WaPo Leaves Fizz Out of Frieden Story: Obama's CDC Pick Favors Sin Tax on Soda

Photo of Ken Shepherd.

Naming a man who wants to levy sin taxes on soda pop to be the head of the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) might not be the politically wisest thing for President Obama to do, especially on the heels of massive TEA Party protests. But then again, with media outlets like the Washington Post leaving that controversy unmentioned, perhaps the White House calculated correctly that the risk of staffing the federal government's public health branches with nanny state activists was minimal.

On May 15, President Obama announced in a press statement that New York City health commissioner Thomas Frieden will take the helm of the CDC in June. Reporting the story in the May 16 paper were Post staffers Debbi Wilgoren and Michael D. Shear (along with some help from staffer Ceci Connolly).

Wilgoren and Shear allowed "an industry-funded group" spokesman to slam Frieden as "barely recogniz[ing]" the line between "government's responsibility in regulating health and what is the individual's responsibility," yet they curiously omitted perhaps the clearest example of the same, Frieden's support of a penny-per-ounce soda tax. This even though the Senate Finance Committee held a hearing on the idea earlier in the week.

Slate's William Saletan noted Frieden's push for a penny-per-ounce soda tax in early April:

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

The food police are closing in on their next target: a soda tax.

New York City's health commissioner, Thomas Frieden, is leading the way. He's the guy who purged trans fats from the city's restaurants and made them post calorie counts for menu items. Lately he's been pressuring food companies to remove salt from their products.

Now he's going after soda. Writing in the New England Journal of Medicine, Frieden and Kelly Brownell, the director of Yale's Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity, propose a penny-per-ounce excise tax on "sugared beverages." That's nearly $3 per case. Why so much? Because this tax, unlike the petty junk-food taxes of yesteryear, is designed to hurt. Its purpose is to discourage you from buying soda, on the grounds that soda, like smoking, is bad for you.

Persuading Americans to regulate soda the way we regulate cigarettes won't be easy. Isn't soda a kind of food? Isn't food a good thing? And isn't it a matter of personal choice? Doesn't taxation to control people's eating behavior cross a fundamental line of liberty?

Those are good questions and many Americans will no doubt be asking them as Frieden's food police activism becomes more widely reported and criticized.

—Ken Shepherd is Managing Editor of NewsBusters


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Nobody touches my Diet Coke!

They can nationalize banks, car companies, insurance companies, the healthcare system, give our interrogation techniques to terrorists, put Bush and Cheney in jail, stop drilling for oil and make cars run on wind....but nobody, I mean nobody messes with my Diet Coke!

Tea party hell!  Diet Coke parties!  This is war!

Angry White Dude

www.angrywhitedude.c...

Jeff,

Glad to see you have your priorities straight. :)

"This
liberal would be all about socialize -- uh, uh, would be about
basically taking over and the government running all of your companies."-Maxine Waters 2008

I'm with you

Since when is soda a "sin"?  I don't smoke, I don't do drugs, I don't even drink alcohol...Diet Coke is my only addiction.  It doesn't pollute the air around me and I can drink it without it affecting my ability to drive or think clearly.  Lay off my Diet Coke, dammit! 

Sugar

I thought this tax was on 'sugared' beverages. That should leave out the diet sodas. Not that I believe it will, I'm sure all sodas will be taxed.

D

Keep the ILLEGALS out, join NumbersUSA to send free faxes to your reps.

What will happen is

What will happen is companies will stop selling sugared soda, and then Freiden will just tax the diet sodas to make up for all the lost revenue.

We'll see how many people

We'll see how many people protest this...soda pop lovers must unite and be heard...'bout time somebody else took a turn about being singled out and taxed for health reasons...after all, you soda lovers are costing as much as the evil smokers do according to some on the talking head shows say...obesity and all related diseases/problems the govt. can tack on...they will...

Smile...be happy....it's your turn in the barrel.

Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart

Al Gore and his ilk want to

Al Gore and his ilk want to tax us for breathing and exhaling so it is no surprise that another democrat would want to tax soda pop.  

All we have to do is look at the EU to find what Frieden...

All we have to do is look at the EU to find what Frieden has in mind for us. The Leftist model always favors the micro-managing, we know better, it's for your own good treatment of us, the vulgar ugly. We must stop complaining and be grateful! What's wrong with us, anyway? Almost everything it seems.

More and more of our country is being run by thugs, and if Rahm gains total control of the US Census, he will design voting districts that will allow him to have his way.

Nanny Frieden

Nanny Frieden's  New York City Health Department began conducting intrusive and pryin g telephone survey's years ago.  He believes that government is better able to make decisions than individuals or businesses.

He is a great match for the Obama Administration.

Sin taxes

Gary Huggins All these comments will be moot when a nation such as Iran or N Korea uses a HEMP weapon above the US. This threat is one that is real and seems to be coming to fruition in US hating zealots.

The Capital clowns are beginning to sound

The Capital clowns are beginning to sound like Puttin.

Remember what happed the last time one man usurpt State's Rights and caused a Revolution though he supposedly did not want to fight his "own south land"?

Will the U.S. become the next East Germany?

I wonder if "We The People" will wise up before anything like this happens [again].

CO2 Regulation

Don't forget that CO2 is what makes sodas fizzy.  This is really just a tax on a manufactered greenhouse gas.  Your pop is causing global warming!  Now that's what I call science!