When a UFO shaped helium balloon took off from Colorado, possibly harboring a 6-year-old boy, the broadcast and cable news organizations were transfixed. But when it turned out to be a possible "publicity stunt" the networks continued to give it enormous amounts of coverage.
That's exactly the opposite of the way the networks covered made-up quotes attributed to conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh that had portrayed him as racist.
ABC's "Good Morning America," CBS's "The Early Show," and NBC's "Today" devoted 80 minutes and 55 seconds to the story of "balloon boy" Falcon Heene on Oct. 16, when it was clear the boy had not been in the balloon and even after the boy told CNN's Larry King that he was hiding because "we did this for the show."
But since the fictional Limbaugh quotes were exposed, the networks spent only 47 seconds discussing it. Only ABC addressed it at all - on "World News with Charles Gibson" Oct. 12 and re-airing David Muir's brief on "Good Morning America," the next day.
That included a comment from Limbaugh defending himself saying, "They have to go somewhere to find concocted quotes, which are now bordering on slander, libel, whatever it is."
Still, the bogus Limbaugh quotes were not a priority for the networks which were happy to spend 100 times more coverage on the possible balloon "hoax." While the broadcast networks never aired the phony Limbaugh quotes, they did indicate he had failed in his NFL bid because of racial comments.
Instead, "balloon boy" was the star of the day. CBS even interviewed a clinical psychologist about the 6-year-old on "The Early Show."
But Falcon's Oct. 15 statement during "Larry King Live," along with the Heene family's unusual background (stormchasing, appearing on "Wife Swap"), led many to question whether or not the entire incident was in fact a hoax or publicity stunt for a TV show.
"Today's" Meredith Vieira asked Falcon's father, Richard Heene, bluntly "was this a hoax or a publicity stunt?" Heene vehemently denied that possibility and admitted to being "ticked off" by all the interviewers asking it.
"Absolutely not and now I'm starting to get a little ticked off because I'm repetitively getting asked in the last couple of interviews. What have I got to gain out of this? I'm not selling anything. I'm not advertising anything," Heene said.
Robin Roberts posited a similar theory on "Good Morning America," saying, "Some are asking, did the family, known for their appearance on reality TV, did they take us all for a ride?" Even if it wasn't a stunt, it was still obvious the child had not been in the balloon, yet the networks covered it overwhelmingly.
The huge disparity of coverage between the two incidents revealed the priorities of the networks. On Oct. 13, Media Research Center President Brent Bozell demanded that news outlets which had run these quotes to prove that Limbaugh had in fact said them. Limbaugh unequivocally denied saying the racist quotes.
MRC also released a Special Report on Oct. 14 about the media's attempted character assassination of Limbaugh, which included the use of unproven quotes generated by left-wing bloggers and authors.—Julia A. Seymour is an assistant editor for the Business & Media Institute.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Well, at least
October 16, 2009 - 11:45 ET by legacyrepublicanWell, at least it was an uplifting story. It really soared over the competition. It had it all, aliens, a kid in an alien aircraft, a family looking for their loved one, fear, hope, and pathos.
Why take time to cover one's own folly in which you lifted something false out of the Internet cloud, aired its use to defame an honest man, routed for his failure with lots of coverage over the lie, and then celebrated his losing as a victory.
Why cover something that makes you look even worse than that six year old boy made his parent's look.
BARF ON TV
October 16, 2009 - 22:21 ET by ptsonThe little kid barfed on the TODAY Show. I can identify, that show has the same effect on me!
Fox
October 16, 2009 - 11:45 ET by BondPlainBondFox has been doing this bluddy story every bluddy fifteen minutes today beginning with Fox & Friends. Enough!
Fox has b-a-r-e-l-y made mention of the fabricated Limbaugh comments (morning line-up). Shep Smith, on Wednesday's Studio B, did the whole "comments attributed" to Limbaugh story and not once - not once - did he mention the comments were fabricated even though that fact had been floating all over the news and the intenet that day (Morning Joe debunked the liars - including their own - with the facts).
Balloon Boy story? He's safe. Ensure Child Protective Services has a good look around the parents, and have them pay the bills for the rescue operation. End of story.
No Surprise Here
October 16, 2009 - 12:09 ET by John Galt1776After all
Look at all the coverage the MSM is giving our Bogus President
Where's The Birth Certificate
BORN IN THE USA?
Obama from Kenya, archived report says
Revives worry about president's eligibility for office
Posted: October 15, 2009
2:34 pm Eastern
By Bob Unruh
© 2009 WorldNetDaily
An archived article from 2004 on Barack Obama's run for the U.S.
Senate in Illinois describes the relative political newcomer as
"Kenyan-born," providing further fuel for speculation over the
president's eligibilty for office.
WND
has noted various news reports that have either stated or implied
Obama's birthplace is not Hawaii, as he has claimed, but Africa.
The issue is significant, since there are a number of lawsuits
challenging Obama's eligibility that argue if he was not born in the
U.S., he does not meet the requirement in the Constitution that the
president be a "natural born" citizen.
WND
further has reported on the disagreement among those documenting
Obama's presidency over which Hawaii hospital was his birth place.
Now have come a flood of blog questions and e-mails regarding the apparently archived article from the Sunday Standard in Kenya.
The report starts out, "Kenyan-born US Senate hopeful, Barrack
(sic) Obama, appeared set to take over the Illinois Senate seat after
his main rival, Jack Ryan, dropped out of the race on Friday night amid
a furor over lurid sex club allegations."
cont on link including photo of article
http://www.wnd.com/i...
crazy story
October 16, 2009 - 12:16 ET by jon_torlinThis balloon thing had "crazy" written all over it. Had the people at my office talking and watching the TVs wondering what's going to happen. I kept asking why they thought the kid was inside, when there wasn't a real obvious way to get in given the dimensions of the balloon (20 feet wide by 5 feet high). Of course, there's never been a story like this that I can remember.
I wasn't worried until they finally mentioned that it had a basket attached to it that fell off and thought "now there's where you really worry about the kid being missing or hurt" but later on, turns out he was hiding in the attic the whole time. But before that, I kept thinking that balloon was an air traffic hazard, could have been bad if it had drifted into power lines, that's about it really. The idea that the kid was in it wasn't believable.
It was a funny thing too, and this could be the same as Rush supposedly saying things when he didn't. When I made the comment that the kid's not inside, one of the ladies (she's a liberal from down the hall, the one who cheered when Soetoro got the Nobel) said "But they are saying that the kid is inside it!" as she gestured to the screen, she was all fretful and stuff.*ugh* I kept saying "it doesn't fit the facts of what is known about balloons and kids, especially with the details given. They said they BELIEVE the kid is inside, but where's the evidence of that?" There were images of that thing from ALL angles to where you could examine it. There was no way a kid could have gotten in there. But she wasn't interested in that, it was that to her, the kid was inside.
So just like Rush supposedly saying things that he really didn't say, or the forged documents of Bush and other things, looking at the facts didn't seem to matter. At least I had a moment of "Told ya!"
At least the kid's safe(heard he puked on Live TV this morning), there was no tragic end to the story, life goes on.
-Jon
BPB... You said it all in
October 16, 2009 - 12:44 ET by bigtimerBPB...
You said it all in a nutshell.
Couldn't agree more...if anything, they parents need to pony up for this...not the tax-payers.
Like I said yesterday, I am glad the boy is okay...still smelled of a hoax to me after 90 minutes of listening to this on and off...and the msm still goes on and on and on...they never know when enough is enough...ever.
Drive-by indeed.
'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart
Hey Julia... Thumbs
October 16, 2009 - 12:39 ET by bigtimerHey Julia...
Thumbs Up!
Your great blog post was just mentioned on Rush's show a few minutes ago.
Cheers NBs!
'Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea'~Breitbart
Great trolls or greatest trolls?
October 16, 2009 - 14:00 ET by someloudthunderThe Heene family seems like they mastered the art of trolling as they fooled an entire nation for at least a good 30 minutes.
I'm not mad at them at all though. I find it quiet humorous.
not trolls...tricksters?
October 16, 2009 - 14:16 ET by jon_torlinI'm not 100% positive on this, but it's looking more and more like a hoax. I hope they have a lot of money though because the cost of an hour of flight for the blackhawk (which I saw come in view towards the end) is about $15,000. Not to mention the use of those rescue vehicles and etc Wait till they get the bill.
But if it is a hoax, it's a good one. Got a lot of people's attention, that's for sure.
-Jon
The REAL Reason for the Continued Coverage
October 16, 2009 - 17:52 ET by richb313The REAL Reason for the continued coverage is because the Media was made to look like the Ignorant Fools they can be sometimes. I woke from a nap (I'm 58, I'm Allowed) to see this story on Fox and all the Cable News Networks. One look at the balloon and I knew the kid was safe. The payload of a balloon that size cannot be larger than 10 to 15 lbs and I am being generous. A balloon cannot lift more than the air it displaces weighs. It is basic Physics folks, the stuff they taught in Jr High and High School. The types of people who go into Journalisim did not do well in these subjects.
I called FOX News while the story was still developing and told them that the size of the balloon was insufficient to lift the weight of a 6 yr old child.
Most Cable News Networks jump right away on a story like this without taking the time to evaluate it before it goes on air. I can understand that because of the pressure to keep the eyeballs. Now they are embarssed and want to make the story it was a setup job. A six yr old said it was a show. If you were a six yr old and looked at all those TV Trucks and Reportes you would think it was a show too. If it was a prank or hoax it probably was the boys themselves that did it.
The family did do questionable things in the past but unless there is some hard evidence and not the ramblings of a frightened six year old who was so upset he was sick I say lay off. This makes all News Organizations look bad.
The media begs for stories
October 16, 2009 - 22:31 ET by GregEThe media begs for stories such as the balloon story so they can use it as they see fit to cover up whatever they may feel they should otherwise be talking about that wouldn't fit their agenda.
Balloon Boy The Movie
October 17, 2009 - 08:17 ET by Sergeant ROCKIt could've been a kitten stuck in a drain pipe or tree just as well. Anything will do so as to avoid covering your own embarrassment.
"I ask, Sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people. To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
George Mason