Hillary Clinton, Queen of Soul? Barack Obama, All-American teenaged girl? That's precisely the analogy that Joe Scarborough made this morning in trying to explain why many Hillary supporters haven't swung to Obama. Hillary was a guest on today's Morning Joe, and the interview offered a number of other interesting tidbits:
- Hillary dodged the question of whether Bill was telling the truth when he claimed she didn't want the VP slot on Obama's ticket.
- The junior NY senator declined to swing at a Sarah-bashing softball Mika Brzezinski tossed her.
- Hillary let slip that she still has her own campaign on her mind.
But let's get back to Joe's conventional-wisdom busting musical metaphor, which came after Hillary had offered an innocuous answer to guest panelist John Ridley's question as to why many of her supporters remain uncommitted to Obama.
View video here.
JOE SCARBOROUGH: Ridley, it's still a hard sell. I mean, that's like somebody going to a store to buy an Aretha Franklin album, and then the cashier trying to push Miley Cyrus on them. It just doesn't work!
As Hillary indulged a hearty smile and chuckle, Mika tried to stop Joe short.
MIKA BRZEZINSKI: OK, OK.SCARBOROUGH: I want Aretha!
JOHN RIDLEY: If you want [liberal] music, and the music is good, stick with the company that put out that music.
SCARBOROUGH: I want Aretha!
As for those other tidbits . . .
Toward the beginning of the interview, discussing the current financial crisis, Hillary spoke of how she advocated certain measures "throughout my campaign."' Check out the video of the moment, which comes at the very beginning of the clip. It seems that Hillary realizes that it's not really a good idea to be talking up what she did during her campaign, but, having begun, plunges on.
A bit later, Mika offered up that Sarah-bashing softball.
BRZEZINSKI: Senator Clinton, the voters will obviously be looking to vote for someone who can take the reins and lead this country into better days. My question to you is: do you think Sarah Palin can handle a crisis like this?
Hillary declined to swing, saying that voters will look at the men at the top of the ticket. Have a look at the video and see if you don't agree that Mika's question seemed to come as something of a non sequitur.
Then came Hillary's dodge on whether she wanted the VP nod.
BRZEZINSKI: You could have really helped the Democratic ticket for sure. Do you ever wish you were on it? Your husband said you didn't want the job.HILLARY CLINTON: Well, it's not anyone's to want or not want. It's up to the nominee.
Malarkey! It is human nature to want even those things that we don't have the ability to make happen. And is Hillary saying Bill wasn't telling the truth when he told The View that she didn't want the spot?
—Mark Finkelstein is a NewsBusters contributing editor and host of Right Angle. Contact him at mark@gunhill.net.





JOE SCARBOROUGH: Ridley, it's still a hard sell. I mean, that's like somebody going to a store to buy an Aretha Franklin album, and then the cashier trying to push Miley Cyrus on them. It just doesn't work!















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
I was listening to this
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 09:15 ET by marpelI was listening to this exchange while I was putting my makeup on. I was sort of glad to see Hillary on the show.
But, the question of the day is why do we care about John Ridley? He's a Hollywood writer. He's no expert. All these Hollywood types think they're experts in politics, and it's mind boggling to me as to why anyone gives them validation...
I'm still stunned that with
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 09:54 ET by motherbeltI'm still stunned that with a straight face she actually said that she believes Barack Obama is better prepared to lead this country out of its financial difficulties!
HUH?
But I notice that she didn't talk about HOW he's better prepared! Instead, she went right into he'll have the advice and support of people who understand what we're going to have to do to get through this
Who, Mrs. Clinton...people like Franklin Raines?
All I can say is I'm glad I
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 10:14 ET by bobthemanAll I can say is I'm glad I have you guys to watch the show and ferret out the highlights. I can't stomach MSNBC anymore. My tolerance for Joe, Mika and MSNBC as a whole is running on empty. Morning Joe use to be a decent watch, but for some reason, I no longer have the patience.
http://politicsofdestruction.com
Agreed, Bob
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 11:25 ET by BlondeSomething has gotten very hinky at the Morning Joe set.
It used to be Joe's show...and he ran it. Now it seems like Bubbles has taken over, and Joe just lets her get away with her liberal twitisms.
I've heard her, on two separate occasions, make the assertion that (1) our military is in shambles and (2) Al Quaeda is reconstituting. Not a peep out of Joe.
I don't know what management has done, but I used to watch it for the amusement factor, when Joe would occasionally slap down one of the myriad liberal talking heads (including Mika the Twit). It seems he's been told to cut it out.
So, I'm not watching any longer, either.
David Gregory, do you know which damn network you lie for? ~ Uncle Jimbo, @Blackfive
Bob, I only watch Morning
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 11:27 ET by marpelBob, I only watch Morning Joe on MSNBC because I get so aggravated with the show, it wakes me up! After getting thoroughly ticked off, I run and take my blood pressure meds and I'm ready to start my day.
TAKING THE REINS
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 12:33 ET by FC DOBBSWHEN I HEAR MIKA ASK HILLARY IF SARAH COULD
TAKE THE REINS FROM A PRESIDENT MCCAIN,IF
NECESSARY, I'D LOVE TO HEAR HER REPLY TO WHETHER
SHE COULD TAKE OVER,IF ANYTHING MIGHT HAPPEN
TO JOE (GOD FORBID).
I WOULD THINK THE RATINGSWOULD PLUMMET TO
AN ALL TIME LOW EVEN FOR MSNBC. MIKA'S ROLLING
EYES,HER CONSTANT INTERRUPTIONS,HER PENCHANT
FOR STARING AT THE TV CAMERA WHILE CARRYING
ON A CONVERSATION WITH A GUEST OR A CO-HOST,
AMONG OTHER THINGS,HAS LED ME TO BELIEVE THAT
SHE IS NOTHING MORE THAN GOOD LOOKING LOW
GRADE MORON WHO OFTEN DRIVES ME AWAY FROM
THAT SHOW WHENEVER SHE FIRST OPENS HER MOUTH
AND SPEWS HER IGNORANCE.
."NOBODY PUTS ONE OVER ON FRED C DOBBS".
B.TRAVEN
Bill was telling the truth
Tue, 09/23/2008 - 18:34 ET by bigtimerBill was telling the truth for once...I don't think she has ever wanted the VP job, plus let us not forget all the internal BS that went on between these people, that some of it did spill over for all of us to watch ..with glee
LMAO...
No Hill is thinking she is going to save her chits and get vengenance in so many ways...including plenty in her party...this is going to be so fun to watch in the next four years.
Sometimes I love this blood-sport.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh