'On Faith' Contributor: Personhood Amendment Was Strategic Defeat for 'Radical Religious Right'
Initiative 26 -- which would have amended the Mississippi state constitution to include unborn children as persons protected under the law -- was rejected by Magnolia State voters last night.
In response, Georgetown professor and Washington Post "On Faith" blog contributor Jacques Berlinerblau quickly hacked out a post celebrating the temporary victory over the "devastating sleeper cell of a law" but warned that in losing, those dastardly villains on the religious right may have actually won (emphasis mine):
[T]he proponents of Amendment 26 probably also knew their cause was doomed once everyone from parents of in-vitro children, to physicians, to victims of rape, found out what it was actually about (that many of these folks were committed Christians is an interesting sidebar).
My contention is that while these activists may certainly hope (and pray) for victory, they understand their immediate task as tilting national conversations to a terrain upon which the radical religious right can better manouver.
...
...[I]n Mississippi and elsewhere the new parameters of the abortion debate will be defined not by “pro-life versus pro-choice” but “pro-personhood versus pro-life.” If that shift actually ensues, then Amendment 26 was a stunning victory.
It was the Christian Right’s ability to completely re-configure public dialogues and perspectives that was the mission accomplished of its most recent blustering.
In the interests of truth-in-advertising, the Washington Post should rename its religion blog from "On Faith" to "Piling On People of Faith."
- Ken Shepherd's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
If not at conception
Submitted by rwnewsnut on Wed, 11/09/2011 - 12:27pm.
then when does life begin?
And they say conservatives are against science.
Liberals won't admit the very science of human development.
When then does personhood get bestowed? The moment the baby appears?
So one day less than that appearance, it is not a person. That's idiotic!
"When then does personhood
Submitted by richflanj on Wed, 11/09/2011 - 3:58pm.
"When then does personhood get bestowed? The moment the baby appears?"
Not even then, according to liberals.
Remember - "partial birth" abortion is essentially infanticide. A baby is delivered and, right before they cross that vaginal line, they are stabbed in the base of the skull. In my book, that is murder. Nothing. But. Murder.
Ken, I beat you to it.
Submitted by motherbelt on Wed, 11/09/2011 - 1:25pm.
I've been saying here for a long time that they should rename the feature "Dumping On Faith."
Hey, at least we got a promotion out of it....we've been promoted to "radical religious right."
It's flattery to be labeled as "radical."
Submitted by Mike Bratton on Wed, 11/09/2011 - 3:58pm.
To borrow an old phrase, if having a saving relationship with Christ doesn't fire you up, your wood's wet.
--Mike