The
AP is breaking another non-story. The headline: "
Many Defendants' Cases Kept Secret"
Despite the Sixth Amendment's guarantee of public trials, nearly all records are being kept secret for more than 5,000 defendants who completed their journey through the federal courts over the last three years.
And right on cue, they blame Bush.
The data show a sharp increase in secret case files over time as the Bush administration's well-documented reliance on secrecy in the executive branch has crept into the federal courts through the war on drugs, anti-terrorism efforts and other criminal matters."This follows the pattern of this administration," said John Wesley Hall, an Arkansas defense attorney and second vice president of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.
The second most popular anti-Bush meme, behind the "Bush lied" screed, is the "secret government" line. So this story sounds like a big deal, right? The evil Bush administration is secretly locking people up and the Sixth Amendment is getting shredded all to hell.
Of course not. In fact, the story itself shows that this isn't newsworthy information. Here are these two highly relevant items from the article:
An Associated Press investigation found, and court observers agree, that most of these defendants are cooperating government witnesses
But the AP investigation found, and court observers agree, that the overwhelming number of these cases sealed for a limited time involve a use of secrecy that draws no criticism.
On top of that, look at the statistics they used to build this case of a "widespread pattern of secrecy in the Bush administration":
Recent Comments
29 sec ago
38 sec ago
1 min 2 sec ago
1 min 4 sec ago
2 min 8 sec ago
2 min 28 sec ago
3 min 37 sec ago
3 min 46 sec ago
4 min 5 sec ago
4 min 21 sec ago