An iconic child (now teen) star performs a pole dance at an awards show aimed at teens. Most of the media shrug. Welcome to Hollywood 2009.
At the Teen Choice Awards, which took place Aug. 9 and aired Aug. 10 on Fox, Miley Cyrus, the 16-year-old Disney-created star of the wildly popular "Hannah Montana," franchise performed "Party in the U.S.A." Clad in short-shorts, high-heeled boots and a tank top that revealed a black bra, Cyrus danced around a pole affixed to the top of an ice cream cart.
Admittedly, the pole moves were a small portion of her performance, but it raised the question of whether a pole belongs in any dance choreographed for a 16-year-old performing for others her age.
Cyrus' stunt, clearly designed to push decency boundaries without actually crossing them, looked more appropriate for MTV's Video Music Awards than for a show that sought the input of kids as young as 13.
Even Entertainment Weekly and the Los Angeles Times, not exactly prudes, thought Cyrus crossed the line. EW's Tim Stack wrote, Cyrus' "stripper-esque choreography, coupled with [her] questionable red-carpet attire, came off completely inappropriate and ill-advised." The Los Angeles Times' entertainment blog read, "Miley goes to far (and too low)" and advised the young singer to "focus less on her props and more on her material." Even MTV's "Hollywood Crush" blog questioned the appropriateness of Cyrus' performance.
Besides EW, the Times and "Hollywood Crush," few media outlets seemed to notice Cyrus' act - strange, since she's perhaps the most famous teenager in America, and is idolized by millions of young girls.
That idolization makes the Cyrus stunt all the more troubling. Carol Platt Liebau explored the effect of sexualized music videos on girls in her book "Prude." She argued, "When admired pop or rap stars model over-the-top sexual availability and sexual aggression ... that behavior normalizes and romanticizes the vulgarity and makes it acceptable. The repetition of the message ingrains unwholesome concepts and builds on them."
For producers though, it's okay to showcase a 16-year-old pole dancing. It's mention of nude photos that crosses the line.
Another crop of nude photos of "High School Musical" star Vanessa Hudgens surfaced on the Internet recently and provided fodder for crude comedian Dane Cook during the show. Cook, 37, called out Hudgens during his presentation of the "Choice Hottie" awards and told her, "Girl, you gots to keep your clothes on! Phones are for phone calls, girl." This line was cut from the taped broadcast, but video of it can be found on the Internet.
Nobody suggests the producers should have kept Cook's "joke" in the broadcast, especially as the show is marketed to teens. But neither should Hudgens be shielded from the consequences of her actions.
Cook's joke, and the subsequent editing it invoked, revealed an interesting dichotomy. On one hand, viewers saw a 16-year-old girl dancing with a pole in skimpy clothing. On the other, a joke made about an adult woman keeping her clothes on was cut from the broadcast.
So what's the message here? Is it that pole-dancing 16-year-olds are acceptable, but calling out adults for indecent behavior is not?
Unfortunately, the Cyrus performance and Cook's comments didn't do justice to the substance of the Teen Choice Awards, which culture warriors might find comforting.
The program allowed 13 - 19 year-olds to celebrate their favorite stars, movies, music and television shows. Despite the appearance of R-rated movies, such as the alcohol-infused Vegas caper "The Hangover," the pot-laden "Pineapple Express" and the raunchy "I Love You, Man" on the nomination list, it was the teen-friendly "Twilight" series that dominated the night with 11 wins. Vulgar comedians Kathy Griffin (who inexplicably turned up with Levi Johnston, the father of Sarah Palin's grandson) and Chelsea Handler lost to the more family-friendly George Lopez.
Disney, the company of (non-pole-dancing) Hannah Montana, "High School Musical" and the Jonas Brothers, claimed 20 awards by the end of the night for its various entertainment offerings.
Teens that voted in the Teen Choice Awards indicated that they know what is appropriate for kids their age. Now if only the adults who run the program would take the hint.
—Colleen Raezler is a research assistant at the Culture and Media Institute




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Oh come on Colleen
August 12, 2009 - 09:34 ET by shawn228So she danced around a pole, it was probably to keep her from falling off the ice cream truck. Her outfit is what millions of teens wear to the mall and nothing wrong with her performance. Sorry this is making a mountain out of a molehill.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
There was no true pole
August 12, 2009 - 09:52 ET by balboaThere was no true pole dancing here. It was more an awkward prop for that cart-thing...whatever that was. But clearly they didn't mind the _suggestion_ of a stripper pole.
Miley is stuck in that weird middle ground where she wants tweens to still dig her, but she wants to move on. So anything she does that's not tween-approved is judged harshly.
Prostitots of the world
August 12, 2009 - 10:58 ET by Roger the ShrubberProstitots of the world unite!!!
Visit The Daily Wave
I agree, Shawn
August 12, 2009 - 10:49 ET by candanceIt was risque, but it wasn't as bad as people are making it out to be. Certainly no worse than Britney kissing Madonna.
Overall though, it just goes to show you that the Nickelodeon is now included in the list of channels a conservative family is told to "just click away." My husband and I don't enjoy watching a teenager shake her naked thighs for entertainment. You're welcome for us paying for it, making it cheaper for you, just so we can watch the news.
And I'm sure NBC is thankful for things like this keeping Chris Hanson in business.
I don't think you need to do
August 12, 2009 - 10:56 ET by balboaI don't think you need to do away with Nickelodeon based on this one incident. There's still plenty of good stuff over there. Sponge! Bob! Square! Pants!
sure bal
August 12, 2009 - 11:03 ET by candanceWith all this free publicity and people saying she looks like an innocent mall-walker, Nickelodeon is sure make certain that this will never happen again....
candance...I'm with you on...
August 12, 2009 - 12:52 ET by PrairieSkyNickelodeon...When our daughter was small (she's 23 now), we watched Nickelodeon often. The shows were silly, clean fun for kids, and we all enjoyed much of what the channel offered. Now, much of what I see there I don't care for, and I'm sorry to see what the channel has become, and I am thankful that it wasn't like that when our daughter was little.
I suppose no one should be surprised at the direction that Nick has taken considering the fact that it is owned and operated by the MTV Networks division of Viacom.
"The problem is not that people are taxed too little...the problem is that government spends too much." ~President Ronald Reagan
Kinda feel like you do,
August 13, 2009 - 06:50 ET by Indiana JoeKinda feel like you do, Prairie, although my son's only 12. I was rather surprised to find Nick is now showing "Malcolm in the Middle" during prime time. Don't get me wrong, I love that show, and so does my son! But, it seems a bit crude and hard-edged for a channel that used to be about entertaining kids. I can see where some parents wouldn't want their young children to watch "Malcolm." The days of being able to trust Nick without constantly looking over your kids' shoulders to "be a good parent" are seemingly going by the wayside.
Why are the tags even more clipped than they used to be?
Overall though, it just goes to show you that the Nickelodeon is
August 12, 2009 - 22:25 ET by shawn228"Overall though, it just goes to show you that the Nickelodeon is now
included in the list of channels a conservative family is told to "just
click away."
I could be wrong but why would they tell you to click away from Nickelodeon? From what I understand Miley Cyrus is Disney and Nick is their competition.
"My husband and I don't enjoy watching a teenager shake her naked thighs for entertainment."
Very interesting, that you consider a girl dancing in her shorts shaking her naked thighs, I guess women tennis players strut their naked thighs and show off their cleavage for 3 hours straight.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
hi shawn
August 12, 2009 - 22:47 ET by candanceThe venue where she did this was not a Disney event. I thought it was the Kid Choice Awards, which airs on Nickelodeon. It was actually the Teen Choice Awards which is produced by Fox.
So my apologies to Nickelodeon. Since I don't watch anything on Fox as it is, apparently my viewing habits will remain the same for now.
As to your point about tennis, I don't watch ladies' tennis and have never defended their outfits. I think tennis and cheerleading outfits usually are too suggestive.
Hi Candance
August 12, 2009 - 22:52 ET by shawn228No problem, you know me, whenever there is any thread about decency I'm like PT on a Palin thread :-)
Miss you on EEIS, hope to hear from you soon.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
Wait, candance, you think
August 13, 2009 - 12:37 ET by balboaWait, candance, you think women's tennis outfits are too suggestive?
Mountains out of molehills
August 12, 2009 - 11:57 ET by TheCynicSometimes conservatives make mountains out of molehills. I agree with the above poster that this is one of those times.
Tip for the article writer:
Not every dance that involves a pole is a "pole dance". A pole is just a prop. Unless she was straddling it naked and hanging upside down from it and taking dollar bills from the audience, there's no reason to call it a "pole dance".
Now can we go back to being outraged about outrageous things and not cluttering up the space with molehills?
This I kinda think is a bit
August 12, 2009 - 09:35 ET by jchutch2This I kinda think is a bit overblown. Miley didn't perform what I'd call a pole dance. She was standing on top of a hot dog type cart and was really just holding on to the pole while she kinda danced. The routines were basic line dancing moves. She wasn't snaking or writhing on the pole. I don't remember seeing her wrap anything other than her fingers around the pole. She wasn't leaning against it or grinding in any fashion. I really think this is much ado about nothing. Just my nickel's worth.
She should learn how to dance
August 12, 2009 - 09:54 ET by mark_bBefore she shows skin and proves that she has no control of her body in motion, she should learn how to dance. More modest clothing could have gone a long way to cover for her lack of talent.
At best this will make fans feel awkward as she parades her little girl body around in adult clothes. She should allow her body to mature a little before going all Brittany on us.
This was a poor choice on her, and her management's part.
It may or may not be
August 12, 2009 - 10:06 ET by mattmIt may or may not be pole-dancing....but whatever it is, this pre-fab stuff is crap. From what I've observed, most kids start mocking Hannah Montana by the time they're 13 or 14.
They knew what it would look like
August 12, 2009 - 11:55 ET by gromitThe producers did and so did the Cyrus camp. She's distancing herself from "Hannah" and ready to be "adult" as soon as she's 18.
And she's not dressed like every other teen. She's in old-fashioned hot pants which are only associated with sexuality.
I don't want my girl watching her and she's not. I *do* click off but I also say how I see it.
I've observed a very crass
August 12, 2009 - 13:24 ET by celatorI've observed a very crass tendency by those companies that market kids for profit, i.e. Disney and other companies. Mylie is a good example, as is Spears.
It goes something like this:
1. Find a pre-pubescent kid with some degree of talent, cut some records, get a tv series, make a movie to develop a same age (10-12 year olds) cohert of fans. Market the kid heavilly. Count the money as it starts rolling in.
2. As the "talented" child develops into puberty (along with the cohorts) begin to sexualize the "star". Dress her more provocatively, have her sing more double entendre songs. These actions feed the growing (and normal) sexual interests of the age cohorts--girls want to imitate the "star" in actions and provocative fashion, the young boys have sexual fantasies about the "star".
3. At the right time, mysterious, half naked photographs of the star are "discovered". The response of the marketers is along the lines of "Those were private. She didn't know they would be released. Oh my gosh this is so awful, and she is so sorry she allowed those pictures to be taken by her boyfriend." And so on.
It is crass exploitation of young people to make more money by treating their "star", as a cash cow,and it's a very ugly business.
No citizen's right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness, or property is safe as long as Obama is President of the United States.
Remember when Vanessa Hudges
August 12, 2009 - 22:21 ET by msh1973Remember when Vanessa Hudges (sp) sent nude photos of herself to Zack Effron? Disney didn't do a darn thing about that...they made another one of those stupid High School Musicial films and got richer. Sigh.
I do remember
August 12, 2009 - 22:27 ET by shawn228She made Disney alot of money and vice versa. She made a mistake, they forgave her and thats thats.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
My point was that Disney
August 13, 2009 - 06:37 ET by msh1973My point was that Disney could care less if their Stars are doing stupid things for kids their age...it is all about the money for them and their Stars.
Its a business
August 13, 2009 - 08:03 ET by shawn228Disney is out to make money like everyone else. If Vanessa said something racist or was drunk driving that is one thing, but these were personal photos she sent and they were illegally obtained, so I don't blame Disney for letting this one slide.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
Miley Cyrus
August 12, 2009 - 12:25 ET by John Galt1776This performance was mild compared to what she does on stage in concert.
Parents should be more conerned about letting their teenage kids watch TV shows with violence and those comedy and soap opera shows that feature dysfunctional realtionships among and between people especially between men and women.
--------------
I actually met Miley Cyrus in a very causal situation and talked very briefly with her. Not enough to get a real read on her. However, i will say that she seemed just like the majority of teenage girls living in Los Angeles and probably America.
I thnk that is why the girls in America love her. She is a reflection of who they are and who they fantazie that they would like to be.
Good Work,Colleen
August 12, 2009 - 12:38 ET by iveseenitallKeep up the good work, Colleen. You are correct in your analysis. Those who laugh it off or excuse it are wrong to do so. Pointing out that it is wrong is what true "feminismm" is all about. Unfortunately, it is much easier to simply look the other way as our "kids" are poisoned by "liberal" relativism. It's been going on for a long time in America. Sad.
BTW--one of Barry's girls is getting to that age. Maybe she perform on a pole, wearing hot pants and boots at the next state dinner.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Yes, because a state dinner
August 12, 2009 - 12:40 ET by balboaYes, because a state dinner and an awards show are about the same thing, not to mention a teen pop star and the daughter of a president.
why, bal?
August 12, 2009 - 12:55 ET by candanceIs Miley Cyrus a reflection of middle America, or not?
I think Miley has, so far,
August 12, 2009 - 13:48 ET by balboaI think Miley has, so far, remained remarkably grounded. In that sense, yes, she's a lot like every other teen. But that in no way means that a performance at an awards show would be ideal for a state dinner, or that the daughter of the president would dress the way she does for a performance.
Not in my household, I
August 12, 2009 - 22:15 ET by msh1973Not in my household, I have two daughters, 14 and 15 years old. As a matter of fact my 14 year old can't stand her and my 15 year could care less about her or her music. She is popular mostly with pre-teen girls and boys who think she is "hot". As a mom of girl that age, I would never let her parade around in "hot pants" and low cut tops showing the outline of her breasts. But hey, it is all about the money!
Good for you msh1973
August 12, 2009 - 22:41 ET by shawn228You are doing a good job raising your children, You proving that a parent can take responsiblilty for raising a child and not blame in on tv or liberalism.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
Bal
August 12, 2009 - 13:01 ET by iveseenitallOh, get the starch out of your shirt, Bal. It's 2009, baby! Twelve- year- olds in hot pants and boots everywhere, especially at state dinners --show the world how hip we are--Yeah!
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Lol iveseenitall
August 12, 2009 - 22:31 ET by shawn228When you wake up at the crack of dawn"bet that offends you as well as a ass reference" do you just think about what you blame on liberalism? Just like how the libs invent things to blame on Bush? Man would I hate to be the kid that loses his baseball in your backyard.
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
Shawn
August 13, 2009 - 11:43 ET by iveseenitallFunny, hundreds of young people who know me don't feel the way you do about me. And I thought you guys hated those who are "judgmental". Check the mirror.
NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"
Iveseenitall
August 13, 2009 - 22:58 ET by shawn228Lol, who's being judgmental. There are many others on this site that talk about liberal bias, but your the only one that constantly blames liberals and indecency on everything and always talk about the sky is falling.
Hardly judgemental when I am stating facts. Wow did not know you know hundreds of young people, are you only nice to the conservative ones? ;-)
"I swear sometimes the self-appointed moral police are as obnoxious and demanding of big government interference as "environmentalist" gun control advocates, labor unions and trial lawyers"~fitzfong
Somebody is whoring out
August 12, 2009 - 17:26 ET by mostlymoderateSomebody is whoring out these young girl at earlier and earlier ages. I used to blame the people like Calvin Klein. In this particular instance, I blame Disney and Miley Cyrus' dad.
I don't think you could call
August 12, 2009 - 20:22 ET by balboaI don't think you could call this performance "whoring out." I reserve that more for what Britney did. Cyrus has been pretty age-appropriate so far.
Disney is notoriously omni-present for anything under their name, so either they approved, or they didn't think this was a problem.
Miley Cyrus acting too adult
August 12, 2009 - 21:38 ET by david999Miley Cyrus at www.google.com and click on Images
She already has cellphone photos "leak" out.
Too adult poses and short outfits.
Stage parents (kids from 2 or 3 different people) that have had her do racy poses for magazines.
I predict she will be the next britney spears.
I think it takes more than
August 12, 2009 - 21:42 ET by balboaI think it takes more than that to indicate a future life of scandal and ruin.
Interesting yet sick game
August 12, 2009 - 23:24 ET by RR GOPInteresting yet sick game we play in this country concerning such things.
One of the 34% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 86% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.
Foundations in Art vs Hollywood
August 13, 2009 - 13:00 ET by AtTheWaterCoolerI've linked to your post
http://www.jeremiahf...
It is sad that we live in a nation were young woman learn that what is important, likable about them is their body. People who buy into that lie will not have success in their lives from this lie.
What is important for employment is integrity ... what is important in a long term relationship is integrity.
The future for those that buy the lie, who think the way to success is their body, is not a promissing one.