Over at the Intellectual Conservative, writer Gary Larson discusses what he discovered when viewing an episode of PBS's "History Detectives":
Entertaining, a smidgen on the shaggy-dog side, the PBS program showcases four academic “detectives” traipsing around the country tracking down arcane histories of assorted relics. It’s a fun program, a fast hour of delicious cotton candy for us history buffs.
It leads us down paths of little discoveries — a shard of bone, a piece of flag, some old cannon ball. Then a “detective” tells us what parts they played in history, if at all. The joy of watching is in the journey.
At the end of each segment, for no discernable reason, a “detective” offers his or her brief uptake, presumably on the subject at hand. Beware. Sometimes it swerves hard left, straight into latte liberal la la land. Revisionism never had it so good.
“Detective” C. Wesley (Wes) Cowan used his brief commentary in a July episode to rip the war. Spewing the usual defeatist jeers (“a mistake,” etc.), Cowan delivers lines in the style of CBS-TV’s Andy Rooney: Cheap shots, drive-by editorializing, strictly partisan; no mature analysis. Hubris reigns; anyone who disagrees can go jump in the lake.
Cowan offers that if only his hero, Sen. John F. Kerry, had won the election, oh, what a wonderful world it would be. Fair enough. Give him that. But what stopped us was his smug, fallacious take-down of the Swift Boat Vets and POWS for Truth — except Cowan did not mention the POWs.
If you did not catch Cowan’s sour-faced invective in Episode #503, you never will. His commentary has been snuffed out by his producers, something of a reverse Orwellian memory hole.
In the original, Cowan said the Swift Boats Vets “smeared Sen. Kerry‘s military record.” In this he emulates leftist ideologues, such as Moyers and other livid anti-war freaks of our times, invoking falsehoods to underscore their arguments.
The full original line, which PBS admits -- even though they've since changed it in the episode -- was "Funded by a wealthy Republican campaign donor, the group smeared Kerry's military record, and possibly cost him the election." Why was the line edited? Because Larson wrote to PBS voicing his complaints as to the characterization of the Swift Boat Vets/POWs. Larson didn't think he would get much satisfaction when he wrote the letter, but, lo and behold, PBS replied and informed him as to the change they made:
REPLACEMENT LINE: "THE GROUP QUESTIONED KERRY’S MILITARY RECORD, AND ACCORDING TO SOME ACCOUNTS, HELPED CONTRIBUTE TO HIS DEFEAT IN 2004."
Bravo to Larson for calling PBS out. As a taxpayer-supported endeavor, it is quite reasonable for viewers to expect Public Broadcasting to be as free of bias as possible.
(Thanks to Newsbusters reader Joe Easley for the story tip!)
—D. S. Hube is an educator and a member of the National Association of Scholars. He blogs regularly at The Colossus of Rhodey.















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
If only PBS was responsible
September 17, 2007 - 16:52 ET by ThisnThatWhere have the adults gone? There should be no reason for anyone to have to complain to PBS to correct its blatant bias. The bias should not be introduced in the first place.
Even though PBS responded, we know that every program has to be monitored for crap like this, and it grows tiresome. And, the damage is always done with the first airing.
Thanks, though, for giving everyone direct evidence of this obvious liberal mindset. It's everywhere.
___________________________________
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber
Another PBS Show
September 17, 2007 - 17:04 ET by Del DolemonteAnother PBS show that displayed subtle bias was the PBS Kids' show called "Liberty's Kids", an animated series about a kid reporter during the Revolutionary War.
One of the repeated memes during the show was that a reporter's primary responsibility was to "question the government's actions".
And who did the voice of Benjamin Franklin? Why, Walter Cronkite, of course!
Brainwash 'em young. Stalin and Mao would be proud of these clowns.
The problem is that
September 17, 2007 - 16:59 ET by motherbeltThe problem is that everyone sees the first, and most never see the correction; they either do it too late, or it's buried at the end of some program or other with an "oh, by the way...."
Mark Twain said "A lie can travel half way around the world while truth is putting on its shoes."
The corollary to this (from me) would be "And by the time the truth gets out the door, no one is paying attention any more."
oh well - on to the next
September 17, 2007 - 17:06 ET by TruthMongeroh well - on to the next "mistake!"
(which will maybe be corrected somewhere later on somewhere...not sure where...if they get enough letters...and have time)
It's almost getting so you
September 17, 2007 - 17:04 ET by mattmIt's almost getting so you can't even watch a cooking show on PBS without some Leftist twist being thrown at you.
What do you mean,
September 17, 2007 - 18:45 ET by dabalWhat do you mean, "Almost"?
Watch the afternoon cartoon shows on PBS. If you can get through one episode that doesn't promote the liberal agenda, I'd be flabbergasted.
PBS cooking shows
September 17, 2007 - 18:50 ET by Cool ArrowMy favorite is "Yan Can Bundle Contributions"
~LYDSEXICS UNTIE!~
See My Post Above
September 17, 2007 - 19:17 ET by Del DolemonteAbout one such PBS 'toon.
Search for relevance
September 17, 2007 - 17:15 ET by CTHaving not seen the PBS program under discussion I searched for a reference to the subject of the program. Couldn't find it in the NewsBusters report or the original blog. Was there a basis for the anti-Bush comment in the first place or was this just another excuse to insert revisionist history?
I suggest that NewsBusters consider an edit of their post and inform us as to what was the subject of the PBS History's Detectives program.
I call the show the "The
September 17, 2007 - 22:05 ET by ahusserI call the show the "The Liberal History Detectives". Each show has at least one liberal slant episode. Most involve the evil white man and (pick one) slavery, the trail of tears, chinese expoitation by the evil white men on the railroads etc etc ad nauseum, or the evil oil companies destroyed the trolley cars and insinuated their foul smelling diesel polluting buses. There was a show about a woman, pre-civil war who had a Koran or some such twaddle, I guess to show how tolerant of muslims we should be. I wanted to like the show but the liberal slant and agenda was so blatant that it was hard to stomach. So I quit watching.
love that show but those
September 17, 2007 - 17:38 ET by pepsiman127love that show but those uber lefties always try to sneak some agenda driven comments in under the radar..im willing to put up with it because the shows content is facinating
History Detectives huh????
September 17, 2007 - 18:34 ET by Lame CherryHaving watched History Detectives a few times as a historian, I could not disagree more with Gary Larson in that program being fun or fast.
It is a program that makes a crime of the century like the murder of Lincoln so borning that watching oatmeal cook is fascinating by comparrison.
The 4 dolts who are the detectives would be better replaced by street bums who were stoned on sniffing paint for a decade as the bums would be more interesting and more brain matter involved.
Mr. Larson needs to get out more.....perhaps go to historic sites and dig around old battlefields open to digging for some real fun and something to delight the spirit in a man as his descriptions are not what that horrid program is.
He deserves full credit for busting Cowan who is brain dead, but he needs a literal existential life as there more fun things in history than watching dolts.
Perhaps he could get a Big 50 Sharps and go shoot targets as a starter in tasting vintage history.
*HIC IACET ARTORIVS REX QVONDAM REXQVE FVTVRVS
It's not enough
September 17, 2007 - 18:55 ET by pbthinkerNo matter what PBS does, it will never be enough until they start providing some balance. Now, they say what they want and, if someone criticizes it, they just might make a correction. Had there been a conservative, on this show, they could have argued the point that Kerry has yet to rebut the majority of the charges these groups made, and still hasn't made his complete service record available.
Never argue with an idiot. They'll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.
The most maddening thing
September 18, 2007 - 08:34 ET by msh1973The most maddening thing about PBS is that it is taxer payer funded...yes, you and I are helping to spread this nonsense!
Kremlin TV
September 18, 2007 - 08:37 ET by Sergeant ROCKPBS is modeled after Soviet TV programming.