Dr. David Scheiner doesn't think the president's health care plan will work, but not for the reasons you might think.
CNN's Jim Acosta devoted a three-minute segment to the Scheiner's left-wing criticism of the president's health care plan, but excluded any other voices, even after the doctor took a shot at the insurance industry.
"Chicago doctor David Scheiner has taken a hard look at Obama's prescription for health care reform and sees bad medicine," Acosta said before explaining why the doctor is "so special."
In fact, Scheiner was Obama's personal doctor for 22 years, but he blasted the president's plan for not going "far enough." Scheiner advocated a single-payer system like in Canada and Europe.
"If I had to say the single one thing that's the worst part of it is that private insurance companies continue to be a part of the health scheme. Everybody keeps saying we don't want the government getting involved in health care - the government is involved in health care and Medicare and it works!" Scheiner said.
In a balanced report, Scheiner's attack on private insurers would have been a followed by a statement or representative from the insurance industry. Acosta didn't produce one. Nor did he point out that since 1970, the cost of Medicare has risen 34 percent more per patient "than the combined costs of all health care in America apart from Medicare and Medicaid." He also didn't question Scheiner about the problems Medicare has created for patients when doctors decide to opt out of Medicare (because of lower reimbursements and "too much" hassle).
Scheiner also criticized the public option part of Obama's plan, warning that people don't know what it is and that if it is "too good" it will be unsustainable.
"We don't even know fully what the public option is going to be. If the public option is too good patients who are sick will flock to it and I'm not sure it will be able to support itself," Scheiner said.
Free market experts have criticized public option arguing that it would supplant private insurance altogether due to an uneven playing field. When Hawaii adopted a universal health care program for children called Keiki Care, "people who were already able to afford healthcare began to stop paying for it so they could get it for free," according to Dr. Kenny Fink.
The Heritage Foundation's Greg D'Angelo said that public plans "undercut" private insurers with lower premiums from lower reimbursements to care providers. He concluded, based on Lewin Group data, that 107.6 million people could lose private employer coverage under such a plan. That number is equal to one third of the entire U.S. population.
Acosta's one-sided health care piece, although critical of ObamaCare, continued the media theme of promoting government solutions for health care.
The Business & Media Institute found in its Special Report: UnCritical Condition that the networks, ABC, CBS and NBC, spent the first six months of 2009 promoting government-run health care and ignoring the failures of similar programs like Medicare, the Massachusetts "experiment" and Keiki Care.
—Julia A. Seymour is an assistant editor for the Business & Media Institute.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Julia...glad you have this
July 30, 2009 - 16:04 ET by bigtimerJulia...glad you have this here regarding Scheiner and what his opinions are regarding this issue...I heard real early this morning on Fox that there was going to be a special alert broadcasting what he had to say from the National Press Club because he was againt O's plan, but they were inferring it was for the good side of the aisle, well, that is how I took it from the News Alert...and then nothing.
Glad you filled me in.
Just lovely...all of it...just lovely.
The far left love him...that's for sure.
Doubling down on stupid is not a particularly good idea. ~Andrew Breitbart
Medicare works? What a joke.
July 30, 2009 - 17:21 ET by Gary HallReally? Let's see. Other than Medicare being expected to run short of funds in the area of $27-$32 Trillion in future years, just what is it about Medicare that works?
Take Dr. Juan Sotomayor, Judge Sonia Sotomayor's brother. His health care clinic in NY doesn't accept Medicare or Medicaid patients.
In large areas of the country, seniors on Medicare can't find a Medicare assigned physician or facility.
Besides, Medicare has simply never been a comprehensive health care plan - it's has huge gaps in coverage; that's why when seniors sign up for Medicare Part A, and pay for Medicare Part B, and Medicare Part D, they run out and have to find a Medicare supplement plan to cover the gaps in medicare Part A and B. Guess who they get the supplement plan from? The government? Noooo - from private insurers... picking up the pieces from the inept government run health plan for seniors.
(;~/ gary
The far left won't support a plan unless it shuts down private..
July 30, 2009 - 19:41 ET by R D Helm...insurers on day one and throws all their officers in the slammer.
-Dave
Dave because in the new
July 30, 2009 - 19:45 ET by Radical1979Dave because in the new world order only politicians are allowed to make money any more.
I'm shocked this old Socialst Doctor
July 30, 2009 - 20:09 ET by Delsawho voted for his favorite socialist candidate is surprised the SOBama plan doesn't go far enough.
No I'm not.
Not really.
Question. Did SOBama hang out with anyone who wasn't a socialist or marxist or communist?
Just asking?
Barack Obama Where are the Jobs you promised?
July 30, 2009 - 20:47 ET by Retired GeekPeople are losing ObamaHope Today.
Barack Obama promised 2.5 million new jobs, instead the Obama policies have cost 2.5 to 3.0 million jobs.
Americans are very resourceful people, most of whom do not live in the past or are looking for some Utopian future.
Any critical thinker knows that most Americans live in the present.
Husbands and wives are worried about buying groceries to feed their families - today.
Most Americans are worried about paying their rent or mortgage payments - today.
Most Americans are worried about paying their automobile payments - today.
When the President of the United States is focusing on creating jobs and bringing relief by stopping job losses, the American people have 'Hope' and will work with the POTUS - today.
When the President of the United States is focusing on things other than creating jobs, that would bring immediate relief, they begin to lose 'Hope', they have nothing to cling too - today.
Most American workers are beginning to understand the Barack Obama policies that are destroying jobs, while they suffer job loss - today.
Families are beginning to tell their children there is NO money for Cheer Leading, dates, sporting events and other curricular activities - today.
Americans are beginning to have phone calls from creditors demanding money they do not have - today.
Millions of Americans are idly sitting around and asking themselves, where are the jobs Obama promised and why isn't he focusing on jobs - today?
Personal Survival is one of mankind's strongest instincts - humans will stampede over anyone and everyone who gets in the way - today.