NBC: Romney 'Scrambles' to Explain Why He Wanted to Let Auto Companies 'Fail'
Leading off Wednesday's NBC Nightly News, anchor Brian Williams spun hard for the Obama administration as he distorted Mitt Romney's opposition to the government bailout of the auto industry: "The fight for Michigan as Mitt Romney scrambles to explain to the voters in his home state why he thought the auto industry should be allowed to fail."
Having ignored the fact that Romney called for a "managed bankruptcy" of General Motors and Chrysler in order for them to reorganize and become healthier companies, Williams announced to viewers: "Mitt Romney's in a tough spot....he's working hard to explain why he was against the government's auto industry bailouts. That doesn't go over well in the state we associate with Detroit and American cars."
In the report that followed, correspondent Peter Alexander continued to portray Romney as a foe to the auto makers: "And at a time when the American auto industry is getting back on its feet, as portrayed in this Super Bowl ad...and evidenced by this General Motors plant in Flint adding a third shift last summer, Romney recently renewed his opposition to the Obama administration's auto bailout."
After playing a sound bite of Romney voicing his opposition to the billions in taxpayer dollars doled out to Detroit, Alexander declared: "A position that may not be shared by many Michigan voters." An unidentified Michigan voter ranted: "To allow the industries that made this state, and made this – put this state on the map, go under would have been absolutely ridiculous. It would have been ludicrous."
After Alexander's report, Williams touted an upcoming story on Rock Center, hailing the auto bailout as a great success: "...a story that Peter mentioned, right out of the headlines from Flint, Michigan, where GM has restored that overnight shift at its Flint assembly plant, a sign of recovery after that big government bailout of the auto industry."
In that Rock Center report later Wednesday night, correspondent Mike Taibbi cheered the infusion of government money: "As the new third shift jobs here have triggered an employment boomlet. They say each job on the line means three jobs in support industry. Well, this is one of the places where that conventional wisdom turns into practical reality....Flint isn't just gaining auto industry jobs. Angelo's Coney Island all-night restaurant, owner Neil Helmkay says business is up 5%, maybe more."
Taibbi described the new jobs in Flint as, "a snapshot of a wounded corporate giant on the rebound, with human consequences beyond....after years of struggle and decline, the nights are again filled with the sights and sounds of an industry lurching back to health. Where hundreds more men and women with families can again support those families."
No criticism of the bailout was included in the story.
Following that report, Williams confessed: "As an American car guy myself, raised in an American car family, it's hard to see anything negative..." He reluctantly added: "...but we should probably remind folks of the numbers. What did GM get from the federal government? How much has been given back? And how much of GM do we all still own?"
Taibbi briefly detailed the staggering amount of money the auto company received and still owes:
Well, they got a lot. GM got $49.5 billion. They paid back about $24.1 billion, a little less than a half, that's the part of it that was a loan. But the U.S. Treasury, meaning all of us, still owns 500 million shares of stock in the reconstituted GM. That's worth about 12 to $13 billion right now. So, we're on the hook, the U.S. Treasury's on the hook, for about 12 or $13 billion right now and they don't expect any further payment from GM. That's still an area of debate.
Rather than end on that uncertain note, Taibbi made sure to reassure viewers: "No debate, though, that GM is back on the rebound. They're back, as you've reported, we all have, as the number one vehicle maker in the world now." It's easy when the government gives you $50 billion.
- Kyle Drennen's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
Stop Talking To These Partisan Liberal Hack Pseudo-Journalist!!!
Submitted by HardRightTurn on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 7:04pm.
You know they're up to no good, they mean to do you harm. Stop exposing yourself to the treacherous lying. They will never let you get your message out. Stiff them just like Obama does the right media.
Canceling the CNN debate is a good first step. Now cancel all leftwing sponsored events.
To more fully comprehend the Left, one must read “Leftism As Psychopathy” by John Ray, M.A., Ph.D. Caution, it might scare you a little bit.
http://jonjayray.tripod.com/psycho.html
bankrutcy
Submitted by ferv888 on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 7:18pm.
did Williams forget that we had stuck billions into the old GM as fools tried to keep it from going BK?
Then the ONE' s crew put them thru BK, and not only gave them billions, but allowed them to carry 40B in tax deductions from the old company.
Tax liability in 2011, Zero!!!!!
where was that story Williams?
So
Submitted by grammajane on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 7:56pm.
Williams, when you fail, are you going to scramble for a bail-out? OMG Sawyer just reported and showed high school girls screaming in delight while meeting Mochelle the caprain of the food police. Sawyer could hardly control herself by this sight. These media freaks get worse every night
Don't keep score in kid's soccer games.
Submitted by Newsbubba on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 8:21pm.
Don't let grownups go bankrupt when they f()<K up.
Train them early.
To no one's surprise, Williams doesn't get it.
Submitted by Galvanic on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 10:08pm.
First, GM and Chrysler had ALREADY failed, so it wasn't a matter of "letting" the fail. A bankrupty would've reorganized the company, and the UAW would've been cut back, too. In a bankruptcy, old contracts go out the window, and new ones are negotiated as part of the reorganization. Additionally, with the UAW holding a lot of GM stock, a catastrophic drop in stock value might've crushed them. Obama bailed out the UAW.
Second, the "auto industry" didn't get a bail out. GM and Chrysler did. Ford didn't want it, and still hasn't asked for it. The begs the question, "What did Ford do right that GM and Chrysler didn't? And furthermore, why should the failed competition get a bail out to keep competing against Ford?"
"Obama bailed out the
Submitted by krendler on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 10:11pm.
"Obama bailed out the UAW."
Precisely. The exact line the Republican nominee should use in the debates if/when this comes up.
"You didn't bail out the 'auto industry', Mr. President. You bailed out the UAW."
Depends on who the nominee
Submitted by Dan The Man 2 on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 12:57am.
Depends on who the nominee is.
krendler, not quite. It was
Submitted by PaleHorse on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 9:12am.
krendler, not quite. It was President Bush who bailed out the UAW. Everyone knows this. No amount of spin will ever change that fact.
PaleHorse LIES again. Right through his green teeth.
Submitted by The Vet on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 9:47am.
President Bush provided a loan to the auto companies and wanted wage concessions from the unions as part of the deal.
Thus the loan agreements drafted by Treasury take a more flexible approach. There are “Restructuring Targets” to be met in the companies’ recovery plans, including moving to a more competitive wage structure by the end of 2009. But there is also some leeway if alternative savings can be found. The restructuring report due March 31 “shall identify any deviations from the Restructuring Targets and explain the rationale for these deviations, including an explanation of why such deviations do not jeopardize the Borrower’s long-term viability.”
It was under President Obama and his flouting of the bankruptcy laws in this country that bailed out the UAW from concessions it surely would have had to give in a lawful bankruptcy proceeding.
Stick to the smartass comments LIAR. You divert into the realm of facts, you fail every time.
You would think that the speed and quantity of those lies ---
Submitted by matthewdean on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 9:12pm.
would wear that green mossy stuff off the dude's teef.
Guess not. :o)
MD
That is Romneys message
Submitted by OuttaMyWay on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 12:47pm.
got a robo call from his campaign yesterday or the day before (i live in michigan) and it was his speech calling out King's lie. Very well done. Goes along ways in this problem. He Named Names, Mentioned the exact problem, then had his highlight calling out the UAW bailout, and would fight the union.
Williams: "That doesn't go
Submitted by krendler on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 10:08pm.
Williams: "That doesn't go over well in the state we associate with Detroit and American cars."
That's ok, Brian. The city of Detroit and cars made by GM/Chrysler don't go over well with the American people.
And of course, Williams disgracefully doesn't bother to accurately convey what Romney's actual position was: Let GM/Chrysler go through managed bankruptcy. Simply regurgitates Democrat talking points, verbatim.
Why does Obama need any campaign funds at all? Seriously. These clowns are doing his bidding for free, daily.
That money pit in the South East corner of the state
Submitted by UpNorth on Thu, 02/16/2012 - 10:37pm.
doesn't go over well with most of the rest of us, either. Nor does Mitt Romney right now. If the best he does in Michigan is a tie with Santorum, he's in more trouble than he realizes. Or his handlers will tell him.
Strange that Bri-Bri didn't mention GM's hidden break, they don't have to pay $45.4 Billion(with a B) in taxes on future profits. So, what would their real profit be, if that wasn't there to fall back on?
Again. Who here can't find Ding Dongs or Twinkies at the store?
Submitted by The Vet on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 12:51am.
Hostess, as we speak, is undergoing a managed bankrupty through Chapter 11. The snack cake industry is not being "allowed to fail" nor is it being "allowed to go under".
Like I told'ya the other
Submitted by killa37 on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 1:09am.
Like I told'ya the other night, Vet - unless Mooooooooooooooochelle is addicted to deep-fried Twinkies or Snowballs, there won't be any hope for this company, as it stands right now. But, if the big-caboose Clydesdale likes those greasy, hot, dripping with oil Twinkies............then they're IN!!!!!
No buddy.
Submitted by The Vet on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 1:19am.
What happens is ALL contracts are wiped out and must be renegotiated. That includes union contracts. Unions are going to take it on the chin just like they should have legally with the GM bailout but didn't.
Union to Lose Big in Hostess Bankruptcy
After Hostess Brands, the maker of Wonder Bread, Ding Dongs, Ho Ho's, Sno Balls, Drakes Cakes and Twinkies, filed for bankruptcy on Wednesday, the company's pinned its future on renegotiating unionized labor contracts.
Hostess Brands cited an inability to renegotiate crippling pension and benefit plans, which made the 19,500 worker strong company vulnerable to cash shortages and an economic downturn -- and were key to in its Wednesday bankruptcy filing.
This is actually their second bankruptcy in less than a decade.
Mrs. Obama will get her Ho Ho's. Don't you worry about that.
I like the idea of unions
Submitted by killa37 on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 1:26am.
I like the idea of unions 'taking it on the chin'.............and I'm NOT talking about the actual working guys!! I"m talking about the actual UNION guys - you know - the ones who are skimming FROM the employers AS WELL AS the employees??? Yeah, that's who I'm talking about. My #1 son is in the stevedore (longshoreman) union in Honolulu - I've seen his paychecks. And I also know one of his co-workers, who also happens to be a union 'rep'. The guy is a big, strong, smart, confident Portuguese-Hawaiian, AND a staunch conservative and union-buster..............and he tells me about the 'fun' that he has at union meetings, just laying down the smack on all of these union brain-washed followers....................and he KNOWS what he's talking about, PLUS he's a phsycial force that they DON'T want to challenge.
Nice
Submitted by HockeyKid on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 7:59am.
Out-thuggin' the thugs. I like it. Mahalo to that guy!
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me
The auto companies did fail.
Submitted by Lipton on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 10:32am.
Success is not getting a giant handout from unwilling investors.
Re-treading his lips
Submitted by NotFondOfLibs on Fri, 02/17/2012 - 2:30pm.
Can anyone confirm that Bryan Williams has had his lips re-treaded since he has been kissing Obama's a**. Just asking.