Vieira Uses Gramm to Disqualify McCain's Ability to 'Lead Us Out of Recession'

Photo of Geoffrey Dickens.

Even though the United States is still technically not in a recession, NBC's Meredith Vieira doubted John McCain's ability "to lead us out of a recession," on Monday's "Today" show. Vieira pointed to McCain's former economic adviser Phil Gramm's "mental recession" comment as a reason to "question" McCain's "judgment," when the Republican presidential candidate appeared on the July 21 "Today" show:

MEREDITH VIEIRA: You know you said, "In a time of war a commander-in-chief's job doesn't get a learning curve," but we are facing a crisis here, domestically, that a lot of people consider more significant in their lives right now, than the war, and that is the economic crisis. You have admitted that your economic policy is a weakness for you, so do you deserve a learning curve, to get up to speed?

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

JOHN MCCAIN: Actually I have far more experience on the economy than Senator Obama. I'm very strong on the economy. I was chairman of the Senate Commerce committee, Science and Transportation, which addresses all these issues. I have a concrete economic plan to fix the problems in America including energy and off-shore drilling. Including the fact that I have nuclear power-

VIEIRA: But look at the man who has established that plan for you, Phil Gramm, who recently called this, "a mental recession."

MCCAIN: -and, and, and hydrogen. Oxy-, uh, hydrogen, hybrid fuels. All kinds of nuclear power. I have plans for all of those and I'm confident we can succeed. Americans working together on a mission to fix our economy, keep them in their homes become energy independent. And I have a strong plan of action, a strong background on the economy to address these issues.

VIEIRA: But Senator, if I can bring up Phil Gramm again. That was your key economic adviser and the framer of your policy until what he called what's happening here, "a mental recession," and that we are "a nation of whiners." He has since stepped down, removed himself from your campaign. But do voters have a right to question your judgment because you said he was the, "strongest person you knew on economic issues." Should they be worried about your ability to lead us out of recession.

MCCAIN: Actually he was one of a number of advisers that I have, that I value their, their views and their, and their opinions and I have a very strong plan of action for our economy. I think most Americans agree with it, including off-shore drilling, which Senator Obama opposes. Including nuclear power , which Senator Obama opposed. I have a strong keep taxes low, we have a very strong economic policy. We're talking about it in town hall meetings all over America. And I've invited Senator Obama to come to these town hall meetings with me and that way people can compare us on these issues that are so important to their, to the future and economy and the future of this nation and I'm proud to have a broad array, including 300 economists and five Nobel Prize winners that say my economic plan is very good.

VIEIRA: Alright Senator John McCain, as always, thank you for giving us your time this morning.

—Geoffrey Dickens is the senior news analyst at the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

if I were McCain I would

if I were McCain I would have immediatly taken Merideth's little premise and asked her since Barak Obama was against the war on terror, against the surge, wouldn't that automatically disqualify him to be commander in chief.  I then would have pointed out that he is against drilling for oil in a time where demand exceeds supply.  merideth, by your premise Obama has no business being President.

DOW

Anyone know where the DOW stood at the close of last week compared to 2002?

%05 niag

JDW

SAPPY NEWS

DAILY WAVE

This is what happens when you allow

game show hosts to become "news" people.

LOL. true. But I actually

LOL. true. But I actually saw this one and could say that McCain won this one. I thought she sounded ridiculous.

I agree with Vieira. Of

I agree with Vieira. Of course McCain can't lead us out of a recession.

Because we're not IN one.

Right

 

But McCain can  still lead us into a recession, he has those kind of leadership skills.

How?

Explain how. A president has virtually no legislative authority apart from a veto or a symbolic executive order.

She's got nerve even using the term 'learning curve'

Vieira: "Do you (McCain) 'deserve' a learning curve?"

Keep reminding yourself that this twit's former gig was on everyone's favorite estrogen-soaked, ultra-liberal cluckfest The View.

Just watching her on the Today show pretending to be a knowledgeable hard-hitting interviewer results in a mental recession itself.

Would she ask Obama if he

Would she ask Obama if he deserved a learning curve on foreign policy and/or military matters?  Uhhhhhhh, I'm gonna think about it awhile and say NO!

You're Not Listening Here

It seems that every interview McCain has these days, the host claims that he says he is weak on the economy.  And every time he responds, "NO, I am very strong".  Ok, while it might not be his strongest field, his position is still stronger than Obama's.  So why aren't the MSM listening here?  Oh, I forgot, they first of all only hear what they want to hear and second, they love to talk about McCain weaknesses, whether real or perceived.  Never do they compare just how strong his weaker points are with Obama's points.

A lot of what Gramm said is true, it's just that a Presidential candidate can't say it.  He would never get elected.

Running with liberal assumptions

This is the same reason why Bush never admitted mistakes to the news media ... because they would run with the "confession" as a way to invalidate everything else you say. McCain's original quote, like the one about being in Iraq for a hundred years, was stripped of any context and became the incessant talking point for Democrats and the media for months. We've learned from experience that you don't give liberals an inch, because they take a mile. 

  • Notice that Vieira started with the premise that McCain was "weak" on the economy. That wasn't because she had done some homework and evaluated McCain's experience ... she just leaped to conclusions based on that one quote.
  • Vieira's deeper political assumption is that economic leaders are supposed to over-emote about the plight of the poor. And if they don't, they're charged with not being "empathetic," and that somehow disqualifies them from making sound economic policy. Look, if the airplane is plummeting down, I don't want the pilots to empathize with my fear -- I want them to fly the damned plane. The economy doesn't need any empathy right now. We need hard-headed leadership, and (pun intended) if anyone qualifies as that, it's Phil Gramm.
  • And for my two cents worth ... McCain shouldn't have ditched Gramm the moment he said something the media didn't like. Instead, McCain should have said that Gramm spoke out of turn, and that he, McCain, does appreciate the tough times people are having now. He should have left it at that. Instead, by dropping Gramm so quickly, he just surrendered to the media's perception.

As for Vieira, shallow is as shallow does.

"We need hard-headed

"We need hard-headed leadership..."

I couldn't agree more. But what you suggest is the antithesis of the prevailing collective mentality of this Republic.

Stoicism is something to be abhorred by these people. It is like a cross to a vampire. That Gramm had the audacity to suggest that people should get a grip on themselves, all they can do is screech and hiss, and not even bother to actually think about what he said.

It must be a very strange place in their little minds... to live in a constant state of fear, anger, and uncertainty... and to completely remove one's ability of self-possession and self-determination.

The more I think about it, it's not a system of representational democracy. It is simply mass manipulation of weak minds.

Yeah. I got the Monday grouchies.

Given a choice

Given a choice between a surgeon with a smooth bedside manner but wobbly hands, versus a cocky prima donna who can slice with the best of 'em, who do you pick?

That's right. You just keep the prima donna in the operating room but away from the bed. That's what McCain should have done with Gramm.

It's interesting that the

It's interesting that the two men we have to "choose" from both have the propensity to throw followers (and family members) under the bus when things get slightly heated. And this is considered a virtue.

And then we are endlessly conditioned by popular culture to "hate" Bush, who has a reputation of being loyal to his people, even to the point of burning his limited political capital (and trust me, I'm no fan of Bush - but give the devil his due).

Meredith Vieira - Curveless

Meredith Vieira's learning curve as a TV "journalist" has yet to budge above that flat line on the X-axis.

   Barack is in Iraq with

   Barack is in Iraq with the three network anchors babysitting him and John McCain went to an interview on NBC.  Which shows the greater political courage and confidence?

Certainly McCain, who has

Certainly McCain, who has been to Iraq numerous times and has shown he is in touch with the reality on the ground, going to a hostile interview takes more political courage than the 24 hour photo op Osama is making with his press team.  It is almost comical the extent which Barak's trip to Iraq is being so hyped and played up by the msm.  I guess since he has been saying things are so bad there it will be news when he has to eat crow and acknowledge we have won.  Somehow how I doubt that will be covered.  Although, Barry is showing some political courage by changing his stance and adopting President Bush's foreign policy which you would think would outrage his base.

Vieira is plain ignorant.

Vieira is plain ignorant. If we were in a recession, Phil Gramm would be exactly the one we'd need to lead us out of it. I guess Vieira has no idea who Phil Gramm is. Someone needs to inform her that Sen Gramm had another job before he got elected. Then again if I were a TV host I too wouldn't think someone with a Phd. in economics would know a thing about the economy.

I wonder if there was someone like Vieira around in 1805 that said Meriwether Lewis? Nah, he's not the one to lead us across this country.

Women

Compare the females on FOX to general media. Why the overwhelming difference?

JDW

SAPPY NEWS

DAILY WAVE

Isn't it amazing how little

Isn't it amazing how little time it took for the economy to become a "crisis"?

To the MSM, every difficulty is a crisis.  They throw the word so often that it has lost all meaning.

 

 

I didn't think it was physically possible, but this both sucks and blows. -Bart Simpson

Vieira is only catering to

Vieira is only catering to the Today Show's core audience...fat, unemployed losers who want to blame others for their personal failings.  When Matt and Meredith need to kill time between segments on makeup tips and Lindsey Lohan gossip, they run phony interviews to make themselves feel intelligent.  Using DNC bullet points as a script, they certainly feel a lot more intelligent than they are.

"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -Ronald Reagan

fitzfong.blogspot.com