On Today: Glenn Beck Beats Back Meredith Vieira's Charge of Hate Talk
Fox News host Glenn Beck showed up on Wednesday's Today show to promote his new book The 7: Seven Wonders That Will Change Your Life, but it was NBC's Meredith Vieira's misperceptions of him and conservatives as a whole that Beck was forced to try to change. After an initial discussion about Beck overcoming his personal struggles, Vieira brought Beck into the debate over whether conservative talk provoked the Tuscon shooter Jared Loughner, as she charged: "You talk about spewing anger in your personal life but also in your professional life, Glenn. I mean there are people who've criticized you and said...you're part of the problem in terms of anger...you've added to this dialogue of hatred."
Beck deftly responded that anything he may have said was not any worse than what Vieira has heard from the likes of Jon Stewart or on The Simpsons, as seen in this fiery exchange:
(video, audio, and transcript after the jump)
MEREDITH VIEIRA: You've said things like and this is, I guess, where the critics come into play and say you've added to this dialogue of hatred... Some things that you have said in the past, just to get them out there and you know this. That the...
BECK: Do you, wait, wait, do you really think that people really don't know the things that I say?
VIEIRA: I think some people do, some people don't. A lot of people do.
BECK: Okay.
VIEIRA: I'm just, I'm ticking off a couple of them. That the President was a racist. You, you said, at one point, you were joking around, that you wanted to poison Nancy Pelosi. You wanted to beat Congressman Charlie Rangel to death with a shovel. In the spirit of this book-
BECK: Like eight years ago.
VIEIRA: In the - that doesn't matter. It's in the past. I understand that. But in the spirit of this book, do you regret that stuff now – having gone through this crisis – say you know what, that was dumb?
BECK: I regret that anything that I said - let me, let me give you this. Anything that I said in jokes? No. Ask Jon Stewart, ask The Simpsons okay?
A little later Beck, appearing with his co-author Dr. Keith Ablow, gave the Today co-anchor some much needed historical perspective on American political discourse:
BECK: Just like Thomas Jefferson and John Adams went back and forth. John Adams was called a hermaphrodite by Thomas Jefferson. Adams responded and said [about] Jefferson, "Your children will be raped and your towns will be burned if he becomes the President." Let's keep political discourse in context of history. Children weren't raped. Nobody killed each other. We have to fix the individual. The problem in Tucson was the individual. Look at the individual and be responsible for ourselves.
Vieira, undeterred from her line of questioning, then asked Beck to comment on Sarah Palin's "blood libel" comment, but Beck, again turned it around, saying the focus of blame in the Tuscon shooting should be on the one individual who actually did physical harm.
VIEIRA: So the controversy around Sarah Palin and when she used that term "Blood libel" what are your feelings about that?
BECK: I think, I think, again, political discourse is dicey sometimes. People don't like it. When the President said, what was it he said? "If the Republicans bring a knife I'm gonna bring a gun." Did he mean that or was that political discourse? He didn't mean that. Let's, let's put things in perspective. Let's stop dancing around the corners and, and looking at Republicans and Democrats and let's start to find real answers. And the real answers are the, are the principles that you will find in this book that will change you. Just change yourself. Don't worry about anybody else. Change you.
The following is a transcript of the relevant exchange as it was aired on the January 19 Today show:
MEREDITH VIEIRA: But you, you talk about spewing anger in your personal life but also in your professional life, Glenn. I mean there are people who've criticized you and said that you're, you're, part of the problem in terms of anger.
GLENN BECK: No, I know.
VIEIRA: Let me just finish the thought.
DR. KEITH ABLOW: You know what I have people in my office who tell me that too, by the way, Meredith. I think that there is a corollary, parallel here. If you're the therapist for a country you have to tell the truth and it can-
VIEIRA: But there's a difference between telling the truth-
ABLOW: -kind of set people back on their heels.
VIEIRA: Yeah but there's a difference-
ABLOW: You're an alcoholic, I say to someone-
VIEIRA: Right.
ABLOW: He says to the country "you're drunk."
VIEIRA: But, but you say more than that. You've said things like and this is, I guess, where the critics come into play and say you've added to this dialogue of hatred.
BECK: Meredith, I can tell you right now that-
VIEIRA: Let me just finish the thought, okay?
BECK: Yeah go ahead, go ahead.
VIEIRA: Some things that you have said in the past, just to get them out there and you know this. That the...
BECK: Do you, wait, wait, do you really think that people really don't know the things that I say?
VIEIRA: I think some people do, some people don't A lot of people do.
BECK: Okay.
VIEIRA: I'm just, I'm ticking off a couple of them. That the President was a racist. You, you said, at one point, you were joking around, that you wanted to poison Nancy Pelosi. You wanted to beat Congressman Charlie Rangel to death with a shovel. In the spirit of this book-
BECK: Like eight years ago.
VIEIRA: In the - that doesn't matter. It's in the past. I understand that. But in the spirit of this book, do you regret that stuff now – having gone through this crisis – say you know what, that was dumb?
BECK: I regret that anything that I said - let me, let me give you this. Anything that I said in jokes? No. Ask Jon Stewart, ask The Simpsons okay?
VIEIRA: You don't think that, that contributes at all to a climate of anger or hate?
BECK: No, I think. No, ask Jon Stewart that question. Ask The Simpsons-
VIEIRA: But I'm asking you that question.
BECK: But I'm saying if you ask that question, to those guys, I think you'll get the same answer. No. Comedy is comedy. When there is, and this is why the lines become very blurred and it's very, it's very difficult to do what I do. Anything that I've said, like with the President, I've apologized for and I've explained several times. That's not where we-
VIEIRA: Have you shifted your lines at all?
BECK: No! You know one thing the media doesn't seem to pick up on is, when I started the 9/12 Project what was it?
ABLOW: It was about honor. I mean the line has been the same. Honoring your principles and values.
BECK: Principles and values. It wasn't the Tea Party. 9/12 Project, which I started, was okay find out what you believe. Educate yourself. Go into your principles and values and make sure those principles and values are there to guide you. 8/28 - everyone said it was gonna be a hate fest. That I was just gonna be a monster. And what was it? It was about honor. There wasn't a word of politics.
VIEIRA: But let me just, again, because this book is about finding your truth and, and owning it do you feel, do you look back over and say, "Yeah I've, there are places where I've crossed the line and I have to readjust the way, the discourse?"
BECK: Absolutely, absolutely! Absolutely. You're not human if you don't look back and say that was a mistake, that was a mistake.
VIEIRA: Like what? What are the mistakes you've made that you think that you say, "Geesh I wish I hadn't done that."
BECK: Let me, let me answer it this way. Back - we, we have such an interesting view of history. Political discourse is sometimes really in your face. Telling somebody that you've got a real problem, sometimes you really get into their face.
ABLOW: You have to.
BECK: Just like Thomas Jefferson and John Adams went back and forth. John Adams was called a hermaphrodite by Thomas Jefferson. Adams responded and said [about] Jefferson, "Your children will be raped and your towns will be burned if he becomes the President." Let's keep political discourse in context of history. Children weren't raped. Nobody killed each other. We have to fix the individual. The problem in Tucson was the individual. Look at the individual and be responsible for ourselves.
VIEIRA: So the controversy around Sarah Palin and when she used that term "Blood libel" what are your feelings about that?
BECK: I think, I think, again, political discourse is dicey sometimes. People don't like it. When the President said, what was it he said? "If the Republicans bring a knife I'm gonna bring a gun." Did he mean that or was that political discourse? He didn't mean that. Let's, let's put things in perspective. Let's stop dancing around the corners and, and looking at Republicans and Democrats and let's start to find real answers. And the real answers are the, are the principles that you will find in this book that will change you. Just change yourself. Don't worry about anybody else. Change you.
—Geoffrey Dickens is the Senior News Analyst at the Media Research Center. You can follow him on Twitter here
- Geoffrey Dickens's blog
- Login to post comments
















Comments
Should have asked her
Submitted by Model850 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:22pm.
Beck should have asked Vieira if the media regrets trotting out the "heated right wing rhetoric" meme immediately after the Tucson shooting, now that it's been shown that political rhetoric had absolutely nothing to do with it.
It would have gone right over
Submitted by WarEagle66 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 2:39pm.
It would have gone right over her head. She was there banging the Liberal Drum.
Nothing Beck could have said, or asked, would have stopped her from...."finishing her point".
Maybe her point was...
Submitted by KyWriter on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 5:05pm.
...she herself is a Liberal Drum who needs banging. Or at least something to staunch her monotonous yapping.
the truth has no agenda...
Submitted by ds7 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:26pm.
beck doesn't have to explain himself to the self-serving trolls in the legacy media.
the truth either resonates with you or you try and spin it so it doesn't upset your precious "feelings."
the liberals don't have any moral compass or sense of purpose, they just want to "feel" warm and fuzzy.
we turn off your news programs, reject your america-hating hollywood entertainment conglomerate and resist the indoctrination of the youth through the propaganda taught in your failing public schools and laughable university system.
we know who you are, and we don't like you.
Viera,et al
Submitted by iveseenitall on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:30pm.
Isn't it interesting that this kind of grilling from the left is always directed toward people with whom they disagree. Never heard Viera and her ilk grilling reps of the Daily Kos or people like Olberman and Matthews who spew their hatred day after day. After the 2000 election of President Bush and V.P. Cheney hate-filled rhetoric from the left began with a vengeance and hasn't stopped since. And I dare say that it will never stop. So as the hypocritic left takes the "high road", their questioning of hate rings hollow. Hatred, to them, is a one-way street and their fingers are always pointed outward, not towards themselves. That would be too honest a reponse. Sickening!
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal" (progressive)
I don't care who you are,that's funny.
Submitted by the struggler on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:30pm.
Speaking of shovel beat-downs.One day Dad caught his shirt on fire messing with model airplane fuel and Grandpa put the flames out with a coal shovel.LOL.Dad was black and blue for a week.
it doesn;'t matter
Submitted by dmaley1714 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:38pm.
Viera says it all in one sentence. "it doesn't matter" she does not care about context , timing , the truth, she only cares about her agenda
That's exactly right
Submitted by Galvanic on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 6:04pm.
No explanations or context are necessary, because they don't matter.
Man........
Submitted by almostacowboy on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:42pm.
...the compromising positions people will put themselves into to sell a book.
Talk to me about "honor" some more, Glenn.
So confronting your enemies has no honor?
Submitted by hbnolikeee on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:07pm.
I guess you prefer to scurry away and hide in a corner.
I feel dirty...
Submitted by bigdaddy on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:54pm.
...I have to confess that I watch 5-10 minutes of Ed "The Red" Schultz's show each day just on the outside chance that the vein popping out on his five head will explode on screen...
Hate to admit it,
Submitted by American.Patriot on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:35pm.
But I watch a few minutes to see what crap he's spewing. I'm concerned that it could spike his ratings to an all time high of 4 viewers...splat
Submitted by Burgher on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:58pm.
I agree Scanners was a great flick
I wish people would go on
Submitted by shannon76 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 12:57pm.
I wish people would go on these shows and call the hosts and interviewers out on their biases. If you're on the air with Norah O'Donnell or Diane Sawyer or Christianne Amanpour or George Stephanopolous or Katie Couric-- anyone pretending to be a straight journalist -- just say, 'Hey, you voted for Obama, right?' or 'Hey, you carried water for Obama's campaign didn't you? You wanted him to win: just admit it. Why'd you do it?' 'Why are you pretending to be straigh news when you're clearly a propagandist??"
I'd love that. John Ziegler did it against Contessa Brewer. I love those moments when someone throws Chris Matthews' thrill/tingle back in his face. He gets so visibly annoyed (e.g. Michelle Bachman on election night 2010)
You took the words right out of my mouth
Submitted by ProudAmerican58 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 2:08pm.
Just get out there and tell the truth. Even if people like Vierra aren't really listening, I'm sure there are plenty of viewers out there who are.
If they can, the bad guys
Submitted by Wawaashkeshi on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 2:59pm.
If they can, the bad guys always cut out any part of an interview that doesn't fit their pre ordained agenda. Great for Michelle Bachman! I loved the look on tingle-boys face when she hit him with the first over hand right!
Casting pearls
Submitted by holeinthehull on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:00pm.
Glenn Beck knew going in that this haggy eyed looking liberal was going to attack him at the right moment. She could not stay on point. If you watch her it looks like her body movements were those of a leopard getting ready to pounce.
All I can say is what I said in my blog
Do not cast your pearls before swine or the unholy
www.holeinthehull.com
Controversy.....? To who ?
Submitted by NeoKong on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:01pm.
VIEIRA: So the controversy around Sarah Palin and when she used that term "Blood libel" what are your feelings about that?
Right there is where Beck could have made her look like a fool by asking her to explain exactly why that was controversial and to whom. All it ever was was a bunch of left-wing media hacks who were still in a froth to get Sarah Palin. The real controversy of that whole episiode was the lamestream media's shameless attempt to attach the Tuscon shootings to Sarah Palin.But let me just, again,
Submitted by StarAZ on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:12pm.
But let me just, again, because this book is about finding your truth and, and owning it do you feel, do you look back over and say, "Yeah I've, there are places where I've crossed the line and I have to readjust the way, the discourse?" Ask yourself this, Meredith--this whole interview was you interviewing yourself about how much YOU thought Beck fostered a climate of hate. I bet you don't even listen to him. Usually the people who know the most about Fox would never lower themselves...and they even say it!True colors are shining through.
Submitted by Ashrak on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:24pm.
Many people who have heard about Glenn, but never heard Glenn himself found themselves puzzled this morning. Cindi was singing loudly, or sure.
Glad he didn't say he was wrong
Submitted by Master-of-Disaster on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:40pm.
I was glad he never directly said he was wrong. Conservatives have got to quit saying they are sorry. A Conservative screws up and they are gone. The problem now is conservatives don't even stand up for themselves or others any more. They just roll over like the GOP and Christine O'Donnel. The minute a liberal says "Aren't you worng?" and we admit it, they take that as they are right which is NEVER right. Conservatives need to break the habit, quit being so damned codependent on the liberals and their media. You cannot win with them and they will betray you at the drop of a hat ala John McCain. What is with that? I love Beck and his journey, which is what it is, is far from over and inspirational to watch. Of course that and 50 cents won't get me a cup of coffee but it is enough to know he is out there and folks can glean some truth from his efforts. Stay off the MSM, no one is watching them anyway.
ticking off a list of them?
Submitted by Hoosier Conservative on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:42pm.
How is Veira sitting there ticking off a list of Beck's greatest hits? Does she listen to his radio show all the time to hear these things? More likely her staff found a list on Media Matters and told her to memorize it. Then she sits there and she's not even listening, she just wants to tell him off no matter how he answers. That was not an interview, it was an ambush. Maybe one day Beck will learn not to do that.
And she still doesnt get it.
Submitted by Utherpend on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 1:54pm.
And she still doesnt get it.
The first thing...
Submitted by Thors screwdriver on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 2:11pm.
Before answering the question the first thing that should be stated: "First, I would like to clear one thing up in the interest of civility within political discourse, do you, Merideth Viera, publicly denounce the outlandish and slanderous lies that were continually spewed on The View, the disgusting vitriol that the sitting President of the United States, George W. Bush was responsible for the deaths of over 3000 human beings as put forth in the movie ‘Fahrenheit 911’, by Michael Moore and as also as repeatedly argued by The View co-host at the time, Rosie O’Donnell. These same things that appear to have, at least indirectly caused the troubled mind of this murderer to perpetrate these crimes. Do you denounce this movie, these ideas, Michael Moore and Rosie O'Donnell? Yes or no.
A similar statement could/should be made for any of the hosts/talking heads/ journo-lists who have spewed their own hate that is suddenly so 'out of fashion'.
Who the heck is this Vieira nut-case?
Submitted by Neox99 on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 2:21pm.
I've never seen/heard her before now.
Two words come to mind - Duh! and Wooooosh!
He was only funnin'?
Submitted by Tomorama on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 2:56pm.
I did notice when someone on the alphabet shows....... actually ANY FN ONE, points out Oblunder and his "heated rhetoric" these jowhorenalists" never have anything to say.
But the the coward in chief got to come out and read a speech written by someone else and he is "above the fray and a great leader" all of a sudden.
Bullshit.
Has Vieira ever had on and challenged Schultz, Olbiedog, Obama.
Submitted by Gary Hall on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 3:39pm.
Has Vieira ever had on and challenged Schultz, Olbiedog, Obama. ...
Congressman Pete Stark, Mike Malloy, Chris Matthews, O'Donnell, Maddow, Congresswoman Karen Bass, Randi Rhodes, Schuster, Bill Maher, Sean Penn, Bill Clinton, .. OK, I don't need to go on - as there are hundreds of national names who's name calling, angry vitriol, or wish for the death of others make Beck seem like a pussy cat.
I think Beck was trying to get her in that conversation - wished he'd just laid out the examples and pounded her with the question, "Why don't you and the rest of the national MSM challenge your own, first?"
(;~/ gary
Please repeat after me, Vieira is a leftist Democrat hack!
Submitted by Rush Fan on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 5:55pm.
One more time. Vieira is a leftist .......Feelings, nothing but feelings.....
Submitted by sheik yermami on Wed, 01/19/2011 - 7:20pm.
VIEIRA: So the controversy around Sarah Palin and when she used that term "Blood libel" what are your feelings about that?
With libturds, its never about substance. Its always about feelings. THEIR feelings......
Beck Tries To Whitewash His History Of Calling Obama Racist
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 6:15am.
Beck Tries To Whitewash His History Of Calling Obama RacistGlenn Beck made the laughably false claim that he only made "one comment, one time" accusing President Obama of being racist, adding, "and I made it early in the morning." In fact, Beck has repeatedly accused Obama of racism and of using the presidency to "settle old racial scores."
http://mediamatters.org/research/201101190052
B......F......D
Submitted by sentry_99 on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 7:44am.
No one cares. There's the door, don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out. Oh and take your media matters trash with you.
On Today: Glenn Beck FAILS Back Meredith Vieira's Charge of Hate
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 8:54am.
Basically, the only way that Beck could defend himself was to argue that his vicious comments were Comedy.
So his Repugnant statements against George Soros were actually Comedy.
Thanks John
Submitted by sentry_99 on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:10am.
We always appreciate trolls who use the same username on every site they spew their lefty garbage. Always lets us know how idiotic they are. I like your comment here. We can only hope you actually did a bit more research and are not still so uninformed.
Thank you
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:22am.
I appreciate your appreciation. I did enjoy creating the ' Laughner is Tim McVeigh TNG ' remark.
IT LEARNS
Submitted by sentry_99 on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:30am.
Glad to see you found that reply button.
As far as your comment goes, I like how you completely left out the Communist Manifesto and picking out one small part of the "poetry class ramble" to make him seem extreme pro-life. I'm not sure where you got he hates non-English speakers but why would you cite anything?
Johnny Boy Fontaine---
Submitted by matthewdean on Fri, 01/21/2011 - 2:40am.
"Basically, the only way Beck could defend himself was to argue that his vicious comments were comedy".
Sorry, Junior, but you have Beck confused with Jon Stewart.
MD
B......F......D : Sorr
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 8:58am.
B......F......D :Sorry that you Loathe the First Amendment. Do you also want to burn the Flag?
Leave it to a Liberal
Submitted by sentry_99 on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:01am.
Only a lefty could construe me not caring what some far left hack site like Media Matters thinks with loathing the 1st Amendment and asking if I want to burn the flag. I suppose you think crosshairs on a map is directly related to violent actions?
Re: Beck Tries To Whitewash His History Of Calling Obama Racist
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:15am.
Sentry 99 :
Is it that you don't care or rather that you neither debate nor debunk Media Matters accusations against Glenn Beck regarding ' Beck Tries To Whitewash His History Of Calling Obama Racist ' http://mediamatters.org/research/201101190052 because they are absolutely True?
Obama has done some strange things
Submitted by shawn. on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:28am.
Saying the police acted stupidly during the whole Gates break in and his AG dismissing the Black Panther voter intimidation issue. Seems Obama does seem use race in his decisions.Re : Obama has done some strange things
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 10:32am.
Did you mention something about race??
You may want to read : Was Glenn Beck's George Soros Takedown Anti-Semitic? By Alex Eichler
Some advice for John Bryans Fontaine
Submitted by Hoosier Conservative on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 10:51am.
Posting links to articles that begin as questions will not help your cause very much. And posting links to Media Matters won't get you anywhere at all. There is is really great idea called using credible sources. You should look into it.
They are
Submitted by sentry_99 on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:18am.
and still no one cares. Good for you. Beck called Obama racist and....................................the crickets keep chirping, the world keeps turning and only Media Matters and thier liberal drones care. If you wanted to actually debate something, talk to Beck about why he thinks Obama is racist and debate the merits of that rather than nitpicking about a "whitewash". You may have problems though since you seem unable to click on reply and instead keep making new posts. Babysteps I guess. I will show you in the next post. Even chatting with you makes one dumber.
Good News!
Submitted by John Bryans Fontaine on Thu, 01/20/2011 - 9:43am.
Hello Sentry_99 :
First, my apologies for questioning your patriotism. I am sure that there are things which we both admire about America : rock and roll ?, Ford Mustangs ? Chevy Corvettes ? , the new Caddy CTS Coupe, Eva Mendes ?
Regarding Glenn Beck, I have started posting ( a lot ) on his site glennbeck :
http://www.glennbeck.com/2011/01/03/in-2011-can-we-finally-focus-on-jobs/
http://www.glennbeck.com/2011/01/04/glenn-beck-fundamental-transformation/
http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/198/47856/
http://www.glennbeck.com/2011/01/18/the-solutions-come-from-within/
http://www.glennbeck.com/content/blog/stu/the-most-hateful-rhetoric-possible/
More of my Liberal Rants can be found by googling johnbryansfontaine and huffingtonpost
Liberally yours,
JBF