved he could do this job even with the disease.Im still waiting for the answer little lib leon.

Leon, you are the one

Leon, you are the one suffering dementia.

Reagan gave one of the greatest speeches in history toward the end of his second term: http://www.reaganfou...

And it must be noted that Reagan was sharp enough to insist the key phrase, out of 2703 words, be included: "Mr Gorbachev, tear down this wall!"

Very Little Fact Here

"Alzheimers develops over many, many years."

True enough, as far as the bald statement, but your implication is totally wrong. From onset to termination, Alzheimers has a maximum life of 20 years, and a minimum of 3. Diagnosis may occur at any point along those spans.

"Ravaging the brain as it goes."

True, though the 'ravaging' effects are not linear, but actually logarithmic, starting off as barely noticeable effects, and ending as synapse deterioration.

"In 1993, it was confirmed that Reagan had full-blown Alzheimers."

Wrong. While his doctor noticed symptoms starting in 1992, the diagnosis was not confirmed until February, 1994. That's worth repeating. Reagan's doctor first noticed symptoms in 1992, four years after he was no longer president, and it wasn't confirmed until 1994, six years after he left office. 

"Thus, he was certainly suffering from dementia during his second term."

Wrong again. While Reagan, in his final term, was almost certainly on his way to getting Alzheimer's, given the 20 year maximum life of the disease, the earliest he could have been afflicted was 1984. At no time during his presidency was it an impairing condition, or was there even functional decline sufficient to render a tentative diagnosis. The slight deterioration in memory is a common side effect of aging, and had his doctors been expressly looking for Alzheimers - and given his family history there is no reason to believe they were not looking for it - they would have been unable to find it.

"Call it educated speculation based on an understanding of the pathology of Alzheimers."

More like speculation based on hearsay and innuendo, since you have precious little correct.

R/
Clyde 

"...the aspirants to tyranny are either the...men of the state, who in democracies are demagogues,... or those who hold great offices, and have a long tenure.." - Aristotle, Politics, c350BC

He spent his last three

He spent his last three years in the White House in an advanced state of dementia.  They hid it well, but I see no reason to repeat that potential disaster.

Reagan's Alzhiemer's wasn't exhibited until after he was out of office when he had brain surgery.

Well, at least it isn't

Well, at least it isn't Dana Bash herself that's accusing McCain of being heartless. It is, of course, "the voters out there who say....". She's just informing him of what all the voters she's been talking to are saying about him. That's all.

More of the "...how do you respond to THOSE who say..." stupidity from the partisan press, injecting their own views into the interview process while claiming to speak "for the people".

Leon...you're wrong, and you're off topic...

Stop trying to change the subject with false accusations.

I believe the infamous (but unbeknownst to you, of course) LMediaL LMattersL number for Iraqi dead was 600,000...and that was about a year ago? I can't remember when that fictional number became the LMainstreamL "fact", but it was and still is fiction.

I believe Senator McCain said, "in the hundreds of thousands, obviously", after admitting that such a thing was difficult to calculate. So, is it 150,000? 200,000? 250,000, somewhere in that range?

No, immediately, 600,000+ seems like a perfectly TRUE number, and, that was many months ago supposedly...which would mean that, according to LMainstreamL LMediaL accounts, there's probably been almost 1 million killed. Mark my words, before the election, we will hear a new, extremely bloated number for the total dead, which will probably be 1 million. However, that number is probably 3x to 4x inflated from the TRUTH.

You'll believe it, Leon, because you want to. And probably because it will be plastered across the front page of Rolling Stone with a picture of President Bush, under the title, "Genocide".

But back to the main topic...

Pathetic, disgraceful interview. Leading the witness much? There is no question that this amounts to badgering and discrimination...if they're free to question McCain's health vis a vis his age, why isn't Baraka Hussein Obama allowed to be questioned about his spritual advisor? Why is Baraka's middle name off limits? What will happen when someone has a sticker or shirt of an "H" with a circle and line going through it? Why is Baraka's sketchy and flimsy record being ignored? Why is Baraka treated as the presumptive next President, while the Republican candidate is treated as a hostile witness?

Leon...get a grip. Baraka is an angry black socialist, his wife is an angry black America-hating elitist snob, and his Mentor, Spiritual Advisor, Campaign Advisor, and friend, the dishonorable Rev. Wright, is a disgraced, America-hating, racist hypocrite.

Or maybe I'm just a racist for wanting to understand just who the people are that are running for President. Thanks to CNN, I now know more about John McCain...he's mad old!! He might croak once he becomes President! Don't vote for him! Got it. Thanks, Ted Turner.

I thought that McCain did

I thought that McCain did pretty well in this interview. He stepped around the BS she was laying. Would love to see her try this on a Dem, but we all know that would be a carrer ender  

"Always do right. This will gratify some people, and astonish the rest". Mark Twain

He did very well...

I certainly would not have been able to be so smooth and clever in letting it be known that she was taking a joke and making into a campaign issue. I probably would have just done the Democrat thing and just walked out of the interview. Afterall, shouldn't Republicans get to boycott news agencies that are biased?

Does anyone else feel as though that is a major issue that has not seen its last moment in the sun? How can these people think that they can run the country, confront our problems at home, and our enemies abroad...and yet they're too afraid of having their words "spun" (anyone else sick of hearing that word?) on FoxNews.

Hello?!?! McFly!! Anyone home?? These Dems are not fit to salute our flag. Oh wait, they don't...

So John McCain is discussing

So John McCain is discussing the state of the economy with Dana Bash and CNN.  Talk about the blind leading the blonde...

Hey fitz!

Pay attention to your comments, there, fella!

Helloooooo! 

David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive

 

Ah, come on!

Ah, come on!